The strange case of Barry Beach

Montanans For Justice, Montana — Fri, 04 Apr 2008 16:37:42 GMT

Montanans For Justice believes, without question, that Barry Beach is an innocent man. Not one shred of physical evidence ties him to the murder of Kim Nees. Investigate it yourself at www.montanansforjustice.com. Thank you, Dateline, for taking the time to reveal a grave injustice in our judicial system and the political figures who are either corrupt or have turned a deaf ear to this case.

The strange case of Barry Beach

J Williams Helena MT — Fri, 04 Apr 2008 17:12:53 GMT

I have studied this case and believe we have an innocent man in prison. Read the facts for yourself at www.montanansforjustice.com

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jeff Knapp, Helena, Montana — Fri, 04 Apr 2008 17:23:27 GMT

This is a case that has gotten a lot of attention from the media here in Montana lately. It is obvious that Barry Beach didn't do the crime, but he is still doing the time. After 25 years in prison, Montana officials need to stop hiding from the truth and let the man out. Find the real murderers and let Montana heal from this travesty.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Anthony Quebedeaux, Helena, MT — Fri, 04 Apr 2008 19:35:00 GMT

This is a tragic case for Mr Beach and the Nees family. After much study of the facts I believe whole heartedly in Barry Beach's innocence. This shows how hard it is for our penal system to reverse itself once an error has been made. In this case detectives coerced confessions from Barry to two Louisianna murders in addition to the Nees murder. It was proven quickly he could not have commited the Louisianna murders. The othe confession stuck despite it not matching the crime scene and no physical evidence tying him to the scene. The State of MT has zealously defended his guilt despite ample evidence to exonerate him.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bob Kolar, Helena MT — Fri, 04 Apr 2008 22:19:44 GMT

To see the evidence supporting the case for Barry Beach's innocence, readers can go to www.MontanansForJustice.com. Montanans For Justice is a group of Montanans from throughout the state who, after careful and thorough review of the evidence, have become convinced that Barry Beach is innocent of the murder of Kim Nees and that the actual killer(s) are still at large. We are current and former elected officials, business men and women, professionals, and folks from all walks of life who want the state of Montana to grant Mr. Beach a fair trial and to honestly seek the truth in this matter.

The strange case of Barry Beach

darlene Peterson — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 00:36:58 GMT

I am so very happy and thankful to Shane, Keith, all the camera people, and NBC for stepping up to the plate on this story. I know you will all be rewarded one million fold for this,, Thank you all for your tireless hours, your patience and mostly for your belief in Barry Beach, his family, friends and the hundreds of supporters. I have known Barry since childhood and I knew Kim and was a friend of hers.. so many people have come forth to tell the truth and it all has been the same, Barry Beach had nothing to do with the brutal murder of Kim Nees.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Julie, Mt — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 01:29:12 GMT

I completely whole heartedly believe Barry is 100%innocent. The truth is there if you look and listen! The real killer or killer's are still out there and no one is looking for them! The entire situation is not right, I do not understand why no one will listen and hear the truth for them selves and except the fact that a terrible mistake has been made.
Politic's should never have been involved, who or what give's them that kind of right! Was he or she there??
My heart goes out to the Beach family.!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Don Flugga, Sandusky, Ohio — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 02:57:20 GMT

Why did the police officer break into the evidence room?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kim Blades, Princeton, IL — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 02:58:51 GMT

I cannot believe how pigheaded the parole board, former prosecutor and others saying Barry is guilty are. My gosh, grant the man a new trial. Find those girls that were seen in Kim's truck cab the night of her murder. Grant one of them a lesser sentence for her turning on her 'friends'. They've even more than likely been responsible for the death of at least one witness, maybe two. Oh wait ... Barry ordered that from prison, I'll bet the prosecutors would say. That's how assinine this all is. The man is innocent. Let him be free and live the rest of his life outside of prison.

FREE BARRY!!!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mary, Laredo TX — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:04:02 GMT

This case and others like it have shaken my faith in our justice system.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dave Miller, Franklin, TN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:04:37 GMT

Unbelievable. With all of the evidence presented, how could an appeal not be granted. The only evidence against Barry Beach is a confession that was possibly coerced? What a travesty.

The strange case of Barry Beach

J. D. Keith — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:04:52 GMT

I think Barry Beach should have been pardoned. There are too many questions about his guilt. He should be granted a new trial immediately.

The strange case of Barry Beach

G. Martin — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:06:00 GMT

This is a perfect example why so many people in this country have lost all respect for our judicial system.

The strange case of Barry Beach

andrew lawson — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:06:44 GMT

Are you kidding me?! OMG this is one incredible miscarriage of justice!! Tell me anything I can do to help and I'll do it! Please help me to get involved as I watched the story and there is PLENTY of evidence to create the "air of doubt" required for a innocent finding in a criminal proceeding! Please tell me how I can help. Had half the same evidence been presented in a courtroom setting originally...who knows but how could a reasonably educated group of jurors NOT see this case as full of questionable issues? I mean c'mon!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Julia — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:07:03 GMT

Hurray for the seekers of justice. Take it to the supreme court and all news agencies!

Don't forget the Texas Border Agents still in prison!

My prayers for you all.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Denise, Belcamp, MD. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:07:21 GMT

I can not believe the system in Montana would allow this man to stay in prison for all this time given the hard facts in this case. I thought this was the United States,not Russia. Shame on you, Parole board.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Eddie Smith ELkins WV — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:07:29 GMT

I only know what I just seen on Dateline, however, I would feel strongly That Sissy was a lying druggy and had something to do with the death. Barry Beach, although was probably destined for prison from his behaviors up until he was arrested for this, was in my view innocent, not just not guilty. He did not commit this crime and it is ashame that he was convicted by corrupt law enforcement. I, the evidence that dateline provided, showed this Retired State Trooper that a innocent man could be convicted on bad evidence, and no one wants to back down, due to the implication of a Prosecutor, who became govenor probably on the backs of cases like this one. Keep us informed, good job dateline, Kieth keep up the good work, your objectively on all sides show a real reporter should be.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sherri Hancock, Omaha, NE — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:07:56 GMT

After watching the show, I am convinced Barry did not do it! I think the only reason they didn't let him go is so they don't set a precedent!! What a shame that the real killers have not come forward or at least somehow said that Barry is innocent.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joy Kaiser, Beaumont TX — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:08:31 GMT

This is a disgrace. There is NOTHING to prove that he killed her! I thought in America, we are INNOCENT until PROVEN GUILTY. I believe we can easily be MADE to say all kinds of things that aren't true when we are threatened.

The strange case of Barry Beach

sherri scholtz, pinconning, MI — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:08:46 GMT

My husband and I just watched this on tv. I am shocked that this travisty of justice is continued. What about the man who broke into the evidence room? What about the hand print and those who have not had their prints taken? There is definately room at least for reasonable doubt.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kim Massa, Newington, CT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:09:20 GMT

Will Dateline follow-up on this story? I really want to know if he ends up being freed! I don't believe he's guilty, and even if so, there is NOT enough evidence linking him to the crime, There's no way he would be convicted in a new trial. However, because of lacking evidence, I don't believe he's guilty, there would have been SOMETHING there linking him to the crime if he did it, Let's face it, the crime scene was a mess. Shame on the Poplar police for not solving the crime with those prints after all these years!

The strange case of Barry Beach

teresa oklahoma — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:09:23 GMT

something is wrong with this case just does not add up how a guy that young could murder someone and not leave a trail of evidence on the body or anywhere else. I find this very odd as well as others I am sure will also. Very funny that a cop breaks in and evidence comes up missing and then what his daughter is one of the people who is looked at as being involved. The confession damned this guy to jail but there is something wrong in this whole deal and some of those involved are going to be found out.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carolyn M. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:09:28 GMT

I feel sympathy for Barry Beach, but get rid of the 1970s "stash." It doesn't help.

The strange case of Barry Beach

julie, northern va. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:09:43 GMT

Something is very wrong in Montana. Why did they not look for the people whose prints were all over that truck? Who are they trying to protect?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joy Kaiser, Beaumont TX — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:09:50 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lorenzo D. Ambrosio..Lauderdale by the Sea, Florida — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:09:51 GMT

I really think that Barry Beach is innocent...I think that the governor of Montana, who was prosecutor at the time, doesn't want to get embarrassed...and he being strong in office, had the board make that decision...politics....that's what it is, and those women are guilty as sin...and poor Barry Beach pays the price....terrible travesty....terrible...release that man, and arrest those women, and impeach that governor, that was the prosecutor....

The strange case of Barry Beach

Layne Hollander, Plantation Florida — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:09:57 GMT

It doesn't take a rocket scientist or even the brain of a child that's completed say 6th grade to figure out that the palm print needs to be followed up on and the political agendas of those for the prosecution and the parole board did not allow an independent objective decision to occur. Dateline would be well served to keep this story active for it appears obvious that an innocent man is behind bars and a dependent drug addict was involved. The bar owners testimony as well as the sister's testimony is powerful and would be given consideration in many less politically charged cases. Barry seems to be the scapegoat for the case now, not necessarily the murder. This is a slow murder of Barry now.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Andrew Potts — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:10:00 GMT

From watching the story on msnbc, it appears that the parole board ignored the evidence supporting Barry Beach. Also, all of the things that were left undone by the local law enforcement in that community was appalling, from not identifying finger prints, shoe prints, and the stealing of evidence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kim Massa, Newington, CT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:10:00 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

nancy drury — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:10:20 GMT

This case if typical of law offices wanting to be "The One Who Solved The Case" and get their names in the paper. Too many other leads. fingerprints, palm print and the footprint. Montanas parole should be in jail or at least receivew the Stupid and Blinded Eye award. If you cant put someone at the crime, then no matter how long they yell I did It, one should never be found guilty if thats all they got on them. Sad Sad..I hope Montanas parole board cant sleep at night. Miss Druggy says Its been so many years but hey I remember going home and to bed. My My how the memory works when its to your advantage.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Megan A. Central, Illinois — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:10:22 GMT

This is the biggest story of misjustice I have ever seen or heard of! I think it's pretty obvious what the motivation for keeping him in prison is. His accuser, now the govenor, doesn't want to be made out as the bad guy. God forbid he was wrong. I hope someone outside of Montana government can help this poor man be freed from a crime he obviously did not commit. My heart goes out to him and his family and also to the family of the victim.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sheila B Darien GA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:10:42 GMT

I am sitting here with my mouth dropped open I can not believe the Parole Board could be so BLIND--I feel with every thing in me that he DID NOT kill this girl--I hope that all these people can sleep at night and one day they will answer to God about this HE knows the truth--all those people standing up for him even the Mayor even her own Sister--what the hell does it take--there's some shady crap going on against this man, it sad sad sad and sickening--looks to me like the law is just trying to cover their butt, I think this was fixed--even their stories are conflicted--

The strange case of Barry Beach

claire Boisvert Dugal — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:10:59 GMT

I would like to correspond with Barry Beach, the subject of to-night's program. I live in Canada and have corresponded during 10 years with a death row inmate now executed. I would like to bring that man hope and keep his spirit up. I am a great grand-mother and love writing as well as having an opportunity to practice English.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kathleen North Platte NE — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:11:50 GMT

This story really move me i do not think he kill her i think they needed a scrape goat and the BARRY BEACH was it the technology of today they could run these prints and know who they are for those witness i do believe them why would any one ruin a marriage over this

for the prosecutor shame on you i want an email our a phone number to tell him what i think of him

The strange case of Barry Beach

Keith Harris Zavalla Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:11:57 GMT

Who were the other two girls were their print compared and the policemans daughter was hers palm print compared

The strange case of Barry Beach

Debra Shortsleeve — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:12:07 GMT

I watched the show and feel that Barry Beach is innocent. Now with the ability to run DNA tests, the evidence should be re-examined. The real killer or killers are out there. By the looks of the woman involved it was probably jealousy. Someones boyfriend made a pass at Kim and the murderer didn't like it. Something along those lines. What makes some men with power act like they are God? This man deserves to live what's left of his life a free man.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sandy, Conroe, Tx — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:12:16 GMT

It sure is hard to believe that the parole board refused to do anything for this man. To me there is reasonable doubt, and it seems to me that they could have let the man out on parole. As far as a POLITICIAN testifying,,,well, I just won't go there.
Does anyone out there agree?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Missy Morris — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:12:23 GMT

Wow, this is completely heart breaking. After watching the story, I still cannot figure out why the board chose to do absolutely nothing. Even if he did do it, (which I don't believe he did) hasn't he spent enough time in there now? How much time would a 17 year old boy today in the year of 2008, actually serve for a murder?? Reflect on that for a while.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Susan Burtch, Arlington, TN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:12:24 GMT

why can they not get the finger/hand prints of the girl whose father was a police officer that broke into the police station and destroyed/took evidence? the girl's sister-in-law testified that the girl said she kicked the deceased in the head? do autopsy reports show that the deceased was kicked in the head? can they rerun the handprint in the data bases? Was the bloody handprint the deceased's blood? Seems to me there should be some further investigating done.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Von Shipman, Valdosta, GA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:13:02 GMT

I am convinced without a doubt this man was wrongly convicted of a crime he did not do. Even if he did it his sentence should be reduced due to the fact he served 25 years with good behavior. Where is the justice...

The strange case of Barry Beach

Genoris Haduck, Social Circle, GA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:13:06 GMT

DNA is not always reliable due to the new discovery that you can have two different DNA, as the program on the medical chanel "I am my own twin".
Fear can cause anyone to lie.

The strange case of Barry Beach

cindy lincicum juda wisconsin — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:13:09 GMT

with the evidence presented to the jury, there is reasonable doubt that he didn't commit this crime. with the palm print why wasn't the girls in question fingerprinted and then compared. Also to many people
had to much to gain. the sheriff, the person to went to become governor, of course the eye witnesses also the many calls to the ploice dispatcher that night. when there own police department said there was only 2 when there was 10..

The strange case of Barry Beach

cheryl greco hallsville, tx — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:13:11 GMT

this is one of the worst cases of arrogance,from prosecutors to police and a so called parole board that i have ever seen. a total miscarriage of justice. i think they should all be fired or dimissed from their jobs. and the people of montana need to impeach that governor. how anybody could be fool enough to believe that this was a fair or just parole board hearing is beyond understanding. way too many contradications in their evidence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Liz Black — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:13:57 GMT

After watching this show, there is NO doubt in my mind this man is innocent. I think this is a tragedy that the law in Montana are ignoring the cold hard facts. With NO evidence at the crime scene and knowing that at least 25% of confessions are not authentic, how can they deny this man his freedom. I will not sleep well tonight, knowing what this man has gone through and the law in Montana are turning their heads to the real killer(s).

The strange case of Barry Beach

nancy drury — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:14:00 GMT

"His accuser was a man whose own career reached the mountain top of influence, prestige and credibility in American politics, and he was impassioned in his belief that the right man was in prison"
WELL HES RIGHT UP THERE WITH THE BIGBOOBS OF POLITICIANS. Getting ahead at the cost of someone else. ( sorry I had to send my remark in 2 messages.)

The strange case of Barry Beach

SD Fincher, Fort Worth, TX — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:14:11 GMT

Judging by the evidence (or lack of it), Mr. Beach wasn't even at this crime scene. It's so obvious that there was a cover up & the cops found a kid they could rail road. Pathetic ! How can a cop breaking into an evidence room get blown off? Who'd do that unless they had something to hide? Perhaps that their daughter was witness or took part in beating someone to death? So the courts get to protect the (obviously) crooked cops? Pathetic squared. If I had a say in Mr. Beach's freedom, he'd be out w/ a huge sum of money for this injustice.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carolyn Coker Hamburg, Arkansas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:14:12 GMT

I think Barry is innocent. Why haven't they done a palm print on the cops daughter? Too many cover ups and bullying went on there. God be with this guy. He's his only hope.

The strange case of Barry Beach

H. Atkinson, Columbia, South Carolina — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:14:18 GMT

This is a political issue. You now have the former prosecutor as the govenor. What about his DNA. There was no match. If there were several people involved, how many footprints were found? What about a polygraph test? Barry Beach is not guilty. If you believe that false conviction do not occur then you must be living in a bubble.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Liz Black — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:14:29 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Steve from Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:15:08 GMT

Just got finished watching your program and i have to say as a Canadian i hope i am never a suspect in your country.Absolutly shocking. Your system,if thats what you want to call it, is broken and needs to be taken apart and fixed.Good luck on your next president it affects all of us hope you can do better

The strange case of Barry Beach

John Byrne, Pittsburgh, PA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:15:14 GMT

I just watched this episode and thought it was well reported with one exception. Keith and the lawyer for Barry made a point of how the prosecutor used the pubic hair evidence improperly at trial. They even inferred that the prosecutor (an ex-governor) committed misconduct. Yet when they had the prosecutor on camera and the parts they showed of the hearing this issue was never brought up. This makes no sense to me and bothered me in that the prosecutor was so sure of himself. Further, I would have argued that if the confession was so good that you didn't need any evidence (as the prosecutor and the board ultimately held) then why did he need to bring up the hair? Keith you blew this one.

The strange case of Barry Beach

d.brown wis — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:15:31 GMT

i believe barry is innocent. the way cops were back than they would say or do anything to get a conviction and stick with it no matter what it took.why did the cop break in and where was his daughter for questioning? i feel for barry for the loss of all those years in prison.some day he hopefully will be freed.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Gary Larbes 3908 Fulton Grove Road Cincinnati, OH 45245 — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:15:37 GMT

Is it just me that thinks there is a cover-up within Poplar! One which involves quite a few people, that control quite a few other people that will make damm sure that Barry will go down for that murder!

The strange case of Barry Beach

shane walker, clay, west virgina — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:15:38 GMT

OMG..i cant not believe this story. i usually dont believe stories like this but how can you not believe this one. barry..my heart goes out to you. i only wish things would have turned out better for you and i'm praying that they do and i believe after seeing this show people will open their eyes and hearts to you. i know i did. i have no idea if you will even be able to read this but some body will. i'm sorry to say this but i'm actully pissed off right now at how things turned out. i believe those girls did it out of jealousy and i do believe what goes around WILL come around. my heart, thoughts and prayers go out to you barry and i only wish there was some why i could let you know. keep your head up and your heart stong.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Steve McConihay Decatur, GA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:15:44 GMT

After viewing your program I was apalled that Barry Beech was not exonerated by the Board of Pardons
and Parole. It is apparent to me that the former
state governor, the Board of Pardons and Parole,
the sherrif's office and the state all conspired
to keep him in jail, rather than admitting their
mistake and shoddy investigation of the crime.
Some of these people that sent Barry to jail
deserve to be in jail themselves for knowingly
imprisoning an innocent man.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Karen Salter — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:15:55 GMT

I've just finished watching "Dateline" and can't believe that Barry Beach is still sitting in prison. It seems so obvious that he is an innocent man. I hope that your broadcast can help him in his fight for freedom.

The strange case of Barry Beach

L.S. Bonar Washington, IA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:15:59 GMT

I believe Barry Beach is innocent. Why hasn't the law given lie detector tests to everyone that has any possible connection to the night of the murder. I'm betting it was the women named as the murderers. I would like to know if Barry's sentence is ever turned around and he is released.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Monica Samayoa, Dallas, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:16:16 GMT

I am stunned and can not believe that with all of the evidence provided for Barry, he is still denied his freedom. How can anyone that knows what the truth really is just stand there and let an innocent person's life go to waste? Clearly there is someone behind this and hope that their conscious leads them to do the right thing. While my opinion has no impact on this Case, I believe one hundred percent that he is innocent and is being robbed of his freedom. My prayers are with Barry and with whom ever has to live with hiding the truth.

The strange case of Barry Beach

L Miller, Indiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:16:30 GMT

Either the prosecutor has something to hide like the police do or he is a fool. These law enforcement good ole boys are never going to admit they could be wrong just so they can save face. Why did a police officer break into the evidence? Is his daughter one of the killers? This whole story seems like one big cover by those who are supposed to find the real truth. The probation board is no better. One day they will all face their judge. He knows the truth.

The strange case of Barry Beach

ro — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:17:30 GMT

I question the confession cassette tape that was alleged to be erased. If so, why was it erased? Who would have benefited from that? Also, what about the police officer who was supposed to have tampered or broken into the evidence room? Why did that apparently happen? Are these questions raised? Was someone perhaps being protected and for what reason?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bonnie — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:17:31 GMT

I watched Dateline NBC's show Friday night on Barry Beach and believe he is innocent . The only evidence conficting him that seems to be present is his confession, of which is not entirely accurate. It is very disturbing to see things so clear like finger prints not looked into. Why would a cop have brake into a locked storage where the evidence was? I would have been interested in the stated reason he did this. That was not shown on this show although his daughter was one considered to have been in the vehicle that night. I hope the Centurion Ministries find who belonged to the many fingerprints in and on the vehicle.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tonya Hamilton — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:17:33 GMT

This is the most ridiculous incarceration I've seen. There is absolutely no proof that Mr. Beach committed this crime and I absolutely agree that there is a conspiracy of political nature that is occuring within his state. What seems to be my biggest concern is the policeman who broke into and tampered with the evidence. This would leave me to believe that his daughter had something to do with this crime and that he used his position to influence others which continued throughout the case until the incarceration of Mr. Beach. It is beyond comprehension to me that this is how our society works and for the parole board to totally dimiss the new evidence. WOW. Based on the prosecutor saying to the original jury that there was hair linking Mr. Beach to the crime should without a doubt lead to a new trial. I think the state which convicted him is just affraid of the amount a law suit may cost them. I didn't believe any one of those men that interviewed and received the confession from Mr. Beach, they all have risks that are associated with this case and their reputations..just amazing what this world is coming to.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Michele, Lithia Springs, GA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:18:11 GMT

I think the decision to keep Mr. Beach in prison was purely to protect the reputations of Marc Racicot and the law enforcement officers involved. Doesn't anyone care who really killed that girl!

The strange case of Barry Beach

jackie, Olathe, KS — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:18:27 GMT

I think it is just terrible, that Barry Beach, is behind bars. I believe intimadation was used and he was young and used drugs and alcohol and this all had to play with how he was interogated. It's just a shame
that people in power can make a life and death decision over someone with power and money and influence. I pray to God he will get parole.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joyce McAbee — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:18:44 GMT

I do not thing Barry Beach committed thia death. What about the cop that stole the things needed to prove who did it. Was not his daughter there? I believe some one is covering up this crime. I watch Dateline about this tonight, 04-04-08

The strange case of Barry Beach

KRW — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:19:50 GMT

At first I was sympathetic, but as the story dragged on (for 2 HOURS) I found myself asking questions that the story was not answering. Too many people who were known trouble makers were supposedly "home in bed" when the crime happened. Riiiight. This story had a significant amount of irrelevant emotional testimony presented, which always raises a red flag with me. Too much of this story focuses on what a choir boy this guy was in prison, yet he was also a serious drunk and substance abuser at the time of the murder. There are many reasons to doubt the original conviction, but somebody murdered that girl. I see as many problems with how this story was presented as I see with the conviction.

Since this story made very little attempt to ferret out the truth, it just questioned the conviction, I found myself forming my own speculations. There may not be physical evidence that this guy was there but that doesn't mean he wasn't. According to the alternate theory, there were several girls and a couple of guys there when she was murdered. What if Beech was there and involved to some degree, but so were the several women? Possibly even JD Atkenson ("Sissy's" brother)? If that is the case, what incentive is there for either side to state the truth? If either side were to fess up, Beech is guilty but so is everybody else. Beech's only hope is if it can be proved he was never there. Taking everyone else down with him wont do him any good since, assuming this is the case, his past insistence on his innocence will not likely buy him enough sympathy to get out. None of those that are out have any reason to change their story at all. What if the whole group was just too damn drunk/high for anyone to recall what really happened?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Silence Dogood — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:20:12 GMT

Coerced confession taken as physical evidence by a parole board? Physical evidence such as blood, hair, foot tracks, DNA completed ignored? This is inconsistent with U.S. law. Something is extremely fishy here. Somebody very powerful must have something dire to lose with the case against Barry Beach. There is no other explanation for the bizarre behavior of the Montana parole board.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carla,BC Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:20:36 GMT

I am not god..and honestly I do not know what really happened all those years ago.But my heart truely aches for Barry.Something in his eyes tells me he is not a killer.My prayers are with you Barry and I will be following and checking on any upcoming decisions concerning this deeply sad and unfortunate situation.In this world of high tech. testing and fair trials where is the evidence? This just seems so far beyond reason.I just cant even get my mind around how this can even be possible....I am just beyond words at the moment.devistated and disgusted in the way this case has been handled.My love and heart goes out to barry's mom...

The strange case of Barry Beach

Michael Schultz — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:20:46 GMT

OK, I watched the episode and have to say that there's a cover-up going on. The corrections board clearly did not weigh any of the evidence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tina, Nashville, TN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:20:48 GMT

I was AMAZED at the decision of the board to keep Beach in prison. I cannot accept that Centurion did not bring enough evidence to cast "reasonable doubt". I just sat slackjawed at the decision, wondering who we need to write to in the justice system to bypass this obviously subjective board. To keep a man in prison for the rest of his life with no hope simply based on a confession (with as much revealing he wasn't there as they say proves he was) with NO evidence whatsoever tying him to the actual crime, seems as unjust as keeping someone in prison based soley on circumstantial evidence...neither being weighty enough to not reconsider other possible scenerios. This case was grossly mishandle with evidence compromised, destroyed etc., and statements made to a jury that were untrue and misleading. Its as if the entire state is hiding something, not just the town of Poplar. If this thing is "settled", then I have to admit I fear the integrity of our justice system.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Richard Patten — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:20:58 GMT

If the program on the Beach case is an accurate description of police investigation and evidence presented at clemency hearing, is is clear that the 'blue line,' of covering for, defending, colleagues extends from police through prosecution on up to pardon board. How to defend a citizen, or oneself, against employees of the state who have a vested interest in keeping their appointments and jobs by defending each other? If I ever saw a case calling for review by an agency independent of the state, this is it. But we do not have such an independent agency; we do not have real justice.
We have not come far enough from the time when an accusation was sufficient for conviction-when one had to prove their innocence beyond a doubt.
This, and many other cases of convictions because of prosecution determination to convict-by distorting and omitting evidence if necessary-reduces confidence in our legal system.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Debra St.CLair Wabash, IN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:21:12 GMT

My heart is sadden by this story. I see a man of great character; unlike the scared 17 year old making a confession. After teaching in a prison for several years, I know all to well how things can be covered up and how difficult it is to get any admittance of a mistake. If there is any DNA evidence that can assist in proving Barry's innocence, I hope it comes to light. Myheart goes out to him and I hope the truth sets him free.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tricia Barber Thurston, Oh. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:22:29 GMT

I would think this case would be very simple...
find whose bloody palm print is on the truck.
The only person trippin' in this case is Sissy.
I really hope Barry Beach will one day be set free.

The strange case of Barry Beach

G Edmiston, St. Louis MO — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:23:07 GMT

After watching this show, I am almost embarrased to say that I believe in our court system. If there is ever a case of reasonable doubt, this is it. I hope the people that are keeping Barry behind bars can live with themselves. I don't believe the parole board, the prosecutor or any others are looking at the evidence with a clear mind. They are relying on a confession from a 21 year old only. As a 21 year old, can any of the people working to put and keep Barry behind bars say they have not reacted to a stressful situation in a manner that more mature people would not question. If you take away the confession, there is no evidence at all that Barry was involved. How can that be? If Barry did this, it would seem there would be at least a shred of physical evidence to link him to the scene. For me, I would like to have had ONE piece of physical evidence to link him regardless of the confession. The lack of physcal evidence, makes the confession lack as much credibility as the prosecution says Barry lacks. Incredible!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Patti Audet, Scobey, MT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:23:34 GMT

I cannot believe that Barry Beach is not innocent in the Poplar murder case of Kim Nees. This case needs to be reopened and retried. The Centurion Ministries cannot be all wrong.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Michelle Ferguson, Centereach, NY — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:24:47 GMT

I believe Barry Beach is innocent and should be released from prison.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dawn Young, Houston Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:25:24 GMT

I had never heard of this case until the Dateline broadcast tonight, and I am stunned.
How in the world is this man still in prison?
Unbelievable and so very wrong.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kim Giuliano — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:25:26 GMT

I am appauled that they didn't release him from Prison. After watching your tv program. That prosecutor has to stand by his conviction because he would look extremely bad now that he is in congress and he was the original prosecutor. How can those people sleep at night, especially if it was that women that did drugs did it. And I was wondering about the girl, her father was the police chief at the time? I thought you mentioned. Could it all be a coverup? And they are protecting the real killer? Just because he confessed, well we all know from other cases that they can break under being cohearsed or forced. I could never live with myself. There was no evidence linking him to her murder, its all because he confessed. I believe if you are a murderer and you did the crime well go to jail never get out as far as I'm concerned, but I don't even know the man, with all the evidence presented I believe he is innocent. My heart goes out to him, his mother and sister.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Amber Fauller Hillsboro, Missouri — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:25:26 GMT

Watching this Dateline special makes me wonder as so many other cases have, is there really justice? In this case, I believe justice is what those in high places of government want it to be. I have seen many "crime mysteries" over time and none have given me such a sick feeling in my gut. I believe that Barry Beach is completely innocent and I will pray for justice for Barry.What this case has demonstrated is that it doesn't matter who commits a crime as long as someone is in prison paying for it, and when the chance comes right the wrong you've done to the innocent it is easier not to admit that you made a mistake.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lawrence Mitchell, Katy, TX — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:25:32 GMT

1) Why was the police officer who broke into the evidence room and destroyed evidence not questioned about why he did this.
2) Coincedentally his daughter was one of those rumored to have been involved. Also, why was she not compelled to appear after receiving a subpoena.
3) How did the prosecutor, police etc. so easily dismiss no physical evidence i.e fingerprints, blood particles at the crime scene matched Barry.

The strange case of Barry Beach

TAMU, Houston, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:25:36 GMT

This whole thing stinks of corruption, from the local police office in Poplar, all the way to the attorney general, and the state patrol board. Why did it take 3 weeks to come up with a decision? It is because someone with a little stroke is covering something up. Somebody in power had a family member or a close friend at the murder scene.

The strange case of Barry Beach

David Rogowski, Milwaukee, WI — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:25:45 GMT

I definitely think there is reasonable doubt that he is innocent. The fact that the prosecution would not even acknowledge this can be attributed to their selfish desires to further their own careers at the expense of an innocent man's freedom. I would not want to live with that guilt. Apparently it doesn't bother some people in their pursuit of power and money.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Colleen, Buffalo, New york — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:25:59 GMT

I don't understand why everyone wasn't fingerprinted in this case...I believe the fingerprints on the truck have to be the killers. What's the matter with the judicial system?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tony Alldredge — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:26:01 GMT

I believe this man is innocent and some crooked people in high places need to be brought down. Also where is this Maude girl at and why wasn't she questioned or check to compare her palm print. I think she was kin to someone at the police dept.This is an outrage!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

wanda magner, Unioncity, Michigan — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:26:29 GMT

You would think the courts especially would want to see everything that had to do with the case to help solve it. All I can say about it is I'll pray for him and hope everything turns out the way it should and I hope with all my heart he gets his life back .

The strange case of Barry Beach

Colonel Sanders, Louisville, KY — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:27:07 GMT

That busted faced crack head Sissy probably did it. And yes, people do give false confessions. It happens a lot more often then people think. People can do strange things after their minds break from being interrogated for hours and hours.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Renee Dale — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:27:10 GMT

Wow - this is unbelievable! No evidence at all! Are we still in America?? I emailed the governor of Montana - such a shame!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jean Norman Aledo, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:27:33 GMT

I just watched Dateline story about Barry Beach and I
believe an injustice has been done to him. I don't believe the Board even listened to his side. I do believe he was coerced into confessing to the crime.
Just because he confessed doesn't mean anything to me
if there is no evidence to prove he did it.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Linda Rivera, Breese, Illinois — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:28:12 GMT

This is a case, of people who have looked at the evidence of a confession and that's all they need. They have looked at this case, in what is known as tunnel-vision. A case that is black&white. I feel so sorry for Barry Beach. I feel the Mayor had a heavy hand over the decisions of the panel. That's why they could not set him free. I'll pray for you Barry. God bless you and keep the faith.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Angela Cascio, Monroe,Louisiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:28:18 GMT

I cannot believe that the parole board voted not to release Barry Beach. If anyone knows about our political system then you also know that the parole board could not vote against the past governor of the state. I would think that their position is probably an appointed one and even if it isn't do you think that they would want to bite the hand that feeds them? I would like to know if there is something we can do to help this guy get a new hearing. By the way, I was born and raised in Louisiana. I also an not proud to say this but I do believe that the law can strong arm someone when they need to.

The strange case of Barry Beach

j.richard liberty hill, texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:28:28 GMT

So, What happened to the police officer that broke in and tampered and took evidence? Does it not seem like he might have known or suspected something and was trying to protect his daughter? I believe this is another of those cases that everyone against barry beach, comes to a conclusion that we've got a suspect, he'll spend the rest of his life in jail so let's just call the case closed and move on to the next one. There is no justice here, during the show all i could think of was...like other stories i've watched, it's the police almost beating, threatening or bargaining to get what they want, just for someone to get so tired that they will just confess, and this story looks like they tried to cut a deal, we'll give you this and help you with that if you give us a story and tell us you did it. I hope the real killers are found and they get what is coming to them, because i do not believe barry beach committed this crime.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mrs. Cynthia Spalding, Outer Banks, North Carolina — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:28:59 GMT

I would like to donate a monetary contribution to Centurion Ministries, the men who have devoted their livlihoods to investigating wrongful prison terms and who believe in the innocence of Barry Beach. After watching your program tonight, I was sadly surprised by the ending and decision of the Board of Parole. If not for people like Centurion Ministries, innocent people would literally rot in jail while the real criminals remain free and never even be heard by us little folks. I've never been to criminal court myself, but I've read, seen and heard enough stories (The Kennedy's for instance, or OJ Simpson, Barry Peterson) where a very poor police investigation combined with a good prosecutor or defense attorney can simply spin a "story" either freeing or condemning someone, completely ignoring facts and evidence. What a nightmare of a justice system we have. Please provide information where such a donation could go, so I (and others) can be on the side of real justice...the true "good guys" with no political agenda. Thank you.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Eileen LaSpaluto — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:29:18 GMT

I find it suspicious that the Ex-governor and the Parole Board in Montana believed that there was compelling evidence that Barry Beach had murdered Nees. What was the compelling evidence? His confession??? It is obvious from watching dateline's presentation that there was NO compelling evidence other than his confession. Where were the eyewitnesses, or physical evidence that inked Beach to the crime? Coud it be that the governor does not want negative publicity nor does the parole board. Could it be that the state government in Montana and the criminal justice system in Montana especially Poplar River might have withheld crucial information OR worse wanted a scapegoat. Why did the police allow the father of one of the girls rumored to be a person of interest access to the evidence room? Why didn't that woman show at the hearing? She should have faced criminal charges as a no show? WHAT ARE THEY COVERING UP!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jerry E Wright ,Mount Vernon, Ohio — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:29:22 GMT

This is the first time I have ever took the time to give my opinion.But I felt I needed to in this case.If reasonable doubt was not presented in this case then God help us.POLITICS & some people's pride is the only reason Barry Beach is still in prison.

The strange case of Barry Beach

perplexed, wolf point, montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:29:31 GMT

Shame on Rascicot (sp?), former governor, for allowing such an injustice. It just seems awfully suspicious that Rascicot even took the case to begin with - guilty or not guilty - our former governor clearly crossed the line by stating to the jury the hair was that of the defendant when there was no scientific data to back it up??!

The strange case of Barry Beach

DONALD, GREENVILLE,AL — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:29:46 GMT

Saw the case of Barry Beach, in Montana. Those no good cops, investigators and that no good govenor are no good! This man is innocent! How did these people get away with this? And what the hell is wrong with the parole board? What,are they in on it too? Or was it just a good show for them! To have that many witnesses come in, and we all know why they came in now, because these so-called officials would'nt listen to them back then! This is an outrage and should'nt be tolerated! I hope someone investigates the whole crew that put this man behind bars! Give them a taste of what it's like! Don't give up Barry!

The strange case of Barry Beach

ruth a mitchell — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:30:09 GMT

i truely beleave that this yung man confessed under severe diresst and itis just an example of how fickle our judiscal system is there are thousands of innocent inmates on death row . he has set an example as a model inmate since he has been incarcerated and if i could set him free and i've never met the gentleman but in my heart i beleave he is innocent and has done his time and paid a horrible price.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Angela Cascio, Monroe,Louisiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:30:17 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Christine Taylor, Toronto, Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:30:20 GMT

It is very clear to me that this was a coerced confession under extreme duress. I cannot believe this parole board would not grant parole. How do they sleep at night? There should be a new trial based on a coerced confession. Good luck to Barry Beach and his lawyers.

The strange case of Barry Beach

CMoore, Dallas, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:30:45 GMT

OMG!!

I watched the story of the Barry Beach case, and quite frankly, I am sickened and appauled by the outcome of this case. Where is the freakin' evidence in this case?? There isn't any! Furthermore, how many confessions are coerced? AND that is ALL they have.

What about the witness that had nothing to gain and a 30-year marriage to lose...WHY would she risk everything to testify that she had 1st-hand knowledge that Barry did NOT kill Kim??

The Former Govenor that stated "that the case had undeniable, indisputable evidence that Barry was the killer"...I call BS on that...if you have it, where the hell is it??? I don't know how he sleeps at night!!He and the Pardon & Parole Board should be ASHAMED!!!

WHAT A TRAVISTY OF JUSTICE!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ann Cox Tupelo, MS — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:30:49 GMT

It saddens me that this man was not set free. I saw Dateline tonight and I was sure that he would be found innocent. I hope he will be able to go and be with his Mother very soon.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Pam Probst Lock Haven Pennsylvania — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:31:27 GMT

I watched your segment on the killing at poplar river, and I do believe Barry is innocent, watch a shame that the legal system has placed an innocent man in prison. I do believe that the girls should all be investigated that night that was there at the party. I hope the law sees justice for this man, and places the real woman behind bars.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carol McCollum, Austin, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:31:29 GMT

I am appalled at the decision of the Montana Board of Pardons & Parole in the case of Barry Beach. In my opinion they are too much influenced by the former prosecutor, who also is a past Governor. Everyone is afraid of losing face by admitting they made a mistake. The verbal support of Barry Beach is overwhlming, and all of the evidence against him is circumstantial. I believe Barry to be innocent; however, even if he were guilty, his exemplary 25-year life in prison should earn him parole.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Susan Washburn Marshfield, Mo. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:31:52 GMT

I think that Barry should have been released. The story about this case seemed to prove to me that Barry is innocent. I hope that someone will come forward and tell the truth and he will be set free.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Angela Cascio, Monroe,Louisiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:32:15 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sarah Phillips, McEwen, TN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:32:38 GMT

I just saw the story and I believe he is innocent. I hope they let him out.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Janet Jackson Houston, Texas 77038 — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:32:44 GMT

I believe the girls killed that girl . I believe out of jealousy. And they cant tell me that the police don't try to pin stuff on you. I have never been in trouble with the law but I have heard some pentifull claims of the police. And I watched this story tonight and her on sister does not believe he did it. That should say something. He needs to be free from this and let him live. Its sad when you are innocent and can not prove it cause no one cares, its not them behind bars for the wrong reason. The parole board has been wrong in many cases but hate to face it. This needs to be corrected and let this man free.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Stan Quarles, Canton, Ga. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:33:05 GMT

If this man is innocent, I hope and pray his lawyers can find a way to free him. 24 years in prison for something he may not have done is beyond horrible.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tim VanPatten Sylvan Beach, NY — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:33:26 GMT

Thank You Dateline for yet another mystery to ponder. This story reay disturbs me. With exception of Beach's confession, there was absolutely no physical evidence pointing to him. No motive.As far as I am concerned they (prosecutors,courts etc)have turned a blind eye on this case. They have got a confession period. Unbelievable. I liked the part where the officer (whose daughter was a suspect) broke into evidence room. Well something stinks in that town and its not the river. The palm print belonged to someone.I think whoever it was that said someone just happened by the crime scene and left it by mistake... yeah okay real detective work there.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Nancy Tervelt — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:33:33 GMT

As I watched this story unfold, it was apparent to me that Beach was innocent. If he was innocent, wouldn't that make many of the authority figures (or should I say political figures) look bad? Could they admit that they were wrong? What I ask is why aren't there authority figures with a backbone and admit that they could be wrong? There is no evidence, and who does that hand print belong to, or has that gone missing from the evidence room like additional items?
This was a sad report that justice has not been served. I am an upstanding citizen, and thankfully, not in the state of Montana. Politics - plain and simple is how it appears to me. But seriously, would the now Govenor actually pursuade the review board, could he? This entire justice systems does not smell good at all. Just commenting on this as I see it.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Marilyn Deery, Brights Grove, Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:33:46 GMT

To the Investigators,
My husband claims, the reason why they cannot find any physical evidence to prove Barry Beach's innocence is because Barry Beach was not there!

The strange case of Barry Beach

null — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:34:14 GMT

It will not be because it may mean someone will actually notice. I may be wrong but it could be a possibility she was jealous and feels quilty and still is in love with her former boyfriend

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dolores T. Kulynych Woodford, VA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:35:09 GMT

After watching this program and many like it, I am considering investing in a date and time stamped video recorder placed in my bedroom to record me sleeping "just in case", as I too would not have a "relyable witness" other than my family. To say I am discusted with "the system" is an understatement!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Stephanie Clark — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:36:33 GMT

Please tell me what an American citizen can do to help in this case. There is no way on God's earth this person could be convicted of this crime today.

I don't know how he could be found innocent, as they seemed to arbitrarily decide he was guilty, without any evidence other than a signed confession, and as the group who took on this case stated they have dealt with fake or forced confessions many times before.

It is my feeling that there is no liklier place for this to happen than in a small town where everyone just pulls in their wagons, and will forever stand by their case, even when it proves to be that the case was never solid to begin with.

I am not one to respond to television or groups, but injustice is something we all need to care about, as we ourselves or our family or friends could just as well be Barry Beach.

Thank you for the opportunity to voice my opinion on this Dateline program.

The strange case of Barry Beach

jeannie montgomery,beardstown il — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:36:47 GMT

i knew when they brought in the governor that Mr Beach was going back to prison,the board wasnt going against him.a blind man an see.mr beach was not involed,in my mind there is a cover up or know!wish i had money for mr beach to help fight.thank u dateline for this story.dont know why dna cant bee used!hope the board has night mares for there descion,they put that man thur hell im shore for3 wks,just to break him down again.im praying he will get outvery very soon,an them girls suffer,an come forward they know they were involed or did it.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Michelle, Wappinger Falls, NY — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:36:47 GMT

I can't understand why it doesn't seem suspicious to anyone that the one girl who people thought might be in on it has a father who's a cop and broke in and contaminated evidence and suddenly some of it went missing at that point. Am I crazy, or is this an obvious thing that should raise questions? And that bloody handprint that is not Mr. Beach's-where the hell would a bloody handprint come from at a murder scene if not from someone involved? This case seems like one where alot was brushed under the carpet to protect some people, yet some obvious things that would exonerate Mr Beach were likewise put under that same carpet. It is a real shame.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Paula Erickson, Minneapolis, MN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:37:02 GMT

At the end of the show about Barry I gasped in disbelief that the parole board didn't believe anything, had no doubts at all and sent that poor man back to prison. I wonder if they're being paid off by someone, like the governor? But other than that, other things puzzled me that didn't seem to be discussed much, if at all. First, I must have missed the first part of the show. How and why was Barry in Montana dating Kim one minute and in LA sleeping in a house where his sister also lived the next. 2nd, when Barry was brought in for questioning in LA was he read his rights, did he have a court appointed lawyer and why would a law officer say he would fry in a LA prison when the crime was committed in Montana? None of that made any sense.3rd, why didn't Centurion Ministries try to get a new trial simply based on the fact that a jury convicted a man without a shred of physical evidence and you have to be guilty beyond any reasonable doubt? 4th, why wasn't there a filing for a mistrial based on the fact that a judge gave him 100 years for this supposed crime. I would think a mistrial could have been filed merely by comparing sentences in Montana during the same time period for similar crimes. The story was fascinating but it just seemed like so many obvious parts of the story were left unreported or misunderstood.
thanks!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Louise Chouinard Scarborough, Ontario Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:37:13 GMT

I have just watched your show on Barry Beach. I can't believe this guy is still in prison. They took a 20 year old kid and scared the life out of him 25 years ago and now he is supposed to pay by living with the dregs of human society for the rest of his life. What weird kind of justice system do you people have in the U.S. No wonder all you have is criminals on the street. You have too many of the wrong people in jail and not enough of the real criminals. Step up and take a good look at your neighbors to the North and our justice system. When we are wrong at least most of the time we make it right. Set this man free and suffer the egg you all will find on your faces instead of letting an innocent man and his family and the family of Kim keep suffering. Grow up America and take care of the actual good qeople you do have living in your country!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jan Holcomb — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:37:36 GMT

I have watched the show tonight on nbc. I can't figure out why the parole board would deny your request for an interview if they believed that he was guilty? If I am going to convict someone on evidence being presented to me, I wouldn't have a problem defending my decision. That pretty much shows me that the parole board is quilty of something, what are they hiding? I'll tell you what it is, they know he's innocent and know that the state could be sued if he were to walk free for convicting an innocent man. As many witnesses that testified, no fingerprints, no DNA testing, and apparently, the guy murdered the girl in his bare feet since the footprints couldn't be connected to him either. It just doesn't add up. Yes, he said he did it, but I think he really was a young scared man who admitted to doing drugs and drinking and truely just wanted to go home. Why couldn't the man that took his confession show up personally in court either? I'll tell you why. He's ashamed of what could be brought out, the real truth, about how he scared this young man to death and then promising him if he confessed, then he could fight it out in his home state. That man needs to have a lie detector test done to prove his innocent in that he didn't threaten him into signing anything. Isn't it funny, the tape disappeared too? It really sounds like a corrupted police force and instead of doing the job right, they messed it up so bad with every bit of evidence, and honestly, knowing how the law works today, with witnesses, fingerprints, DNA, who in their right man would convict someone like Barry??!! The parole board needs their heads examined BIG TIME and shame on them.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tony Alldredge — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:37:48 GMT

This man was framed by that local police dept.Where is this Maude girl at. Why would the woman at the club say that these girls were there until 2:00 at closing yet two of them say they were at home by 11:00. these girls are lying and somebody has been covering this up.How do we help this man? Outrage!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Janet Kauker, Bay Village, Ohio — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:37:51 GMT

I just watched "A Killing at Poplar River" and I was left with two thoughts.

First, the transcript of a confession, when the original tape has gone missing, is very fishy.

Second, the parole board--that issued such an incredibly important decision VIA EMAIL!!--may have been influenced by a member of the prosecution's team who has huge political ties and ambitions.

Frankly, I believe that Barry Beach is just another sacrificial lamb on the altar of American politics.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Wayne E. Whiting, Winston-Salem, NC — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:38:11 GMT

This indeed is a strange case. Is there any way that you can advise if the Montana Supreme Court will or has rendered a decision? There seems to be a tone of conspiracy.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kenneth Moy, Monroe, LA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:38:14 GMT

Don't you think that even if Beach is guilty he has served enough time and has possibly been rehabilitated?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jan Feese Campbellsville,Ky — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:38:52 GMT

I'm no CSI but why didn't the authorities take fingerprints of the girls and shoe prints and have them take a lie detector test? It seems the only person the Montana board listened to was the prosecutor turned govenor. They discounted the bar owner making liars out of the girls and all others who came forth. The sheriff's department did a lousy job of investigating this murder and I hope they can sleep at night knowing they could have put an innocent man away for life. Why weren't the other 2 girls mentioned? Hope the truth is revealed someday.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Leslie V., Arlington, TX — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:38:59 GMT

We hope Mr. Beach gets his story heard all the way up to the US Supreme Court if that's what it takes.

It's hard to believe there were so many bloody finger prints along w/ foot prints w/ no evidence placing him anywhere near the crime scene yet he gets committed after being drilled by cops. It's also hard to believe evidence that could prove his innocence disappeared & stolen including a taped confession that turns up in paper form yet he still sits in prison. It's so obvious a cop took that tape to cover their butt over how the confession was coerced. It's awfully suspicious too that a cop can break into an evidence room, steal evidence & nothing is done? Did we hear it right that this cop was the father of one of the suspected girls? One who told her sister in law she kicked the girl? Unbelievable. We can hear "cover up" all the way in Texas. What does the prison board have to gain? Keeping their cop friends from getting into trouble? Keeping the state/county from forking over $$ for false imprisonment.

We've got our fingers crossed that someone w/ reason will listen to him & set him free. We just don't believe he did it.

The strange case of Barry Beach

M. Farrelly, Knoxville, TN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:39:11 GMT

I just watched the Poplar Creek story about Barry Beach. I was devastated at the decision of the parole board. There is no doubt in my mind that the parole board ignored the evidence that was presented. The reason being that the original prosecutor's status as a powerful political figure intimidated them. To have crossed him would be most certainly detrimental to their lives. I do hope Centurion Ministry will not give up on freeing this man from prison. Poplar Creek, Montana and Monroe, Louisiana should be ashamed of this police work. It will be difficult for me to sleep tonight because of this disturbing story.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mark Pa — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:39:48 GMT

The prosecution seems to have waffled in their attempt when they stated that Barry seemed to recall memories that helped him in his defense but his memory failed him when he couldn't recall anything that might hurt him. This is exactly what the prosecution is doing and did to get a conviction. The hard evidence that the prosecution does have in the finger prints/palm prints were conveniently placed at the crime scene by a passer~by..... Also all the valuable testimony in Barry's defense the prosecution once again conveniently serves to ignore?

It appears to me that it's the prosecution that has failed to take advantage of the evidence that would be beneficial to Barry and only use the evidence which is none whatsoever to continue to hold Barry in prison....

They need to be looking for the person who the finger prints and palm prints belong too!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Art Murillo, Houston, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:39:49 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach raises serious concerns about, not only our criminal justice system, which I still believe is the best in the world, but in all those human beings, the stewards of our criminal justice system, who stubbornly maintain their attitudes of denial despite overwhelming evidence. The prospects of exposing an ugly truth about our criminal justice system somehow drives those individuals on that parole board to essentially lie to themselves. I can only speculate that it was too much to ask these people on that board to refute law enforcement officers and prosecutors, especially their former governor - God, I just hope he didn't appoint any of those parole board members because this travesty of justice couldn't possibly get any worse.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Donovan Hawkins, Princeton Ky. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:39:55 GMT

Once again, I am disappointed with NBC. When they are not exploiting mentally ill people on their "To Catch a Predator" series, they are luring millions into watching a show that means nothing. With the "Killing at Poplar River" episode, I was led to believe that an innocent man would be released. I personally rejoice when this happens. Putting innocent people in prison is one of the worst acts the American justice system commits. But this show was obviously one sided, and did not eloborate as much on the case of the prosecution. This was a keen and shady attempt to keep people in front of the television. In the end, there really was no story. Obviously NBC thinks an innocent man is in prison...woopadeedoo! Several innocent people are in prison. This is the American justice system we are talking about. Why do a story on this guy...especially when he doesn't get out. Don't get me wrong, this would have been a great story if he would have been released, but he wasn't. Therefore, this story should have been left alone. I am tired of the hoodwinking committed by NBC, with all of their stories; even with politics, trying to lure people. I need honest journalism. I will stick with Jeopardy, Leno, and all the good shows on NBC, but not news or news specials. I am trying to stop watching this Dateline garbage along with all news stories from NBC, and stories like this help me NOT to get entranced by their luring ads for them.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joyce Eilerman-Wahlke,Peculiar,Missouri — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:40:03 GMT

If I was on a jury for the case on Barry Beach there is no way i would beable to find him guilty of murder.There is a complete lack of evidence and his confession does not coincide with the real evidence.The whole case seems to be tainted by over zealous law enforcement officials.I feel sorry for anyone being tried in the state of Montana .Obviously there judicial system is not fair and corrupt.After watching Dateline i could not find one FACT to find him guilty.I hope Barry is given another chance to seek justice and given a fair trial outside of Montana.Show Me The Money, is that what Montana is all about??

The strange case of Barry Beach

Terry Autry, Little Rock, Arkansas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:40:21 GMT

What a poor example of the legal system at work... Someone please find the two Louisiana men who confessed and were later released from all charges. This could posibly back MR Barry Beach's recelection of his own confession. I believe the reason the actual tape of his confession was lost was because the LA investigators may have added stuff to it... They could have written anything they wanted to on there and claimed it to have been Barry's words... Sounds very sad to me, that the eduacated people on the parol baord couldn't see through that... A possible cover up is in place... Two dozen finger prints and no matches??? 20-21 blows to her head and a woman admitting to a few of them... One man wouldn't / couldn't do that... The initial rummors were that a group of girls had done this... Looks that way to me... All of the witnesses who came forward... The nice woman who owned the club, that placed them out and about at 2am, the farmer who seen several people in the truck that night... That many people can't be wrong... A good man is behind bars and all the state of Montana has to go on is a typed confession from crooked *(&*&^%$^$... Some people need to get real and do the right thing here... What ever happened to "BEYOND A SHADOW OF A DOUBT???? Where do I send my donation to support his case??????
Very Respectfully,
Terry Autry

The strange case of Barry Beach

Don Jones Rome,N.Y. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:40:33 GMT

Wrong person convicted. Can't understand why more investigation wasn't done on police officer whos daughter might have been involved that broke into the evidence room. Something smells there !

The strange case of Barry Beach

James Clewis Sr. Inkster, Michigan — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:40:58 GMT

so we see again are justice system as whole not wanting to really find out the truth, because the embarrassment it may bring upon the people involve with the case, because of there status in society today. which should not matter, has long has the truth comes out. the biggest problem i have is the fbi considers the palm print to be the subject why is there no d&a, why not ask the 2 lady's being accuse for there palm print to prove there innocents in this crime. and if the d&a was not the victims get there d&a also.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Diane Smith, Louisiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:41:00 GMT

Just another example that we live in a prison nation. The last time I check the US has the highest incarceration rate in the world. Louisiana has the highest incarceration rate in the nation (and the world), so what does that say about Louisiana's law enforcement personnel. Politicians have been running on political platforms of being tough on crime. Prosecutors are suppose to represent the people and pursue justice, not just to get a conviction by whatever means they can. It's time to be smart on crime and stop locking up innocent people just to say the crime has been solved. It's also time to start letting people out of prison who no longer need to be incarcerated. Twenty years is long enough for those who have demonstrated good behavior and participated in positive activities while in prison. Prison should be for young predators who need to be in prison and not old men and women.

The strange case of Barry Beach

LouAnn, Tampa, Fl — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:41:01 GMT

This is is the first show I've seen, where I had no doubt in my mind that the Accused was innocent from the beginning to the end of the show.

It's just amazing how many people have LIED in this case. Whether he is innocent or guilty, a lot of people have lied on either side, which indicates to me that a lot has gone on behind the scenes that we don't know about.

Confusing--how the DA was twisting things, mostly dismissing things, like when he said Beaches sister never came forward to say that she saw Barry asleep in his bed around midnight. But she did tell the police, they just wouldn't "Allow" her to testify in court, because she was a sister.

It's very sad that an innocent man has to be imprisoned for life, because of corruption and politics, but I think that is what happened. It's not hard to deduce how "The Closer" got his reputation.

It's also seems very reasonable to me that everyone would be giving this guy a break and some benifit of the doubt, since the evidence was destroyed/lost /whatever. Are there no repurcusions for that? WTH??? I know what my boss would say if I destroyed or lost important paperwork that could never be replaced. I'd be out the door.

The strange case of Barry Beach

kyle lanning ,atwood kansas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:41:07 GMT

Keith Morrison did a great job on the story of Barry Beach . i dont know if he is inocent or not..i would like to think he isnt giulty..I hope you do some stories on bad police , it seems that the prosicuters alot of time dont care if the guy or gal is inocent or not...please people in this country we need to do justice thats what is so good about this country we have the chance to be great and we will never be untill we do justice here in our own country, the military has to they get put in jail if they dont so why dont the police or prosicuter go to prison.. it makes me sick to see all the people in prison that havent done the crime there in there for, but the police that have lied and cheated our still cops, makes me sick that as americans we allow this...please keith do a story on the police...

The strange case of Barry Beach

Louise Chouinard Scarborough, Ontario Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:41:10 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Faye Thrailkill, Opelika, AL — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:41:15 GMT

After viewing the two-hour commentary, I was absolutely stunned by the decision of the parole board. After so many additional witnesses came forward with their testimonies, how could the board have come to such a unanimous conclusion? I can only believe that they did not want to admit any failure on the part of their justice system. It is incredible to me that they sat there and listened to the proprietor of the club/bar that the "group of girls that had visited on the evening of the murder" had lied regarding the fact that they were home in bed by 11:00 p.m., and the proprietor testified that they kept coming in and out of the establishment well into the early morning hours and could not possibly have been home in bed as they said they were. This individual was quite elderly by this time and I can see absolutely no reason for her to be anything other than truthful. Why would one of the girls' (Atkinson)brother (already serving in prison) tetify that his sister said she had been a part of the perfect crime? What about the person who testified that the [Atkinson] woman had told her that she kicked Kim Nees several times in the head. What about the gentleman who said he saw a bunch of girls in the truck? There were just too many incidents that occurred and too many testimonies to allow anyone to believe that the defendant was guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Shame on anyone who would not look at all of this testimony objectively! Why would the Centurion group invest so many years in their investigation if they were not convinced that an injustice had occurred. I for one would never wish to see a murderer released but in this particular case, I do believe they have the wrong person locked up. There were just too many individuals who appeared to have no particular vested interest either way and who were testifying on the defendant's behalf. Even the victim's sister tetified that she did not believe they had convicted the real murderer. I aplaud the efforts of the Centurions and hope that the case will be brought before the Supreme Court and that justice will prevail. By the way, I had no knowledge of this case prior to viewing it on Dateline this evening.

Jane Q. Citizen

The strange case of Barry Beach

THOMAS, AUSTIN, TEXAS — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:41:31 GMT

MY BLOOD IS BOILING AFTER SEEING THE BARRY BEACH CASE IN MONTANA ON DATELINE! THIS MAN IS INNOCENT AND THEY ALL KNOW IT. HELL, ANYONE CAN SEE IT! DOES THE PAROLE BOARDS HAVE A MENTAL DISABILITY WHEN IT COMES TO COMPASSION! HOW MANY PEOPLE DO THEY NEED TO COME FOWARD? YOU CAN SEE THEY EITHER DID COME FOWARD IN THE PAST AND WERE'NT LISTENED TO OR WERE AFRAID OF THESE DIRTY LAW ENFORCEMENT PEOPLE, IF THAT'S WHAT YOU WANT TO CALL THEM! IT'S A DISGRACE AND SOMEONE NEEDS TO LOOK AT THIS CASE IN A HIGHER POSITION THATS NOT IN THAT CROOKED STATE OF MONTANA! LET THAT MAN OUT OF JAIL AND PUT THE REST OF THEM IN!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kim — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:41:55 GMT

I am appalled at how the Montana parole board hid behind their email and unaimously & so blatenly ignored the evidence that proves this poor man should be set free! He was a child for gosh sakes when he was verbally and mentally tortured by these hillbilly cops who just wanted to solve a murder quickly. The old "closer" guy who actually took the confession on "tape" somehow "lost" the tape and was able to remember word for word what to write down to make sure there was a viable transcript? That is barbaric and just absurd! I just wanted to laugh at these hilbilly people on the parole board--they look like Aunt Bea, Uncle Sam and company all supporting the the former DA--then turned governor, sherrif & deputy. Any objective person with or without a degree could plainly see that there was not only no evidence but that this poor kid (now a man after 24 years) was guilty and that the evidence actually does support that other people did it! Why did they say NO? Because they are not going to call those old "lawmen" (the sherrif and the DA) wrong after all these years. It is obvious that they are wrong and this was a case of a poor, confused kid who was coerced into admitting that he did it. But the tape that was made with his admission was conveniently "erased". And no one in Montana is smart enough to believe that that could be "fishy?"

The strange case of Barry Beach

Pam Klocek, Minneapolis, MN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:42:10 GMT

After watching the Poplar Murder, I still dont feel that things were answered. Like why did the police break into the evidence room? And why is a cohoerced confession being held as truth over DNA and why wont Montana allow for further DNA testing? I think there is a lot of cover up in a small town and that there is more to the story as well as with Barrys side of the story. Something smells there and I dont think its the cattle.

The strange case of Barry Beach

lynn oak harbor,ohio — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:42:29 GMT

sounds like a cover up somewhere in that little town maybe the sherrif was involved or the police man who broke into the evidence room. no evidence and yet he sits in prison what ever happened to innocent before proven guilty i see no proof of his guilt! where were all the parents to these girls to say we know are daughters are innocent? didnt see one parent of them say not my daughter why???????

The strange case of Barry Beach

Frank Maston Kalamazoo,Michigan — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:42:52 GMT

Was Barry Beach ever given access to a lawyer during the intense interrigation(good cop,bad cop) preformed in Lousiana?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kathleen Brown, Austin, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:42:52 GMT

I was wondering where Barry Beach is staying? I am 55yrs. old and I do not want to marry him or any of that silly stuff I would just like to write him sometimes. Could you help me? I thought your report was very good.I am retired and have never written anyone in prison. I feel he is innocent.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kim Duncan, Hot Springs, AR — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:43:32 GMT

Time to call in the Enquirer to find the real killer or killers. The men that prosecuted him are so sure that they can't be wrong. I find it really disturbing that a "law enforcement officer" can tamper with evidence and it is not being addressed. Time for lie detector tests for all.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Adam Hickey, Philadelphia, PA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:43:35 GMT

This story was amazing yet very sad. It was very clear to me that their are serious problems with this case. I cannot believe this man is still in prison with absolutely no physical evidence linking him to the crime scene... This is depressing.

The strange case of Barry Beach

W.S San Angelo Teexas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:43:39 GMT

I just watched the show on the killing at Poplar River and all I can say is YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING. I kept an open mind all through the show and at the end I still could not see how he could have been convicted on the confession alone . There was nothing that that would have made me give a guilty verdict. I think there is a cover up going on and some people got away with murder.I have one question why was the officer who busted in the door to the evidence room called and why was`nt his daughter tested ? Now if I missed that some where please let me know. But it sounds like someone was tampering with evidence. This case smells bad and something should be done and I think the people of Montana should not be the Judges anymore. Don`t get me wrong I have family who live in Montana but just like in any state there can be corruption. I lost a family member to murder so I can see both sides ,but I as a believer in God could not have set on a panal and heard all I did tonight and still kept that man in prison saying to heck with the evidence he confessed so he is guilty and then go home and sleep ok.I pray God brings out the truth soon.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jim Androl Riverview Fl. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:44:08 GMT

I watched the program on T.V. tonight and I think Mr. Beach got a bum rap to make other people look good

The strange case of Barry Beach

David Kalosky,Kaleva,Mich. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:44:18 GMT

I watched the program tonite and it seems to me that Montana has a serious problem with uneducated citizens not dueing justice for Barry from the first jury, prosecutor who these same people elected Governor to the parole board, when there is no evidence you can't convict anyone. I'm embarassed by the ignorance around the U.S.A. and would be fearful
of a trial of my PEERS.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tracy Woodson, Wimauma, Florida — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:44:54 GMT

With what I seen on you program, I would have set Mr. Beach free. I am not sure what the parole board heard that caused them to deny his release. I think this is very sad. I will be praying for him, and that the real killer (s) are brought to justice.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ollie Nixon, Crown Point, Indiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:45:05 GMT

I suggest that the Montana Prison Review Board did a remarkably bad error in denying at least some level of clemency for Beach instead of the complete denial of prison release for him. Apparently, Beach has proven he is a model prisoner and should be paroled; not necessarily proven not guilty but at least paroled. 25 years is long enough.

The Board’s ruling is telling every prisoner that is either innocent or guilty that there is no sense in being a good prisoner and trying to improve your direction in life because you won’t get out.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Toni, Wisconsin — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:45:30 GMT

After watching dateline this evening, I was greatly distressed at the end result. The evidence seemed irrefutable that Barry Beach could be guilty. How could the state not see the clear evidence? I hope the attorneys appeal this all the way to the Supreme Court.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Faye, Opelika, AL — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:47:06 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sharon Smith Alliston Ontario Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:48:36 GMT

I watched Dateline NBC this evening, and believe
that Barry Beach is not guilty and would like
to show my support. I was wondering if there is
any way that I would be able to write to him
just to show my support. You can email me.
Thanking you in advance. sharon

The strange case of Barry Beach

John Everett, ST. Louis, MO. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:49:45 GMT

After watching the show it was clear that the parole board was NOT going to go against their former prosecutor and two time governor. After all, they can't let little things like truth and justice get in the way of protecting the reputations of their own. GOD help us all.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joel LeMaster, Republic, MO — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:49:55 GMT

Is it possible to get Barry's address? I would like to write him a letter. This story was amazing and I am in shock that this man is still in prison. My heart goes out to him and can't believe that the justice system will not re-open this case. There is no doubt in my mind that Barry Beach did not commit this crime. Again, I would like to write Barry a letter and tell him that I am praying for him.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Nancy Christianson — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:50:02 GMT

After watching this show I can only conclude that the prison board decided to have a hearing so that they could put an end to the movement to set Barry free. It seemed to me that they disregarded, at the very least, a large amount of evidence that would suggest reasonable doubt as to Barry's guilt in this crime. Beyond that, after 25 years in jail he has paid the price for the crime-guilty or not. I can't believe that even one of those board members could see how easy it would be for their own child to end up like Barry. The board and the people involved in the original conviction of Barry can't bear to consider that a mistake could have been made. One can only hope that some day they will realize how fallible we all are. Free Barry!

The strange case of Barry Beach

D Burchill Miramichi NB Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:50:22 GMT

It seems the way the story was presented that the Governor might have been involved in silencing the
parole board...

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jane Q. Public, Lincoln, Nebraska — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:51:32 GMT

I'm not surprised that Mr. Beach has had no success with the system in Montana. I doubt that the prosecution, judges or the parole board would do anything to change the conviction even if they found that someone else had committed the murder. They would never back down. Convictions are like notches in a prosecutors gun. Justice be damned.

Here in Lincoln, Nebraska we have the same system of close-knit prosecutors and judges. Once caught in the justice system's web, you'll never get out. Even the defense attorneys seem unable to get fair rulings during court proceedings. If it happens here and in Montana, it probably happens all over the country.

I certainly have no faith in the "presumption of innocence until proven guilty" concept we profess to our youth in civics classes. The reality is, it doesn't work that way. Kangaroo courts are alive and well since the business of "get tough on crime" came to life. People who have the misfortune to experience this first hand or have a family member who is, are afraid to say or do anything because they risk being placed under the microscope of law enforcement and being harassed and intimidated. If you speak out, you may also subject the alleged offender to further wrath. It is no wonder 1 out of 100 people in this country is in prison and we have the highest incarceration rate in the world. Yet our government has the gall to shove our system down the throats of other countries while we build more prisons.

If there was another frontier to escape to, I would consider gathering up my family and leaving my home country as my ancestors did.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Rebecca Clift, Cheshire, CT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:51:38 GMT

This was a fascinating program tonight. I only hope thatthe justice system takes a much closer look at this case, and Barry Beach is indeed freed some day. He and his attitude are a testimony to God's redeeming grace.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jean Felts Germantown, MD — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:52:09 GMT

None of the defense witnesses had anything to gain by their testimony, yet all of their accounts were dismissd by the parole board. It is not human nature to put oneself in a position like that for no reason. Some people might-but to assume that 34 people would do such a thing willingly is ludicrous. The one person who had gained much from the conviction was the prosecutor. He did, indeed gain much. His political rise to power obviously occured beause of his role in prosecuting this case. His reputation would be sorely tarnished if this case was overturned.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Boo, Atlanta GA. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:52:17 GMT

Did any of the suspects or Barry himself ever take a lie detector test????????
It looks like the girls are responsible for the murder.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Matthew Simeone, boston, massachusetts — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:52:29 GMT

I recently watched the documentary about the Poplar murder and to say the least am totally convinced that Gary is innocent. As I am sure everyone who has heard about it is, with the exception of the corrupt judicial system of Montana.This is by far the saddest story I have heard of and was totally shocked and sickened by the verdict. This story is comparable to that of the Doris Jimenez murder because not only is justice not served for the victim, but also another innocent life has been ruined. As a truthful, honest person I can't comprehend how the people responsible for this atrocity ( sissy,her acquaintances, calhoun, prosecutors, the dirt bag governor,etc.) can live with themselves. I can only hope that someday they will have to answer to the almighty. I have heard many horrible stories in my life, but this one is by far the worst one. It actually hurts me and I am a free man.

The strange case of Barry Beach

charles frank — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:52:53 GMT

This case is a travesty. The people involved in the interrogation, prosecution and conviction of this man are sociopaths. Justice could never prevail for Barry Beach when the prosecuting attorney at his trial is also the govenor of that state.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Chris, Mechanicsville, VA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:56:03 GMT

I just watched this story and am thinking that there is collusion and corruption in high places, and that those involved in Barry's conviction are much more interested in protecting themselves than in knowing the truth about this murder. The prosecutor (and former Montana governor) did a lot of blinking as he spoke. Though I'm sure he knew better than to look away, the persistent blinking seemed to show his uneasiness. I am glad that the Centurion group is plowing ahead, and trust that the truth will come to light and that corruption in the Montana state government will be exposed... in the meantime, I wil pray for Barry to have the strength to continue bearing his troubles with grace, doing good where he is, until the time comes when justice prevails.

The strange case of Barry Beach

gregory lewis amor LaPorte IN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:56:24 GMT

I found the fact that the two things that could prove BARRY'S storie , the supposed "pubic" hair and the tape of the confession happening just as it took place that day,perhapse as BARRY said did.As it is the transcript would only have what they would want in it ,and the father of one of the girls belived to be involved steals the only physical evedents.And it seemed very evedent that the now govoner had for one an agenda to convicted andtwo some say over that board.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dax Freeman, Graham, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:56:40 GMT

I just finished watching Dateline and I am simply stunned. I think I am most angry at the fact that a man is in prison for commiting a crime in which there is no evidence to prove his guilt. Yes, he confessed, but as the show stated, confessions can be coerced. The simple fact that all those people came forward with personal stories, yet were ignored by the pardon board is just beyond me. I do not know all the facts in the case, but I feel that Mr. Beach is innocent. In a strange way, I hope I am wrong, becaue the thought of an innocent man being condemned to spend the rest of his life in prison is truly heartbreaking.

The strange case of Barry Beach

John Doe, Seattle, Wash. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:57:03 GMT

It amazes me how anyone can be conficted of any type of crime when all of the evidence doesn't even link them to the crime scene. No weapon, no motive, evidence used that was deemed wrong. What ever happened to one of the girl suspects father, who was a local police officer and tampered with the evidence. Entirely to many unanswered questions.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Laurel Danville,IL — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:58:49 GMT

I watched this story about Barry Beach tonight on Dateline, and i don't think he commited the crime. I have a friend that also confessed to doing something that he did not do, he told me that in the confession room, that they(the investigators) cranked up the heat, meaning, turning up the temp gage so that the room felt very HOT, and then proceeded to tell him that they knew that he had commited the crime at hand, even thuogh he knew he did not. They kept after him, and after him, until, just to get out of there he said he did it.
It seems to me that the police, and mind you, not all of them, want a confession because they don't have any other suspects and are needing someone to pin it on.
I personally think, that in the case of Barry Beach that they thought they had their guy, only based on suspicion(please excuse my spelling). I think that Kim probly picked up a hitch hiker or maybe that those girls that they mentioned are involved somehow, hopefully for Barry, his lawyers will uncover the truth soon. I really truly believe that he is inacent. Hopefully for him, and his mother that someday real soon he will be set free.
Thank you for letting me comment on this.
Laurel
From IL

The strange case of Barry Beach

OJ McBeth, Sulphur, Ok — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:59:01 GMT

After watching the outstanding documentary by Dateline's Kieth Morrison, pertaining to Barry Beach. I find it appalling that the final outcome of the Pardon and Parole Board's decision was based on political consequences, rather than the facts and testimony presented.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Chris, NH — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 03:59:27 GMT

I watched your show, and truly believe that Barry Beach is innocent !! I thought that there would be a happy ending, that Barry would be released....Seems like there was alot of corruption in that case.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Les. String — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:00:01 GMT

The program of Barry Beach was heart wrenching. My heart is heavy after watching it, I actually believed he would go free. His accusor and other's who had the opportunity to allow this man a chance at a life are sick people. Some just ignorant and cannot see anything except their own hope for power. I call folks like this "wannabe's" they are extremely insecure. They want to be seen and known as successful and powerful. They actually think it makes them look important and smart. There was no evidence to link him to the crime, except a story made up by a scared little rabbit to get away from them. Even his own statement was inaccurate, as he tried as a young 20 year old to create some sense of what they were doing to him at the interrogation. He made a horrible choice that night in that room with men who have no consciences and they used it for their own gain in society.

I wonder who is covering the ass of the fellow/officer who broke into the room at the police station. Why wasn't that exposed and investigated more, whose father was he. That spoke volumes, but then no one wants to listen!

Good luck to the team of men who are not willing to throw this man away. I am ashamed of our society and the eagerness to convict an innocent person. Barry is a better person than I would be under his circumstances, I don't think I could or would want to live with what he has to endure. I am so sorry for him and his mother. I truly hope and pray that someone finds a way to get this man his life back. I am not a person who wishes bad things unto others but I am hoping that all involved in this nasty, dirty little secret to condemn Mr. Beach pay for their sin!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lisa Taylor, Winnipeg, Manitoba Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:01:10 GMT

I hope you stay on this story. I believe Beach is innocent.Does the fact that he is native as were many of the witnesses for him have any bearing?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Chris Balentine — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:03:48 GMT

It was very upsetting to watch, clearly he was not guilty. How could the jury confict him with no evidence at the scene of the crime? Shame on the sheriff the procecutor,etc.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carla Ohse, Custer, MI — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:03:49 GMT

I cannot go to sleep tonight because I am so outraged by the injustice in Montana against this obvious innocent man. What can I do to help him?? This story sounds like it happened in another country not America. I have never written to anyone before like this but I have never been so upset before about anything I have seen on TV. Thank you, Keith, and the other men who stood up for Beach. I think the governor is behind this denial for Beach's parole.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carla Ohse, Custer, MI — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:05:15 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jefferson, Boise., ID — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:05:47 GMT

What a fantastic story. But. C'mon. Seriously.
How could a guy from Libby Montana put an innocent man behind bars like that? SHAME ON YOU Mark Racicot.

Maude Greywolf [sp?] (the daughter of the Sheriff's Deputy who desecrated the evidence room) did it...or she was one of the group of girls who did.

This is what journalism is all about: exposing an appalling and outrageous miscarriage of justice.

What a shame.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Judy Wall, Fort Wayne, IN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:06:36 GMT

I would like more information. Consider a additional porgram telling us more about the police officer that broke in and took the sweater (his daughter wss one of the original suspects?), etc. For the Dateline program I believe Barry Beach to be innocent and pray in the end he will be found to be and be released.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Terrence Burke,West Monroe,La. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:06:50 GMT

I beleive the State of Montana is affraid of admitting to their mistakes.If no hard evidence is present to keep Barry Beach behind bars,then he should be set free by facts,not be held in prison by alligations.And as far as Barry admitting to something he did not comment,pressures of admittance of guilt is a common practice of law enforcement.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Diane Brode, Silver Spring, Maryland — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:07:19 GMT

My husband and I just witnessed 2 hours of disbelief. We were both shocked at the outcome of this entire Dateline story on Barry Beach. We're disgusted with the Montana Justice System. How can the life of this man rest in decision of people who clearly have not listened to the PEOPLE of the USA. It is a disgrace that this man has no physical ties to the crime scene but yet the people have judged him in being guilty b/c of a forced confession. This government needs to give this man a second chance at life.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Francesca Dunaway — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:07:49 GMT

I wanted to know is there any way to contact Barry beach. I would like to be supoportive im in is figt for justice. It is a long fight. I have a soon to be paroled husband coming out of the kentucky justice system for a crime he did not commit. Upon his release of parole in Jan '09, we will pursuee is case to prove his innocence further. I do know how difficult it is to be without someone believing in you and giving you hope and encouragement.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Charmaine Kizy, Chicago, IL — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:09:26 GMT

A certain discernment came to me while watching this special (Barry Beach). When watching and now reading about this murder I never got a sense of the sister (Pam Nees) ever being investigated. Where her palms prints ever taken? Was she ever investigated? It seems all to incomplete. It just seems more conceivable that a group of girls could have done this which may explain the number of blows to the head. Would a man need as many strikes to have the same outcome? I would never underestimate the convincing power of a jealous 14 year old. Just my feelings.

The strange case of Barry Beach

DJ — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:09:40 GMT

I wish i could say this Dateline episode shocked me.
What i did find surprising is the complete and total lack of ANY credible evidence linking Mr. Beach to this crime.
I hope that he can find justice on the Federal level. Because the state agencies always sem to protect there own...

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jessyca Bercot Geneva, Indiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:10:07 GMT

I just seen this show and I am shocked at how the higher ups treat him. I can't believe that out of all the people that say Sissy and Mod were there that they just brushed it off. I DO believe that Barry Beach is NOT guilty. How can ALL those people after 24 or so years all of sudden come together at the conclusion of them ALL saying stuff about those two woman. While on taping Sissy was lying. YOu can tell it in her eyes. She is to finiky, way too defensive. I believe in Barry Beach and I will pray for him.

The strange case of Barry Beach

bob papa — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:10:19 GMT

why didn't they do DNA of the hand print of blood on the door of the truck?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dayna, Radford, VA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:10:19 GMT

After hearing all of the evidence that points to the group of girls committing this crime I was appalled at the outcome of the parole board in this case. I hope that the Centurion Ministries doesn't give up on it until that poor man is freed. It appears that there are some people in high places with a lot of power getting away with taking this man's freedom to hide their connection.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Brenda Sorensen, Rapid City, SD — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:11:00 GMT

Did they fingerprint Maud Greyhawk to see if she matched? They avoid some of the simplest things that would help answer the questions---did all the girls get fingerprinted? If not, why not? They only addressed two of them. How does the Prosecutor explain away the fingerprints/footprints/beer cans and the multitude of evidence not linked to Beach? I hate not having the whole story.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jessyca Bercot Geneva, Indiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:11:04 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Amanda Armstrong Superior Montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:12:56 GMT

I think He Is INNOCENT!!!!!! I cant believe the Parole Board made the decision they did! Watching the show I was certain Beach was going to be released! In my heart and in my gut through the whole story I had this STRONG feeling he was INNOCENT and "Set up" for the crime! Knowing what I do know and also hearing the side of the state of Mt on this case if I would have been a juror for this case I would have with out a doubt said he was INNOCENT and would have been able to sleep very well at night with my decision!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mike, North Salt Lake, Utah — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:13:14 GMT

One thing is for sure. Those involved in the murder of this girl will pay for their actions, either in this life, or in the next. And those responsible for framing Beach, will also pay for their actions, one way or another.
It also seems to me that Montana is in the middle of a major cover up, and so far they have been successful. (At the expense of an innocent man)

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jane Doe,,, Rock Island, Illinois — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:14:43 GMT

I watched this program tonignt and still cannot understand why this man is still in prison. run that blood or prints today and you might find the real killer or killers, I don't believe this man did this. He had countless people of his behalf deny that he could do this. Today's society is innocent till proven guilty. Just because they had a confession dosen't mean he is guilty, where is all the evidence, he was 17, was a lawyer present during his arrest or is it that he was never offered one. BIG NO NO!!!
Shame on you!!! I also think it was probably a bunch or girls. Why would a business owner tell you she had been with a bunch girls and problems with them all night have to gain with her statement. Where is the justice. He has countless people on his behalf standing up for him including the dead girls sister what do they stand to gain. Give this man a shot at freedom and do the right thing and let him go . I and others that watched the program could not beleive it when they prison board said No ARE YOU KIDDING ME!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lisa Scalzitti — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:14:47 GMT

THE BARRY BEACH CASE.................................

I watched Dateline on Friday April 4, 2008. It featured the story of Barry Beach and how Centurion Ministries, Inc. are trying to help free him. As I was watching the show with my husband, I had a weird visual when they showed the pictures of the crime scenes. Whenever Dateline would show the thumb and palm print (as everyone was calling it) in the truck, i was seeing something else. To me it looks like a footprint! Has anyone given theory to the print being an actual left foot, and not a palm and thumb at all? I brought this to the attention of my husband, and he agreed with me. The print looks like a left foot with toes pointing upwards, but turned slightly to the right! As if the foot was being braced against the passenger's side

I hope this message finds its way to Keith Morrison! I tried looking up a website for Centurion Ministries and they don't have an email address or phone number to contact them

The strange case of Barry Beach

James Mickey Gamble, Jackson Hole, Wyoming — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:15:56 GMT

Very interesting to watch the peope who were so sincere and supportive, including the State Senator who I know very well. I am offended by the attitude of the Parole Board, why do we keep people in prison who have indicate they do not belong there? Is this the reason we lock up in jail or prison one person in every person in America? We take the word of the parole board and the Sheriff who knows? How does he know? I admire Governor Marc as much as anyone I know, but I also know Barry, and I believe him, always have!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kim, Houston, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:18:31 GMT

Good Report! Hopefully Justice will come for Mr. Beach.

Maybe someone can actually figure out whose bloody prints are all over that truck! That would be novel. Some people need to be subpoenaed.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Maxie Polizzi Vanceboro, N.C. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:19:47 GMT

I'm very curious as to why no mention of Sissy or anyone for that matter to have been ordered to take a polygraph,would that not be helpfull to Barry in proving his case.? My heart goes out to him,I understand his plight & how those incredable christians feel,God bless you,don't give up on him,God sent me into life, a deformed orphan & the only blessing he gave was a heart with eyes that can see into hearts of others & I can see Mr.Beach is an innocent man.I'm 62 now & spending my remainder typing my life with the only finger I have, it's my theraputic way of getting vindication in hopes of a book someday.There are despicable cops, D.A.'s & judges etc. that destroy lives of magnanamous people & I have no doubt that if I hadn't moved miles into another county, I too would be sitting in prison. There are so many complicet in the tactics used, I couldn't win but I KNOW you will, a heart blessed with eyes don't lie.Again,I'd like to know if a polygraph was administered & how can I learn when & what the outcome of the Supreme Court decision will be. Thank You

The strange case of Barry Beach

Erica, Minneapolis, Minnesota — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:21:11 GMT

After watching this episode tonight, I feel Montana (and the police involved) is false in there information and can't except the fact that they are WRONG! The two crack heads had part in it (why couldn't you find the other two women? Or two guys involved) They are probably hidding in Mexico and having a hard time dealing with life since they had part in a murder. I know if i was getting question, I would probably admitt to it too! Even Kims sister does not think it is Barry. When Barry Beach gets out I hope he sues the state for everything they have. He does NOT deserve to be in jail and I support him.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bonnie Davies, Anaconda, MT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:23:02 GMT

I watched the story about Barry Beach & feel that he has been imprisoned wrongfully. I will pary for his pardon to be soon.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Helen Manning Baltimore, MD — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:23:40 GMT

The more I watched this show, the more outraged I have become. I planned on changing channels at 10PM but found myself unable to do that. I was sure, after all the overwhelming evidence that he would be set free or at least allowed a new trial. I was horrified when those arrogant fools refused do this!

This story just wreaks of cover-up!!
I think more research needs to be done on the missing evidence and what could possibly be gained by it's disappearance? Or more precisely, who does it benefit? And what about the person who kicked in the evidence locker door? Where do they fit into this picture. Or better yet, why wasn't the town more anxious to find out who did it? Shouldn't they have been living in fear for their own safety with an unknown killer on the loose?

What about all the footprints at the scene? Doesn't this suggest more than one perpetrator?

Who elected those people who declared themselves judge and jury? Are they up for re-election possibly?

Those people in that town should be outraged! This could be anyone of them or a member of their own family with all the shoddy police work, missing evidence, failure to supply all known witnesses to the defendant's team.

Another thought was his original attorney and why weren't these questions brought out at trial? Does he/she have any ties to Poplar Ridge?

I've got to close for now, I'm just getting too upset and I have high blood pressure!

PS: 62 yr old female

The strange case of Barry Beach

Steve, Dallas, Texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:23:44 GMT

It's unbelievable that a jury could conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that this man comitted this crime. The legal system at the state level has clearly lost its check and balances when a man's life is taken from him when the prosecution team has not addressed so many unanswered questions associated with this crime. Moreoever, the political gains at stake then and now for the persons on the prosecution team are absurd.

The strange case of Barry Beach

ashley decker hardin, montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:24:20 GMT

i am a family member to maude grayhawk. she is my aunt by marriage. my uncle dana kirn knew facts and accounants of her that night kim died. my uncle was getting ready to tell the FBI in billing about maude. but two nights before he was to be here tracy and maude lured my unlce back her house and savagly stabbed him to death. when you aired this just one day before his five year anniversary of his death it hit my mom (dana's sister) hard. we all heard all the stories but only maude, sissy, and joan will be able to tell the truth. one day i hope to see barry beach free and those girls pay for what they have done. thank you.

The strange case of Barry Beach

A, Miles, SJ, UT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:25:29 GMT

This appears to be a tragedy. After watching the show I can't understand why he continues to be behind bars. The board of pardons statements were waek at best and didn't address the facts presented to them. I hope he gets another review and SOON!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mark Roberts Piedmont, Mo. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:26:25 GMT

I watched the Barry Beach Story tonight,as all of us have seen most prosecutors will do anything to jump start their careers,and this one is plain as class Barry Beach was not set up once but two times once by then Prosecutor and and by now Govenor all the eveidence that would have cleared this man was not used and destroyed something has to be done about these lawyers most of which propell themselves in to politics thst are alredy serve thier apprenticeship as crooks when they make it there makes no difference if someones life is destroyed because this is a lawyers world, no wage concessions, no conceince,no penalty for KNOWINGLY prosecuting innocent people THIS MAN IS INNOCENT..and the crooked prosecutor/ Govenor should haft to take Barry Beach,s place in prison. there Is rumblings in the background that something must be done about this AXE and HATCHET Justice thanks hope you can read this.. I am not a lawyer so i don,t have a smart secretary to write mine..I hope you stick with this case this is worse than the rash of Sex cases by govenors.thanks

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lorraine Fournier — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:26:58 GMT

No one mentioned whether or not the policeman who broke into the area where the evidence was held and then was missing was ever interviewed etc. Wasn't his daughter on the list of girls to be questioned? I couldn't believe the ending of this story, something is wrong.

The strange case of Barry Beach

J. Turnage, Westminster, CO — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:28:30 GMT

I view body language as teller of tales. In my opinion the demeanor of the Parole Board members was defensive and it appeared early that they had already made up their minds to deny clemency. You might review their body language and see what you think. It is difficult for people of higher powers to admit wrong or making a mistake.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Denise miles city Montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:30:14 GMT

It looks to me like the great governor of Montana screwed up, so the board of pardons doesn't want him to look bad! Only conclusion I can come to. By the way what ever came of the woman that was involved- Maude, that didn't show up to testify? I think this case should be investigated by someone who doesn't really care what that the ex- governor of our state messed up big time. also what about his testimony about the hair? I'd like to see more about this case and what people on the outside can do to help.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cindy Sachtleben, St. Louis, MO. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:30:50 GMT

This story is a travesty of justice! Is the Board of Probation & Parole appointed to their positions? If so, who makes the appointments? Common sense tells you that the former prosecutor, who is now (or was) govenor of the state has enormous influence over who receives appointments. When I heard that the now Govenor was the former prosecutor in this case, I knew Barry had absolutely no chance of parole.(This is called pride & politics!) No matter how many lie dector tests Barry might take he couldn't win! Anyone with sense knows that the Govenor would absolutely stand behind any case he tried and anyone on the Board of Probation and Parole who bunked his view would loose their job. They knew it also...why else would they refuse to discuss the case. You only refuse when you can't (or are afraid) to face the truth. This is also true for anyone else in the state system who tries to speak up or "prove" that the former prosecutor (now ...Govenor) was wrong! I certainly hope the Centurions Ministeries take this to the Supreme Court because that is the only hope they have for an impartial review. And by the way, dosen't anyone care that one of the alleged perpetrators father was a police officer in the town who allegedly took evidence in a murder case from the evidence locker?? Funny how the police department won't allow anyone to search the locker for the maybe "lost" evidence. They all know what happened to it! Dosen't anyone else care that the other alleged perpetrators (other kids supposedly at the scene) to the crime never had their fingerprints taken to compare to the scene? (oh...I keep forgetting..this is a small town...everyone knows everyone...even the Govenor!). I would bet the police officer (who took broke into the evidence locker and took the sweater evidence)never had his daughter's finger prints analyzed! OH....I forgot, the Govenor (I mean prosecutor) in this case worked in the same small town....he knew all these people.... Funny how the system really works. Until you are a part of the legal system, you won't learn that the real truth dosen't always prevail.....sometimes the real reason justice isn't achieved is plain and simply due to politics....not the real facts!

The strange case of Barry Beach

brigette great falls, montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:37:07 GMT

I cant believe all that "non"-evidence was ignored...that is the only part that has me doubting this man was the killer... there SHOULD be footprints..fingerprints...DNA.... SOMETHING ...some obvious for sure evidence. I think at the very least,...based on this person's prinson history (helping the female guard...calming riots) a chance at parole would be reasonable.. also... the story states there were no fingerprints of the four or five people in that truck .... who ever determined who was in the truck? it may not have been Sissy and her friends... but COULD have been other people?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Gail Bearden, Aztec, NM — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:39:02 GMT

I am a 57 year old woman who, I believe, has very good discernment. I do not believe Barry killed Kim Nees for one moment. My heart goes out to her family and to Barry's mother,Bobbi. Prosecutors will always defend their "honor" at the cost to innocent people. Some day the true judge will set them straight. How I wish there was something I could do to help this man and his family, but all of our hands are tied because of the egos of the powers that be.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Michael S Southeastern Montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:39:17 GMT

The Montana Judicial System is suspect. Most of the county Sheriff's back in the that eara were hard pressed to perform there duties, without any real forensic backround or experince.
I have been following this story in the Billings Gazzette and on our local news. I feel that there was a lack of physical evedence. Surely not enough to convict Mr. Beach. There was an overwhelming need to pin this murder on someone. there was not much discussion about the break in at the Police Department. But if the you concider the person murdered and the life style of Barry Beach at the time it fits. the rebel vs. the valictorian. Small town mentality in ruraul MT is still the same. MT Parole Board will not muddy the name of Former State Attorney, former Governor, or the State crime lab's short commings. I believe in capital punishment when it applies, I don't see it here.
Hang in there Mr. Beach "The Truth will set you Free".

The strange case of Barry Beach

robert hodge/ 9145 w co rd 1125 s crothersville in 47229 — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:41:33 GMT

sounds kinda like the same case of kattie colman frome crothersville indiana a chuckie hickman confessed to murdering her but evadence says he didnt then dna proved another guy tony stalkelman did it thay got dna off a sigeret butt so they can do dna and settel this case if not thay are cuvering things up sounds like he is not guilty do reacearch kattie colman crotharsville in

The strange case of Barry Beach

Theresa Lemley, Lexington KY — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:49:57 GMT

Keith Morrison...What do you believe??? You sat and talked to this man face to face... did he or didn't he do it. You have to have a gut feeling.

Do you believe it was Maude Greyhawk??? If Barry Beach is innocent ... she is guilty... she needs to confess. Maybe that retired officer can interrogate her like he did Barry??? what do you think??

The strange case of Barry Beach

Chris P, Effingham, IL — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:50:12 GMT

It is unbelievable that this case wasn't dismissed solely on the account that his attorney was not present during questioning. With all the forensic capabilities that we have achieved, it is absolutely ridiculous that anyone be convicted without forensic evidence proving their guilt. The Prosecutors did not prove anything.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sue Maney, Belgrade, Montana 59714 — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:52:22 GMT

I have been following the Barry Beach case for a long time now and truly believe he is innocent. I am an amature investigator and have been working on a similar case for a friend for 6 years. I watched the program on TV tonight and I keep thinking the same thought. Where is the motive for Barry to kill Kim Nees? Earlier in the case, a mention of a girl being jealous of Kim with her boyfriend. But I see no follow -up. Who was boy? Which girl? etc? I would be digging a little deeper for the motive....I would like info on writing to Barry and/or his lawyers (to help where I can) Thank you...Sue

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jane Doe, Billings, Montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:57:20 GMT

Everyone in Poplar knows Maude and Sissy did it, why do you think Sissy does drugs so much? As for Maude, why do you think she never showed up to Barry's clemency hearing? I'm from Poplar and my family lived on the hill over looking the murder scene. My great-grandmother lived right next door to the Sparvier's. She also heard partying that night, and she saw a vehicle down there. My great-grandmother died in 1993, so she can't testify. But she did hear alot of people partying down there that night, which wasn't unusual because it was a favorite party spot for the younger generation. But Poplar is a small town, and if Barry is the murderer beyond a doubt, than why are people still talking about Maude and Sissy? Only people that are from Poplar would know what I'm talking about. You have to be a long time resident there to know what happens around there and what is said by who. It makes all the difference. Marc Racicot can say whatever he wants, he can say he thinks Barry is guilty no matter what in his mind, but for people living in Poplar, it's a VERY different story. This NEEDS to be investigated more, as a former resident of Poplar, I highly recommend that this be solved. I would like to go back and live there one day, but for now, I don't feel my children are safe living in a town where murderers wander freely. As for Sissy, she looked like she was on crystal meth when they interviewed her on Dateline, she was very shaky. She's hiding something, and she knows it. I just don't know how they can live with themselves knowing what they did to Kim.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tara,Buffalo,NY — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:57:47 GMT

This is the first time that I have herd about this case and after watching the way that it was handled I do believe that at minimum this man should be given a new trial. We have a real problem with the judicial system in America and if we do not act on it thousands of innocent people will continue to be put in prison for crimes that they did not commit.

The strange case of Barry Beach

LDV, Hurst, TX — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:58:00 GMT

My heart breaks for Mr. Beach. It doesn't sound like much has been made about evidence disappearing (including a tape that could prove Mr. Beach was coerced). Or the cop breaking into the evidence room & taking evidence (the father of one of the girls who told someone she kicked the victim??). Also, there's no evidence placing Mr. Beach at the scene & he gets life?

There's nothing worse than people in the legal system using their power to coerce people into confessing & others using theirs to protect those who are abusing their power.

We hope he finally gets his freedom.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Terry Knudson, Kalispell, Mt — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 04:59:12 GMT

As a former resident of Poplar who was born and raised there and spent most of my life there, I have been following, with great interest, the case of Barry Beach.

I remember when Kim Nees was killed. Such a beautiful and smart girl, whose whole life was ahead of her. It was such a tragedy for the family.

For the last few years there has been a lot about the case in the newspapers & TV. I have found it very interesting because as far as I new Barry was the killer and was convicted. I never heard much about this case through the years. Now I really wonder if he was the killer or not.

I don't doubt for a minute that Sissy Atkinson and Maude Grayhawk were involved. Ms Atkinson is probably one of the most treacherous people around and how she has avoided prison time herself, is beyond me. Maude Grayhawk was also involved (indirectly) in the death of her husband, Dana Kirn, about l0 years ago. Also, when they talk about the breaking and entering and destroying of evidence the night after Kim was killed, it was her dad Steve Grayhawk that destroyed this evidence. Why did he do this? It's too bad that they didn't have DNA evidence then.

So what I think is that maybe it is time to set Barry Beach free. The truth will probably never be known for sure who really killed Kim Nees on that June night in l979.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cali Cooper, El Dorado Hills, Ca — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:01:22 GMT

Thank you for your thought provoking piece. There is no doubt in my mind that this man is not guilty. More corruption.....when does it end?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kimberly Payne- Cullman, Alabama — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:03:07 GMT

My husband and I watched as you told of this horrible, horrible travesty of justice. I was physically sickened by such obvious wrong doing on the part of, not only the local law enforcement, but the prosecuter as well. I truly hope that each of them saw this story last night......... If for no other reason, to see how incredibly ridiculous & quite frankly stupid, they each sounded as they each stuck by the previous ruling. Of course they will stick to that story, they have to cover themselves! Shame on the prosecuter & shame on both of the local law enforcement agencies & shame on the FBI!!!!!! It is corrupt worms like these that make it hard to trust the gentlemen & women who REALLY love their jobs and want to do the right thing, i.e. catch the REAL criminals!!! May God have mercy on their souls.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ro Chavez — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:06:12 GMT

Dear Dateline,
Very interesting case...my thought is that we have come so far in our technology and DNA...I can't believe nothing at Barry's hearing was not pushed to get more samples on the blood...Something in the panels decision was to strange...Could they know someone close to the REAL killer...? Where is the girl that had the father in the police force...? Was he protecting her from prison...? I believe this young man had zero to do with it and I also, know that he was co-erced in confessing...It happens alot here in my town...So, how does one as myself help support this man in prison so they can go forth and get him OUT...It is really sad to see our judicial system not fair to the innocent...

The strange case of Barry Beach

vicki sparrow, mims, florida — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:07:39 GMT

Cases similar to this occur throughout our country. Central Florida has its own version in the case of Tommy Ziegler. Gross evidence overlooked or suppressed by up and coming state attorneys who are now big names in state government fuel this type of ongoing travesty. The Montana Parole Board should be ashamed. I wish Mr. Beach well.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Candy,BrokenArrow,Okla. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:08:39 GMT

I can't beleive this. He should be out they didn't even listen to the case. You could tell the girls were lying.He should be set free.How sad!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lauren tucson az — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:08:42 GMT

There is no way this guy is guilty, small town mentality. Shame on them

The strange case of Barry Beach

Vogel,Michelle Phoenix Az — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:10:08 GMT

This is the most discusting injustice there is no physical proof of Barry Beach murdered this young women. It seems to me that someone high up or too lazy is trying to cover up who really murdered this woman and distroying the life of an innocent man. This makes me wonder how evil people can have such good karma and good people like myself and Mr. Beach get such bad things happen to them what is the real meaning in life.

The strange case of Barry Beach

C O Arizona — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:11:24 GMT

What I don't understand is why Maude Grayhawk is being so evasive. Why can't they bring her in and check her finger prints?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jenny Busdon — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:12:58 GMT

After just watching Dateline this evening I cannot believe that BArry Beach was not given a full pardon. O.K. so he did confess - but I think it was simply because he really thought he would be put into the electric chair for killing those other women in Louisiana - that was found later he had nothing to do with. It is amazing what intense interrogation can do to the mind. Let's face it - no DNA, no definite proof at all - on this alone surely the Parole Board would have doubts. I am blown away that the poor guy is back in jail. Somthing is dreadfully wrong here. I have never commented on a Dateline case before, but this one is very troubling and I hope that the Governor and the Prosecution will begin to feel some guilt about being so darn adamant of HIS guilt when SO MANY doubts definitely exist. Thank you Dateline for bringing this to viewers attention - hopefully it may help Barry get the freedom he deserves if enough people get behind this case. It is shameful!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cassandra Seattle.Wa — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:15:41 GMT

I'm appauld at the fact that the police and the prosecution escape freely from any charges of wrongfully convicting this man and many others just to further their careers. When is it going to stop! If they were held accountable it would not happen. I hope he is able to sue the state and get millions because he deserves it.

The strange case of Barry Beach

G. Minus , Tucson, Arizona — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:16:55 GMT

I think he is innocent, How can These people of authority be so stupied? its all politics, We Need to get our country Back, Set Barry Free!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joanne Barselou — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:18:38 GMT

Nobody will match OR UNmatch their fingerprints - "The police have tried all resources" (Except the girls) to solve this crime???

Yet they will convict and send a man with minimum evidence for 25 plus years???

SAD men - grow up - you are not that cute to fool us

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dick Carter, Nyssa, OR. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:21:31 GMT

I watched your program tonight on "The Killing at Poplar River".

It saddens me when I see the egos of men stand in the way of justice. When men become to caught up in their level of incompetence to do the right thing.

I understand where the authorities involved would be embarassed if the truth came out and Barry Beach was proven innocent. Barry made a mistake, he confessed, but it is a known fact that interigators (skilled) can get a confession out of almost anyone using the proper techniques.

What I find terribly depressing about this story, is that there is no follow up on behalf of the local authorities concerning this new evidence. And that they are totally unwilling to take a fresh look at the evidence they have. To follow up more on the bloody palm print and the unaccounted for fingerprints. We can understand their Policing Department is small, but assistance is available, if they would only ask. It is time to break away from the "good ole buddy" system, time to quit basking in knowledge that "we solved this thing", and truely clear their conscience once and for all by reopening this case to see if they actually do have the right person behind bars.

The strange case of Barry Beach

ojohnson, sun city az — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:21:37 GMT

watched tv presentation lived there about thirty years. Don't like the appearent cover up of witch hunt of prosicutation.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jack Schaible, Idaho Falls, ID — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:22:31 GMT

What about officer Grayhawk breaking into the evidence room and "contaminating" evidence? Why wasn't anything more said about that? Surely that incident was investigated, especially given the fact that his daughter was an original suspect. And what ever happened with Maude Grayhawk? Please follow up with any new developments on this story.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carolyn Daily, Coffeyville, KS — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:23:02 GMT

I was appalled that the group hearing the case of Barry Beach could not see the truth when, in essence, it was pinned to their very noses. It appears that they were swayed more by the feeling of obligation to protect a former Governor’s reputation than they were by the mountains of evidence before them. The arrogance displayed by the officers from the initial investigation seemed a sad play, which from this viewer’s perspective, made them look guilty as sin for not properly investigating the matter in the first place. And Then, all that forensic evidence disappeared?? Oh, PALEEESE! And they said the witnesses testifying for Barry couldn't be considered credible. Well, just how credible is the team that miraculously made all that evidence go away and never allowed anyone to try and find it. I can personally believe the lady who put her 30 year marriage on the line for the sake of the truth. However, how could anyone truly be expected to believe the men who “lost” all
The evidence?
Is it any wonder that people are so reluctant to trust in our judicial system? When protecting former Governors takes priority over cold hard facts of evidence. And who, I ask, is ever going to feel safe when the investigating/arresting officers, who are sworn to seek and expose the truth, choose instead to cover up the crimes of their own children?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sonja. Tampa Florida — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:25:05 GMT

Can Dateline look into other cases that these detectives have done to see if there are any similarities in them? More false confessions? I hope that Dateline will look more in detail to this and keep following this. Something jsut isn't right. I really hope to see more uncovered in this... Better hurry the old detectives look like they are aging quickly.Dateline producers.. Don't end this story!!! Keep us updaetd of the events.

The strange case of Barry Beach

michele globe ,arizona — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:27:17 GMT

i think that he is innocence and he needs to fight for what he believe. plus if he was 20 years of age at the time the law can make you tell them what they want not what the real truth is . the man is innocence and he should be able to go home to his family.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joanne Barselou — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:28:24 GMT

CAN NOT BELIEVE THIS HAS HAPPENED HERE - OBVIOUSLY THE GOOD OLE BOYS OF POLITICS HAVE NO CLUE ABOUT REAL LIFE - JUST "HOW CAN "i" GET MORE VOTES, CLOUT, MONEY, BENEFITS, FREE TRIPS, ETC.....

DO NOT CARE ABOUT JUSTICE - 'JUST ME'

The strange case of Barry Beach

J C Hermanson — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:31:22 GMT

After watching your program tonight,,,,I,,,,CAN NOT,,,understand "HOW" the patrole board ruled like they did! ""I"" strongly feel that this man, Barry Beach, ""did not kill her"" and should be free. As this case goes on,,,,,,,Barry is losing MORE days of his life in a place that he SHOULD NOT BE! I am hoping that they keep fighting for his release,,,AND,,,get it for him! After watching, I think that it "WAS",,,THE GIRLS that killed her!!!!!!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Phyllis Jimenez Pearce, Arizona — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:40:31 GMT

In the case of Barry Beach, there were to many things that did not add up. It seems his original attorney didn't defend him at all. Tonight in front of the parole board, the centurion ministries and other people that spoke made it abundantly clear that this man did not commit this crime. I believe that law enforcement forced a false confession and that the parole board was put under pressure or they were not listing or seeing any of the evidence in front of them for them to make the decision they did. Why is it they never questioned the officer who stole the evidence? Why won't they let anyone find out who the bloody palm print belong to. This town knows who killed that girl but they are covering it up. Why is the justice (and I say that with lots of reservations) letting them do it. They are blocking anyone from finding out who really killed her. Has justice been served in this case, absolutely NOT>. The ones who should be investigated are the officers involved and the parole board for misconduct.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mrs. Mattox — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:48:34 GMT

I believe that Barry Beach is innocent. I also believe that the pardon board did not vote to free him because of the town or state politics. By that I mean I think they are all in denial and just want to cover their own actions, and are not willing to do what is right and free, Barry. It is a sin and a travesty. Maybe the Centurion Ministries should appeal to the Supreme Court, or Pardon from the President. Just a thought.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jennifer Rankins, Painesville, Ohio — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:54:15 GMT

I watched this show Friday night, and I just wonder if anybody ever thought about the finger prints belonging to that police officer (the father of the one girl) that broke in and destroyed evidence. Seems to me he was helping cover up the crime to save his own daughter from being a suspect. I would be anything the print belong to her or her or her father. I was very surprised he was not considered especially since he have motive to cover up the crime to save his own daughter. Whatever happened to that girl anyway?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Rochelle, HB, Calif — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 05:57:17 GMT

It breaks my heart to know innocent people are in prison serving time, life for something someone else did.
I understand how someone of such a young age could confess out of being scared by someone of authority.
There are alot of us out here pulling not only for Barry but of the hundreds of others who are innocent.
Shame on our system.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tamara, Perrault Falls, Ontario, Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:05:56 GMT

I have just finished watching Dateline this evening watching Keith Morrison's story....I think it is a case for the American Grand Jury....this man confessed after being coerced as a 20 year old in Louisiana.....20 years old! Look at the officer who at the time brought on the confession.....likely scared the s%#t out of the young lad......Brutal! nice to see how money is spent....nice to see who is in charge of the law in Montana.....perhaps their conscience is fine, wonder how they've slept in the past 24 years, knowing what they've done to this man???????

The strange case of Barry Beach

Valerie Egan, Victoria, British Columbia — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:08:25 GMT

I can't believe the parole board would not grant him a new trial or even parole with all the evidence put before them. A 17 year old giving a confession smacks of police harrassment--I can only imagine the questioning that went for hours upon hours to finally get the confession which they had prepped him for all along. The DA is a pompous arrogant man who probably benefitted by getting a quick conviction of this kid at the time.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Michael, Powder Springs, GA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:10:05 GMT

One thing I wish the former prosecuter would have been asked is about lying about the pubic hair being Beach's.

Plus, How can the Parole Board say that his testimony is hard evidence, when the evidence they have doesn't even point to Barry?

How can the Parole Board say his testimony wasn't forced, seeing how the same police department had 2 other confessions overturned...

The strange case of Barry Beach

Linda Greene, San Francisco, CA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:12:29 GMT

I just watched the Keith Morrison report on Barry Beach.
I wish the parole board could, in some way, be examined and questioned as to their competance to arrive at the guilty verdict.
They should be put on trial.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Natalie, Oregon City, Oregon — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:13:47 GMT

I can not believe the outcome of this case. It drives me insane that yet there was no PHYSICAL evidence to support that Barry did infact kill this girl the state of Montana believe they have the power to take his life away. It's scary to realize that the people who have the most power in some states are ignorant. There is no justice in America and never will it be. I pray for Barry and my heart goes out to his family, but more than this I pray for the senetors, cops, judges, and the parol board who helped keep Barry in jail because one day they will have to stand before the face of God and account for the awfal things that they have done to this man.

The strange case of Barry Beach

John, Los Angeles — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:16:14 GMT

Unbelievable story.....if anything it shows the amazing corruption that has engulfed the Montana State Law enforcement system. I wonder how much pressure the parole board in Montana received to deny the parole request. At the very least, the law enforcement officers involved should have been able to admit that they would look into things again based on the new witness testimony. I would say that a boycott of the State of Montana is in order. I certainly wont be spening my money there anytime soon.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Grace E. Castle — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:18:56 GMT

It's depressing that these stories are still continuing to exist! Ten years after the National Conference on Wrongful Convictions and the Death Penalty (held in Chicago) our nation's prisons still hold the wrongfully convicted and the "officials" are still playing the same game---with no personal consequences even when their errors are proven. Kudos to Centurion Ministeries for their continued work on behalf of Barry Beach and others.

The strange case of Barry Beach

MW, Seattle, Washington — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:19:30 GMT

I watched the program on Barry Beach. What crossed my mind during the program, was the break-in and missing evidence. Did the program say that a police officer was responsible--a father of one of the girls? If that is so, it would certainly raise questions of cover up within the department....

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bijan, Valleja CA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:19:43 GMT

There was a bloody towel found that, allegedly, had someone other than the victims blood present. This towel has not been tested for DNA. Could this possibly be the evidence needed to prove Gary Beach's innnocence?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jeri Alarcon Sandpoint ,Idaho — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:20:00 GMT

Please join us all in pray for Barry's peace and release as well as his precious mother and sister.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Patty, Bremerton Washington — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:20:31 GMT

I just finished watching the story "The killing at Poplar River" and I am ashamed of our system that is keeping an innocent man in prison.

Not being able to remember almost everything that happened to us 20 or more years ago is incorrect- unless a person has been a heavy drug user- I might believe that.

Barry Beachum needs to be set free and we need to make sure of it. There was no evidence proving he was at the scene of the crime and that was not good enough for him to be set free. Yet, when it came to trying to convict the drug addict- they said they didn't have any evidence that put her at the crime scene. Ok, what is wrong with this picture? This is really upsetting, and makes me wonder how many more innocent people are doing time for someone elses crime.

RELEASE BARRY BEACHUM- HE IS AN INNOCENT MAN. HELP ME HELP HIM- WHAT CAN WE DO TO GET HIM RELEASED?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jill Roombos, Tucson, Arizona — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:21:35 GMT

Please tell Barry Beach not to give up. I've seen these cases before. Unfortunately, all authorities for the State of Montana, the prosecutor, Sheriff, Perole boards, etc. have to kiss each others political butts and stick together. This appeal will have a better chance when these people start to leave, retire, etc. and the next generation takes its place. They will feel more removed from this case and will be more likely to look at the facts. Just hope Barry, you don't have to wait too long. But before that I hope the supreme court has half a brain otherwise the political shame of Montana will be known all across the country. I can't believe what good liars all those politiicans are. They could not even admit that there MIGHT BE A SHADOW OF A DOUBT with any of the evidence. All I can say to them is God examines hearts and if you have anything to do with keeping an innocent man in prison, you will have to answer to God for that and your formalities of going to church every Sunday are not going to change anything. The way politicians lie through there teeth is nothing new, I'm from Chicago, and it is done even by presidents, i.e. "I had nothing do to with bugging those headquarters." Nixon, "I did NOT have sex with that woman." Clinton. "We have evidence that Iraq has weapons of mass destruction." Bush.

The strange case of Barry Beach

ANNE MARSELLA, STOCKTON, CA 95209 — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:21:52 GMT

I WATCHED YOUR SHOW TO NIGHT. IT WAS VERY GOOD . I THOUGHT FOR SURE HE WOULD BE PARDONED OR RELEASED. WAS TOTALLY SURPRISED! IF YOU CAN'T GET HIM A NEW TRIAL WITH A NEW JURY, WHAT ABOUT TRYING FOR A PRESIDENTIAL PARDON?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Anji Joubert, Bend, Oregon — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:24:17 GMT

I just finished watching Dateline tonight about the murder in which Barry Beach was convicted. I find it so hard to believe that there is no DNA evidence linking him to the murder at all. I hope that the Attorney's that are helping him to get out of prison don't give up. There are so many people who are wrongly convicted of crimes and I believe that this is one of them. I also find it interest that cops are allowed to lie and intimidate to get a confession. Isn't that why there are so many false confessions? It sickens me to think that this poor man is living his life in prison, when evidence points in another direction. I hope that one day, Barry is freed and allowed to live his life as a free man.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Alma Carey, Burbank, CA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:24:37 GMT

I've just watched this show.
I would say it's a case of "putting a head on a pike".
That means, grab someone, anyone,cut their head off, put in on a pole or spear, and display it to the townsfolk, so they think the crime's been solved and taken care of. Case closed.
This group of law enforcers, judges, governors, etc., need to be personally studied and questioned about their competence and actual qualification to do their jobs.
This could happen to anyone.
It is OUR freedom and rights that are at stake here.
Absolute power corrupts.
The judge that set aside the clear data regarding the lack of proof, and the further denial for a new appeal, HIS decision should be set aside.
They should NOT think they have final say regarding someone's right to appeal a wrong conviction.
EVERY POINT regarding evidence should be allowed and looked at again, NOT disallowed.
This is a man's life we're talking about.
Not an approved choice of lawn cover.
TOO BAD that it is taking time and effort. We as free citizens need to expect the right to be treated with complete respect.

The strange case of Barry Beach

jerry doe — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:26:41 GMT

You gotta feel sorry for Marc R. who was the prosecutor who later became Govenor and wasn't he a national Republican leader at one time.
There he is telling the jury in opening statements that the pubic hair ties the accused to the murder whereas it was only analyzed as consistent. It works and he goes on to a great political career.
But now it looks like he is wrong. Can he admit it? Of course not because it would cast him in a negative light. The pardon board(did you see the elderly male member just nodding as Marc spoke-his mind was made up)has to agree because they would have to admit they made a mistake and pay millions and what about others in the state prisons-we would have everybody saying they are not guilty.
Loved the old sheriff from Louisina-great photo in his wooee police uniform. He looks like a caricature from the 60's.
The FBI should get involved because it was an interstate conspiracy by the police to frame this guy.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Matt Smith, Fernie, BC Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:30:58 GMT

Well I just watched this show and I'm almost sick to my stomach. What about this pubic hair found at the scene? The prosecutor said it was Barry's, and that is miss conduct, non admissable, the case should have been thrown out right then and there.
And what about the cop that broke into, the evidence?
What kind #$%* is that?
There must be a petition some where that I can sign.
No wander people don't trust the justic system.
NOT GOOD :O(

The strange case of Barry Beach

Breezy, MT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:33:35 GMT

It's hard to believe that they can't connect any of the evidence to Beach yet they still think he committed the murder. Sissy looks like someone you can really believe and have faith in. NOT! Wasn't her dad and Maude's part of the police that broke into the evidence room? What about the death of Steve Kerr another one that had knowledge of the murder and then was killed by a man named Tracey the boyfriend of Kerr's ex-wife. ???? I don't know if he did it or not but you would think to convict him something would have to match the fingerprints blood type or some type of evidence. I'm not a rocket scientist but I didn't see anything that would remotely connect him to the case. Too bad Timer Moses is dead so we can't ask him about the case.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jackie Cleveland,Seattle,Wash. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:36:14 GMT

I find it incredible,that this is such a miscarriage of justice to the young man Barry Beach and the towns people of poplar. It is apparent even to me that the panel of judges that heard the parole hearing,were in their entirity, in colusion to carry out this gross miscarriage of justice! I hope that this is not the end of the story and that justice will prevail!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kathy price Bainbridge Island Wash — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:36:38 GMT

I am confused as to who the bloody hand print belongs to that was on the vechile??? that should shed light on the killer or participant?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Suzanne Luis, Redding, CA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:36:51 GMT

What would it take to have the body exhumed? What did he coroner's report say about the head injury? It seems those powers that be have a powerful incentive to support the ex governor.
Can a case like this be brought to the Supreme Court. There is no way the state of Montana is going to admit to guilt outside of an intervention from God. I lived there years ago, if there was a hearing it was for the purpose of laying this conviction to rest not getting to the truth.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Miriam, Vancouver, WA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:41:00 GMT

To paraphrase a famous song…
That’s the night that the lights went out in Montana
That’s the night they locked up an innocent man
Well don’t trust your soul to no face-saving sheriff or governor
‘Cause the police officer’s daughter got bloodstains on her hands…

The strange case of Barry Beach

Judi Sims-Roseville,California — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:47:17 GMT

This case is overwhelming.Can only say as young as Barry was(when arrested in this case)that it could very well be a possibility he was scared or pressured into a confession.Without doubt,other witnesses have come forward in Barrys behalf,is their testimony really only hearsay?I believe this case needs to be corrected-Prayers for Barry,please.He needs justice.

The strange case of Barry Beach

lisa herrig bonney lake, wa — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:51:06 GMT

I just finished watching the story on Barry Beach and can not figure out why he was not freed by the parole and pardons board. It is quite obvious that this man is innocent of the crime. You hear stories everyday of police coersion in confessions being made by individuals all in the name of keeping a good record in how many winning convictions they can get regardless if the person is innocent or guilty. I hope the law enforcement involved can live with themselves as they have for the past almost 30 years that they probly wrongfully convicted this man.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Donna Bailes, Ione, California — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:53:57 GMT

That Parole board needs to be replaced!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cara Brennan, Tucson AZ — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:56:57 GMT

Seems to me a case of small-town cops bungling, a Southern cop priding himself getting a confession no matter how it's done, a prosecutor (Ricocet) with an eye on a governorship wanting a conviction under his belt, and egos taking over. Evidence was lost and there just wasn't any evidence, except a coerced confession, to convict Beach. Ricocet misrepresented to the jury the hair found belonged to Beach. Ricocet, having been governor, was more impressive and respected by the Montana Parole Board than the "Easterners' who were trying to influence their decision. I believe Beach deserves another hearing and a parole.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Maureen Gabourie, Vancouver, B.C. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 06:59:15 GMT

It seemed, by the end of Barry Beach's story, utterly impossible that he would not be going home, where he clearly belongs. As someone once employed by lawyers, and formerly married to one, I was often amazed to witness the enormity of the fierce competitiveness in the courtroom, the need to win and be right, with the actual human being at the centre of the case diminished to a mere footnote.
Should a petition be started for Mr. Beach, I would be at the front of the line to sign it, his case is so compelling.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Donna Bailes, Ione, California — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 07:00:17 GMT

The judge should have heard the case I hope the Supreme Court is willing. The new evidence should stand for something in this case. A young person can easily confess out of fear and there is no physical evidence that he did this!

The strange case of Barry Beach

anonymous, reno , nevada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 07:01:07 GMT

I think that the parole board is a bunch of losers for not freeing barry beach. he seems so sincere. and all the evidence points to that awful group of women.i hope he gets freed. it is infuriating that people can be kept in jail without any evidence and left to rot there when they are innocent!

The strange case of Barry Beach

CAROLYN MILLER, OREGON CITY, OREGON — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 07:02:24 GMT

FROM 9 TO 11:OO I WATCHED THE CASE OF BARRY BEACH. NOW
IT IS TIME TO GO TO BED, AND I AM SO ANGRY WITH YOU FOR PUTTING US THROUGH THIS, REALLY, LEADING US TO BE-
LIEVE HE IS INNOCENT AND ME BELIEVING HE WAS, RIGHT UP
TO THE LAST MINUTE, AND THEN SENDING HIM BACK TO PRISON!!!!!!!!!!HOW DARE YOU!! WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF PUTTING EVERYONE THROUGH THIS, INCLUDING FAMILIES AND FRIENDS AND US WHO HAD TO LISTEN TO IT? FOR WHAT? THIS
IS THE WORST ONE YET. YOU HAD US ROOTING FOR HIM ALL
THE WAY TO THE END, AND THEN SENDING US OFF TO BED SO
MAD, I TOLD MY HUSBAND, I HAD TO VENT THIS TO SOMEONE
AND WE SPENT A LONG TIME FINDING THIS SPACE. I FELT SO
CONNECTED TO THIS STORY, YO WOULD HAVE THOUGHT IT WAS
MY OWN SON. WHEN THE FINAL THREE SAID "NO", I WANTED
TO SCREAM AT YOU, FOR LETTING THIS HAPPEN. YOU LEAD
US ON, AND ON, AND ON, AND THEN THE FINAL BLOW. I GIVE
YOU THE LOWEST SCORE THAT CAN BE GIVEN,FOR TWO HOURS
OF ANXIETY AND THEN YOU SIGN OFF. YOU PROBABLY ONLY
READ THE GOOD ONES,BUT I FEEL BETTER!!!!THANKS, AT
LEAST FOR A SPACE TO COMMENT.
,

!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cynthia Galvin Puyallup, Washington — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 07:27:51 GMT

I believe this man is innocent. I worked 3 years at McNeil Island State Prison as a correctional officer, with minimum, medium and maximum level inmates,(approx 1200 inmates). Certain superiors would call me in their office periodically, (mostly when an infraction was written against an inmate). Requesting me to rewrite my report, to read their way, falsely. Quote " because they wanted the infractions to stick". I witnessed many times other fellow officers and my superiors bully inmates and deny the accusations later.

I wrote my infractions the way I saw the incidents happen. (Funny they never called me in on inmates appeals etc. wonder why)?

My brother has been in law enforcement all his life to current day. The stories have not changed since I worked law enforcement.

Then;
Not to mention all the crooked officials that turn up in the media almost everyday somewhere; for lying, stealing, buying drugs, tampering with evidence etc. Many of these officials credentials were just as good as the one's in Mr. Beachs' trials and hearings. Why should this officials be considered any different.

I am a 48 yr old female. At 37 I worked at the prison. My superiors were unable to intimidate me., I never wrote the infractions their way. I wrote them the right way, honestly.

At 37 years of age I was educated, developed a good level of wisdom and had 20 years life experience.

Had I of been 21 years of age they could of broke me down, to write pretty much anything.

If I were age 17 they definetly would of broke me.

I say this knowing from my own experiences. And I believe a vast majority of people would agree that at age 17 we are still vulnervable, easily intimidated scared of the unknown, immature etc.

After watching the show on Friday evening, and re reading this article their is no doubt in my mind Mr. Beach is innocent.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Doug Bevans, Dexter, Oregon — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 07:38:41 GMT

Hi Keith
Excellent show! I would say to anyone, watch this and know, that there are many things seriously wrong with the case brought against Barry Beach.
By the end of the show I was entirely convinced he was in fact innocent.
Thanks,
DB

The strange case of Barry Beach

Janell Forgey Estacada, Oregon — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 07:43:10 GMT

Great Story!
Well Done Centurian Ministries! Barry Beach should have been released due to your investigations of his case.
Wish everyone well in pursuing the soonest future release for Barry Beach.
Thank you Dateline for this story.
People of Montana, you may need to do some serious re-evaluations.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mark S. Penn — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 07:52:34 GMT

I watched in sadness to the conclusion of this report. Something truly smells here. Why not more investigative reporting on the "cop" who kicked in the evidence room door and his daughter? And, how about the so-called transcript of the confession? Selective quoting perhaps? Hearing the audio and the duress one is under rather than reading words can be entirely different! God bless Centurion and the work they do. How many more are locked up erroroniously? Anyone who has ever faced a felony charge soon learns when it comes to the D.A., its all about the conviction ratio and their career path than real justice. Sad, its truly sad...

The strange case of Barry Beach

Giancarlo Mancarella, Los angeles California — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 07:55:53 GMT

With all this evidence in his favour, the story of Mr. Barry Beach it's a clear case of injustice. I am so sorry for him, i'll ask all my friends to write a comment or a letter to him. This is Democracy, it is time for us people to speak up, loud, in the name of Justice, and have him released.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carol Cooper ,Victoria,British Columbia, Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 08:03:11 GMT

Dear Mr. Morrison, I was very touched by the story you aired on your Dateline show tonight,about the Poplar River murder.Was Barry Beach ever given a lie detector test to prove his innocents? Were the fingerprints or footprints of her socalled friends ever checked? Was the murder weapon ever found? There seems to have been a lot things overlooked,and they did not place him at the crime scene. I hope he will continue to receive help to clear his name, and get him out of prison. The evidence clearly shows he is innocent of this crime,and some one else has gotten away with this tragic murder.

The strange case of Barry Beach

panama city beach fla betty hicks — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 08:59:35 GMT

i think this man is innocent and i dont see how anyone could think otherwise i dont know who did kill that young girl but i do think sissy is worth more investagation into her involvement

The strange case of Barry Beach

Christine Stoll — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 09:22:05 GMT

I think a polygraph should be taken of all the girls, and anyone else expected in this crime. I believe Barry Beach is in jail for a crime he did not commit and it is our duty as US citizens to get him out of jail and put the guilty behind bars for life.

The strange case of Barry Beach

CAMELLIA BROWN, ITHACA,N.Y — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 10:09:27 GMT

hi my name is camellia brown from ithaca,n.y.i whacthed the the story on the kim nees case and i think that barry beach is innocent of the crime that he has been charged and convicted of in 1983. besides the confession there is nothing linking him to this crime.HE WAS FRAMED FOR THE CRIME AND NO ONE WANTS TO SEE IT.there were numorus witness saying that this woman joanne confessed to this crime on more than one occasion over the years.shes a LAIR and MURDER and she and the others that were involved with this crime got away with it and the state of montana is not doing any thing about it.barry beach confession was not accurate. i think that he was scared in to making that confession and that detectives in both states are covering it up. HE IS INNOCENT AND HE SHOULD BE FREED SO THE REAL KILLER OR KILLERS CAN BE ARRESTED,CHARGED AND CONVICTED WITH THIS CRIME. i would just like to say to barry beach STAY STRONG AND YOU WILL BE IN MY PRAYS.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ceil Dileo Hamilton NJ — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 10:10:07 GMT

No one tells a investigation like Keith Morrison he has such a goood way with every show he does.

The strange case of Barry Beach

mark abbott delavan, WI — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 10:43:42 GMT

Assumming no material facts were left out of the reporting. An objective viewer has to conclude that Barry Beach is LIKELY not guilty. The Parole board bowed to one man's testimony vs. 30 for. How sad for this man and this state having the parole board communicate via email, cowards.

The strange case of Barry Beach

joni davis oak lawn il — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 11:04:52 GMT

how can we help? please tell us who we can write this is not supposed to happen in the U.S. Every american that hears this story should be afraid for themselves and there childern? I used to want to move to Montana but not after hearing this story. Please let us know how can we help. Sincerely, Joni Davis

The strange case of Barry Beach

Richmond, Virginia — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 11:07:16 GMT

I can see how someone after hours of interegation might admit to something they didn't do especially after they have been told how they are going to fry in the electric chair.
I don't understand how he can be found quilty when there is do tangible evidence( such as fingerprints, dna, etc. many people have confessed to crimes they didn't do. From the information I saw on Dateline, I think Barry Beech is innocence and I would like to see him freed.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Marilyn Churchill, Green Bay WI — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 11:52:33 GMT

I can't help but feel, after watching the story of Barry Beach last night, that there is a real possibility of miscarrage of justice. At the LEAST, there was enough brought out to bring reasonable doubt to the guilty verdict. It's hard to understand on what 'evidence' the former prosecutor is so sure that Beach is guilty; how in the world, based on the the total lack of any physical evidence, can he be so arrogantly sure? More likely he and the parole board are digging their heels in and simply refusing to entertain the thought that they might be wrong. At the least, it seemed to me that Beach might have been paroled. What a disturbing story of justice in America.

The strange case of Barry Beach

C.C. Bennett, Metairie, Louisiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 12:00:09 GMT

I listened to Dateline last night and I haven't been able to sleep very much since. After all the evidence was presented I really do not think Barry Beach killed Kim. Please understand I live in Louisiana and I know how the law enforcement agencies are here. Nothing would suprise me about how they go about getting "confessions". So to the men who are trying to free Barry, I say keep on. I will keep Barry in my prayers that the Supreme Court will really look deeply into this case. Something is not right here.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mark Armstrong Clay Twp. Michigan — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 12:06:07 GMT

I was just wondering why the misconduct of the prosecuter wasn't brought up in the parol board hearing. it seems to me that a lot of this kind of behavior is alot more common in the people that seem to have the elected power given to them,how can you shrug off evidence that is clearly there or tell someone to omit it.
lets say that the correct person that did this murder is caught in this case and Barry Beach is proven innocent make the people responsible for there wrongfull conviction accountable for there actions put them in front of the justice system.
how come the police officer that broke into the evidence room isn't sitting in jail or his daughter, I think the parole board should be sitting in front of the supreme court if that happens.
when it's all said and done the public has to pay with there tax dollars make the prosecution pay out of there own pocket to devistate them as it's done to the wrongfully convicted.

The strange case of Barry Beach

george shearin, richmond, virginia — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 12:50:00 GMT

I am stunned by the parol board decision, then , maybe I'm not. For them to grant a pardon would mean that they would be admitting that so many people in the 'system' were wrong, and they did/would not do that. I thought from the start that Barry did the crime, but as the evidence was found and presented, at the end I knew he did NOT and for the parole board to deny his freedom is truly an injustice.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jess, Ft. Peck Ind. Reservation - Poplar Montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 13:01:24 GMT

I'm suprised there aren't any blog posts yet! I am not a "blogger" but after watching the Beach story on Dateline last night it pushed me to make an attempt (at blogging). The only people saying the man is guilty are the ones with something to lose or gain. So I guess the people of the community are lying? yeah right! I live in this town and see on a daily basis the high number of assaults that take place in such a small community - the women here (not ALL!) are always beating other women because of jealousy. It sickens me that any prosecutor would have taken this case to the level they did with such sketchy (at best) so called "evidence".

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dee Stru, Hicksville, NY — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 13:08:22 GMT

This is a very compeling story. An excellent job of reporting on the part of Keith Morrisson. I am truly impressed at how you clearly presented the evidence for both sides objectively. Re Barry Beach- this reminds me of the Marty Tankilof story here in New York. The police and prosecuters unwilling to admit that they were wrong. And that they sent an innocent person to jail and are unwilling to rectify it. Based on the facts, I believe that Barry was bamboozzeled. If there is a way to petition the Governor of Montana for Barrys release- I would be willing to sign it. Twenty nine years is enough.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Michael J. Evans — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 13:17:42 GMT

I was amazed by the decision of the parole board that Barry Beach was guilty of this crime. What I saw was a political ambush. We all know that people will confess to anything if enough pressure (or torture) is used. Even John McCain caved. Sadly, there was no video of the Louisiana interview with the "closer". The fact that other confessions taken by this officer were found to be false (surely gained by the same kind of pressure exerted on Barry Beach) should have held weight in the board's considerations. Of course, the retired "closer" would deny the abuse. He's living on a pension from the state.

The prosecutor, former Governor Racicot, said that he believed the confession held the same weight as physical evidence of Beach's guilt (though there was no physical evidence that he wasn't home in bed as he sister said). If the statements in the program are accurate, the board reiterated what the former Governor stated in the hearing. How would the public see the former prosecutor if the board voted against him? How many members of the board belong to the same party as the prosecutor? How many owe their positions to this man and the political life of the state of Montana. How many plan their retirements from this service?

I believe your program proved that Barry Beach is innocent and was railroaded by the system into a false confession, and that he is forced to remain in prison because of the politics that outweigh the truth. Power and privilege have won again.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cheryl Rizzo,Roxboro,N.C. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 13:57:07 GMT

I watched this last night and it was very disturbing. How could anybody in their right mind keep this man in prison and still sleep at night. I think he's a scapegoat for some evil doings that went on in that town. The governor of Montana should commute his sentence and let him out.

The strange case of Barry Beach

R. Nieraeth, Bonanza, OR — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:06:13 GMT

Your story on Barry Beach brought back memories of my family living in Poplar, MT. We left in '95, not a place to raise a family. Law enforcement on the Fort Peck Reservation was subpar. Federal, state and local officials rarely work together. Pretty much on the same level as those officials in Louisiana that questioned Barry. So it wasn't surprising that the wrong person was sent to prison.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Gail LaCross, West Springfield, Massachusetts — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:12:26 GMT

There is no DNA evidence then or now to support the conviction of Barry Beach. Beyond reasonable doubt!!!
Was the jury not instructed correctly? Did the judge
forget that evidence is required to convict a person of a crime? That if Barry Beach's confession
(tape gone missing) was so damning, why didn't anyone pay attention to the fact that some of that confession
was inaccurate? clothing, keys in the ignition. What about the palm print in blood? Obviously whoever left
that print was there when the violence occured, if it wasn't the victim's or Barry Beach's, whose was it?
Small town, small minds, why not fingerprint/palmprint
everyone involved with Kim Nees? A police officer in that same small town broke into evidence because his
daughter Maude was implicated! Does that not corrupt
not only the evidence, but the law enforcement as well?
New Trial!!!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

marjorie christian, thompson falls, montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:21:39 GMT

Beach's hearing was a lost cause from the get-go. The man who prosecuted him is now a former governor and curently a powerful lobbyist and high ranking republican politician. I'm sure he knows each parole board member personally. Even though there is eough evidence to suggest others committed this murder Beach doesn't stand a chance against such power. Every adult in Montana should protest the board's ruling, this could happen to any of us.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cheryll Lara, Casper, Wyoming. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:23:44 GMT

Mr Morrison, I watch your show all the time and each story is gripping and most times heart wrenching, often times leaving a person feeling helpless, angry and definatly questioning the state and integrity of the Justice system. But this story had us in tears. What can we do as citizens of these United States to help this young man?

The strange case of Barry Beach

cat johnson — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:27:44 GMT

It seems to be that the power of the Governor of Mt. has more power than anyone else in the state, as the board was doing what they were told. It is so true our system is broken and corrupted, as Texas where I live, is the same. The sadness of this case kept us awake last nite, as many other people I'm sure. I truly hope the Christian team wont give up, and when the govenor is no longer, maybe Barry can be free. I'm sure the good Lord will make things even in the end, for everyone.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Anita Baumgarner — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:28:27 GMT

All of those who convicted Beach should have to take a polygraph test....the girl they thought was involved....her dad is a policeman who kicked in the door of the evidence room...kind of suspicious...wouldn't you think...of course those who put him behind bars, especially the one with a political career wouldn't change his decision because ...what would the people think...he madee a mistake....he needs to fess up to it. There was too much politics involved with this...how sad that the people not releasing him didn't take a good look at ALL of the evidence.
Anita

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jean Lehman, Blue Springs, Missouri — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:29:03 GMT

There is no way I could have convicted Beach. Not enough proof. Did the sister have any proof that she did try to tell authorities her brother was at home? At the hearing was the prosecutor ever called up to explain why he told the jury the pubic hair matched Beach. This is a travesty of justice. Other people have been let go with more proof of guilt. What happened to his truck that broke down?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joe Morgan, Lakeside, Ohio — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:35:22 GMT

Centurion Ministries is a wonderful action group and I commend them for it. I find our justice system really lacking in this case and I feel Mr. Beach has been wrongly treated. How can anyone ignore such truths uncovered by the Centurion folks that falsify the confession of a young terrified Beach? I cannot imagine a sheriff and a former governor remaining so committed to a confession over so many facts to the contrary.

The strange case of Barry Beach

N Moran, San Jose, CA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:37:43 GMT

This is a total miscarraige of justice. This man is innocent. The board is protecting Mark Roscoe, now governor and the police that investigated. To disregard evidence that proves Beaches non-involvement. Mark Roscoe says that there was no evidence putting the others there, well there is non putting Beach there. Beaches "confession" was false. look at the record of the officers that tried to pin it on the other two officers. This man is innocent. This man is innocent. The officer via and the governor are trying to save their hides so they are going to stick to thier story. How do witness become liars???

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bruce Bryan, Casper, Wyoming. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:43:34 GMT

I was left outraged for this young man. Once again that big black stamp "CASE CLOSED" prevailed over Justice. The fact that a law official, broke into the evidence room,(not to mention that he was "related" to another person or people being questioned in the case)should have brought Barry Beach a new trial, confession or not!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Anita Baumgarner — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:45:19 GMT

His accuser has something to hide or /and is protecting his political carreer...
Centurion Ministries...I commend your work...don't stop...several of us after hearing the dateline 2-hour special on this killing believe some of those people(the ones who convicted Beach) in that town are hiding something because it involves their loved one or friends. Some dirty fowl play is going on with those who convicted him. The girl's own sister believes Beach is innocent. Beach is innocent....
My family and I believe the Centurion Ministries is right...there must be something one can do.....
The parole board...we do not think much of them...I wonder why they didn't listen to the real evidence???
Keith Morrison..nice job reporting...I would keep on this one...what can the people do????We are a family that has never been involved with the law except for a speeding ticket years ago...we are concerned about this and do not feel it is right... there must be something that can be done...

The strange case of Barry Beach

Donna Harris Nashville Tn — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:55:23 GMT

Sorry Berry If a politician is involved you will stay in prison the rest of your life.
He made his career on your case. and will pay anyone to keep his cover up secret. It would distroy is career for it to be found that he is corrupt.

Which is the case of most of the politicians in America today it makes me Sad to report this but its true.
They are all lawyers and use the system for their advances no matter who they hurt or step on to get where they want to be. The law enforgement in the area daughter prints was never checked and I do not believe for one moment that anyone other then that man broke in to the police dept. and stole all evidence.

The united staes marchal needs to go into this place and conduct an investacation on not only this case but all cases in the last 25 years contact your united states mashal office if they get enough complaints from the people in that area they have to do an investication. these small towns think they are above the law but they are not. They Don't up hold the law. They think They are the law which is not the case!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Craig Robinson, Saco, Mt — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 14:56:55 GMT

I live in Montana and I'm shocked how the crime was investigated initially and their dismissal of testimony that affects the investigation now. Not only was their a coverup initially, currently it looks like this still applies. It's evident to me that this crime is still unsolved and the people involved in this investigation have no desire to know the truth. You can't tell me that a body drug 100 yds wouldn't have left foot prints. This police department make the keystone cops look like professionals. GET IT RIGHT MONTANA! Don't let this distortion of justice continue even if the former governor is involved.

The strange case of Barry Beach

marge st. paul minnesota — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:12:58 GMT

Fact and feeling tell me he didn't kill Kim Nee. I questioned why the parole board would discount this.
Then it came to me,of course....'mustn't make the former governor look bad'. I would imagine he is still very prominent in the state.

The strange case of Barry Beach

esu, Rutledge, GA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:21:44 GMT

The prosecutor in this case used the conviction of Barry Beach as a step-stool to become govenor. That is why he won't even entertain the idea that he may have convicted the wrong man. I believe that the board of appeals was threatened and bullied into their decision, just as Sissy's brother was warned not to "commit perjury". Why were they allowed 3 weeks to arrive at their decision? That's plenty of time for someone to "change their minds". What a pathetic show of "justice"!
Barry your in our thoughts and prayers. I am glad that you have made such a tragedy into a triumph.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Susan Schindler — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:21:48 GMT

The refusal of the Parole Board to reopen this case is appalling. There are at least two cases of people (Thomas Arthur and Troy Davis) on death row where the same thing is now happening. In one case, DNA is available. There is something horribly wrong with a criminal justice system whose default position favors "finality" over seeking the truth.

The strange case of Barry Beach

L.S. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:32:01 GMT

Could the body be exsumed and tested for any evidence of DNA?

The strange case of Barry Beach

john doe — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:32:05 GMT

free barry beach, i live in poplar and everyone knows he's inocent. just by viewing sissy atkinson's interview, her body language & statements she said just told on herself...everyone know's sissy, maude kirn, rhea reddog and some other girls killed this poor incocent girl over jealousy, these girls were in no way school girls. anyway i just wish montana will look at the new evidence. & richy mcdonald lied to u guys. i worked at A&S industries in every dept. & in know way is it ever that loud in that company. he even lied in uniform as did dean mahlum & grainger as he was just wet behind the ears as an law enforcement officer. sissy atkinson is one humongous liar & i hope she burns in hell for what she did. and the other girls along with her.

The strange case of Barry Beach

JoAnne, Hartford, Connecticut — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:42:29 GMT

Shame on DATELINE.

Before yesterday, I had never heard of Barry Beach, Kim Nees, or Poplar, Montana. Upon hearing of them, I was intrigued. After seeing the report, I did a little research, maybe an hour's worth. Here's some of what I found.

Centurian Ministries founder, Jim McCloskey, stated in your report that he never takes a case unless absolutely convinced of the inmate's innocence. Considering that he previously has touted the "innocence" of a guilty man, Roger Coleman, his certainty cannot be given great weight. For years, McCloskey screamed that Coleman was innocent of the murder of his sister-in-law. As with Beach, he developed theories about other killers. Even after Coleman's execution in 1992, McCloskey worked to demonstrate his innocence. Eventually, the Governor of Virginia agreed to DNA testing. The samples were sent to Canadian laboratory for testing--just to be sure that they were handled by a neutral party. The result? Coleman was guilty. For McCloskey's apology, see Centurian Ministries' website.

As for Beach, he claims that his confession of January 7, 1983 was coerced and was false. Why then did he confess again, in his lawyer's presence, on January 11, 1983? That lawyer now says that such second confession did not occur. If not, why did he wait so long to say something?

In your story, you reported that Barry Beach's sister was "not allowed" to testify at his trial. The person who stopped her from testifying was Beach's lawyer. Why? Because her version of an alibi conflicted with the alibi given by Beach's mother. Instead of presenting two alibis that conflicted with one another, the lawyer chose to only present the mother's version.

Additionally, analysis of the bloodly palm print was worthless. They were unable to determine whether it belonged to Beach, Nees, or anyone else. In other words, it could have been left by Beach or it could have been left by Nees. There is no evidence either way.

A bloody towel was found about a block away from Beach's home. The blood did not belong to Nees and it did not belong to Beach. Indeed, there is no evidence that it was connected in any way to the murder. Perhaps some kid used the towel to wipe off blood from a cut. No one knows. This is not an episode of CSI where fictional investigators conduct fictional tests. Ask any forensic scientist to watch a couple of episodes and they will report back that much of what you see is scientifically impossible. In other words, science fiction. But, it makes good television.

Fingerprints on the truck. None of them belonged to Beach. In his confession, however, he stated that he wiped off the truck after the murder to remove any prints he may have left behind. Also, the truck did not belong to Nees. She had borrowed it from her father.

Dateline and McCloskey point to the rancher's testimony that he saw several girls with Nees in the truck. You failed to mention that he had been drinking that night and that he waited decades to report this "sighting." He also stated that nothing much was going on in town that weekend but, in fact, it was a rodeo weekend with lots of activity.

You mention that footprints could not be matched to Beach. Yet, you also explain that the murder occurred at a "popular party site." If this was a popular location, you would expect to find lots of footprints.

Finally, after announcing that the Montana Board of Pardons and Parole had decided to give Barry Beach a hearing unprecedented in the United States, McCloskey scoffs at the result and questions the Board's sincerity. Read the Board's decision at www.mt.gov/bopp. They heard evidence that would never be admitted in a court of law and still concluded that Beach was guilty.

Everyone wants to be a hero. Freeing the innocent man is the stuff of movies. Except in a few rare cases, though, the guilty are guilty. Nevertheless, in its report, Dateline accepted Beach's story without any skeptism. No research at all; I did this in an hour. You simply accepted McCloskey's claims and became an advocate for Beach. We, the viewing public, deserve better. Kim Nees deserves better. When you accept one side's version of events without thought, you abdicate your responsibilities.

In the future, I hope you will try to do better.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jeanie McCoy, Idaho Falls, Idaho — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:46:35 GMT

This story has haunted me. How could this travesty not be corrected? Why won't officials even consider looking back at the past evidence? Everyone makes mistakes, even police and prosecutors. They should allow the evidence to be re-examined rather than continue to allow this travesty to continue.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Grace Dowling Apple Valley, CA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:48:02 GMT

Poor Barry! Coerced into a confession for a murder he didn't commit. What about the cop who broke into the evidence room and tampered with evidence? And how convienient that his TAPED confession was erased or disappeared. What of the 'fed' Facts of the crime that were wrong?... and Barry supposively getting those very same Facts wrong in his "confession"? I'm
agast at the very obvious, & intentional cover-up of the truth! Can the President pardon him? Barry cer-
tainly isn't getting justice from the state of Montana! I hope you let Mr.Beach know that their are people praying that he will be exhonorated, and that justice will be done. Hang in there brother, don't give up hope. I pray you'll come out of this better, not bitter, and the Lord will restore all the years that the locusts have eaten away. Sincerely, Grace

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tamara Owen , Leicester,NC — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 15:54:42 GMT

What I don't understand is, why did the girl that her dad was a police officier break into the evidence room? To me that would point a finger right at her maybe he destroyed the evidence that would convict one of the real killers. This a pure case of black & white but no wants to admit that they are wrong, they know they are wrong I wouldn't want to be in their shoes when the real truth comes out and it will.

The strange case of Barry Beach

William Irene, Albuquerque, New Mexico — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:02:51 GMT

Letting Beach free would be a slap in the face to law enforcement and a former governor. The ministries need to take this past the state level otherwise he'll stay in jail. What's funny to me is what looked to be a law enforcement officer said Carl Fourstar was lying because A & S was too loud - really? That's just not true if the ministries countered that arguement... The problem seems to be that there are more people out there that know that Sissy & her friends either bragged or confided in them regarding Kim's death. Unfortunately in a town called "Stab City" - folks are more likely to not put themselves out there to help - otherwise this community wouldn't be so crime ridden (it takes a village?). What's wrong with Montana law enforcement to allow one of their towns to get such a heinous nickname? (a whole 'nother can of worms I guess...)

The strange case of Barry Beach

Rebecca, Massachusetts — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:06:53 GMT

I can't believe Montana would not give Barry Beach parole after the hearing! There is a lot of doubt how Barry was convicted. His confession would not stand up to careful scrutiny! Those women who deny having to do with Kim Nees's death should be jailed, not him. Sissy is a drug addict and from what I see in her interview & behavior, is in denial. No wonder she takes drugs to escape the real truth.

FREE BARRY BEACH! Let the case go all the way to the Supreme Court. I give praise to the hard working defenders of the Centurion Ministries.

The strange case of Barry Beach

John Edwards, Denver, Colorado — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:11:00 GMT

What ever happened to the premise that even in the event of eye witness testimony or ocnfessions, that the crime scene evidence must still support the ocntention that the accuser is guilty, or there is reasonable doubt? There must be "guilt beyond a reasonable doubt" to convict. There seems to be a mountain of evidence supporting reasonable doubt, and yet, he has not even been granted a re-trial. In todays justice system, with today's new scientific ability to analyze evidence (superior to that of 25 years ago), this man deserves a new trial. Just because you have a politician defending himself in the public eye, is absolutely no reason to imprison a possibly innocent man. Give the man a new trial - with all the evidence provided - and then let a jury decide.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Denise Stevens, Albuquerque, NM — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:21:30 GMT

It's clear to me that Barry is innocent. The governor showing up at the hearing...come on...of course that would concretize Barry's "guilty" verdict. I do not know how all these people, including the killers, can sleep at night. This is outrageous. If some authority figure told me that I had to say what he wanted me to say/confess, and if I didn't, he would watch me "fry", and if I were 20 yo, I truly think I would have done what Barry did.

The strange case of Barry Beach

jon doe,austin,texas — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:29:42 GMT

It seems to me the parole was trying to cover up for corrupt policemen and a ex govenor that want a future in politics.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carol Ferrell — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:34:28 GMT

It is evident to me he was worn down (it has happened before by Police) to make him admit killing her. I BELIEVE HE IS INNOCENT AND I HOPE AND PRAY HE GETS OUT SOON. Those "lawmen" don't want justice, they just want to be right. I think something should be done very soon to get this innocent man out of jail. I was once stopped by a policeman within a mile of my home and arrested by an out of control (emotionally) policeman who treated me like a criminal because he saw me putting on my seat belt. I am 69 years old, always obey the law and yet this jerk treated me with no respect and even brought tears to my eyes by his bad behavior. These are not policemen, they are bullies. This jerk gave me a ticket for no seat belt on, even though I was putting it on.
C. Ferrell, San Diego

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tina Offner, St Louis, MO — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:35:01 GMT

I am convinced that this is obviously a case of major cover-up because so many of the towns girls were involved. What about Steve Greyhawk, the cop who broke down the door to the crime lab and stole the evidence, whose daughter Maude was implicated in the killing? And why were her fingerprints never compared? It seems that the former governer and sherrif also have an interest in covering up. Were their daughters involved as well? I believe Barry Beach is innocent. It is very understandable that a 20 year old could be intimidated into making a false confession.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Craig Smith — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:38:24 GMT

Barry had no motive. Strange that the sister had someone read her words at end...did she know all the time...she went everywhere with her sister. Beach's step mother set the the whole thing into motion. He was in his own words always high on drugs and alcohol...his mental faculities diminished most likely. The exgovenor seemed almost demonic.What a nightmare..It would make an excellent movie...Barry could get the money to have another appeal...Stange that they would grant an appeal/have so many supporting him/even betraying loved ones...the fact that one of the girls father a policeman! broke in and destroyed evidence. His daughther must had confessed. All too sad.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bob Los Angeles Ca. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:41:08 GMT

This man needs a new trail in a federal court! This whole case stinks of a cover up! This small town does not want to know the real truth.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Annette Hall, Knox, In. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 16:55:52 GMT

This case is most interesting. I watched it and came to only one verdit....he's not guilty. No evidence to link him in any way and too many mistakes by the police. The eye witnesses are the key. This needs to be re-opened.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dave Bennett, Bremerton, Washington — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:04:31 GMT

I seem to have some kind of a talent for reading people. When I saw the three persons on the parole board, I told my wife they were only holding it because Dateline was involved, and they were going to deny his release regardless of the evidence presented. No honest person can believe Beach is guilty. The dishonesty of the opposition is evident on many points. For example, they claim if others were involved, then someone would have said something during all those years. Then they ignore those who did say something. Their arrogance and utter disdain for Mr. Beach and his supporters was proven when they waited 3 weeks to make their decision, and then issued it via e-mail.

Mr. Beach was confident before the hearing, saying "I have a team behind me." Mr. Beach, you used to have a team behind you. Now you have America behind you. This isn't going away.

The strange case of Barry Beach

NE MT Resident — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:06:57 GMT

I thought a jury was told "guilty beyond a reasonable doubt". Doesn't all of this put doubt into whether or not he is guilty? I don't think he would've been found guilty in a court of law in today's world.

The strange case of Barry Beach

jill gelbspan — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:26:35 GMT

we are haunted by this story & confused re: why 1st degree murder? why not 2nd or manslaughter? he'd be out by now. Seems like his attys did a horrible job of representing, investigating, etc. & the "Panel" that unprecedently heard the case seemingly just killed time for 3 weeks, without serious consideration of the new evidence, including the research re: confessions of the innocent. & what guy knows that a girl's blouse is "polyester" vs. cotton blend, etc.? Our hearts go out to Barry.

The strange case of Barry Beach

flourgirl, helena, mt — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:28:12 GMT

I don't see where the police officer breaking into the evidence room was questioned. Is there a reason this was seen as insignificant?

The strange case of Barry Beach

kim robert, edmonton alberta Canada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:28:24 GMT

I wathced Dateline last night about the Barry Beach story and was astounded with the Parole Boards results. This is a travesty and he has spent his life in prison for a crime he did not commit. It is beyond comprehension that evidence just disappeared,
and those girls said "conveniently" were home in bed @ 11:00 that night. My heart goes out to Barry Beach himself and his heartbroken mother. I am from Canada and believe he is innocent. God Bless Him.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Deb, Eau Claire, WI — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:28:38 GMT

I believe that Barry Beach is innocent. Centurian Ministries clearly proved that fact. I don't know what the Review Board is up to but they all looked like throw backs from the 1940's and I distrust them.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joan rogers, Chattanooga, TN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:37:00 GMT

I'm suprised that they never used a lie detector on anyone in that case.

The strange case of Barry Beach

S Carter, Pueblo, Co. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:38:29 GMT

Barry Beach may have confessed to this murder years ago but with the blood,prints,hairs,clothes his where abouts not matching why was he not released.All of that should have been tested before convicting him in the first place not just going by a confession.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ray Jones — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:48:41 GMT

We watched this case of Barry Beach on Dateline. I think Barry Beach is innocent. All of the evidence you brought can't be overlooked. The Police lost to much evidence there was nothing to connect him to the murder. It's as if they made a mistake and no one wants to own up to it. They should have released him with all the new evidence and witnesses that pointed to someone else. I think the confession to murder was coerced by the two Police Departments. If I can do anything to help free Barry Beach please let me know.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Amy, Traverse City, Michigan — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 17:55:47 GMT

This story was incredible to watch. It seems that there are so many holes in the case and yet they close their eyes to all of that and allow this man to stay where he doesn't seem to belong. I really hope that the real killers come to justice, because based on the evidence this guy isn't the "right guy".

The strange case of Barry Beach

Laura, Raytown, MO — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 18:10:55 GMT

Was anyone watching this last night? There were many points presented that cast a long shadow on both his guilt and innocence.

Has anyone been so scared that you'd say anything to get out of the problem? I have and I believe Barry has too.

Yeah, he admitted to killing Kim Nees and who would do that? Many have made false confessions. Due to undo stress. Stress isn't always predictable you know. Every person handles stress in a different way, their way.

The initial investigations cleared him of any involvement. The police down in Monroe LA had no business interrogating Barry because that was not in their jurisdiction but should have held him and give time for the decetitives fly down from Popular. The sheriff's deputy who supposedly coerced a confession out of Barry was not believable. The photo's of him taken back then told me all I needed to know about him. A cocky, arrogant, bully who had no business wearing a badge. The video feed in the hearing room confirmed he still was plus he smiled to much. The conflicting evidence cast reasonable doubt. The wittness's who came forward cast more doubt. Sissy WAS NOT believeable at all. To many witnesse's coming forward who didn't know the other all reported the same thing, she confessed! She was defensive and why should she be if she wasn't there? The other girls who didn't show up after being summonded say something about their involvements. The whole story reminded me of Justin Barber, who like Barry, got the short end of the justice stick.

I hope Centurion Minisitries never gives up on Barry. I wish that they too would look into Justin Barber's case because I believe his is innocent also.

As for Barry, my heart goes out to him. Yup, he did something really stupid and so have some of the officals up in Montana. I can't say who's dumb or dumber here. It shouldn't be our legal process who wears the dunce cap but here I believe they are.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Alice Wheeler — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 18:21:19 GMT

When I saw this report last night with all the evidence pointing away from Barry Beach, I knew this case was used as a stepping stone by the States Attorney to the office of Governor. What a callous man! How could anyone covet the self-glory of a governorship by sacrificing an innocent young man's life. How could he and his "Closer" have questioned Barry Beach, a little 17 year old boy, without an attorney present or his parents? This could have happened to your son or mine. A productive life destroyed by the greed of those in power! (I shall never vacation in Montana!) Of course the parole board could not vote against the word of the former governor - they could lose their jobs, or were they paid to cast the "No consideration" vote? Even my 5th graders could see through this farce of a hearing. I hope they each (the parole board members) develop a terminal disease and die a long painful death. May the fires of Hell be extra hot when they arrive!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Rocky Karlage, Cincinnati, OH — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 18:35:28 GMT

Keith Morrison presented an incredible, well balanced investigation into the supposed guilt of Barry Beach, and the real crime of those who appear to have murdered Kim Nees and got away with it. I watched with incredulity as evidence which was presented by the state of Montana to convict this man was denied by a parole board as 'relevant' when it had been constructively and evidentially presented that it did not implicate Mr. Beach in any way. From the stated 'forced' confession which had the ring of truth that it was coerced, to the former prosecutor/Governor who was "sure" he was absolutely right and impuned the defendant's character even with the the lack of proof of his guilt staring him in the face, to the women who should have at least been implicated in the case, to the Poplar police officer who was convinced he couldn't be wrong no matter what the evidence was and how much witnesses stated he was wrong, it appeared obvious that finding the truth was not the most important thing to these people. Standing "right" in their original beliefs to send what looks like an innocent man to prison was paramount in the statements of each one who used inaccurate evidence to maintain they knew what they were had done and were doing. What also seemed obvious to me was the unique staging of this parole board review was finally used to attempt to put the matter to rest instead of actually giving the man a chance at freedom. It's sad that any justice system can be misused by those with power to protect the real guilty; especially when it looked as if those who convicted Barry Beach have the guilt of a town coverup on their own hands. By the evidence presented and abandoned, quite a few other people should be serving time in prison for misrepresenting the facts; not just the murderers. No, Poplar Montana may not be equipped with a CSI Miami to examine forensic/DNA evidence, but it has the duty to properly use evidence and not cast it away in favor of a 'confession' that did not present conclusive facts that Barry Beach had murdered Kim Nees. Justice is supposed to carry forward evidence without doubt. There is nothing but doubt in the conviction of Mr. Beach. I hope and pray Centurion Ministries have much success in freeing this man from prison despite the lies of the guilty and the use of law against their efforts. My best wishes to Mr. Beach and them. Thank you for presenting this excellent story Mr. Morrison.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Don Pucilowski, La Grange, Calif — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 18:46:18 GMT

Has there ever been a prosecuter that said " I made a mistake" and petitioned the courts to set a prisoner free. Most that I witnessed have only bowed to a outside relative or group that did extensive investigation and proved a person innocents. In the case of Barry Beach I feel that the three panel parole board mind was made up befgore they steped into the hearing and it was a exercise futility. As I watched the testimony of the the witnesses for the defense I believe the if the woman Grayhawk where made to testify it would have added considerable credence to his innocence instead of a relative coming in with hear-say evidence, saying "yes" she kicked her a few times, "WHY WAS'NT GRAYHAWK BROUGHT IN"?? I must commend Centurion Ministries for the exhasting efforts they made in proving Barry Beach's innocents.

The strange case of Barry Beach

bernice johnson alpine, ca. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 18:48:07 GMT

I would be interested in knowing the education of the parole board and their background. If they are tied to the ex-governer and others. There should be a more extensive explanation of their denial of parole for Berry Beach. There is such a huge injustice done to Beach by their lame reasoning.
The parole board appeared to be in 16th century. LIke they just walked out of the woods.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Veronica Woodall Elberton GA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:10:52 GMT

I was so upset over this story, I have seen alot of intrest from the public in different dicussion boards on internet today, so that is good to know there are people who believe in the innocence of Barry and I just can't see how they can inprision someone for 100 years with no more evidence then want they had, I mean please! I'd love to do something to help just don't know what to do. But there are people that have been proven with D&A and have not spent no where near 100 years in prison. I just can't believe there was no parole given to him.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Elona Autaubo, Oklahoma City, OK — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:11:20 GMT

I think Beach was targeted because he is part Native American. I think the sheriff was racially motivated and intimidated a 20 year old kid into confessing to a crime he did not commit. I think that those girls killed the girl and that her dad, who was a police officer covered it up for them, especially his daughter, because she is probably the one who did the killing. I think that the parole board was contacted by someone (I have no idea who) and was TOLD not to parole Beach. I hope that the truth comes out and that Beach will be released from prison. If not, the accusers and all those involved in covering up the case will all burn in hell.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tonie Monarres Phx. Az. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:22:54 GMT

I watched the program on April 4 ,2008 "The Killing at Polar River" It was truely strange. Confusing,Why Was All evidence not enough for this board.Or were they attracted to the faint smirk, that Barry had while beening interviewed.I kept thinking why is he smiling about.? Is it the camera? Or was it The class of witnesses? Which made the board think above them.( I am of the class of witness)

The strange case of Barry Beach

eleanor bat — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:23:15 GMT

I have neve been more upset over a case as this one. I am not sure if Beach is innocent or guilty . I do know that there was not enough evidence to convict him. What a sham that review board was. My partener said to me before the case was discussed that they would do nothing and he was right. The lessed they could have done was make him elegable for parole. The probblem with the justice system as far as I can see is that no one ever admitts they are wrong.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Unknown — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:23:39 GMT

Well In my opinion I believe Barry Beach is not guilty due to the fact that there was a few girls I believe that killed Kim Nees because of Jealousy. Even if he was guilty I believe they should still give him parole. There are so many murders and killing on the Fort Peck Reservation that nothing is done about it or solved. I was born in Poplar and raised in Wolf Point and you hear so much problems of girls being jealous of others, then all of sudden someone gets killed. I just don't think there is not enough justice being done on that reservation. There are probably so many people that killed someone and running free because of crooked law enforcement.

The strange case of Barry Beach

eleanor bart — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:24:04 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

C Borg — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:32:05 GMT

I am stunned! I saw the show last night and it's still on my mind a day later. I wish there was something that I could do to help that poor man. Keith Morrison, you did a great job!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dianne Hanson, Billings MT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:35:48 GMT

I am particularly interested in Barry's case. I lived in Plentwood MT about 80 mi.E. of Poplar, for 30 yrs. I believe Barry is innocent. Any time there is a chance of an innocent man dying, the case needs to be looked at again. I hope that those working hard for his release are succesful.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mike Kidd — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 19:52:44 GMT

Since the confession isn't shown in this story, I have to go by what is there. If this was a rage killing then the fact that the confession included that there was damage to the steering wheel is not believeable. Also no finger prints of the guy or footprints would mean that it would have been planned and rehearsed before being committed and even then evidence is always left. In the dark he would have needed to removed his footprints but leave all the rest. Then the unknown person who checked out the truck and left the bloody print would need to not come forward during this to say that they were the one who looked at the truck in the dark, got something wet on their hand, and left not knowing that a murder had taken place.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lisa, Tennessee — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:15:43 GMT

My parents and I watched last night. I feel for Barry. I feel there was enough said and presented that should have got him out on parole at least.
It is obvious that those who had the power to do so were influenced, as many people would be, the former prosecuter/former Governor of 2 terms. When there is evidence that many have confessed, yet they were innocent and surely it was obvious the man who described the electric chair would be easily capable of doing just what Barry said he did, and then there is NO DNA evidence linking Barry, yet one of the girls' dad who was a police officer stole evidence.
This should have been a mistrial the first time.
Why won't someone find out who the palm print belongs to? Barry has proven himself the past 25 years he should be given the benefit of the doubt and his freedom.
I'd like to say to Barry. I wish this had worked.
Don't give up. If you've accepted Jesus as your savior that is the most important thing in this life. You had the opportunity to influence many lives. Anything is possible for GOD. I hope you will find or have found peace.

With Christ's love,

Lisa

P.S.
Kim was born just 2 years before I was.
Her own sister was not outraged about Barry's hearing, in fact, she seemed to feel he was innocent.

Isn't there anything we can do to stop injustice of just because someone becomes Governor he can influence the fate of someone else's life?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Nancy Riha Portland Oregon — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:18:56 GMT

I am stunned at the out come I thought he would at least get parole. I have emailed the present Govener of Montana with my outrage at the lack of commitment to research the prints and the list.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Judy Stanfield, Phillipsville, CA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:20:39 GMT

This story really got to me. It seems to me that Barry Beach was rail-roaded by the cops back in 1979. How on earth can they convict someone just because they confess? And just who did he confess to but Louisiana cops, who are known to be corrupt. I thought they needed evidence to prove someone guilty and it seems quite suspicious that someone broke into the evidence room. Why was that person not questioned? Seems he was trying to destroy evidence that implicated his sister or daughter or whatever she was. To not even grant this man a new trial makes me think it is all about the good 'ol boy syndrome and rather makes me feel that I would never want to visit that part of Montana, because the government is so corrupt. It makes one more point that our legal system is flawed beyond repair.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Judy McLaughlin, Ione, WA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:37:02 GMT

I watched last night with hope that maybe the parole board had changed. But I was not shocked that they would not budge. If you are going to get in trouble don't do it in Montana. My son was sentenced to 80 years and had previously been sentenced to 25 for stabbing a boy that thankfully did not die. He needed help (he was 15), not prison. But this state has no tolerance or even accountability for when they convict someone wrongly. My heart goes out to Barry's mom. The system is so screwed up justice is not what is going on in it. The detectives lied to me and I still refused to grant them questioning my son, but they called back later and lied to his step-dad and got his permission. His confession should have been thrown out. They can lie and do wrong to get what they want but that is OK by them. I would love to tell you in detail how this state really deals with matters. I fortunately live in WA state.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tom Hart, Mountville, PA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:45:53 GMT

Great story! I don't believe justice was served and am not sure why they even convened the special hearing. Someone must have gotten to the board members before they issued their decision. It was a victory for the Montana political machine in protecting the ex-Governor.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Shannon, Traverse City Michigan — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:48:29 GMT

Wow, Im still thinking about this story after watching it last night. I want to believe that Beach had nothing to do with this but why on EARTH would you confess to something you did not do? You could poke a million needles in my eye before I would confess to a murder I didnt commit!! However, if he didnt do it..Man, all those wasted years in prison.
Usually when I watch these "True Crime" type shows Im convined from the beginning of guilt or innocence...this one has me baffled. Please keep us updated on the outcome of this very interesting and tragic story.
Thank you
Shannon

The strange case of Barry Beach

Laurel Boulds-Fisk, Newcastle, WA — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:51:45 GMT

I'm sitting here watching this and completely on the edge of my chair hanging onto every word. You see I grew up in Poplar, MT and graduated in 1978. I was attending Eastern Montana College at the time of Kim's brutal murder. I knew Kim, but I wasn't like a best friend or anything. But, I did hang out with some of her friends. Growing up in Poplar was not the best of times for me. Some of the so called bad girls mentioned were all around my age, I'm 48 now. Anyway, one of the girls mentioned I had a confrontation with 2 times during my high school years there in Poplar. Once, when I was a freshman and again when i was a Senior in High School. Both incidents not pretty. Every body knew them and most did their best to avoid any confrontations with them. I feel bad for Barry Beach and his family I graduated with his sister Barbara. All these years I believed he was guilty, but after seeing this Dateline Special I feel quite differently about it. Back then in the mid to late 70's the cops of Poplar were just as crooked as they come. If we were ever stopped they would confiscate your beer or dope and keep it for themselves. Yes, we were quite the partying town, not much else to do. My parents Drug Store got repeatedly broken into and nothing ever done about it. Even the latest breakin after my mom sold the building and hadn't quite gotten everything out yet. There were several witness, the police had a complete description of the car down to the sticker on back windshield, the 2 men and 1 woman. You think they could have caught these people, and probably even knew them. But, even if they did they probably got a slap on the wrist. That's how corrupt the police are in Poplar, they don't really care. I still fear for my sister and my mom there. I had nightmares for years after leaving Poplar that someone was going to Kill me and for no reason, but perhaps because I was white, blue eyes and blonde hair. It's funny how people perceived my family, just because my parents owned the local drug store there in Poplar for over 40 some years they assumed that we had it made that we were rich or something. We got buy, but we were by no means rich in the terms of financially. Well I'm going on and on here, this whole thing just brings up alot of painful memories what should have been the best years of my Life. My only hope is that the killer or killers come forward, but you think that will ever happen. If it does happen I'll be surprised. These killers will most likely take it to their grave. I wish to remain annonamys, only for fear of my family that still live in Poplar.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joanne C. Standerfer, Emmett, Idaho 83617 — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:55:59 GMT

What is wrong here in our great America? Anyone with just a half a brain, after watching this on Dateline, would KNOW this young man did not have anything to do with this girls murder.
You need to throw out everyone of the people on that board who denied him his freedom, and get people who know what they are doing and re-try him.
I beleive the sheriff or what ever he was, who went in the evidence room and tainted the evidence, who's daughter would not come and testify, is covering up for her. He and his daughter need to be investgated to thoroughly this time. Remember, the sister-in-law testified, her sister-in-law told her she just kicked the murdered girl in the head a few times. Which tells us she and maybe the other girls were there! Not that Barry was there, but the girls!
I was so upset with the way this ended, I couldn't sleep. Think about Barry Beach! Every day and every night, living with this over his head. He did not do it! Now he lives with men who really have killed someone, eats with them, sleeps in the same building with killers. This is so wrong.
To the Centurion's, Please don't give up. You are in the right. It will happen soon. You will prove him not guilty.
Barry, hang in there. Someday you will be free.
God Bless you all.
Joanne

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dan Kitzmiller, Cincinnati, Ohio — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 20:59:13 GMT

Do you think this man is innocent? It apppears from your story there is reasonable doubt as to his guilt. Why is Gov. Racicot hanging on so tightly to a confession made years later in La.? He seems to be smarter than that.

The strange case of Barry Beach

jane harvath — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 21:06:31 GMT

If Barry Beach did commit the murder then my husband and I feel 25 years is enough. He was a very young man and probably was scared to death being threatened in Louisana with the electric chair. We are certain his confession was coerced and he did not do it. The parole board (in our opinions) did not want to offend the former governor, sheriff, or detectives, I don't think they ever considered doing the right thing. We will never set foot in Montana if this is their type of justice. Shame on the Parole Board and everyone that didn't want their reputation tarnished, seemed justice wasn't the most important thing to do.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Stephanie Larkin, Columbia Falls, Montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 21:11:29 GMT

After watching A Killing At Poplar River last night, I had some lingering questions regarding the police officer in Poplar MT who broke into the evidence room and destroyed the physical evidence. I understood that his daughter was on of the alleged who could have done this. What came from that investigation of the police officers action? How ironic that the daughter had said she would show up at the hearing and then did not. I am in total shock that the Montana State Parole Board after reviewing and hearing the witnesses testimony did not at the very least probe futher into the investigations findings. I am a resident of Montana and would like to think that our public officials would see that possibly this case would warrant further investigation. I can only say that at the end of the show I felt that the law enforcement in Poplar Montana was protecting the killer or killers.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Laura Lee Callahan Great Falls, Mt — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 21:17:03 GMT

I have read many articles on Mr. Beach while living in Montana. After watching the dateline episode, I cannot help but wonder if he was not kept in prison because of a police cover up. It is the only thing that makes sense to me, and several others, after hearing the facts presented on Dateline. For starters, why , if he confessed, did they 'misplace & lose the tape' ? Was he coerced into this confession? Because, if he was, as he has claimed, it would answer THAT ONE BIG question if they had not LOST that taped 'confession'. The police also conveniently lost the one hair sample found at the scene. It smells like a rat to me, and many others that have watched the Dateline episode. We cannot help but be led to the assumption that a police officer was involved, maybe even responsible for her death. Also, I am sure the Board of Pardons will hear much static from this Dateline episode. They seemed to not even be open , had their minds already made up, before even hearing his case recently. I am a follower of cases of this type, believe most are guilty, manipulative, and sociopaths, but I am not sure of Mr. Beachs guilt. What else can we do ??????

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sharon, Baltimore Maryland — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 21:26:08 GMT

This man is innocent! Come on the parole board just don't want to go against the former governor.They are afraid to say he never proved his case. Picture any 17 year old being an "outsider" in the south being threatened with the electric chair, no matter what he said, or going back home. The so called "story" that the police would help him if he confessed makes perfect sense to anybody with any forensic experience. It only sounds like a "story" to those naive enough to believe that,"that kind of stuff just don't happen". Just listen to the stories of any law enforcement relative. This man needs help.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Barbra Green — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 21:27:56 GMT

This is one of the saddest stories I have ever read.......It is remarkable that this man has sooo much courage to stand up for himself and try repeadily to regain his freedom! Its too bad that the justice sytem is so curupt in the form that it can not correct its errors! or at least live up to them! I pray for this wrongly accused individual and hope that something can be done so he can live whatever kind of life remains for him!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Julia Doolittle, Shreveport, Louisiana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 21:30:06 GMT

I was totally enraged after watching your broadcase last night. It was so obvious that the parole board is appointed by the Governor. I don't understand how you can commit a man to life in prison without parole without any hard evidence whatsoever to keep him there. It was so evident that he is not the personal who should be in prison, Sissy and the other girls should have been looked at more closely, especially the girl whose father was the police officer who detroyed the evidence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Becky Bragg Glasgow Ky. — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 22:01:54 GMT

I watched this show knowing that at the end it was going to show this man hugging his mom. I was shocked when the show ended and he is still in jail. I can't believe they did'nt set this man free it's so sad!!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

EDWARD MILLER DERWOOD, MARYLAND — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 22:26:00 GMT

I WATCHED THE DATELINE SHOW ON BARRY BEACH AND I HAD A COUPLE OF THOUGHTS
(1) DID BARRYS DEFENSE STAFF RUN HIM THRU A NUMBER OF POLYGRAPHS TO VERIFY HE WAS IN FACT THRUTHFUL?
(2) I WOULD SEARCH MORE COMRADE AND WORKER TESTIMONY ABOUT THE WOMAN THAT WAS THE DRUG ADDICT THAT WAS SUPPOSEDLY HEARD MAKING STATEMENTS THAT SHE AND OTHER GIRLS HAD DONE THE KILLING OF THE NEES GIRL.
(3) DID THE KILLINGS IN THE SOUTHERN STATE STOP AFTER BARRY BEACH WAS SENT BACK TO MONTANA FOR TRIAL?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lois Western Montana — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 22:37:10 GMT

I believe Mr. Beach to be innocent. I watched Dateline last evening, and believe Mr. Raciot swayed the Board.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Beverly Harris, Carmel, IN — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 22:49:36 GMT

IT IS QUITE OBVIOUS THAT THE FORMER GOVERNOR OF MONTANA HAD A LOT OF INFLUENCE IN THE DECISION MADE BY THE BOARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SHAME ON THEM ALL!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jeannie Ulrich Mandan, ND — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 22:54:17 GMT

How does the parole board sleep at night? There was absolutely no evidence that Beach was guilty with the exception of his bogus confession. A perfect example of justice gone wrong. I was so infuriated at the end of this very sad story. Why can't the prosecutor and detective admit they were wrong. Has anyone given Beach a lie detector test? Too much of this type of justice going on in the US!!! PRETTY SAD.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Missy Clutter, Clarksburg, WV — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 23:06:38 GMT

Thank you Dateline for Again bringing to light another amazing story.
I am amazed that Barry Beach remains in our system. As an American Christian, who Thanks God everyday for my many blessings, I am amazed that our system cannot admit when a mistake is made. This man did not do this crime. I will pray for him and his family.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Karen Gunier, Holt, Missouri — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 23:22:30 GMT

I am appalled that this man was not given clemency. I am ashamed of the board, the sheriff and the former prosecuting attorney. It is more than obvious they are more concerned about how bad they will look because they were wrong, than they are about keeping an innocent man in prison. I think all of them should be hooked up to a polygraph and asked some very direct questions to see how honest they are and where their ego's rate. It is people like them that should be in jail. Not one shred of evidence did they find showing that man was there. They dismiss all the evidence that was their. Shame on them, Shame on them and especially shame on that sheriff and the prosecuting attorney who then became governor. This case is probably one case that helped him become governor and he did nothing but make himself look like a FOOL on National TV. I surely am glad he was not my governor. Sham;e, Shame, Shame on everyone. This is a HORRIFIC CASE OF COMPLETE INJUSTICE. A BLIND MAN COULD SEE THROUGH THIS ONE!

Barry Beach I AM SO VERY SORRY, SO VERY, VERY SORRY!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tony Schmitz Wyoming — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 23:32:51 GMT

Thank you Dateline for covering this story and thank you Keith fr asking tough questions.

The strange case of Barry Beach

J. Greene Carson City, Nevada — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 23:34:20 GMT

The Dateline article brought back some memories of my time in Poplar, and this only pertains to the Atkinson family. Sissy was a few years younger then I was and she was basically nonexistant kid to me at that time. J.D. was a major thorn in my side as we had always clashed, but that was a part of growing up. J.D.'s prison testimony aganinst Sissy under duress by Montana's legal system seems very crediable to me. I would go to my grave supporting J.D.'s testimony because I know him to be an honest person.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Patti Smith — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 23:42:26 GMT

I couldn't believe that the Montana Board of Pardon and Parole could ignore all the indications that Beach was not at all the most likely suspect here. The implied involvement of Maude Grayhawk and her policeman father should have totally discredited the prosecution's position. It seems that being connected with the law in Montana makes you invincible! I truly hope that there is a groundswell of objection to this decision even after all the evidence that has been presented in Beach's defense. I, for one, would be glad to help the Centurion group keep working to get him out of prison. Enough is enough!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Marietta Jaeger Lane, Three Forks, MT — Sat, 05 Apr 2008 23:57:44 GMT

I am a friend of Barry Beach and a believer in his innocence. I am also the mother of a little girl who was a kidnap-murder victim, lest I sound like "a bleeding-heart liberal). I watched your DATELINE special re him on Friday, April 4. Thank you for publicizing his situation nationally! All we can hope and pray for is that your program will generate new info, leads, etc.
I do wish, however, that more information had been presented re Barry's intensive interrogation, i.e. the number (approx. 17) of hours he was questioned (badgered, harrangued, threatened, intimidated)without interruption or relief by teams of two men, each taking a two-hour stint, and the fact that throughout all those hours he was not given any food, drink or allowed even a bathroom break! That kind of info might help folks realize why/how he finally "broke weak".
Also, I appreciate your inclusion (near the end of the program) of Barry's sister's confirmation of his presence at home in bed at the time of the crime, especially her statement that her testimony was offered but disallowed at the time of the trial, and then Racicot's stupid question about why she "waited for 25 years" to come forth with that testimony. The system and the politicos involved simply do not want to hear, let alone admit, the horrendous injustice that has been done to Barry! Especially since one of the main "law enforcement officers" who had been involved in the case is currently running for the office of Montana State Supreme Court Judge.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Phyllis Blevins, Lincoln, CA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 00:05:23 GMT

Re: Barry Beach, why has no one looked into the law inforcement "person" who broke into the evidence locker? - was that person destroying evidence - could it be that that person's family member was involved in the murder? Why was this never brought up in the trial? Why was "everyone" who was interviewed "sooo positive of where they were etc. (ex: the two girls who said they were home at 11:00p.m. BOTH at precisely 11:00p.m.but stated otherwise by the "bartender" at the bar that night?) Why is Mark Roscoe SO POSITIVE if his evidence? Is this a cover-up for a prominent person's daughter? Are they all afraid to talk? Why are some of the girls "not available"? Have they left town - and if so, why? This man is innocent - who's covering up???? I wonder why Dateline has not followed up on this? (You don't miss much! Afraid of a prominent person like Mark Roscoe? By the way, he looks very hagard! My comments only.

Phyllis Blevins

The strange case of Barry Beach

Denise,stacy,mn — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 00:41:31 GMT

It's pretty easy to see Barry Beach is an innocent man. How very sad he has lost so many years of his life behind bars. I hope he isn't forgotten. Thank god for these wonderful men trying so hard to prove his innocence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

j.m.raadt savage, mn. — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 00:52:07 GMT

amazing. if this is all the evidence i don't see how
they could convict this guy of anything. there is more
doubt here than you can shake a stick at. was the parole board sleeping, check out the lady of the left.
to the parole board, sheriff, and the sanctimonious
prosicutor, remember to ask the lords forgiveness
before he sends you to hell.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joe Smith pheonix az — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 01:03:32 GMT

I don't understand why they just don't try to match the fingeprints or habdprints up with the other suspects they first had. I also do not understand why the father of one of those suspected girls (the police officer who broke into the evidence and destroyed it) was not arrested for tampering with evidence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Gregg B. Dery, Appleton, Wisconsin — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 01:04:42 GMT

What needs to be done and how can I help? Surely, the sitting governor could set things right.

The strange case of Barry Beach

M. Kerner — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 01:18:49 GMT

No question about it. Those skanky girls (now old ladies)killed Kim. I wasn't surprised to see how inept that county sheriff handled everything, not even getting palm prints from all the parties of interest. I lived in Montana for a while and experienced first hand the "good old boys" network, which was evident from the prosecutor (now ex-governor)to the idiots on the parole board with the low IQ's. I hope Barry can get a new trial and be able to present ALL the forensics.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jennifer rOgers, Princeton, NJ — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 02:08:03 GMT

Keith -- What a wonderful ability you have to draw the viewer into the narrative! I taped the show and watched it tonight...Immediate reactions? the former governor and prosecutor has a lot of political sway...also, a question: why can't prints (too bad it's too late for DNA)be taken from the 4 women in question?...love the ministries guys...I'm from a family of lawyers but just fyi, people DON'T CONFESS TO A CRIME WITHOUT A LAWYER PRESENT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jean Snow Saratoga, California — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 02:14:53 GMT

Your show last night on Barry Beach was so moving I'm surprised you haven't had any other comments at this time. It is my hope that someone with influence in this area will come forward to help this wrongly accused man. The Montana board who listened to the evidence presented by the ministers, Barry's sister, his mother and his neighbors must have been hard of hearing. And, in his confession Barry talked about a plastic bag and dragging the body by the shoulders. No plastic bag was found and she was dragged by her feet. No blood evidence was ever found. His confession given to that monster sheriff in Texas made sense to me. He was harassed and terrified by his interragator. There is absolutely nothing to prove he was even close by. His sister saw him asleep in his bed on that night and morning. The crime may never be solved but they sure have the wrong person locked up for 100 years. This is a terrible injustice!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Victoria Lambkin, Boston, MA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 03:10:55 GMT

I found this episode of Dateline very interesting and compelling. As a fond reader, I recently finished John Grisham's novel The Innocent Man about Ron Williamson and Dennis Fritz who were wrong convicted of murdering a woman in Oklahoma. This case, with the confession occurring around the same time as the Williamson case have striking similarities. I think this should have been pointed out in the program. The "dream confession" that was used to convict Williamson and Beech's "they told me to make up a scenario in which I was the perpetrator" are very much in the same category. I am outraged at the injustices that occurred to so many people in the 1980's, but am also not surprised that none of these convictions took place in a metropolitan area. It seems like the smaller towns in the US were able to get away with violating civil rights in order to "get their man". I very much enjoyed this program and look forward to watching another.

The strange case of Barry Beach

A. MCDOWELL, RUTHERFORDTON, NC — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 03:34:04 GMT

HE IS INNOCENT.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Von Shipman, Valdosta, GA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 04:12:15 GMT

This dude needs to be set free. He is innocent of the crime.

The strange case of Barry Beach

db — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 04:16:53 GMT

I think the parole board who listened to the 2nd hearing are not interested in any real facts since they are looking at this case through a keyhole. Hopefully, his attorneys will be able to take it to a higher level and perhaps a "real" trial. db

The strange case of Barry Beach

jane doe — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 04:52:57 GMT

he is not guilty of anything FREE Barry

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tim Price, Spokane, Washington — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 06:11:28 GMT

I watched your show last night (4/4/08). That Sissy Atkinson is as guilty as can be. I didn't like her; she lied and gave off bad vibes. You ask how can I justify this remark? I was born and raised in Billings, Montana and spent twenty years in the Air Force. Seven of those years was Special Duty as a Military Training Instructor at Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio, Texas. My job there was to train recruits for military service. I learned how to tell those who told the truth from those who lied. When ever I had a recruit who wasn't honest I could feel it in my gut. Watching Sissy Atkinson gave me that same gut wrenching feeling. If she didn't deal the death blows to that girl herself, she was the person who made it happen by soemone elses hand.

The strange case of Barry Beach

wendy — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 06:17:09 GMT

I watched the video...sorry, but I think the guy did it. I don't like him, would not trust him at all. He appears to be highly manipulative, a con, someone who thinks he is above it all. I think the parolees probably know more than us and we have to trust them. According to them, he knew details that went alongside the evidence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jake, Texas — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 06:48:47 GMT

This is so unbelievable. There is no conclusive evidence to prove he is guilty. Therefore Barry Beach should be released from prison- even if there was a feeling/vibe that he could be guilty. What happened to being innocent until proven guilty?? They have to let him go.

In addition, the crime scene was a mess and never should have been handled in the manner it was. Any idiot would know that. Perhaps they should go after the detectives, police, etc. I find this so disturbing and have to believe there is corruption of some sort going on with those involved in the case.

Interrogation does not work. People can, have and will continue to admit to things they never did under pressure. This has been documented time and time again. I could totally see myself admitting to something I never did out of fear under pressure- perhaps I would even believe that I did do it if someone repeatedly told me I did.

The strange case of Barry Beach

M. Rich, San Diego, CA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 06:57:12 GMT

After watching this story on Dateline I was shocked at the verdict of the three person panel. This appears to be, at least from the info we have received from the Dateline story, a real miscarriage of justice! What a tragedy, first, for Kim Nees and her family. Then Barry Beach & his family. I wonder if this case is an example of "the good ole boy network" at it's finest and the police "brotherhood" protecting one another? From the prosecutor, the sheriffs, to the 3 person panel. That is my perception - this case MUST be heard by a much higher court, even if it has to go to the State & then Federal Supreme Courts. What a shame our justice system seems to work so slowly. I hope Dateline keeps us up-to-date on the progress of this case. Bless those Centurions and I can only hope they will press on until Barry is a free man - or until the prosecution can prove beyond a shadow of a doubt (other than the false confession) that Barry is truly guilty.

The strange case of Barry Beach

PHYLLIS MANION LOUISVILLE KY — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 08:25:42 GMT

THIS IS SO VERY UNBELIEVABLE. I CRIED WHEN THE SHOW WAS OVER THE FORMER DA ALSO FORMER GOV. OF MONTANA AND THE RETIRED ENTERIGATOR BOTH GAVE ME THE CREEPS AS DID THE CRACK ADDICT PATTY. THEY HAVE GUILTY ALL OVER THEIR FACES WHAT ABOUT THE POLICEMANS, DAUGHTER ? I AM STILL IN SHOCK OVER ALL OF THIS THAT WAS A DIRTY POLICE FORCE AND THE EX GOV AND ALL OF HIS FANCY TALK DID NOT IMPRESS ME AT ALL. I WILL PRAY FOR MR BEACH AND HIS FAMILY, WHAT AN INJUSTICE I HOPE THE GRAND JURY CAN SEE THROUCH ALL THE SMOKE AND MIRRORS

The strange case of Barry Beach

Gary M Paddock Tucson Arizona — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 10:54:55 GMT

Having watched the show and the support Mr Beach has from so many people, I feel strongly that he should be pardoned and released. Please advise as to what one can do to see this done.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Francesca Walker — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 11:19:01 GMT

Mr Morrison, I am unable to find any information regarding Mr. Barry Beach. He was the focus of your broadcast on April4,2008. This was an exclusive on dateline's part. May I ask are there any updates on this man's whereabouts or how one would correspond to offer hope and encouragement. You see My soon-to be -released on parole husband has undergone and perserved through some of the worst conditions while in the kentucky dept. of corrections. They have abused him destroyed his personal property and have just tried every wich way they can to block his parole. I do want to offer barry hope and encouragement andf allow him to know bad things happen to good people. May I look forwarsd to your prompt and corteous reply? Thank You, Francesca Walker.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Eileen Laraway/Connecticut — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 11:49:31 GMT

Hello,
I was VERY upset to hear that the parole board refused to free Barry Beach. Can you give me information on how to write or call Barry and the group who tried to help get him released (the Centerians?)This is the first time I have been moved to email anyone this has greatly affected me. Thank you for your time.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bob Hewes New Smyrna Beach, FL. — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 13:34:21 GMT

If there ever was a case of extreme reasonable doubt, this is it. If all the factors that came up at the hearing were brought forth in the original Barry Beach trial, he certainly would have walked. Another case in America, where the defendant did not have the money to hire a good defense. (See OJ trial)

The strange case of Barry Beach

Brenda Leonard, Richmond, VA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 13:43:43 GMT

I missed the beginning of the story, but I sense that lies were told either to save face, cover up criminal activity or protect someone of high ranking position. What was the motive? Did the victim have knowledge that needed to be hushed, perhaps a crime ring among the authorities? Did she have a relationship with someone of authority? If the girls were the murderers how did they leave the scene? Can the governor of the state call to reopen the investigation since the local law enforcement was uncooperative in letting the evidence be scrutinized by todays technology? There seem to be a lot of areas that need further investigation.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jennifer - London, ON — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 13:54:40 GMT

After watching the program aired on April 4th, I can't believe Barry Beach is still in prison. It seems too obvious that he is innocent!?!?! I just really think he has not been given a fair chance - what about the group of girls...... I don't believe they are completely innocent! What a tragedy!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Steve Pike, Springfield, Missouri — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 14:22:09 GMT

Keith:

I watched your report on Friday night. Please keep hounding these Montana folks. This looks like a clear case of people in power too proud to admit they might have made a mistake. The conclusion of the Board of Pardons was bizarre.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carmen, Summerfield, FL — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 14:51:32 GMT

Seems to be the "good ol' boy's" up in Montana have won again; their "opinion" is what keeps Barry Beach in prison, instead of the FACTS. UNbeleivable what the higher ups do with their Power in this country!! Must Pray for God to intervene! I wish Mr. Beach well.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Priscilla Goodrich Brooklyn, Mi — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 14:58:49 GMT

The parole board; the one in the middle must be Sybill's mother and the two wimpy's on the end don't have a say so in the matter. I doubt one bit if they even discuss the case. They must be living in the early ninteen hundreds. Cops stick to their guns they don't want to be embrassed by their ignorance, and of course that goes for the prosecutor also. I think the man is not guilty and the cops in the south probably did scare him half to death. If he is guilty then show the evidence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carla Amann, Youngstown,Ohio — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 15:18:45 GMT

I watched this fascinating program and sat in utter disbelief at the final outcome. How could the Montana Board of Pardon and Patrols hear the same evidence I heard, yet translate it in a totally different manner? Barry Beach is an innocent man and Centurion Ministries proved that beyond the shadow of a doubt. Two people lost their lives that night, but one of them has a chance (and deserves that chance) to begin theirs again. I'd like to know what I can do to help give Barry Beach that chance.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dave Smith, Atlanta, GA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 15:22:07 GMT

Unbelievable! What a travesty of justice. The accuser himself should be put in prison; he is just another example of someone more interested in their own career. What good is accomplished by having a person such as Barry have to languish in prison the rest of his life when there is so much to cloud the charge of his being guilty? It makes one sick at heart to see how the parole panel could not come to a different decision. Doesn't the court of public opinion carry any weight?

The strange case of Barry Beach

DOROTHY JEANNE DAGOSTINO, CHESTER,PENNA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 15:22:30 GMT

i watched this story because my so is serving a life sentense without parol in penna; and he also told untruth to police , because of their questions;we didn't have the money to fight i wish i could find someone to fight with me;he has seved 11 years in pa state prison. great story keep things like this to open the outside people the wrong justice done to so many, thank-you so much.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Eric Simmons, Stevensville, Mt — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 16:03:27 GMT

There are keys in the ignition of the Nees' truck in photo #6. Was this photo taken later after the truck was driven somewhere or as found at the scene? If this photo is as the truck was found then anoher inconsistency exists concerning testimony about the keys.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cat Geiger — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 16:07:05 GMT

I do believe Barry is innocent. I can't believe after hearing all of the evidence, the pardon's committee didn't free him. I will be praying for Barry and for justice in this case.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bobby Skaggs, Goodyear , Az — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 16:21:18 GMT

What happened to the cop that broke into the evidence locker and stole evidence critical to this case?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Barrie Boulds, West Yellowstone, MT — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 16:27:13 GMT

Bravo Dateline! What wasn't mentioned in your story was that Sissy Atkinson's brother, Robert "Bobby" Atkinson was the Chief of Police in Poplar during the murder!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Patricia McWilliams Visalia , Calif 93277 — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 18:02:45 GMT

I just seen this dateline show, and beleive that barry is indeed wrongly convicted. I would like to write to barry and corrispond if possible. thank you.
I am so sorry for the mother Bobbi Clincher.God Bless and keep you and Barry strong.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Janice Foster — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 18:02:52 GMT

I think this case is rediculous. Anyone with half a brain could tell this guy is innocent. Why he confessed( I don't know) Is't there some kind of justice for him. I would like to write to him, if for nothing but moral support. I haven't thought of much else since I seen this Friday evening. It is so wrong!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Elease King, Kaysville Utah — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 18:08:13 GMT

I would like to send a little money to the Cheritable group that is trying to free Barry Beach. Please send me their address. I was outraged at the state board's decision to fall into line with the original prosecuter, the now powerful govenor and others. I feel certain that there are people in Poplar who have been protected from the very beginning. I am personally aware that occasionally a police officer will turn attention away from people he chooses to protect. It probably took the whole three weeks for the powerful political pressure to convince EVERY ONE on that parole board to get in line for their "unanimous" decision. I feel OUTRAGED.
Sincerely, Elease King

The strange case of Barry Beach

Lorene H, Penticton, BC, Canada — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 18:23:33 GMT

I would like to know how to contact Barry Beach? Does he have an email address? yahoo address? msn address? Please let me know. I would love to be able to support him and just feel he needs to hear from all of us. Thank you.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jim, Oakland, CA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 18:35:20 GMT

Prosecutors, judges, parole boards are notoriously unwilling to admit an error, notoriously committed to sticking up for each other no matter what. The physical evidence against Mr. Beach is non-existent. What physical evidence does exist points towards others. And the evidence that the confession was coerced and manipulated is overwhelming.

It is extremely frightening to see how easily someone can be framed and how little they can do about it afterwards. Cases like this would make me quite reluctant to convict anyone of a serious crime while serving on a jury. How would you know that you weren't be lied to and manipulated by the police and the prosecutors?

If the honest police and prosecutors out there want to preserve their reputation, they should be in the forefront of demanding new trials in cases like this.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Michelle Stutts, Andrews, SC — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 18:45:42 GMT

This is a horrible story. This man has spent more time in prison than most murderers. Why won't the state just release him and let him go on with his life. He seems to have made the most of this bad situition. And turned out to be a decent person, despit his situition. None of the states evidence points to hil, except for the corrupt police mans sorry attempt to frame him. Let him out!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cassandra Lovelace Cathedral City, CA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 19:55:24 GMT

From your story it is not right that a 17 yr old is in jail for life with no evidence except a coerced confession. Must answer who do the finger prints belong to. Must answer who broke in and took evidence that was in police control. I think from watching the show that it was someone related to law inforcement or someone in law inforcement. Don't understand how under oath false statement was given on hair belonging to Barry was not a true statement. Something is very wrong in POPLAR..

The strange case of Barry Beach

Neva Spotted Wolf, Glasgow, MT — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 21:16:09 GMT

First of all, I would like to buy a copy of the Tape "Killing at Poplar River". You know, I went to school with Barry and Kim. I lived next door to Laurie on the westend right across the street from the water tower. We were best friends, Kim also, we would hang out all the time after school. Kim and Laurie were a grade ahead of Barry and I. Hell,all of us used to play kick the can together on the block Kim and Barry used to live, which was on the other side of the water tower. Those were the days. Anyways what I'm getting at is, I know how Poplar can be. I experienced it,when I came to Poplar and started 6th grade a group of girls wanted to beat me up just because I was new and from Frazer. Laurie and Kim became my friends not only because we lived by each other but because they weren't like that and I wasn't used to fighting believe me you learn eventually how to defend yourself quick in that town. So I know how girls can be there, cruel and jealous. That's what it was, jealousy. I believe it was those girls who did this to my friend. Centurion Ministries came to me about 2 years ago and asked if I knew something relating to this case. Heck, I told him, "if I knew something then, I would of spoke up and the person(s) who did this would be in prison. And Barry wouldn't be where he is today. And Kim would be resting at peace. Seeing Sissy on TV made me sick, lying b-----, you could just tell she was high, probably on pills. And to use that lame excuse, "I got a drug problem". I used to like Maude but that coward couldn't even come forward is beyond me. You know what comes around goes around that's why all these things that have happened in their lives and their kids lives which hasn't been good. I hope and pray something comes out of this by you airing that tape. I can't wait to put flowers on Kim's grave and a ribbon that says " you can finally rest in peace, my friend". And maybe go with Barry to the Nascar races when rightful justice is done.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Leslie Langdon Renton, Washington — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 21:39:55 GMT

What about lie detector tests for Barry and his sister. I really can't believe that he is quilty as charged.I'm also quite surprised that no one else has made a comment about this program. I hope the Centurion Ministries doesn't give up on him. I truely believe he is innocent. What possible motive could he have had? Versus the jealous girls?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tara, Spokane Washington — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 22:02:13 GMT

Can someone please ask President Bush to free Beach before he leaves office? Beach obviously didn't do it. Did Sissy Atkinson ever take a polygraph test? Way too many unanswered questions in this story!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Katrina , Idaho — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 22:16:56 GMT

The interview lead by keith Morrison was very thought provoking and unsettling in how the events played out in this case. It is obvious that Barry Beach was and has remained a person well liked by many indivuals in the community as well as the mayor and others.
It seems that the sheriffs and his attorneys are hiding evidence perhaps one of thier own and there for are adamant that Barry is Guilty. I would highly suspect the sheriff who was telecast and "preasured" Barry to confess. I say if none of the prints match Barry or the ring of girls what about the police. When the evidence doesn't match and yet the police won't back down it seems fishy. They are hiding something. This was well presented and should be persued further.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Annie W., Atlanta, GA — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 22:30:20 GMT

How can we help this man?????

The strange case of Barry Beach

James Folds, Salem, Ohio — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 22:30:34 GMT

Why is it the prosecuter, parole board and law enforcement officers involved in this case so sure Barry is guilty, while the townspeople of Poplar, including the victim's sister so doubtful? Are their egos so big that they have lost their ability to reason. As for the prosecuter/ex-govenor, he offers no real basis for his opinion other than if he says so then it is so. That 'confession' is is no better the 'physical evidence', and certainly not suffcient to put someone away for life.

The strange case of Barry Beach

MARY, FALLON, NV — Sun, 06 Apr 2008 22:49:32 GMT

AFTER READING THIS STORY I WILL NEVER BE THE SAME. I WANT TO BELIEVE WE LIVE IN A COUNTRY WHERE MANKIND CAN HELP ONE ANOTHER, NOT SEND SOMEONE TO PRISION WHO EVEN THOUGH THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE TO DO SO. THAT A YOUNG MAN MAY BE BROW BEAT INTO A CONFESSION BY SOME EGO GLUTEN COP. THE EVIDENCE THAT WAS PROVIDED WAS OVERWHELMING THAT BARRY IS INNOCENT AND SHOULD NOT BE IN PRISION FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE. HE HAS MORE THEN SERVED ENOUGH TIME EVEN IF HE HAD COMMINTED THE CRIME, WHICH HE DID NOT DO. I FEAR FOR MY GRNADCHILDERN, THAT THERE ARE SUCH COLD HEARTED PEOPLE IN POWER, WHO HAVE NO REGARD FOR ANYONE BUT THEMSELVES. THE EVIDENCE THAT WAS PROVIDED PROVEDBEYOND A DOUBT THAT BARRY WAS AN INNOCENT MAN WHO HAS BEEN PUT BEHIND BARS FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE. WHAT IF THAT HAD HAPPENDED TO ONE OF OUR LOVED ONES OR THEIRS FOR THAT MATTER. MAY GOD HAVE MERCY ON THEIR SOULS, WHEN THEY NEED TO ANWSER WHY THEY LET A MAN STAY BEHIND BARS FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE, WHEN HE WAS INNOCENT. ALL IN THE NAME OF THEM KEEPING THEIR NAMES CLEAR AND NOT BEING ABLE TO ADMIT THEY MAY HAVE MADE A MISTAKE. I AM SO ANGRY AND UPSET BY THIS, I FEEL AS IF I WILL NEVER FEEL THE SAME WAY ABOUT OUR JUDICAL SYSTEM OR TRUST PEOPLE WHO RESPERSENT US EVER AGAIN. I WILL PRAY EVERY NIGHT THAT BARRY WILL BE REALSED AS HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN YEARS AGO. MY NEPHEW AND ANOTHER YOUNG MAN WERE HIT AND KILLED LIKE ANIMALS BY A DRUNK DRIVER, THIS WAS NOT HIS FIRST OFFENSE FOR DRUNK DRIVING. HE WAS ONLY GIVEN TWO YEARS IN PRISION. WHAT IS WRONG WITH MONTANA AND THEIR JUDICAL SYSTEM, IS IT REALLY THAT CORRUPT. MAY GOD HAVE MERCY ON ALL OF YOU AND MAY GOD BLESS BARRY.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Deborah Fitzpatrick, East Greenbush, New York — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 00:15:26 GMT

I have never written in response to a story but this story is just not leaving my mindI keep thinking about it all the time.
This case seems so messed up,even if Mr. Beach did commit this murder so long ago, He is a changed man, that made a serious mistake as a kid.He has paid his dues. So many worse crimes have been committed and done less prison time. Even the murder victim's sister thinks he is noy guilty. What is up with no chance of parole! Even Charles Manson has parole hearings!
Please where can we start a petition or email to get this man released?

The strange case of Barry Beach

stephanie foy elliottsburg, pa — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 00:17:14 GMT

i truely believe he is not guilty, why can't they make those other girls give dna or finger prints? why did the one girls father (a cop) break into the evidence room? if that were a kennedy it would have turned out different. come on date line, you can do something, you're powerful

The strange case of Barry Beach

Nikki North, Excelsior,Mn — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 02:07:31 GMT

Those involved in the legal process which put Barry Beach in prison for murder appear to be more interested in protecting their political reputations rather than whether justice was achieved. If the holes in the so called "confession" of a scared 21 yr. old along with the overwhelming lack of physical evidence doesn't plant even a seed of doubt in the minds of Beach's accusers (not to mention all the other testimony in his favor), maybe such devine talent should be used to help O.J. find Nicole's killer

The strange case of Barry Beach

Amy Sims — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 02:55:36 GMT

I do beleive that Barry Beach is innocent. I have heard from people and even been told by an ivestagator,(when my son was in jail) they told me if he would just admit to what happened then he could come home, well he sdid admit and just like barry, it wasnt so. They fooled me so i do honestly beleive that they did that to Barry Beach. It seems like they are not as willing to to do DNA and prove his innocence as they were to putting him behind bars. Oh it is so sad to me, and they know they are wrong WRONG for doing people this way.

The strange case of Barry Beach

B. Arneth buffalo .new york — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 03:09:09 GMT

thank you for the story on berry baach.my heart gos out to him and his family. this is one more innocent person that I can add to my list of a unfare justices system. I to have been fighting along with my brother for 15 years to prove his innocents.I have even refused to sit on a jury because of the injustices my brother recived.if possble maybe just maybe you can help me find someone to look at the facts of my brother case they would be astonsed at the inconsistents of facts and how laws were not follow or just plain out ignored. so can you please please help me to find justices not only for my brother but for the victim. thanl you.

The strange case of Barry Beach

NONNIE SCHNAUFER, 49 ROOSEVELT AVE. WEST HAVEN CT 06516 — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 03:17:27 GMT

FIRST, I WANT TO THANK DATELINE FOR AIRING BARRY'S STORY. THE NUMBER OF WRONGY IMPRISSONED PEOPLE IS HORENDOUS AND A DISGRACE TO THE JUSTICE SYSTEM AND A GROSS DISSERVICE TO THE VICTOM, THE VICTOMS FAMILY AND THE COMMUNITY. FEW YEARS AGO MY 11YR OLD DAUGHTER WATCHED A NEWS SHOW (NOT SURE WHICH ONE) WHERE A PERSON WAS LOCKED UP FOR A GREAT DEAL OF TIME UNTIL OFFICIALS FINALLY FOUND THE REAL KILLER. SINCE THEN SHE HAS SAID SHE IS GOING TO BECOME A DEFENCE ATTORNEY TO HELP PEOPLE WRONGLY ACCUSED-SHE IS NOW 14 AND STILL HAS THE SAME GOAL. AFTER SEEING THIS SHOW ON DATELINE I AM SICK TO MY STUMACHE THAT THIS POOR MAN HAS LOST SO MUCH OF AND WILL CONTINUE TO LOSE HIS LIFE AS AN INNOCCENT IMPROSONED MAN. I FEEL LIKE I NEED TO DO SOMETHING BUT DON'T KNOW WHAT OR HOW. IF THERE IS ANYTHING I COULD DO PLEASE FOR BARRYS SAKE AND THE SAKE OF KIM NEES AND HER FAMILY LET ME KNOW. I TRULEY FEEL THAT THE DETECTIVES, THE MONTANA GOVERNOR (FORMER PROSECUTER), AND OTHER LAW OFFICIALS ARE DOING EVERYTHING IN THIER POWER TO KEEP THIS MAN IN PRISON-TO PROTECT A CHILD OF "ONE OF THIER OWN" (THE COP OF ONE OF THE GIRLS 1ST SUSPECTED AND TO KEEP FROM LOOKING LIKE FOOLS; BY GOING AS FAR AS THREATENING EVERYONE ON BARRYS DEFENSE AND MOST LIKELY THE APPEALS COMMITTY. WHY ELSE WOULD IT TAKE 3WKS FOR AN ANSWER THEY ALL FELT SO STRONGLY ABOUT? YOU'D THINK THEY WOULD HAVE GIVEN AN ANSWER WITH IN TH 1ST WEEK ESPECIALLY BECAUSE OF THE CONVICTION IN THEIR ANSWER. PLEASE TELL BARRY-GOD HAS A REASON FOR HIM BEING IN PRISON. EVEN IF IT FEELS LIKE GOD IS PUNISHING HIM-LOOK @ THE LIFE OF THE FEMALE GUARD HE SAVED-I'M SURE HE'LL DO EVEN MORE WONDERFUL THINGS WHILE HE'S THERE. IN THE MEAN TIME WE WILL PRAY FOR HIM.
THANKS AGAIN.
SINCERELY,
NONNIE SCHNAUFER

The strange case of Barry Beach

marie pa — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 03:54:28 GMT

I cannot believe the parole board denied him parole, clemency, a new trial anything. Thank goodness I do not live in Montana!! If Barry Beach's case is not full of reasonable doubtI do not know what is!! What a miscarriage of justice!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Post My Opinion, Atlanta, GA — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 04:49:33 GMT

I have just finished watching the video clips of the Dateline program about Barry Beach. Until recently, I had no knowledge of this case, but have researched it online as thoroughly as possible these past few weeks. The Dateline program was one of the last things I reviewed.

It is hard to believe this nightmare can continue in America. Good for Dateline for shining the spotlight on this awful situation.

What a horror life has been for this man. God bless the people at Centurion Ministries for doing their best to right this outrageous wrong and correct this clear miscarriage of justice.

It's obvious that the Governor of Montana (Barry Beach's former Prosecutor--hardly a disinterested party) made it clear to the Parole Board that they would suffer the consequences that Governors can make Parole Boards suffer if they did the right, honest and just thing and paroled this man.

No doubt the people on the Parole Board decided crossing the Governor was just not worth it. Everyone one of them should have to spend 24 days in prison--one day for every year he has been ther--then revisit Barry Beach's case. I promise you, they would decide differently.

The strange case of Barry Beach

David Fry — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 06:03:44 GMT

I can't believe the parole board didn't give this man parole after whag they heard.I hope someone will give him a chance.

The strange case of Barry Beach

C. Mccoy Sneads, Fla. — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 11:04:43 GMT

I watched this show as it aired, and taped it to watch again to make sure that I really understood it.
It was facinating. I couldn't help but notice that the
part of the law enforcement officer who broke into the
evidence room the night after the murder was just glazed over. From the show, I couldn't tell if his
daughter was an initial suspect on the actual night of the murder, or not. If not, it is very strange that he would do such a thing. Could he, in fact be covering things up on his own behalf? I am divorced from a law enforcement officer who eluded to things changed to fit what was needed to fit the crime. Why did this man break into the evidence room? What is he
hiding? I hope that in the near future that an explanaton is forthcoming. I happen to be a correctional officer. I do not wish to see a murderer
go free. But, in this case, I do have questions as to who is really responsible for the murder of Kim Nees.
Please do not let this question go unanswered. Frankly, I
could not believe that this was not picked up on by your staff who does an excellent job of investigation
work. I hope in the near future that a true explanation of what happened to this girl is forthcoming. All is not what it appears to be.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Joan Simms Rancho Cordova, CA — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 12:53:47 GMT

I was outraged at the outcome of the appeal he was
given. Weren't those three people hearing what the
rest of us heard? Didn't they realize that when he
gave his confession he was a scared 20 year old KID!!
(I also love it when Keith tells any story. His unique way of tell it is UNIQUE! I"m always happy when I see it's him.)

The strange case of Barry Beach

Marge C , Elgin Illinois — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 15:06:23 GMT

I too feel Barry is innocent! Why don't they question the police themselves as to why the evidence is gone? Maybe ask the person who kicked the door into the police station. I also believe the parole board might have been paid off or at least afraid of the prosecuting attorney that he might do something to affect their careers. Something is not right!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tracey Idaho — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 15:17:58 GMT

I also watched the Dateline program on Barry Beach. It is my understanding that much of the evidence for this case was lost. When Barry requested a DNA test performed on the alleged pubic hair found his attorney's were told it could not be found. The Justice system in Montana is going to great lengths to keep Barry imprisoned whether he is guilty or not. In case of the evidence presented, I believe he is not guilty.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Danny Poplar, Mt. — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 16:45:05 GMT

I live in this small town where this took place. Barry is innocent, everyone know's this but nothing was done until centrion ministry came into the picture. We Pray that one day Those that are responsible for this will Pay dearly. They not only took Kim and Barry's lives from them but many many more over the years. They have destroy people and they have hurt many girls so there is a back ground on these gals that are the guilty parties. Time to make them pay. Start With Maude she will be the one to break.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bonnie Mc., Wyoming, Minnesota — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 17:34:37 GMT

The ex-governor of Montana along with the deputies, & anyone else who thinks Barry is guilty will have to answer to that some day & it won't be nice. How can they even live with themselves after all these years, the only thing I can think of is a cover-up, you scratch my back & I'll scratch yours!! How pathetic!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sandi Hausner, San Antonio, Texas — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 18:01:24 GMT

How disgraceful is it that those policemen and the prosecutor don't want to admit that they made mistakes in this case and are willing to have an innocent man spend the rest of his life in prison? I can't imagine how they can live with themselves. There was enough reasonable doubt brought up by the Centurion group for them to see what a mess they made of that investigation, and the parole board should have realized that. It's a shame that Mr. Beach will spend the rest of his life in prison because they are too self righteous to admit they are wrong. The whole situation is a disgrace and once again proves that our justice system is flawed beyond repair.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Newt, Missoula,Mt. — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 18:17:28 GMT

Now here's one that people don't know about. One month after Barry was turned down at his clemency hearing William David Faught is granted parole and is now in the custody of Anaconda, Mt. branch of probation & parole. Who is Mr. Faught ? Dave Faught was given 1200 months for the deliberate homocide of a mentally handicapped girl who he stabbed sixteen times. Yeah, the kangaroo court and parole system in Montana at it's finest.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Faye Meredith — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 18:37:02 GMT

I firmly believe there is injustices and this one is blatent! How can you keep punishing Barry Beach when it obvious he didn't have anything to do with this murder! Accept your mistakes - It's scary to live in small town USA and small state Montana!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Brandy Utah — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 18:43:40 GMT

I know nothing about the town, the people, the case, the crime, nor the law enforcement in this small town. What I do know without a doubt is that this man is innocent. I do not know what the heck is wrong with these small towns as I come from one myself in Utah but it seems to be the same story no matter what small town it is. Crooked cops, wrongfully accused serving time just so the real criminals which are probably those friends or families members of the law enforcement officers in these small towns. I pray that the board of pardons in Montana come to their senses and let this man go free before he dies in there and the truth comes out and they feel like real fools. Then they will have to answer to the higher power for the wrong fate that they have given this young man. We are praying for you Barry Beach and for the Nees family as well so that the REAL killers are brought to justice.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Renee, Oklahoma City, OK — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 19:03:13 GMT

We hear more and more stories like this....the judicial system doesn't want to admit their mistake. Why is that more important than DOING THE RIGHT THING?? If I lived in Montana, I would be SO ASHAMED of my govenor. This situation needs a hero. What about it Mr. Governor?? Can you do the right thing???

The strange case of Barry Beach

Rhonda, Ft. Worth, Texas — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 19:21:32 GMT

I usually am not one to get on a band wagon or have my views publicly displayed. However, in this case I will go outside my norm. I find it total incomprehensible that the board of parole in Montana let the pressure of politics guide them in making a decision that was so blatant as the nose on their faces as Barry Beach innocents is.

Our justice system will let gang members, illegals and highly dangerous people back on the streets due to overcrowding, but not let a man that by all counts is innocent have a chance at life. Is it the fact that the former governor and the police detective wouldn’t back down to save face – after all they do have reputation to uphold!

Please…. What is this country coming to?

The strange case of Barry Beach

B. Thelen, Columbia Falls, MT — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 19:54:20 GMT

Wonderful job Keith Morrison! I moved to MT 6 years ago and have never heard about the Barry Beach story. I am appalled that we have such corrupt politicians and "dirty" police officers. Shame on you Marc Racicot! - I'm voting Democrat this year just because of you! What happened to "reasonable doubt?" - a taped confession with the tape missing is not substantial evidence at all. And anyone can type anything on a transcript! Maybe Governor Schweitzer being the honest good man that he is could help Barry! He could be the real hero in all of this and bring justice and peace to Barry, Kim's family, and the folks of Poplar! Here's the address to our Governor now - write him a letter - keep em' coming - somebody has to help this guy and someone has to make a difference!

Governor Brian D. Schweitzer
Office of the Governor
Montana State Capitol Bldg.
P.O. Box 200801
Helena MT 59620-0801
(406) 444-3111, FAX (406) 444-5529

Lieutenant Governor John Bohlinger
Office of the Lt. Governor
Montana State Capitol Bldg.
PO Box 200801
Helena, MT 59620-1901
(406) 444-3111, FAX (406) 444-4648

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tambra Lee, Saint Paul, Minnesota — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 20:54:38 GMT

I've not been able to get this story off my mind. It is so obvious that Barry is innocent. A young man...20 years old that drinks, drives fast, etc. is an easy target in a small town with something to hide. On top of it, the former Governor was the prosecuting attorney? I also thaught that it was odd that the parol board sent out an e-mail almost three weeks later stating that his parol had been denied. Is there anything that any of us can do to help. My heart just goes out to this poor man.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Glenda Gilham, Browning Montana — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 21:02:23 GMT

This case boils down to the Governor, He and the elected Sheriff built thier political careers from this. They do not want to admit they were WRONG!!! Poor Berry Beach. He will rot over these men not taking responsibility for their ERRORS. More than that the Parole Board of Montana look like a bunch of uneducated Hicks!! What a bunch of Clowns. after only a few minutes into the program it is obvious that these politicians are behind the Big screw-up of "Justice".

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tracy, Combined Locks, WI — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 21:12:03 GMT

This case is a severe miscarriage of justice. What it is boils down to is Marc Racicot using this case as a stepping stone to get to where he is today. It is a cover up that needs to be uncovered. Rather than focus on Barry's innocence, focus on FINDING THE KILLER! Then he will be freed. Find someone who is NOT afraid of Racicot and company and who will go up against him, fight him and call him on his lies. There's little doubt in my mind that one of the killers is that Maude Greyhawk. Why else would her own father - a police officer break into the evidence room?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Linda, Oregon — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 21:27:16 GMT

Very hard to believe what we saw on Dateline. Just scares me to think we drive thru Montana to get to our home state of ND each summer. Like my mother would say "Something is rotten in Denmark" or in this case, in Montana. Puts a bad light on the mostly good folks of Montana and one must question the intelligence of the police and others involved with this case. We must support Barry with our money, prayers, and whatever else can be done. This is almost comical if a man's life wasn't involved

The strange case of Barry Beach

Susan, Deadwood, SD — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 22:00:15 GMT

Been thinking about this story all weekend. What about Barry's age at the time of the crime? Should he have been considered a juvenile? Was there a lawyer present for any of the questioning? Assumed innocent until proven guilty? He was not proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt! Investigate this further, PLEASE

The strange case of Barry Beach

m,koustas - toms river nj — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 22:05:09 GMT

The prosecutor in the orignal case is now the governor, who was going to vote against him? The people who were on the Board didn't even have the nerve to look him in the eye and say he was guilty, if I remember right they send an email. Of course he was innocent but who had the nerve to say that the governor is lying?

The strange case of Barry Beach

CAH Montana — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 22:35:51 GMT

Write our governor, write our attorney general, please put forth all your words, questions and support where it needs to go, not here!! Please help Barry Beach!

The strange case of Barry Beach

J. Anderson — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 22:51:51 GMT

It boils down to politics. They didn't want to tarnish the Gov's record with this. That is what is boils down to. Time for the real murderer whose father stole the evidence as a cop to come forward. I believe that is one of the girls they mentioned, the one who failed to show up with subpeona.

The strange case of Barry Beach

duane774, Ft. Lauderdale, Fl. — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 23:32:37 GMT

I spent a year in jail fighting for my freedom, for a crime that: not only did I not commit, but a crime that never even happened. I was fortunate, the Jury found me 'Not Guilty'. However, the prosecutor tried with all their power to have me convicted for what amounted to a big lie. I always maintained my innocents and I am totally convinced that there are many innocent people in our prisons. I believe Barry Beach is one also. I hope Barry Beach get his freedom soon. Put it in Gods hands Barry, put it in Gods hands.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tammie Miller — Mon, 07 Apr 2008 23:43:12 GMT

I lived in Wolf Point Montana at the time this murder happened and I remember then that the rumors where a bunch of girls killed her because she was white. I can also remember other kids telling me that it wasn't a good idea to go party in Poplar because bad things happend to white girls.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Diane, Southern California — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 00:23:09 GMT

A policeman, who just HAPPENS to be the father of one of the suspected girls, breaks into the evidence room with no disciplinary action brough against him...hmmmm...and the parole board discounts ALL evidence proving Barry's innocence...hmmm...Obviously a cover-up is going on in Poplar that the parole board is perpetuating!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ex-Montana, Somewhere, USA — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 01:00:22 GMT

I would like to thank Dateline for filming this program and airing it. The saddest part of all is the law in Montana has and continues to act with injustice in many cases. Barry Beach is only one Montana person who's life has been altered by the law and elected officials. Nothing has changed for the better in the 25 years Barry has been in prison. We have laws in the United States to protect innoccent people, the problem is that Montana lives by it's own law. I would like to see Dateline return to Montana and bring the spotlight to other cases. Please follow the Barry Beach case. I can only hope that in his attempts to gain freedom, he takes down some of the corrupt people in power in that state.

I would like to return to my home state of Montana some day and not have to fear the law.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Daryl W. Craft — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 01:20:57 GMT

I,ve all the so called evidence against Barry and it all seems bunk theres nothing. As for his confession I was questioned at the same time by Via and Calhoun and Barry is telling the honest truth about there methods of interegation I believe it was coerced because I know how they worked they tried o get me to tell them things that I knew nthing about .

The strange case of Barry Beach

Gerri Williston, North Dakota — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 01:27:56 GMT

I am from this area and I grew up thinking that this man killed her. All the "facts" that I heard, based on Barry's confession aren't even true. There was no garbage bag, no evidence tying him to the crime, but he was guilty and that was that. Looking at it today, none of the evidence connects him to the murder. I can see that he was a scared young boy and I want to know where was his lawyer when he was being question by this scary looking lawman that interrigated him. I'm sorry, but he even looked scary to me 25 years later. Why can't the case be reopened? Someone needs to find out why that tribal cop broke into the evidence room. There are so many questions that need to be answered for both families sake. I think that it is owed to them. Also, how can a prosecutor say that this mysterious hair was Barry's when there was no way to prove it back then, and stand by that now without DNA testing. It seems that there was more than one cover up or agenda here. My prayers are for both families.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Becky Bruno, Arvada, Colorado — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 03:50:55 GMT

I have never been so outraged by something I saw on tv in all my life. Barry is innocent. I can't believe the cop who broke in the door to the evidence locker was not questioned. What about his daughter not showing up for the hearing, what about all of the people who heard Sissy bragging about being part of the murder, including her own brother!! This truly is a travesty of justice, but I like so many others was worried when the report said that the former prosecutor went on to become governor. Of course he's not going to admit being wrong, and the parole board will of course back him up out of fear of losing their jobs. Isn't there anything that can be done? I feel so sad for you Barry and for your Mother. My son is in County jail right now for a petty crime he DID commit and it tears my heart out. I can only imagine how your Mother must feel!!!! I will pray for both of you and for all of the people who are tirelessly working to set you free!!!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Elaine,SnowCamp,N.C. — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 04:17:11 GMT

What is wrong with all our court systems? Why are the quilty set free to go out and kill again! It is so plain to see that Barry did not kill Kim. Just like what happened in N.C., Duke student killed and instead of looking for the killers they just waited until they killed again at Chapel Hill. Set Barry Free!!!!!!!!!! He Is INNOCENT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jason J. Lay, Helena, MT — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 04:20:03 GMT

ANYONE may write Barry Beach support letters at the following address:

Barry Beach, AO#21520
Montana State Prison
700 Conley Lake Rd
Deer Lodge, MT 59722

You do not need to be on an approved mailing list, but you may not send him any items other than correspondence. I'm sure Barry would love to hear from his supporters. Thanks.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Helena,Florida — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 04:25:28 GMT

I hope there is someone w/money who can help fight for his freedom. Those who put him in prison should be invesigated, do you think they would admit to lying? NOT!!!
It is a shame and it obvious innocent man is in prison. LET HIM GO! HE IS INNOCENT!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Christie, Seattle — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 04:30:44 GMT

I'm outraged after watching this show that this man is still in prison. What ever happened to physical evidence? He was a young, scared man when he "confessed" all those years ago. We all make poor judgment at times and he was no exception. Cases like this make it hard for me to believe in our justice system.
I hope these men fighting for his innocence keep at it and I pray for their strength. Hang in there Barry. The truth will come out one day. God bless you.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jason J. Lay, Helena, MT — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 04:56:59 GMT

montanansforjustice.com is a great website to learn more about this case, examine voluminous pdf. documents, and to contribute to Barry's defense. And there is a blog there too!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Karen, La Quinta, California — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 06:51:50 GMT

When I graduated from Poplar High School in l970, things were different. I don't remember anyone taking hard drugs and marijuana was not a big deal at that time. Also, there were no 'girl gangs' that I was aware of. My little sister (by eight years) had a different experience. By the time she was in high school, she was so harrassed by 'girl gangs' that my parents were forced to send her to finish high school in Billings, while living with me. I believe she was targeted by these gangs, as was Kim Nees, because she was a "rich" farmer's daughter and they envied her.

Until I saw the Dateline show, I had assumed that Barry Beach had killed Kim Nees. Now I'm not so sure. The case is definitely complicated, mostly due to the pathetic initial crime analysis. But finger-pointing at any law enforcement past the local yahoos is pointless. Let's put blame where it is due - on drugs. Where's the big story about how drugs have taken over the reservation since the 70's? In this case, all you have to know is that druggies have poor reputations, poor judgement, and poor memories.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Crystal Albanese, Poplar, Montana — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 13:33:17 GMT

To see what the towns folk of Poplar are saying about this, check out the http://groups.msn.com/AllFortPeckTribalMembers/messages.msnw

The strange case of Barry Beach

Patricia Kramer, Teaneck NJ — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 13:43:53 GMT

I am totally disgusted with our judicial system.

Barry, we are praying for you and believe you will be released. Remember the scripture...."every hidden thing shall be revealed", those who are responsible will have to pay for their crime, it will suddenly come to light with no doubts to your innocence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Janice Roseberry, Valley Grande, AL — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 14:01:29 GMT

My son is in prison in Alabama and is charged with a crime that was actually never committed but through the court system, he was tried and convicted and never allowed to testify in his own behalf. Once you are in prison, the courts don't want to hear anything you have to say. It's not about TRUTH, it's about a CONVICTION and how they are not going to say they did wrong. I sympathize with Mr.Beach because until this happened to my son, I didn't realize how many innocent men there are out there in prisons because of lies and politics. My prayers are with you.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Janice Roseberry, Valley Grande, AL — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 14:01:30 GMT

The strange case of Barry Beach

Terry Bagley, Bar Harbor, ME — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 14:08:56 GMT

Is it possible to take a backdoor approach to help Barry Beach? For example, have the FBI investigate the police officers and govenor's mishandling of evidence, ect. or get a pardon from President Bush;
offer a big reward and ammunity to someone that would like to step forward for Barry that was involved?

The strange case of Barry Beach

Wesley Headdress, Wolf Point, Mt. — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 14:47:13 GMT

Free Barry Beach!!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ruth Hansell,Burlington,NC — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 16:15:00 GMT

April 8th
I just read all the comments from last Friday. My husband and I were also shocked that Barry did not at least get a new trial. Injustice served, Hopefully, Keith with your help, he will get a new trial.

Burlington, NC

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carol from Montana — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 16:27:49 GMT

Marc currently serves as the Chairman of the Republican National Committee. Nominated by President George W. Bush, he was unanimously elected to this position in January 2002.

He is no longer Governor of Montana, he has progressively gone up the ladder.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Moe Wosepka, Helena Montana — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 18:13:59 GMT

I attended the parole board hearing for Barry Beach, and one thing that impressed me was the commitment the witnessnes made to testify. Some of you may not understand the distance people have to travel in Montana, but those who traveled from Eastern Montana to testify logged over 1000 miles round trip. They were the closest of all of them. Others came from Eastern North Dakota, and even Alaska. One of the witnesses was advised by her Doctor not to travel becuase she just had heart surgery, but she came anyway. It tells me that Barry Beach has tremendous support, and a belief that he is innocent.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Fearfull in Poplar — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 19:03:44 GMT

Why didn't they mention that Sissy Atkinson Brother Bobby Atkinson was head of the Police force back then. Both Sissy and Maude had family in the police force when this took place. To my understanding when Orrie Burshia went in to tell them that those girls did this to Kim they just didn't take her serious enough. I think they need to lean on Mike Longtree for the TRUTH about that night. He seen this and sould be a man and start telling the truth.
There has been a shadow over Poplar since this crime took place. This is not the only girl that they hurt the beat another one and damn near killed her too. Didn't even know her, she now lives in Billings Mt. They should question her about what they did to her. Sissy still goes around bullying people around at her feabeal age of 52 she looked 100 years old probably because this haunts her everyday. And as for Maude she lives in fear everyday that she will be caught. Barry is innocent and needs to be released to live his life out.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jeff, St. George, UT — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 20:43:18 GMT

I was considering Montana as a place to practice medicine and raise my family, but after watching this show that is no longer an option. This show shed some bad light on Montana's leaders. The parole board members are fools! Mr Racicot reminds me of ex prosecutor Mike Nifong. Unfortunately Barry Beach didn't have the financial backing like the Duke students to go after overzealous prosecutors who will ruin people's lives for political gain. The plain and simple truth is that he LIED to the jury. That alone should be grounds for dismissal or at least reason to retry the case. I hope Barry Beach files a civil lawsuit against that bonehead Racicot.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Wanda Stewart — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 21:57:13 GMT

I can't get this story out of my mind. It's SO obvious that Barry Beach was innocent, yet he was railroaded by some crooked cops and politicians. How can any American have faith in our criminal justice system after watching this story? This kid was railroaded, and it started with some crooked cops here in Louisiana. Unfortunately, it appears that Montana's cops and politicians are even more pig-headed and corrupt than the ones here in Louisiana. I applaud the men who have worked for 10 years on this case and I hope they won't give up until someone listens. The governor clearly won't admit he's wrong and he apparently appointed the parole board, so they bowed to his wishes. Thank you, Dateline for bringing us this story. I certainly hope you'll follow up on this.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Betsy Edwards, Vail, Colorado — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 00:08:59 GMT

Please boycott Montana until Barry Beach is free. This is ridiculous. Write to your local papers and let your friends and neighbors know to BOYCOTT MONTANA UNTIL BARRY BEACH IS FREE.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Bobbi from Minnesota — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 00:43:18 GMT

After reading all the articles I could and the videos, I really feel he deserves a new trial. This is absolutely terrible that they are not even allowing a new trial, what are they worried about coming up?? I am furious over this!

The strange case of Barry Beach

J. Klein, Billings, MT — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 01:43:29 GMT

Here are some facts that DATELINE conveniently LEFT OUT. The three "witnesses" that came forward: Richard Holum (convicted felon - drugs), Dun O'Connor (convicted felon - drugs), JD Atkinson (currently incarcerated for ding, ding, ding: DRUGS). You all want to run Sissy A. through the mud for admitting she's an addict but DATELINE doesn't want to tell you that the key witnesses supporting Barry Beach are involved with DRUGS. Stick that in your meth pipe and smoke it.

The strange case of Barry Beach

jen from michigan — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 03:37:41 GMT

Please contact the Montana travel and tourism link
www.travelmontana.mt.gov/CVBCONTACTSHEET.pdf. I realize it is a pdf but copy some emails and send them out letting the state know that people will not be traveling and spending their vacation dollars is such a ridiculously corrupt state.

The strange case of Barry Beach

17 year old Montanan, Somewhere, Montana — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 05:06:18 GMT

This case is ridiculous, Barry Beech is a innocent man! Marc Rosco is an arrogant egotist who is too pig headed to admit that he is WRONG! He rides the confession to the point it will break, because thats the only evidence he has. There is no physical evidence pointing toward Barry. There is more evidence pointing in the direction in Sissy Atkinson and Maud Greyhawk than Mr. Beech. And because he was once the Montana Governor, the Parole Board are almost as crooked as Rosco and won't cross him and possibly show weakness in our past leaders of Montana. Sheriff Malum won't admit he's wrong because it'd make him and his corrupt department look bad. For God's sake one of his own deputies who happened to be Maud's father broke into the evidence room and ruined all the evidence which could convict his daughter and Sissy to take a pee! Wow how much more of a hint do u need! Oh and the Louisiana Detective(who's department has a terrible faulty conviction record) is obviously corrupt as well claiming him and Sheriff Malum only talked twice on the phone when it was logged more than ten times! Which could explain why the TRANSCRIPTION(which could have been altered in any way) of the confession that The Detective from Louisiana wrote happened to be more from the mouths of The Poplar police department than from Mr. Beech's. Barry is innocent! Free this poor man. Mr. Beech had more than 30 witnesses on Mr. Beeches behalf who are by far more credible than Sissy. For God's sake she is an admitted addict to meth and cocaine! That woman has smoked her sense away! And there are 3 credible witnesses who have her possibly in the vehicle and have heard her admit to the crime. Even the victims sister spoke on behalf of Barry. THE VICTIMS SISTER!!! Mr. Rosco and Mr. Malum, you two are what is wrong with the judicial system in Montana, your working too hard trying to save your own face and credibility rather than save this man's LIFE! Listen to the people and look at the evidence! You two make this 17 year old feel embarrassed and ashamed to be a member of this great state. I just can't believe these two men are ruining Barry's life. I hope Centurian Ministries keep working hard and fighting for Barry. Break this crooked and corrupt system! I believe Kim Nees is looking over her killer's shoulder, But it in no way is Barry Beech's!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Deborah,Catonsville,Md — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 06:06:49 GMT

There is no evidence of Barry being involved in the horrible death of that young girl.I myself having a 17 year old daughter would want to know absolutely,without question who was responsible for her death.I feel for the families involved and hope and pray for some resolution.If there is anyone out there who knows this man is innocent and has any information I pray that they have the strength to do the right thing and come forward.Stay strong Barry!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Brian Zietlow — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 06:17:46 GMT

I like many others grew up in Poplar. I left in 1982 and knew many of the individuals suspected of being involved. You have to realize that several of the individuals believed to be involved were of tribal prominance in that town. The BIA and local tribal police were not about to investigate the dirt on their own prominent families.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Melanie, Irvine CA — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 07:12:37 GMT

I just finished watching this online and am astonished that apparently there is a killer (assuming that they are not deceased) running around because the wrong person is incarcerated and no one wants to acknowledge the reality that a mistake was most likely made. If I were intimidated into making a confession there is a good chance that I would not remember the details of it either!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Nancy Vargas Avondale, AZ — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 12:22:42 GMT

It truely saddens me to think that we live in a world with so many people who have no heart or conscience. Please help me understand how we can allow a 17 yr old BOY go to and stay in prison for a crime he simply did not do.
What we need to do is put aside how it happened and who is responsible for it(because they will meet their maker) and focus on what it will take to free an innocent man.
I have a question for the people responsible....
how do you live with what you have done and continue to do to this man and his family? do you realize how much he has been deprived of, if his youth alone isnt enough but you cheated him out of a life that you obviously take for granted. The very same mercy that Barry asked the judge to show him will be the mercy you'll be asking God for.
One of you has got to break the silence and come forward. Tell the truth, put an end to all this. Give us all hope for the world we live in and follow the conscience man gave you and the heart God gave you and let the truth be known.
To Keith Morrison and Dateline... I stand up and applaud you for airing this story. OUTSTANDING!!!
To Barrys mother & family... you are remarkable!! from one mother to another, your tears will not go unnoticed, for every tear you cried will be that many special moments you'll have with Barry. I truely believe that. God bless!
To Barry... I will remember you in my prayers, after listening to your story, I cant help but admire your strength, I can only imagine what I would do being in the same situation. And even now, as I write this to you, tears come to my eyes when I think about the hope and faith I could see in yours. You have paid the dues for another mans/womans crime and although not fair, I have to believe theres a good reason for the sacrifice you've been made to take. When you are released, I believe that you will not have to search for happiness like so many of us do, for happiness will search for you. And your dreams of showing your sobriety to your family will come true. Barry...You're my hero too!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dee, West Windsor, NJ — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 12:41:18 GMT

After watching the show I was filled with anger and disgust for the perpetrators of this blatant injustice and their stubborn refusal to admit their error. Especially former Gov. Racicot who is a smart and sophisticated man with may years of experience. He knows that false confessions happen-- or he should-- and this case has all the red flags of a textbook false confession. He is apparantly a man without shame or conscience and a glowing example of why we must be sceptical of the ethics and motivations of police and prosecutors. Prospective jurors all over America need to be wary any time a defendant 'confesses' to a crime. I does not matter that they allegedly provided information that 'only the killer would know'. The crucial question is--did they provide information that the POLICE didn't already know?!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Justice Served — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 15:18:09 GMT

Here is a question, if Barry Beach was innocent, why did he have acting lessons before appearing before the parole board and on Dateline? Why did his attorneys have to train him how to behave in public? Mr. Innocent with his big doe eyes, sitting in his non-threatening pose, using all his most polite language, crying at all the right times. He behaved like a manipulative sociopath trying to con the parole board, not like an innocent man fighting for his life. I wonder how many marriage proposals he's had since the show aired.

The strange case of Barry Beach

tim doe — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 16:41:16 GMT

Very interesting video i had lived in poplar around the time when kim was killed and for years the word was around that sissy was involved and one of other ladies that interviewed was involved in another beating to dead of another female after the kim's death, some habits are hard to change. Knowing and living some of the life styles in poplar at that time no one goes home at 11 thats when things are just getting started get real. Barry's innocent come on gov its okay to admit your wrong dont let your pride stand in the way of a man life.

The strange case of Barry Beach

?, MT — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 16:58:09 GMT

Why has nobody mentioned that Barry is white and that the other people suspected are Indian? On the reservation, there seems to be two systems of justice-one for the whites and one for the Indians.

The strange case of Barry Beach

George — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 18:01:16 GMT

I watched the program it seems that the ex govener still has alot of power because it appears that he is so innocent. I can't believe that he is still in jail.
Other people have beenn found innocent with much more evidence aganst them

The strange case of Barry Beach

sharon s. — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 18:17:55 GMT

I SAY WE START A "FREE BARRY BEACH" CAMPAIGN!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Monte, Breckenridge, CO — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 20:37:40 GMT

You may send correspondence to :

Mr. Barry Beach AO#21520
700 Conley Lake Road
Deer Lodge MT 59722

let's flood him with letters of encouragement and support.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Carly Sioux Clincher-Stump MT — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 23:24:06 GMT

Well all I have to say is, Thank You America for seeing all the injustice my Grandma Bobbi and Uncle Barry have had to go thru all these years. Thank you for your words of support.

The strange case of Barry Beach

CindyM, torrance, ca — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 23:56:53 GMT

Cool hand luke .... so sad.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Follette, formerly of Poplar, Helena, Mt — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 01:42:10 GMT

this is the kind of law and justice that we have to deal with everyday. Our family had a neice and nephew killed in Poplar, neice was a hit and run accident, no one was charged. Rumours say a tribal CI was protecting his own. My nephew was beaten to death by 4-6 men, no one was charge, same rumour was said about this CI. There were alot of witness's to my nephews murder, but they say self defense. My nephew was covered in bruises. He just graduated high school in May and died in Dec. This is the kind of law and justice we deal with on a daily basis.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cindy Graham — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 02:25:50 GMT

What a joke our justice system has become. For this parole board to sit and listen to all the testimony and still believe he is guilty is crazy. Who are they related to and covering up for? Girls at this age are the meanest and nastiest creatures to their peers on the face of this earth and are undoubtedly the ones guilty. Why do you think they all look so old and haggard at they young age they are now? Guilt will do awful things to you. I hope Mr. Beach is freed so he is able to spend time with his Mom while she is still alive.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ashley Walter, Lafayette IN — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 05:18:23 GMT

After watching this episode on Barry i was devistated st the out come. How awfull is it that a innocent man is serving his life in prison when the killer"s" are out and free. The so called "system" of justice these people are practicing is beyond morbid. I guess in Montana you dont have to have facts and evidence to convict someone for a severe crime. It is sad to know that the people you are supposed to trust to protect you, your children, can be so stupid to be blunt. This is a innocent man, a waisted life sitting there serving time with his head high. We can only pray that justice will prevail for him,if not here than in a better place. People practicing such ignorance should not be aloud to practice law. It is very sad to see the pride of the dectecives to be mistaken for convidence. Clearly its does not take a rocket scientist to see Barry is innocent, apparently it doesnt even take their poor excuse for a justice system.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Nikki - Northeastern Montana — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 06:02:11 GMT

It's a shame of what happens on the reservation. There was a murder what happened, a low-life stabbed and killed a very liked man. The murderer was walking the streets a year later, with a smile on his face. The legal system is a joke on the reservation, and so are alot of the authorities. Alot of it depends on who you are related to. People DO get away with murder on the Fort Peck Reservation.

The strange case of Barry Beach

tim white, sisseton south dakota — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 14:45:27 GMT

I lived in poplar when kim was murdered and for years the rumor was that some girls killed her. I personally know one of the women interviewed and feel she would be capable of doing something like this and as for the other that was interviewed by dateline she had been involved in a beating death after kims death seems that old habits are hard to change. One of the things that stuck out in the interviewed was that sissy and the jackson lady both said that they were in by 11. Knowing poplar at that time things are just getting started at 11 really unbelieveable for me. So many things pointing at the women who murdered kim I think the governor needs to shallow his pride and do whats right.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mary From Oslo Norway — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 15:48:33 GMT

I have watched your programe over and over again, and still can't believe that, this is really happing in "AMERICA"!!!! Somebody pinch me please!!! Can the Montana police force, find it possible to maybe look closer within themselves, maybe they might find the killer? Or is this why the killer is still not found??? Makes one wonder!!! I am praying for both families in this case!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Kathy, Billings Montana — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 16:58:21 GMT

It's obvious that the Sheriff had no experience in crime scenes and he should have called for help before anything was ever touched! People who live in the area still say Barry is innocent but everyone is afraid to talk. The deputy who broke into the evidence room is the uncle of one of the suspects! I'm totally ashamed of my state for mishandling this case from the get go.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Wes Sims Monroe, Louisiana — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 17:01:34 GMT

Mr. Beach is, in all likelihood, innocent. There is no doubt that his rights were violated. If you really want to help him, you need to focus on the Ouachita Parish Sheriff Department’s long history of coercive interrogations. Jay Via taught at the local Law Enforcement Training Academy in West Monroe. A few years ago, he told a class that he could get anyone to confess to anything, anytime. A trainee who spoke up and told him that teaching this was wrong was told, “If you believe that, you don’t belong here.” This Academy in West Monroe, Louisiana trains police officers for this entire area. The techniques they have perfected are something you would expect only in a Third World Country, yet you will find this being practiced by their “trainees” all over this part of the country. Louisiana has the highest incarceration rate in the nation. That is no accident. They’ve been doing this for generations. You need to look into their long history of “losing” interrogation tapes and their suspect’s 100% recall of detailed facts that they could not possibly have known. You need to look into their “special holding cells” out at Ouachita Correctional Center with no cameras where people tend to become injured during processing or incarceration.

My other post was deleted; I guess it was too long and contained too many details. I wouldn’t stick my neck out and write this if I didn’t think you were really trying to help people. Thanks for the good work, Dateline.

The strange case of Barry Beach

James Garcowski, Berea, Ohio — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 17:37:02 GMT

Let this innocent man go. Obviously he is not the type to have uncontrollable rage. Look at his record in jail. Thank you dateline for bringing this travesty to light. I want to help Barry out.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Silky, New Jersey — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 19:03:00 GMT

It's evident that Barry Beach's innocent of all. As we come to realize the system never works. My advice to this matter will be to all lawyers(Nationwide) who believe in their hearts that "He is innocent" to come foward and represent him also, and at least try to get him out. A polygraph should be giving to those suspect it of the crime.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Dan Gengler, Helena MT — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 19:28:23 GMT

The Montana Attorney General's office has fought tooth and nail to continue to incarcerate other clearly innocent, wrongfully convicted persons. The last such person was Jimmy Ray Bromgard who was ultimately released from prison, exonerated by DNA evidence decades after his conviction, over the objections of the AG's office who to this day still clings to the certainty of his guilt.

The MT AG's office continues to peddle their story that neither Barry Beach nor Kim Nees can be eliminated as the donor or the bloody palm print. The FBI CONCLUSIVELY determined that the bloody palm print belongs to neither Barry Beach nor Kim Nees.

After the state has conveniently "lost" all potentially exculpatory evidence in this case, let us hope and pray they have not now "lost" Kim Nees' case prints, allowing them to perpetuate the bald faced lie that the bloody palm print might have been Kim Nees.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Laura, Minneapolis, MN — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 19:39:06 GMT

I just got the chance to watch the show. I used to live in MT and have seen first hand some of the things that go on. I know JD personally and I know he is telling the truth about Sissy. I dont know her, but of her and what I hear, she is a very viscious person. I think that the comments that the parole board made about Barrys confession being the same as physical evidence was an incredibly stupid thing to say. I believe totally that Barry Beech is innocent and I think DOC should be practicing what it preaches. Take responsibility for your actions and own up to making a mistake. I think it is very sad that a man has lost 25 years of his life because nobody wants to admit they could be wrong.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jane Doe, Spokane WA. — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 20:54:55 GMT

I was born in Poplar but was raised in Wolf Point. I recall when growing up that Poplar was a scarey place to go to cause of all the fights and killing. When I got older my friend would always wanted to take me with her to Poplar. Everytime I went there with her girls would look at me mean and have that jealous look on their faces. I was always freaked out of getting jump or killed because I look like a white girl. Well I believe with all my heart those girls killed Kim Nees due to jealousy and hate. There is so much killing taken place on that REZ and nothing is done about it because of all the crooked JUSTICE. I believe they need to get something done on that REZ so people that really committed the crime can be caught and pay for their price. Geez can't the darn Montana Parole board see what was being put in front them of all the testamonies and the crap of the crooked officers. But thats Montana for you dense and blind or just being paid off by crooked people to cover themselves up. I believe Barry Beach is NOT GUILTY. So I'm going to pray that God will reveal the real killers that did this to an innocent girl who did no harm to anyone.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Mireya Rosario, Jersey City, NJ — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 21:13:14 GMT

I read and saw the video and there is no evidence that Barry killed Kim Nees, Im shock with the system in Montana, they dont know what they doing. Barry is an innocent man he should not be convicted of a crime that he didn't commit. There is no evidence showing that Barry, is guilty he is an innocent man and need to be out off jail. There is alot of people on his sight that knows his innocent. The evidence shows that it was not a man or a woman but a group of girls did the crime, because there were jealous of Kim. They should go after them and leave the innocent man alone. Lawyers all around the world should get together and represent him and try to get him out. Twenty-four years is a long time for an innocent man.
I give my heart to the Nees family, and to Barry and his family.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Cynthia Free, Harrison, Arkansas — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 00:18:18 GMT

This boy needs to be heard. This was posted on prayabout.com:
chasefreeman harrison, AR
in terrible need of help if i may ask that all you pray for me please. i need help in so many ways, that i cant hardly stand it anymore. i am in the 10th grade and is having a really hard time right now. i was a average kid, until i got into the 10th grade, then teachers started telling me i was no good, fat, and i would never be a leader, i would always be a follower. its really hard on me because my mom works 7 days a week and 3-5 nights a week, so shes really never around. my dad is caught up in drugs really really bad, and hes not the same person i used to call dad anymore. my grades in school started dropping and i dont know what to do anymore. so please, please help me and give me advice a show me a way to get out of these problems. thank you all very much.
This is my nephew, he has been through a lot, one day a student set his shirt a fire, and the teachers response to this was what do you want me to do about it, I didnt see who done it. There has been more than Chase that has been bullied on, at this school. You are not excepted at this school unless you play sports or you are a teachers child. You would not believe the amount of children that have dropped out because of the way they are treated. My sister (Chase's Mother) has went to the teachers and they are very rude to her, and the same reaction for the principal and the super. and I think that they should be stopped and I think placing them in front of the world would make a difference. Chase has always had high hopes for a great education and he always did talk about college but now all he talks about is quiting school. Why should they make the choice for his future, I thought that was up to the children to have a bright future. Thank you for listening. Cynthia Free

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ashley Holzmueller, Fairbanks Alaska — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 00:22:36 GMT

Wow!!! that is all I can say! I didn't even get to watch the program when it aired, and stubbled across this article- I think I speak for almost everyone that has heard/read this when I say that those cops should be put in jail instead. Where else in the world is a cop able to break in, tamper with evidence, and nothing be done!! How can they pull in 34 people to speak on his behalf, show that the confession is bogus, and not have a single shread of evidence linking him to the sceen of the crime- AND THEY DIDN'T EVEN GIVE HIM PAROLE!!!!! Barry, if you are reading this just know that even people in Fairbanks, Alaska can clearly see that you where done wrong! I hope you get the chance to live your life someday as a free man, with all your family and friends that love and support you.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Laura, Olympia, WA — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 02:44:17 GMT

Don't place your trust in a stupid polygraph either. They do NOT determine guilt or innocence- it is a means, or tool of intimidation by police. They are also allowed to lie about results, just as they can lie about witnesses and evidence. You will rarely (if ever) find anyone in a position of the judicial system that will admit they are wrong, or made a mistake. Look what happened in Ada OK. Arrogance knows no bounds. Over 200 men have been exonerated since 1989, and I am sure there are more awaiting their turn, just as Barry. It IS sad that the lack of trust/respect we can have for law enforcement, but they are playing God with people's lives, and innocence be damned. I pray for Barry & others like him.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Melanie Irvine CA — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 03:15:13 GMT

I have read many of the comments and I have to say that those that attempt to cast doubt on his innocence are trivial. The ministry readily admitted that they have been wrong before and that they will probably be wrong again! This is why they are trying to get ahold of whatever evidence is left to do DNA testing and have been DENIED. The fact that this happened on a reservation comes as no surprise to me. They are their own law, at least the Navajos in New Mexico are considered a sovereign nation, and the state and feds cant touch them and they know it. THIS is why the scum that did this is remaining silent and no one is investigating. They can't. And the guilty parties know it. I have written a letter of support to Barry Beach, and I hope that everyone that has posted here will also do so.

The strange case of Barry Beach

backtrak — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 03:58:26 GMT

Some girls probably did kill Kim Nees because out of jealousy two rough ladies attacked a young bartender after she got off work because she did not want anything to do with them over a year ago. The girls that attacked the bartender are still running free on the reservation and only one got one night in jail. The law enforcement on that particular reservation is linked with most of the killers and drus dealers and parties that take place when incidents occur, but funny how nobody ever gets any punishment for brutal crimes and murders. The law enforcement system in Poplar is the worst ever.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Gerald J. and Joanne H. Gray, Albuquerque, NM — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 04:02:03 GMT

What about all the evidenace that was presented about the women involved at the scene - the kicking of Kim's head, the breakin at the Poplar police station by the policeman (father of one of the girls who was accused of being involved), and what about the testimony of the brother of Ms. Atkinson (the drug lady), and the sister-in-law of one of the girls involved? Why aren't people using this evidence? The Montana Parole Board clearly appears to be protecting and listening to "only" the Montana prosecuter who reached the "mountain top in American politics" - Mark Raciot. This entire indictment appears to be somewhat "fishy". I wonder if Barry were a wealthy white guy from a larger city, would this case take on a different look? It's not hard to see what is truly happening and we believe that Mark Raciot should have looked at the evidence in more detail (as any excellent lawyer would do.") Did Mark R. interview the little sheriff from Louisiana who threatened and interrogated Mr. Beach? This sheriff's evidence is really shakey. He could be lieing and no one seems to be questioning his part in this horrible unjustifiable incarceration. We truly believe Mr. Beach should be given clemency - perhaps by Governor Schweitzer of Montana. He is NOT guilty. What a pity and how sad. Hats off to the Christian Lawyer group - they are dedicated and true warriors and are honest in looking at the "true" evidence. How can this happen to Mr. Beach - being incarcerated when there is not any physical evidence? Also being a victim of sloppy and very questionable detective and "cop" work from the very beginning - what a shame!!!! Has anyone taken into consideration his age at the time, the threats in Lousiana by the sheriff, the fear instilled in Mr. Beach's mind causing him to say "he did it"? It just seems to be a case of "well, let's get it over with; he can't prove that he didn't do it, because he already said he did." And that's all they are going by. If they overturn this case, Mr. Raciot (the man at the top of the mountain in politics) will look foolish and the parole board can't be a part of that, could they?????? Is the Montana Prole Board looking out for their fair haied boy, Mark Rociot, the former Govenor of Montana?? Looks might fishey to us.

The strange case of Barry Beach

poplar resident, ft peck reservation — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 04:21:43 GMT

how did Ritchie Mcdonald end up on the stand, he's about the biggest liar and probably linked to the girls that killed Kim Nees, I know because he lied in a court room against a mother who fought to get her children back! Just because he knew the father. That should tell you what kind of law enforcement program there is back there, and funny how Maude Gray Hawk's dad (the cop who removed evidence from the Barry Beach case) got Maude quickly out of town right after her husband was brutally stabbed. Sissy Atkinson is already half dead from drugs I don't know why she just does not testify and end her life with society. Who smokes a cigarette and lies in front a a camera, no conscience, her mother would totally be ashamed but then again she has always been a disgrace to the atkinson family.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Paul Waldon Monroe, Louisiana — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 13:13:11 GMT

Good job, Dateline, for reporting on this case. The main evidence against Barry Beach is an obviously coerced confession; he even confessed and supposedly provided details on other murders in Ouachita Parish that he could not possibly have committed. There was a precedent set in Louisiana last year where a former inmate sued those who “malpracticed” and had him unjustly imprisoned. He won a very large civil settlement after being set free. I believe that is the reason this is being fought so hard by former Detective Jay Via and others involved. They know they are personally liable. On the website, Montanans for Justice, it was stated that Detective Via and other deputies in Ouachita Parish used religion during their coercive interrogation. They are still doing in Ouachita Parish to this day. They will first threaten and verbally rough a suspect up then, after several hours of this, they will bring a deputy in who claims to be a preacher. He will try to befriend the suspect and serve as his spiritual adviser. He’ll try to convince him that “God wants him to confess,” after praying with him. This goes beyond coercive. It’s predatory. Those responsible should have to pay a monetary settlement to Mr. Beach, for all the years he has spent in prison. No conviction based on coercive religious interrogation techniques should ever be allowed to stand. The doctrine of “separation of church and state” was violated. This continues to this day. Where’s the ACLU? There needs to be some checks and balances. They shouldn’t be able to feed details into an interrogation and use these coercive techniques, no matter how “sure” they are of a suspect’s guilt. If he’s guilty, let the case stand on its own merits; don’t manufacture guilt. Let’s send a message to these backwoods Brown Shirts: this is the United States of America and we will not put up with this!!!~

Justice for Barry Beach!

The strange case of Barry Beach

MARY KIMANI — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 14:57:13 GMT

Its unfortunate that someone has to spend time in prison for something they did not do. Its been 25 years for barry in prison, God knows what he would have done in those 25 years of his life, out of prison. Nobody was there during the time of the murder, that is a fact. So we dont know what happened, all we are doing is putting little pieces of evidence and information together. Barry seems like a descent man, very descent. But life is not fair sometimes, but a writer said that we make it that way. Whether he is guilty or not, that story taught me a whole lot. I remember thinking sometimes i complain about why someone has to live in a multimillionare house and no me in it. But is comes down to, thanking the Lord for each new day. Barry is struggling and fighting for his life, and here Iam complaining about how unfair life is because i cant afford that million dollar home. People have bigger problems, and really go through hell everyday, we just dont know abou them. I now count my blessings, everyday. Barry hang in there, all things work for good, there is a reason why you are in there, and a good one too, maybe you will impact so many peoples lives in there, that it will leave you speechless, like the guard you saved in there.

The strange case of Barry Beach

John Early, New York, New York — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 19:14:06 GMT

Would Barry Beach have been convicted to life had he been white? It's very true he frequently abused drugs and alcohol. In fact, maybe that's why he "confessed". Wasn't his confession -- graphic and chilling, from what I read of it -- taken under stressful circumstances without a lawyer present, when perhaps he was still high on, or coming down from, drugs or alcohol? Shouldn't that have made his signed confession inadmissible as evidence? The Monroe PD was already looking for, and bring pressured to get a confession from, anyone who fit their profile of their local serial killer. Maybe seeing to it that last night's nuisance the drunken Indian gets his comeuppance, was all in a day's work.

The only smoking gun here is his confession, and that, it seems to me, was gotten under duress.

I fail to understand why someone whose only crime seems to be a substance abuse problem, should go to prison for life. Simply put, there was/is insuf- ficient evidence to convict and he was never proven guilty on any solid evidence.

Like Centurion Ministries, I would not want to have incarcerated for life anyone who didn't do the crime.

In 1966, I worked with Isidore (Issy) Zimmerman, who spent 24 years in prison for a murder in which he was later exonerated of participation. Zimmerman was later recompensed, albeit inadequately, and he died a broken man. So I know firsthand that injustice can happen. And all too frequently does indeed happen.

Real justice might not have been done in this case, and that is why needs to be reviewed, -- yes, again. And again. for as long as it takes to get at who actually did the crime. No matter who it is.

Rushing to judgment never solves anything. After all, it is just possible that the real perpetrator(s) is/are still out there. Somewhere.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jennifer, Los Angeles, CA — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 20:40:00 GMT

I really believe Barry Beach is innocent. The evidence AND witnesses provided by Beach's defense team overwhelming proved doubt on his guilty verdict. Even the victim's own sister believes he didn't do it! Not only that but the witnesses and evidence pointed to the real killers! I was shocked when the parole board made the wrong decision based on all the evidence and witnesses! Perhaps someday the Nees girl that was tragically murdered will gain true justice by freeing Barry Beach and gathering the real murderers.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jan Holcomb, Ohio — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 20:45:50 GMT

I was so upset after watching the show about
Barry Beach. There is no doubt they convicted the wrong person. I was so upset, I even wrote to the prison in Monanta telling them that the parole board ought to be ashamed of themselves. They decided to defend their decision by sending me transcripts from his court hearings and still could not answer my simple questions. They brought up his drinking, his smoking pot and a few other mishaps as a young child, which is not relevant to the case of a killing!! Whose bloody palm print, footprints, and fingerprints were those? They were proven not to be that of Barry Beach. And what about the cop breaking into evidence room? He couldn't answer that either. All they could do to defend themselves was to remind me that the prison didn't put him there, it was a jury of 12 people that convicted him, not the parole board. Too me, it now all falls on the parole board after all the evidence is out in the open now, that the parole board just doesn't want to open up old news. That tells me that they are protecting somebody, but who??? If I were them, I suppose I wouldn't either, knowing how stupid they would be known to look towards the public's point of view. And to Barry, stay strong and keep up the faith. God will have his turn at the people that placed you there and what comes around, goes around. I hope this goes all the way to the Supreme Court to put Montanna in it's place, and they all get fired. I don't care if they are volunteer people who work on the parole board or not, they are in the wrong and they know it. On top of everything, I hope the state looses millions of dollars if this ever does go to the Supreme Court, because you(Barry) should be entitled to every penny of it after what you've been through. I even told the prison to post something on this website and atleast try to defend themselves considering they think Dateline was being "one sided" and as you can see, they haven't even done that, what does that tell the "American people"? Everybody needs to write into the prison and let them know what a screw-up they are and don't deserve to serve on the board.
Jan, Ohio

The strange case of Barry Beach

Betty, Marshalltown, Iowa — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 20:54:50 GMT

Sign this petition to free Barry Beach! http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/freebarrybeach/signatures-1.html

The strange case of Barry Beach

Betty, Marshalltown, Iowa — Fri, 11 Apr 2008 21:07:08 GMT

Please write to the tourism people in Montana and let them know you are boycotting the state. Find their addresses at http://travelmontana.state.mt.us/CVBCONTACTSHEET.pdf

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jane Doe, Poplar, MT — Sat, 12 Apr 2008 10:43:15 GMT

Governor Brian D. Schweitzer
Office of the Governor
Montana State Capitol Bldg.
P.O. Box 200801
Helena MT 59620-0801
(406) 444-3111, FAX (406) 444-5529

Lieutenant Governor John Bohlinger
Office of the Lt. Governor
Montana State Capitol Bldg.
PO Box 200801
Helena, MT 59620-1901
(406) 444-3111, FAX (406) 444-4648

DATELINE: please do a follow-up story.

The strange case of Barry Beach

gene,mt — Sat, 12 Apr 2008 17:04:33 GMT

when some murders on the reservation are committed the murderer(s) get only a few years in prison.this man was sentenced to 100 years.in other cases off the reservation the sentences have been less that 100 years.questionable evidence,questionable whitnesses and comments after the fact by various people sure make it hard to belive he should be in jail.he's put in 25 years,he should be let go.he's paid his dues.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ana Krstic Windsor,Ontario Canada — Sat, 12 Apr 2008 20:47:59 GMT

After watching the show, i truly think that this guy got framed for something that he didn't do!! I truly hope that he will get released from prison!! Good Luck Mr. Beach!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Jaded, Billings, MT — Sun, 13 Apr 2008 12:33:24 GMT

As a person that lived in Poplar for the first half of my life, and whose father graduated and lived most of his life there, I understand why he spent so many years and continues to live behid bars. I have to say that what happened in the trial of Barry Beach is not surprising. Knowing and believing in his innocents is easy because of in small towns there are politics that run blood deep. It probably does not help That Marc Roscot built his carree on this case, and believes with all his heart of Barry's guilt that he cannot admit he is wrong. I bet that he never even went to the crime scene or even spent more that 15 minutes in Poplar. I just hope and pray that Barry hold his head high and in the end will be freed from this injustice.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Katzy in OHIO — Sun, 13 Apr 2008 21:42:07 GMT

I can't believe he is sitting in prison with the fact that they didn't have a shred of evidence against him. I also can't believe they can't prove otherwise!The only thing I cannot understand, is why would you confess to a crime you didn't commit, and what about the details he gives? I still believe he was set up, but I can't comprehend why you tell a lie just because you are scared. I know it happens, but I don't see myself doing it.

The strange case of Barry Beach

CookieB in MassillonOhio... — Sun, 13 Apr 2008 22:47:53 GMT

I don't understand how they can put a man in prison without sufficient evidence. IF he DID burn his clothes, where were the remains? What evidence do they have that this even happened? Also, if he wanted sex so bad, why wasn't she raped? What about this boy witness? Where is he now? Also, how do you LOSE all the evidence? If the cops/authorities lost it after the fact, there needs to be a thorough investigation of them, right? You just don't LOSE all that evidence. It was covered up. It ticks me off..it's wrong. It is such a sad story. The poor girl needs to rest in peace and the truth needs to be told.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Tim Wilson Springville, Ca. — Mon, 14 Apr 2008 06:27:05 GMT

I just finished watching the complete show. Barry Beach did not commit this crime. Its obvious from the bartender that said she was being bothered by the three or four women until closing time at 2 am, that said they were in bed at 11:00 pm., to the women that said she was told by one of the women that was apart of it, that she only kicked her in the head a few times. You people in Montana are obviously corrupt, and do not want to admit you did a terrible job of investigating Kim Nees murder.Anyone with commom sense can see that Barry Beach did not commit this crime. There are some women on the loose that did.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Danielle, Vermont — Mon, 14 Apr 2008 18:41:56 GMT

I am disgusted by the actions, or lack thereof, of the law enforcement officials involved in this case. How can they look in the mirror everyday, knowing that they blatantly ignored valuable evidence that could, and would, solve this tragic case? It's sad and pathetic that they would choose to keep an innocent man behind bars for the sake of saving face and preserving their own comfortable ways of life. No wonder so many Americans, myself included, have zero faith in our "justice" system. My heart goes out to both the Nees family and Barry's. I truly hope that this fight for truth and justice is not yet over.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sanyd Durham, Salt Lake City, Utah — Mon, 14 Apr 2008 21:06:07 GMT

Isn't there another group called, The Innocence Mission? Perhaps it would be helpful if they too were to become involved. John Grisham wrote a true crime novel of two innocent men who were eventually freed due to the help of this group. John Grisham could prove to be a valuable ally and I'm sure could interest other groups finding this case completely repugnant (that a man could be found guilty on such flimsy evidence, or better yet, lack of).
Sincerely,
Sandy of Utah

The strange case of Barry Beach

Melanie Irvine CA — Mon, 14 Apr 2008 22:52:15 GMT

They say that Barry confessed, but they asked him to present a scenario that he THOUGHT happened in connection with Kim Nees murder and THEN to place himself in the place of the murderer and tell them how he would have done it. Its so glaringly obvious that they twisted this scenario into a "confession" so why would Barry Beach even remember confessing!? It is clear psychological manipulation, and the fact that Marc R. marginalizes him for this is absolutely atrocious. He apparently is not aware of how utterly transparent he is. I simply cannot rest until Barry Beach is free. Please sign this petition: http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/freebarrybeach/index.html

The strange case of Barry Beach

Yvonne Allen, Lacey, Wash. — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 08:22:39 GMT

Mr. Beach should be given a second trial based on the shadow of doubt which envolopes this case. Despite my love for our country and way of life its imperative that the justice system takes a good honest look at itself and make the neccessary adjustment before its too late.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Katie in Ohio — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 13:23:08 GMT

This can't be! The truth is right in our face, yet the crooked authorties in Montana get away with lies and tampering of evidence. If they are so certain that Barry is guilty, then why destroy the "truth"??
Let's rally together and put the RIGHT people in prison for this murder, and charge a few others for their unlawful participation. Maybe Kim can then rest in peace.

The strange case of Barry Beach

LMK, P.I., Iowa — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:41:48 GMT

I have been investigating this case for a number of years, even before I graduated from school with degrees in Criminal Justice and Investigations. I believe that without a doubt, Barry Beach did not commit this crime, but he may know some information behind it. As far as the group of girls goes, they as well know something or were there but did not partake in the actions. Reason Barry confessed: He was under attack and the confession was taken under duress. He was being lead to confess, and even in a 20-year-old who has been in custody before, this time can be very stressful and lead one to say anything brought to them. It is pretty sketchy that the tape recorded interview has been 'lost', my theory: one of the interrogating officers said something they shouldn't have and it was caught on tape. Better to rid of the evidence than to have the culpability fall on law enforcement. These officers and governments were far to anxious to just have someone in custody, they skipped over many important factors and forced an arrest. The crime scene itself was not processed correctly nor was the collected evidence. Fingerprints, handprints and shoe prints should have all been tested against ALL suspects and not just the few of common. The one thing that seems similar within all the suspect stories: They don't ever deny involvement right away, their either don't remember or don't "think" so. Could the murder actually be the bad result of a drug party gone bad? Maybe Sissy, Joanna, and Maude along with Kim decided to smoke some dope or otherwise, and if any were unexperienced, this first time dope fiesta could have triggered a angry-paranoia within one of the girls, causing them to lose track of time, space and reality. The secret these people are withholding is like a game of Jenga: pull the right one and they all could topple. But one thing is for sure Barry Beach, did NOT commit this murder and I will put my life, education and money on it.

The strange case of Barry Beach

LMK — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 17:44:27 GMT

If anyone would prefer try to free Barry, world-wide petition anyone? Sounds like the only ones who think hes guilty is the Montana Parole Board and officials

The strange case of Barry Beach

Montana Friend — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 18:24:24 GMT

It is clear to me the detectives in Louisiana had Barry so twisted by the time they got the confession, and then they sold it to the authorities in Montana and the bought it hook line and sinker without checking to see if it was correct or not. Why are they so afraid to look at the bright truth staring them in the eyes?

The strange case of Barry Beach

The Fitzgerald's — Tue, 15 Apr 2008 23:12:32 GMT

Political coverup. Too many high powered people protecting each other. No follow up on cop kicking in the evidence room. No follow up to having his daughter's palm tested for a match (maybe why he disturbed the evidence in the first place. Sounds like he knows something).
Not all people who's names came up were fingerprinted for comparison?
This is really scary. How many of these cases happen in a small community where no one hears all the facts. These men did not do their job correctly and impartially. They are protecting someone. The fellow officer's daughter?
I hope Barry will be set free and I hope that the parole board is investigated.

The strange case of Barry Beach

an "inmate" of FPT — Wed, 16 Apr 2008 04:29:18 GMT

the saddest part of all this is that there aren't enough people with backbones here to do anything about the things that happen around here. the police forces are inept. To you former residents, congratulations! I'm glad you had the sense to get out with your families still intact. Any time you think you're lonesome for here...just read the daily blog and that thought will quickly leave your mind. Ft. Peck Reservation is a totally disgusting place to live.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Margaret, Havre, MT — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 02:31:26 GMT

I graduated with Kim and went to school with Barry Beach. For years I condemned him. Now with the information that has come forward I believe Barry is innocent. I have always had unanswered questions about Kim's murder and those questions are still unanswered. Who's hand print is on the door? Why was there never any mention of tissue analysis from under Kim's fingernails? (Was none ever taken?). You cannot tell me they only found 1 hair sample. What about the bloody towel? My 12-year-old even noticed the coincidence in that all three suspected girls were home at "11:00".

I believe that ex-govenor Racicot's cases all need to be investigated. This is not the first time that he put a presumed inncent person behind bars for 20+ years. Maybe he is the reason the evidence at the State Crime Lab cannot be found and there is no record of the evidence being destroyed.

John Grisham's book "The Innocent Man" is based on actual cases of coherced confessions that took place close to LA. Using a persons fabricated story of committing a crime has been used as a confession many times. After hours and hours of interrogation a person will do almost anything to get the torture to stop because they the believe the American Justice system will keep them safe.

Barry has served 24 years. I believe Barry Beach should be released due to lack of evidence.

The strange case of Barry Beach

J. Hall - Tigard, Oregon — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 02:43:39 GMT

As always, Keith Morrison, did a fine job of reporting this sad story. I hope "Sissy" keeps feeling guilty for the wrong she has done and the others that have put an innocent man in prison.

The strange case of Barry Beach

MJ — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 03:04:55 GMT

What about Kim's boyfriend? Nothing has ever been mentioned about him. Where was he that night? When was the last time he saw Kim? Just a FYI.. Kim's boyfriend's brother was the man who murdered Kim's grandfather.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Brenda D., Jefferson Iowa — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 06:59:55 GMT

I just finished watching the program on Barry Beach. I am sickened and disguted by the so-called justice system and especialy the by the verdict rendered by the Montana Parole board. While one can undertand some sort of sick reasoning behind the original investigators and prosecutors need to believe in their case, there should be hope that a parole board would be an unbiased audience. How could they have denied this man his freedom or at least some hope of freedom after all of the evidence and lack thereof? I once was proud to say my family hails from the great state of Montana. Today I will say that with a little less pride.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ohio — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 11:53:34 GMT

There is a blog comment on another site where A girl claims she knows a girl involved, and was taken into her bedroom about 10-15 years after the murder. This anonymous girl says she was a teen at the time. Apparently, she showed her a key ring necklace or something in her jewelry box. She said she ripped it from Kim's neck when they killed her, and has been keeping it ever since. The anonymous writer says she was threatened if she every told anyone. Now, do any of you believe this took place, and have any locals ever heard of this story? I would like to think that if this really happened, this person would come forward and give details. On the other hand, I certainly hope someone isn't blogging for attention.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Melanie Irvine, CA — Thu, 17 Apr 2008 16:38:12 GMT

Please sign and express your thoughts here: http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/freebarrybeach/index.html

I would also encourage everyone to contact their representatives in congress to raise awareness on Barrys case. Thanks

The strange case of Barry Beach

Becky Schwartz, Missoula, MT — Fri, 18 Apr 2008 03:26:22 GMT

I am a Montana native, born and raised here in this beautiful state. I Love Montana, but at this moment I am embarrassed. I am embarrassed of our "justice" system and our so called political leaders. Are they so vain that they would rather leave an innocent man in prison for a crime he did not commit than to say sorry we made a mistake? In my personal opinion, Mr. Beach is still in prison because of political Ego. Small town police department with an officer whose daughter is/may be involved, head prosecutor who later becomes our Gov. with greater political asperations, come on - they don't want mud flung in their faces. This is political all the way. There is NO evidence against this man. He is innocent and should be released from prison.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Melanie Irvine CA — Sat, 19 Apr 2008 03:38:24 GMT

Hi everyone, sorry for the repost, but I just wanted to make sure you all are aware that we have a petition for Barry. I would encourage all concerned to please sign. I have already emailed the link to my state congressional representative just to raise awareness

http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/freebarrybeach/index.html

The strange case of Barry Beach

Darlene Peterson, Montana — Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:27:33 GMT

I just attended a rally in W Yellowstone.. it was not a huge rally, but we passed out flyers, had our posters up when the people attending the Tourism convention walked in..some made comments like"wrong place" some asked "who is Barry beach?" some commented that "bring Raciot back and put HIM on trial,, Barry Beach is innocent" others wanted to learn more.. www.montanansforjustice.com
One of Schweitzers "goonies" was there, trying to be all tough, we had gotten permission to be there,to hand out our fliers and everything BEFORE we even went out.. the "goonie" asked "do you have a permit to be here and handing out fliers?" I told him "we have cleared this with the police dept and we were told we were fine." With that, he told me he was going to call the police..when he did.. he found out we had cleared it all.. and he was MAD. The rally was peaceful and quiet.. we have been told from some inside that it was all very positive and people were really talking.. even newspapers have contacted us in regards to the rally and the FREEING OF BARRY BEACH..
I am a lifelong friend of Barry's and we Thank each and everyone of you for your support.

The strange case of Barry Beach

REZZZRUNNER — Mon, 21 Apr 2008 00:06:04 GMT

I live in NE Montana about 50 miles from the "rez" and we too have the same problems with law enforcement here. When we do get cops that transfer in to work that they don't last long before they're leaving. The "Good ol' Boys Club" rings a bell. As far as Poplar goes......I think there might be a few good people but around the corner lurks evil. I'm sure we don't hear a 10th of the crime that happens between Poplar and Wolf Point not to mention the stuff that goes on that never , never comes out. Think of all the crime that goes unnoticed!!!! I'm sure a blind eye is given 80% of the time. It's sad in the fact that there will be no stop to these kind of actions. The young see this and they too think it is proper behavior and the circle of this life just grows darker and evil!!!Please flood these e-mail address above. We need to help the innocent..even Barry!!!

The strange case of Barry Beach

Ronnie, Meeker,Oklahoma — Mon, 21 Apr 2008 07:13:26 GMT

The courts are set up so that someone is punished. It doesn't matter whether or not the person is innocent or guilty. They are getting better thanks to the CSI's. There have been several cases here in Oklahoma that were so similar. They need to let him out so he can enjoy what's left of his life but, they are afraid of the lawsuits now. I would like to updates on what happens to him and the others involved.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Sandy — Mon, 21 Apr 2008 09:19:16 GMT

Centurion Ministries should contact a program at Northwestern University that deals with these cases. Sorry, I don't recall the name of the program. They started taking on and investigating cases of wrongful imprisonment, usually the convicted were on death row. Students and Professors had quite a few cases overturned in Illinois. I truly beleive that's the reason the Death Penalty has been suspended here. I think that Centurion Ministies has done a great job but everyone could use help sometimes. Good luck to Barry and Peace to the Nees family.

The strange case of Barry Beach

Angela Brown — Mon, 21 Apr 2008 19:53:00 GMT

After reading about Beach I am scared of our justice system. They have an innocent man in jail and we have four killers on the loose. The reason the Parole Board won't let him out because they are going to get sued by Beach . LET BEACH GO!