Dueling movie versions of a crime

Doug Fransen — Fri, 11 May 2007 21:17:25 GMT

I'm Tom Morgan's former brother in law. I'll admit I don't know Tom well but after he had me read his screenplay something inside told me he was Jennifer's murderer. Your blog comment about a 'devoted' brother reminds me that when I read the screenplay I was convinced there was a possible incestuous relationship between Tom and Jennifer. I believe Tom got jealous and murdered her. The murder, as descibed in his screenplay, seemed to have too many minor details to have been written by someone who wasn't there.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Leonard Trimmer, Hamilton, OH — Sat, 12 May 2007 01:17:28 GMT

Tonight's story strikes close to home - a botched investigation, an obvious suspect, no justice, workings or non-workings behind the thin blue line, and a family who cannot find closure... On November 25, 2005 in London, KY, my daughter Jessica Trimmer got into a domestic dispute with her live-in boyfriend. She fled on foot toward the local bus station, for the first time leaving behind the two children who he never supported with spoken intention to return to get them, after he had called 911 on her. He went out after her in the dark and ran her over. Instead of calling 911 this time, he called his father to the scene. The pair drove her to the hospital in a different vehicle, still not alerting anyone, then dropped her off, returning to retrieve the initial vehicle. She died alone in the emergency room. The boyfriend claimed it was an accident and to date has not been charged with a crime. As in tonight's story, the victim's family is told that the investigation is still ongoing, despite the witness accounts that the family has helped come forward. Police told us the same things - that WE would be responsible for ruining the case. I hope that you may find an interest in our story for a future broadcast. We are stuck in trauma, same as the Morgan family. It will be interesting to see how tonight's story ends.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Angela Florence, SC — Sat, 12 May 2007 01:51:39 GMT

I am outraged by what the officer in Michagan is saying. This family had nothing to do with it. How dare him try to tear a family down like this after all they have been through!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Kyle Kirchhevel — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:06:25 GMT

The SECOND half of your report was great Keith... as for the first half, I have no idea because the idiotic NBC affiliate here in Jacksonville pre-empted your first hour to air a special on who made the cut at the Players golf tournament. Eagerly anticipating the episode coming online so I'll know what the heck happened in the first hour. Moug sounds like a bitter wannabe to me. Oh, and one more thing... I HATE GOLF!!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Lynn McClellan — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:09:18 GMT

A superb Dateline, one of the best ever, and narrated by the great Keith Morrison, who narrates everything he does with a style that is all his own. Even when the program is not one of the best content wise, listening to Morrison is a sheer pleasure.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Catherine Renne, Columbia, MO — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:12:48 GMT

You have restored my faith in the media. I am a middle-aged, white female in the town where some of you colleagues may have recieved their Journalism degrees (and where some will be given out this weekend). I am a conservative, but have been burned by local law enforcement, using lies to make simple traffic cases. These experiences have caused me to totally distrust law enforcement as a whole. My son feels the same (19) and if I were black, I don't know what I'd do. Your very clever turning of the tables what what I was hoping for. Bravo, and this conservative may end up watching more MSNBC because of THIS STORY. Who was the pathologic narcissistic liar after all? Law enforcement of course. My hope is that the vindictive obscentity that "Pat" tried to perpetrate, will allow for a very large and lucrative lawsuit, with you're all's help. How more disgusting can one human be? I do believe in Hell, and Pat will be there, burning and turning!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Natalie, Owensboro, Ky — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:15:15 GMT

I watch the show to night and I believe Tom had nothing to do with her death. I think the dective slash movie director i just sore because he did not get to direct the movie and he has no real evidence to suspect Tom. I hope they find the person who did that to her and her family may some closure. I hope the are able to move on and keep her memory alive.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Woody Rogers, Washington, DC — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:19:06 GMT

Tonight's episode, Scenes from a Murder, was one big bust. Two hours of my time invested for NUTTIN'. I've been a big fan of Dateline until tonight. If Dateline's story inventory is this bad, then the powers that be should just call it quits and sign off. If it had been April 1 today, I would have chalked up this program as one not-so-funny April Fools Day joke. We deserved better.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Anne West, Farmington Hills, MI — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:19:48 GMT

What an unbelievable story! I live across the street from Livonia, and the detective from NC summed it up best in his assesment of the police work in Livonia. " a patrolman with a rookie attitude". And it really does say something about a cop that doesn't even follow up on alibi's or review the case first hand or even read the case file.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Evie Smyth, NYC — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:24:32 GMT

I always love shows like yours, that feature crime stories. However, I am VERY DISAPPOINTED every time you use Keith Morrison, because each and EVERY TIME I hear that mans voice narrating, I FALL RIGHT TO SLEEP and miss the entire story! I am an INSOMNIAC, but that man speaks in such a monotonous, boring tone, it works like a Valium I.V. for me! That is the ONLY TIME I EVER fall asleep in front of the TV, or ever even go to sleep before about 2 or 4 AM!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Rita harden Greenville,SC — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:25:34 GMT

I had an important phone call and missed the last part of this show...grrrr, I wanted to know what the ending was, was it her brother that killed her afterall? Thank you very much...I love this show!!!!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

mike, Michigan — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:28:52 GMT

I believe that Tom was/is a substance abuser and down on his luck during that time. He said himself he lied to Moug because he was "Doing some things he shouldn't be doing at the time". I see Tom calling his sister and stating he was coming over. This is why she was at home and not at school. Tom arrives and wants to take the fossil watch to go sell for dope. He gets into a fight with his sister and by accident or not, kills her. I do not believe that the suspect in jail would do the crime during the daytime hours. Why not interview the trailer suspects girlfriend that he called on the payphone. If she picked him up after he spread gasoline all over the place, he would have smelled like gas. I think Moug is right on with Tom being the main suspect and the Sheriff who is in a political position will never admitt he botched a major murder investigation.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Amy, Greensburg, Indiana — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:35:17 GMT

Keith Morrison did an excellent job reporting on this story regarding the death of Jennifer Morrison. I found it to be terribly sad and troubling. I will not forget this story. I hope Dateline will follow up on any new information regarding the case. The poor Morrison Family-God Bless them for their strength!! And God Bless Keith for doing the family/Tom justice.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Nancy Coxall, Framingham, MA — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:47:57 GMT

What about the man who comes to town and will fund the independent movie, but only if he can direct it himself. The detective pushed aside and not wanted or needed for even consultation during the making of the movie? The brother has turned out to be a very strange character, but to go on and on, year after year pretending to be driven to find the murderer, makes him much, much sicker than to have a sick passion for his sister…..not to mention the whole family torching Jennifer to protect him and then they ALL act as normal as you or I. I think there is something we still have not heard, yet!?

Dueling movie versions of a crime

AL Cheek, Anderson, SC — Sat, 12 May 2007 02:59:30 GMT

you would think that if Pat Moag was such a good cop, he would have checked out all the alibis and details of each person's story before making accusations, especially before giving a lecture to fellow officers. How can you tell other people what to do if you haven't done the basics yourself?

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Michelle, Cincinnati, OH — Sat, 12 May 2007 03:05:09 GMT

I truly feel bad for the Morgan family. Not only have they lost their daughter and sister, but now they have this crazy man out there accussing the entire family of covering up this crime. I think that Pat is finding a way of getting back at Tom for cutting him out as director. To the Morgan Family I say God Bless You and I hope that the true killer is found and that the police don't follow Pat's crazy accusations!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

David Beauchamp, Boston, Massachusetts — Sat, 12 May 2007 03:18:05 GMT

I came home from dinner with my wife and turned on the television and saw this program and watched this segment on Jennifer Morgan. I saw the face of an old friend and a family that I have known my whole life and am sick to my stomach that Patrick Moug can slander their names. To say that Tom was responsible and somehow his brother and father helped is disgusting. Tom said in the program that the family is close. Not only are they close but they are the salt of the earth. I have not been around them for a number of years as I now live in Boston, but spent my entire childhood car-pooling to school and playing in their yard. To see them being dragged through the mud is not only awful to them but such an injustice to Jenny. If anyone watched this and think that Mr Moug has any leg to stand on, please realize that his assertions are so far fetched, and that he is messing with the wrong family. 22 years ago yesterday my mother passed away, and I was reminising with my brothers about our childhood, and so many storied involved the Morgan's. I cannot emphasize enough, that these are good people, and do not beleive Mr. Moug's twisting of the story. I will say it again, that it is not only not fair to the family, but to Jenny. I went to Moug's web-site and read a story he tells about learned behavior and am so bothered by him making an assertion that Tom "learned" this beavior from his father. To infer that Jim Sr was abusive of his kids is disgusting. He is a fine man and this family will survice this slander. God bless the Morgan family.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Loreda Williams, Sarasota, FL. — Sat, 12 May 2007 03:34:07 GMT

I watched this show and could not wait to find out who really did it. But... I missed the ending by 10 minutes because I fell asleep. Was it determined who really did kill her? I would love to know the answer..... Thank you.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

David Beauchamp, Boston, Massachusetts — Sat, 12 May 2007 03:37:10 GMT

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Interested Viewer, Pittsburgh, PA — Sat, 12 May 2007 03:47:07 GMT

Keith, You are guilty of slanting your story, too. It seems that you spent most of your story defending Tom, even though his story/movie very specifically accuses another person, Chris. At the same time, your rhetoric and approach to Pat Moug's story was to make him look vengeful and that Tom could not be a suspect. I guess some of your feelings may have come out in your story. In your story, both Tom and Pat had issues with Kenney Boone's approach to the investigation. You did not spend much time regarding their issues with him. I also find it interesting that Kenney Boone has a strong feeling that the person who may have committed the crime lived across the street from Jennifer. Your story was two hours long and you spent two minutes at the end of your story mentioning this fact. That's odd. How about Kenney Boone? He thinks he has his guy and thirteen years later, all Tom and his family gets is...what? How come Tom still thinks Chris did it? In your story, Kenney Boone says Chris has an alibi, yet Tom still goes off and writes his story, makes a film accusing a guy that Kenney Boone says is not a suspect. That's odd, too. Also, how come he did not communicate with Pat Moug? Something is not adding up. Nevertheless, your story did not do justice regarding Kenney Boone and the issues both Tom and Pat had with his approach to this thirteen year investigation. Frankly, what did you accomplish with your two hour story? Maybe you could have spent more time with Kenney Boone and the guy who is in prison that once lived across the street from Jennifer. Wouldn't that be more beneficial for Tom, his family, Pat as well as actually working towards clarifying who killed Jennifer? Instead, we received your personal slant on the story. Maybe the tabloids will pick up your story. It had that feel to it.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Nick Seattle WA — Sat, 12 May 2007 04:35:20 GMT

This was an insane case with some of the most unsuspecting twists and turns but I'm glad to know that Tom has managed to put this case back into the spotlight and maybe find the true killer. I think it absolutely absurd to suggest that Tom killed her.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Danielle Oroville, CA — Sat, 12 May 2007 04:38:27 GMT

Um, hello, milky white substance in a fire? My fiance is a firefighter, and milk based products (like icecream) would not be left behind as a "milky white substance" after a fire...it would be completely evaporated. Pat is just interested in Tom because he wasn't picked as the director. I have a B.S. in Psychology with a minor in criminal justice. If Pat thinks that because he took a two day seminar on Forensic Psychology, that he is able to read people, he is an idiot. It takes more than four years of college to get that indepth with someone...oh yeah, and lie detectors aren't allowed in court because they are unreliable. This is a loving family who lost someone, and got nothing from the justice system. Hello Pat, you are not in the department investigating this crime. It is clear that the only evidence you have is your speculation as to what occured. Unfortunately real cases aren't built upon speculation. It is sad that he is talking about justice for this girl, when it was her brother who came to Pat...he wouldn't have given a second glance if Tom never approached him.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

J Stock, Indiana — Sat, 12 May 2007 04:41:24 GMT

As I watch this program I missed one thing. If the watch that belonged to Jennifer's brother was found at the crime scene how did it get there?

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Nicole, Philadelphia, PA — Sat, 12 May 2007 04:53:02 GMT

I missed the end of the story tonight. My VCR tape didn't catch the end of the story. What happens? I'm so curious to know who the killer was. Please fil me in.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Edward Arnold, Torrance, CA — Sat, 12 May 2007 05:12:34 GMT

‘Scenes of a Murder’ was well done. Thanks to Keith Morrison’s excellent coverage and top of the line editing it was spellbinding. The red herrings kept us guessing. Thanks much, and stay on the story.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

gloria tomer, tulsa, ok — Sat, 12 May 2007 05:18:55 GMT

I've always read that one common indicator of lying, is when the eyes look down and/or to the left when one is lying. In both instances when you asked Tom Morgan if he killed his sister, his eyes definitely looked down and to the left! It was creepy, because until that point I thought 'there's no way that guy killed his sister'.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Tamera VanHorn Owosso MI — Sat, 12 May 2007 05:26:17 GMT

I want you to know how deeply affected I was by this tragedy and your program on Friday, May 11 about Jenny Morgan. I can tell you that by Patrick Moug making those accusations about Tom Morgan and James Sr. and Jr, he was totally off base. I have known the Morgan family for over 35 years when we played together in our back yards in Michigan and I babysat for them. This tragedy needs to be resolved and justice served but not by Patrick Moug placing any of the blame on the Morgan's. They are truly a remarkable family who deserves none of these absurd remarks!!!!!!!!!!! I was appalled by his outlandish remarks and accusations.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Vanessa Somerville, Marine, IL — Sat, 12 May 2007 05:34:41 GMT

It is amazing the Morgan family has not sued Mr. Moag for slander. The district attorney in whatever county Livonia, Michigan is in would also be well served to review all the cases detective Moag has brought to trial over the years.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Ted Anderson Mount Vernon WA — Sat, 12 May 2007 05:36:50 GMT

Has Sheriff Boone interviewed the possible killer that lived across the driveway from Jennifers trailer? During your last interview, he stated he could put in in the area next to her trailer. If this possible killer is in a jail for the same type of situation, they why hasn't this person been interviewed? I bet the Morgan family would love to know! By the by: I require Executives - Board of Directors for my new corporation

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Debra Los Angeles, Ca — Sat, 12 May 2007 05:44:07 GMT

I was reading the coroner's report on Jennifer Morgan. The roommate said that she last saw Jennifer the night before she was murdered, but on the second page of the report, the report states the roommate last saw Jennifer at 1020am ,the day of the murder. The report says the roommate left for work at 0720am.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Greg D. Central WA. — Sat, 12 May 2007 05:45:16 GMT

I think that Sheriff Kenny Boone has it right in that the murderer was and is the man who lived next door to Jennifer Morgan and whom is now serving time in a federal prison after being convicted of breaking into the home of and raping another young woman. I bet it was him. That handsome sheriff has it right.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Joy Edwards — Sat, 12 May 2007 06:47:22 GMT

Regarding the story of Jennifer Morgan, the police officer, Pat, should be discharged from the police dept, sued for all his worth and very ashamed. I am sick after watching this. He was jealous when he got removed as the director of the movie made by Tom and defamed him personally with no evidence. I am disgusted that he is a police officer in this country. He is only interested in his personal justice. What kind of person would accuse a brother that loved and protected his sister of not only murder but incest? It amazes me how some people can sleep at night. Is there not a law against making a documentary filled with horrible lies? This is an instant in life when I hope for the sake of the Morgan family, what goes around, comes around. Monster is the only word that fits here.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Hourie, Sherman oaks, California — Sat, 12 May 2007 06:52:25 GMT

Dear Keith, I watched the episode about Jennifer Morgan's investigation, and I am so sorry that the family still has no closure. I was thinking why not call the real Alison DUBOIS and see if she can solve this mystery. I love watching the Medium and I have seen the real character work crime scenes and help authorities & families, why not get her help in all these mysterious and unsolved murder/crime cases?

Dueling movie versions of a crime

FRANK SERNA, ESCONDIDO, CA — Sat, 12 May 2007 07:05:20 GMT

HELLO KEITH: YOUR REPORTING OF THIS MURDER IS VERY INTERESTING AND LEADS ME TO ASK ABOUT JENNIFER'S GOOD FRIEND WHO SAID IN YOUR INTERVIEW WITH HIM, THAT JENNIFER HARDLY NEVER WENT TO HER TRAILER IN THE MIDDLE OF THE DAY. IT LEADS ME TO BELIEVE THAT SHE WENT TO HER TRAILER BECAUSE SOME PERSON SHE KNEW AND TRUSTED WAS MEETING HER THERE. I DONT REMEMBER THE SHERIF EVER FOLLOWING ON THAT LEAD.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Mindy, Toledo, Ohio — Sat, 12 May 2007 08:44:10 GMT

This story both broke my heart and disgusted me. How dare that cop, Pat Moag, bring such wild and insane allegations based on absolutely nothing but a grudge? I bet the only reason he said such awful things is because he was miffed for not getting to direct the movie, like he wanted. He's a horrific person, and he shouldn't be allowed to be in police work. I hope the family finds the real killer. And I can guarantee you, her brothers and father were not involved in it.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Mary, Columbia, SC — Sat, 12 May 2007 11:50:18 GMT

I am from a neighboring county to Florence and attended Francis Marion University from 1995-1999. To say the least, I was shocked when I turned the channel to NBC last night because I had never heard of this murder.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Jennifer, Columbia SC — Sat, 12 May 2007 13:28:13 GMT

I knew Jennifer, while at Francis Marion. She was a great person, who was always kind and helpful. I hope that her murder will be solved; 11 years is too long for a family to still be in the dark about what happened to their daughter. I was shocked in 1994 to find out that she died, and it still bothers me that they have not found anything substantial to go on after all of these years.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Porter Osborne, Jr. (South Georgia) — Sat, 12 May 2007 13:52:42 GMT

Being the obviously self-absorbed guy that he is, I'm sure Pat Moug is monitoring this blog to see how his "theory" played out. Moug is an idiot. Using the death of Jennifer Morgan to further his own fame seeking interests is disgusting. While Moug may have a few sycophants in Michigan that viewed his slanted "documentary" and concluded that Tom is the probable killer, it is pretty clear what the rest of the country thinks of Moug and his "theory."

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Marie, Michigan — Sat, 12 May 2007 14:34:12 GMT

Did all the posters of these comments watch the same show? There obviously is bias going on in the reporting of the story and all sides have their own idea of a suspect. To say one side or another is horrible for their beliefs is crazy. Thank goodness for all the controversy because that it the only way this crime will be solved.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Michael Meines, Lakewood, WA — Sat, 12 May 2007 15:06:33 GMT

DATELINE is my favorite show. Usually, I don't get angry watching this program but last night was an exception. Because of his lack of "investigating" his speculation leads and evidence, Pat Moug revealed his true purpose...to pay back Tom for not choosing him as the director. Officer Moug should be removed from the police department for misusing his authority and sued for slander. By the way, Keith Morrison is the best investigative reporter in the business. His voice and inflection are second to none.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Anderson TR CEO Mount Vernon WA — Sat, 12 May 2007 15:11:21 GMT

If you missed the end of this show, NO-ONE has been charged, her brother is NOT responsible! Has Sheriff Boone interviewed the possible killer that lived across the driveway from Jennifers trailer? During your last interview, he stated he could put him in in the area next to her trailer. If this possible killer is in a jail for the same type of situation, they why hasn't this person been interviewed? I bet the Morgan family would love to know! By the by: I require Executives - Board of Directors for my new corporation

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Keegan H. — Sat, 12 May 2007 16:16:12 GMT

People keep saying that Pat was just angry over being dropped from the film. Did anyone even think of the fact that Pat was planning to use the "investor" tapes as a way to gain some sort of logical suspicion on Tom? When he was interviewing Tom he was trying to find a way to somehow catch him. I think Pat was just using his role as a would be director as a cover for what he was really doing. If your going to be directing a movie that has no financing, why wouldn't you show possible investors your investor tapes? I believe Pat achieved the suspicion on Tom but as for the father and brother it seems a little far-fetched. Sure they were based off of characters in Tom's script, but for someone who has never written a screenplay of some sort, or who hasn't written pretty much at all, I'm sure they would use features of characters they could describe, characters they would know. Tom didn't write his family into the script to show how they did it, he wrote them in because it is always easiest to write about what you know. Why someone would want to write their family into a "based on actual events" movie about your sister's unsolved murder is beyond me but I'm sure it inst anything incriminating.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Blanche Coleman_Anderson — Sat, 12 May 2007 16:35:45 GMT

I watch the show and had to leave and I could'nt wait to find out who mueder Jennifer.I think that the murder is nearer than they think. The sheriff needs to investigate that neighbor.Someone close by her who was watching when she came home that day probablywent over, while she had the door open and attack and killed her.If you come home for a short period just to run in and out to get something, you will sometime leave the door ajar.So all you wanna bes detectives such as Moug look closer and check out her roommate as well(first suspect!!!!). I have a BS. Degree in Criminal as well.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

BETH — Sat, 12 May 2007 17:22:54 GMT

IBELIEVE Tom DID IT I CANT understand WHY HE WOULD USE HIS ON NAME IN THE MOVIES IS HE CRAZY? IT DONT MAKE SENSE also what about sweaters under the bed before the fire how woul;d he know these things derles he was there. i dont care how good you think you know a person you will be surprise how sick they are. and if if that had been another state of another what he wrote and use his name like know all those then didnt pass someone will be in jail.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

kathy miller-clapp — Sat, 12 May 2007 18:34:21 GMT

I am so shocked by this story. I grew up with the Morgans and have known Tom most of my life - and to even suggest that he would do anything like this is sick and wrong. Tom is one of the kindest, caring people I know and his family is so loving. These accusations are so wrong and it makes me so sad that Tom and his family would have to even waste their energy with this trash, instead of spending their time finding the real killer. I want Tom to know that everyone stands behind him and not one person believes this crap. God Bles Tom and the rest of the family!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Catherine South Carolina — Sat, 12 May 2007 18:55:44 GMT

Good show Keith. Tom seems like the most viable suspect to me - it seems odd that Sheriff Boone has all but discounted that theory. Tom's story of finding out that his sister has died was bizarre. Tom's dad calls him and says "whatever you do don't come home until tomorrow. Your sister died. Don't come home until tomorrow." And hangs up. What is this all about? You've just called your son to tell him his sister has died and this is the entire conversation? This might be part of the reason Pat Moug wondered if the father was involved in covering up the crime. Is this the father's code to Tom that it's safer to wait a day before coming home (police presence wise, etc.) The strangest part of the story is the script Tom wrote. Not only did he place himself at Jennifer's house before the crime but scripted himself as the object of jealousy/romantic rival of Jennifer's boyfriend. He says he did it to make Jennifer "pure" (didn't want people thinking she had two relationships going at once). Not to say I agree with Moug's theory that there was an incestuous relationship. His whole white creamy substance theory is ridiculous. But a lot of psychologists would say he has put himself at the scene of the crime for a reason. And though I think Moag is jumping to conclusions by saying Tom's father and brother burned Jennifer's body I do think the sheriff should look into whether Tom had any assistance in covering up the crime. Another commenter suggested the theory that Tom called Jennifer and asked to meet her back at he trailer. A fight could have broken out (over Tom's drug use perhaps) and he killed her either accidentally or in sudden rage. And, though it's not admissible in court, he did fail the lie detector test. They are not 100% accurate by any means but they are accurate enough that investigators frequently use them. All that said, there certainly didn't seem to be enough proof against Tom to arrest him or bring him to trial. That Moag character has his own issues and has not added any credibility to his case. The Sheriff seems to be completely passive and disinterested in delving into Tom as a suspect. Jennifer's ex-boyfriend was also a viable suspect. Did the sheriff fully investigate him? It's hard to know. The neighbor with a rape record seems more remote. It seems more likely that Jennifer knew her killer and had gone home from school specifically to meet with him. This one might never get solved.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Liza Page, Chicago, IL — Sat, 12 May 2007 19:30:22 GMT

Other lead that no one seemed to follow up on--this "friend" that the brother was visiting, and even stayed with another night after the dad told him his sister was murdered and not to come home for another day.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Barbara Mozingo, Bolivia, NC — Sat, 12 May 2007 21:11:49 GMT

WOW, I thought the rookie MI. cop presented his case poorly. The only way I would believe Tom committed the murder of his precious sister was if he was totally out of his mind on crack cocaine or if he has a severe mental illness which was out of control. I would place my bet on the Florece Co. sheriff having it correct.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Sylvia Harmon, San Antonio, TX — Sat, 12 May 2007 21:41:55 GMT

For many years I have been an avid reader of true crime and watch many true crime stores on TV. This story held me spellbound for two hours. I feel 99% sure that Tom is not the killer and about 75% sure that the neighbor is the killer. I don't understand why the story did not focus more on the neighbor. I feel 99% sure that Pat was "out to get Tom" and I was happy that the story ended with the sheriff saying that he did not believe Pat's theory. Please, MSNBC, do a follow up on this story.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Tim, Kannapolis, North Carolina — Sat, 12 May 2007 23:12:24 GMT

Just goes to show again that here in America, Cops no longer uphold the law, THEY ARE THE LAW. How can a cop so far away, without being involved in this case, acuse her brother. He is just being a big baby cause he didnt get the Directing part in the brothers film and he knows THE RIGHT PEOPLE to now make the Morgan family, as he said, PAY. Cops are dishonest, I have met a few good ones, but very few.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Jaye & Jo, Los Angeles, California — Sat, 12 May 2007 23:17:41 GMT

Hi Keith: My husband & I both are career Police Detective and CSI Officers ith more than a combine total of 60 years experience.Having done arson investigations; the problems are that alot of evidence goes up with the flames. Also, within the past 14 years science has done leaps and bounds with technologies that were not available at the time of the incident. As far as Mr Moag; we have never heard of Livonia Michigan and if Mr Moag is any example of the training, talent, professionalism on that Police Department they are in sad shape. I noticed that he didn't have any experts that spoke defending his wild-ass-conclusions. If his education qualifications are only a 1 week Reid Interrogation School and a 2-day up-date work shop that is pretty lame. I have a BA in psych/criminology & MA Admin of Justice and have atttended many continuation education classes, including the same training schools he claimed that gave him his expertise. I know in Southern California we would never get a filing from the DA on the witch hunt evidence that he laid out. Hopefully his acting is better than his law enforcement knowledge; what a joke. He would do better getting a stand in job for Michael Chiklis. Also, was it necessary to show shots of him working out in his wife beater t-shirt (he needs to beef up his arms more). I suggest he leave the Morgan family & the law enforcement of Florence alone and start looking into "his crystal ball" and tell us what happened to Jimmy Hoffa or DB Cooper. I commend you on calling him on his assumptions.. My regards to the Morgans. May they realize that Mr. Moag doesn't represent the rest of the law enforcement community.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Corey Cicci, Los Angeles, CA — Sat, 12 May 2007 23:39:21 GMT

Corey Cicci, Actor from Among Brothers Hello, my name is Corey Cicci, and I'm one of the lead actors in the film Among Brothers. I feel compelled to write a few comments, since I know Tom Morgan and worked with him on this film, and because I have met Patrick Moug and have seen his documentary, Bold as a Lion, in its entirety. A quick note...I feel as if I have kept an open mind throughout this entire experience, from first reading Tom's script in 2004, to speaking with Tom about the facts and his opinions on the case, shooting the film Among Brothers, speaking with the Morgan family, meeting Pat Moug, watching Bold as a Lion, and finally, watching the Dateline feature. I have never been quick to judge anyone, and I have been cautious about forming and sharing my own opinions on this bizarre case. Having said that, here is the big problem I have: the root of Mr. Moug's theories and accusations comes from Tom Morgan's script, and this script is a work of art. Although it is based on actual events, it is still a work of fiction. You can decide for yourself as to whether these "clues" are some cause for concern or are completely ludicrous. But the bottom line is that Pat Moug pulled alleged facts and evidence from a screenplay. (Furthermore, the video interviews in Bold as a Lion between Tom Morgan and Pat Moug were shot as short promotional videos in order to pitch Brothers to investors. They are not recorded depositions, and they are not testimony. Like Tom's movie, they are artistic in nature and should never be mistaken for fact.) So why did Tom Morgan write himself at the scene of the crime in his movie? I've spoken with him about this, I've thought about it on my own, and I'll tell you why -- because it is a metaphor for how Tom feels. I believe he feels as if he should've been there to protect his sister, as if he barely missed the opportunity to prevent this outrageous crime and save his sister's life. Pat Moug thinks that Tom's writing of himself at the murder scene (and writing much of the movie from the killer's point of view) is some kind of mistake or "slip up" on Tom's part, revealing that he was actually involved in the crime. To me, it has the opposite effect. It shows that Tom can write about such a heartbreaking event with no barriers. This is his way of finding closure -- by trying to understand the actions of the killer(s), by trying to think about what the killer thought about that terrible day. Instead of simply thinking of the killer as some violent psychopath, he thinks of this person as a human being and tries his best to understand them. Tom Morgan loved his sister, and writing about her death is how Tom has been able to move on. If my sister were murdered, I would hope that I could be as strong as Tom Morgan and capable of thinking about her death with as much insight and lucidity. I'm proud to be a part of the film Among Brothers, and I'm proud to know Tom and the Morgan family. Whether or not this crime is ever solved, Jennifer Morgan's life will continue to be remembered and celebrated, as it should be.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Rayne Poussard — Sun, 13 May 2007 01:16:13 GMT

Keith, I was mesmerized by the content of the Jennifer Morgan Murder as presented by MSNBC. It was a sad episode unlike thousands more like it throughout the country. Livonia detective Pat Moag took a giant leap of faith in making such an assessment against Jennifer's brother Tom because including himself in a screen play or of reportedly failing a lie detector test or responding the person responsible for the murder should be prosecuted and sentenced accordingly by the court or looking downward when asked if he killed his sister. All of these things in and of themselves does not make one "a murderer". I think the country sheriff has nailed his best suspect who is currently incarcerated in a federal penitentiary on an unrelated crime. Detective Moag should spend more time on the beat and less time making movies. It might serve him better as a Detective. He reminds me of the Palm Beach Detective who botched another murder and upon a thorough investigation it was learned the Palm Beach Detective was nothing more than a "hair dresser"!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Lisa, Georgetown, SC — Sun, 13 May 2007 02:29:02 GMT

For my sanity . . . PLEASE let me know what happened at the end. After watching for 1 hour & 45 minutes, I fell asleep! The last thing that I remember was SLED investigating Tom after failing a polygraph. Then I recall the detective making a film and showing it to a group of friends at a theater. Thank You

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Peter Ross — Sun, 13 May 2007 03:33:09 GMT

The allegations and aspirations of the dangerously intrepid among us should always be held suspect. I couldn't think of a wider conflict of interest than the agents among us who aspire to influence the police, the press, and the slippery domain of infotainment that barely seems to separate them.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Susan, Yuba City, CA — Sun, 13 May 2007 05:19:56 GMT

I agree with Natalie in KY...the "movie director" seemed awfully interested in the story when he thought he could make money producing it. Then, when he's replaced by someone else, his project becomes one of framing Tom. I'd like to hear Paul Harvey's "rest of the story" on this one!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Jade, Evansville, IN — Sun, 13 May 2007 05:37:06 GMT

Very even handed reporting, albeit a surreal story that you would expect from a paperback novel rather than real life. I hope there is a follow up to this story sometime in the future. I'm very interested in how this all will unfold.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Sybil Okla. City OK — Sun, 13 May 2007 07:08:34 GMT

What confuses me about Tom is: Failing the lie detector test. How did his watch get into her hand if he wasn't there? And what was she doing at home early - maybe to meet him in response to his request for help or something. His nonchalant attitude. His knowledge of the crime scene. I'm not saying it was murder - maybe an accident that he thought had to be covered up to avoid self incrimination. These questions would need to be answered for me if I was the investigator.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Sharon, St. Cloud, FL — Sun, 13 May 2007 07:44:24 GMT

Was this story really worthy of 2 hours reporting time? Because I felt slighted. People playing detective without having all the facts and at the end absolutely no new evidence and taxpayer's time and monies wasted. Supposed Michigan do-gooder could have just submitted evidence to Sheriff Boone for consideration. I think Dateline can do better.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Nancy, UT — Sun, 13 May 2007 15:22:18 GMT

After watching the whole program I was appauled at Patrick Moag. He has no evidence against Tom but wasn't reluctant in accusing him and bringing the Morgan family down with him. Maybe he should check his ethics before deciding on his own who is guilty. I was disgusted by him.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Christine Daniel Smith, Charleston, SC — Sun, 13 May 2007 19:09:57 GMT

I was room mates with Jennifer at Francis Marion. She is a beautiful person that just made you happy when you were with her. Jennifer and I would go to her home in Mrytle Beach some weekends. She loved her mom. This story did my heart good to see her family and past pictures. I can not believe that anyone would consider that any member of her family would be involved! Her family was very close and very supportive. My prayers go out to her family! I still think about Jennifer as I go through my daily life. How I wish I could share with her all of my blessings. Jennifer touched many lives while she was here. She made many lives better! I wish my boys could play with her and listen to all of our stories!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Erin Barry-Lasceski, St. Johns, MI — Sun, 13 May 2007 19:36:15 GMT

I agree with the comments written by David Beauchamp (Massachusetts). I, too, knew this family. While I was in college, I dated Tom Morgan. There is absolutely NO WAY that Tom (nor his family) would commit this crime. Tom comes from a very close tight-knit, loving family. It sickened me to see Pat Moag's version. I hope that Dateline's story stirs up information leading to the arrest of Jenny's killer and eventually gives the Morgan family some closure. My thoughts and prayers are with all of you!

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Pat, Louisville, KY — Sun, 13 May 2007 20:11:01 GMT

I have seen Tom Morgan's movie and Pat Moug's documentary and each is specific regarding a theory of who killed Jennifer. Keith Morrison, through his editing of Friday night's Dateline, also put HIS spin on the "who done it". Unfortunately, Keith Morrison is guilty of doing what he accuses Pat Moug of doing. He seemed to be damning Pat and protecting Tom, while not doing much to follow up on a lot of holes investigation headed by Kenney Boone. We did not get enough of this part of the story. I do not think Keith Morrison did Jennfer "justice" either; a bit hypocritical. Ironically, Tom Morgan's movie is just as accusitory as Pat's documentary. Yet, Keith Morrison's Dateline story went to great lengths to show one side, protecting Tom and damning Pat. If you have not seen Tom's movie AND Pat's documentary then Keith Morrison's report would make you think exactly what HE wanted you to think. It is easy to persuade people when they do not accurately get both sides of the story. Keith Morrison's story did not help answer to many questions to who killed Jennifer. Shouldn't that anger the Morgan family?

Dueling movie versions of a crime

R. Gray From Florida — Sun, 13 May 2007 20:11:07 GMT

I feel Sorry for Jennifer because she DID NOT deserve to die like that! Her age got to me because I was at the same age when she got murder, she was a month older then me and I DO NOT LIKE to out live a person like that. The stupid moag is a retard! I believe that Tom is innocent. Chris Woodson might be innocent, But the guy across the street IS NOT innocent and might be the one who killed jennifer in the first place.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

earth — Sun, 13 May 2007 21:44:00 GMT

most of you people are missing the overall LARGE picture. ALL THESE COPS ARE DOING THIS!! They attend a class and think they deserve a diploma. that’s why its a certificate and NOT a diploma. who knows if the guy teaching the class didn’t have ONLY a certificate, but should have a degree in said field to say the least. cops are out of control and believe they are all at the top of their game. few are, and usually they're in control of the shop, not a worker bee. don’t get me started on these DA's either. these guys have some who couldn’t be more guilty and they want more evidence to prosecute. and then you have others that just go after the innocent based on other liars. like those lacrosse players who were supposed to of raped that stripper or dancer broad? what’s up with that DA? then to suggest that the guy nailed his own sister? i mean, i hope they are so suing that wanna be law enforcement excuse of an earthling. and finally what the hell is dateline doing anymore? tabloid TV, no different than any other show from maury to springer to okra, just no audience participation. But seriously pat, take up sky diving or something man.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Joe, Johnstown PA — Mon, 14 May 2007 04:38:56 GMT

Great story, it certainly had my attention throughout the entire show. I agree 100% with the detective from S.C., when he stated Pat was simply a young cop trying like hell to make a name for himself. The sad part about that is, Pat's bizarre investigation ( how can a legitimate detective investigate without checking out the alibis? ) came at the expense of a murdered woman and a very distraught family. Incest?, a family covering up the crime?, what on earth is going on inside Pat's head? Thank God he's in Michigan and I'm in P.A.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Angi, Colorado Springs, CO — Wed, 27 Jun 2007 22:16:54 GMT

I missed the original airing of this episode but just watched the entire thing online. All I can say is that the brother is innocent, the Michigan cop is an idiot out for revenge for being cut out of Tom's movie and Kenny definetly has something there with the neighbor that is in jail for a VERY similar crime as the one committed against Jennifer. Also, SHAME on the cop that accused the Morgan family of having anything to do with their daughter's (sister's) death.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Corey, Hickory, North Carolina — Fri, 10 Aug 2007 11:15:37 GMT

This story is probally one of the best storys I have ever watched. Now that I watch the story I am going to sit back and watch the movie again. I was an extra in the movie when they produced this back in 2004. I had read the script most of the way through and it was put together very well. But now that I have seen the story on Dateline it makes me wander myself....who really did do it. Thank you MSNBC for doing this story and too all who read this you should go out and get the movie and watch it. I went and bought a copy when it was released and everyone who watches it enjoys it.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Dan, southern california — Thu, 16 Aug 2007 06:55:25 GMT

I think Pat Moag achieved his goal. He is now a "known" figure in the media. Many aspiring directors try to find ways to jumpstart their career.
Unfortunately, Mr Moag used a sad story about an unsolved murder to do so. People will do anything to
find success. Tom is a genuine person, Pat Moag should be ashamed. I am totally blown away, shocked, and completely angry that the Morgan's haven't pressed charges against Mr. Moag. Please, if any of the family members read this, I am a lawyer, and from what I've seen on dateline you have a case against Pat Moag for defimation of character and slander with malitious intent. Please put this pathetic excuse for a cop in a court room. I hate no one, but this is the closest I've come to doing so. Poor Jennifer, I want to express my deepest regrets to the Morgan's.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Dan, southern california — Thu, 16 Aug 2007 06:59:57 GMT

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Evelyn, Philadelphia, PA — Thu, 16 Aug 2007 17:05:43 GMT

When asked what would be the proper punishment for whoever killed Jennifer...Tom said, whatever the courts decide...WHAT?!...That is not what you would be thinking if they killed your sister whom you loved and were sooo close to...Tom is a LIAR...and how was it that his lie detector test was an error?

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Marinade Dave, Casselberry, FL — Thu, 16 Aug 2007 18:36:27 GMT

I watched the program last night and it was extremely compelling. I put it on while flipping through the channels and for two hours, I was glued. Very well done.

To say that Pat Moag is a nut case is too much of an understatement. Here's a cop gone bad. He lied through his teeth when he said being replaced as director had nothing to do with his obsession to frame Tom Morgan. Moag reminds me of those old time Jim Crow sheriff deputies who had hanging trees all around town. "They's guilty 'cuz I says so. Hangum!" Where was the white substance the coroner never found? When did Tom Morgan say it was vanilla ice cream he brought over to his sister's in the semi-fictional screenplay? Where was the proof the family covered up her death? To accuse poor Jennifer's father and other brother, too? Wow, I sure am glad he never pulled me over. I think we've all run across cops like him. Personally, I think he should have been a security guard in a fast food restaurant parking lot somewhere. Why would a career cop still act like a cop wannabee? Hey, Pat, stay away from Orlando. We don't like your kind around here! Maybe, I'm your guy, but I have an alibi. Too bad you're not smart enough to check it out because you hate to be wrong.

As far as Jennifer's brother, of course he's going to have a strong opinion of who did it. If my sister died, I would go after that creep and be just as obsessed about his guilt as the idiot cop was with him. The major difference between the star cast members, Pat & Tom, is that Tom was the victim's brother. The cop was laughed all the way back to Michigan with only intangible evidence between his ears. What was that comment he made? Something about not caring who he put in jail? Something about not caring if they're innocent? I wonder how many people he personally obsessed over and now they are locked away. Ego, ego, ego. Good thing he doesn't have authority to arrest people all over the world like he dreams of.

Oh, thank you, Mr. Morrison. It was a superb piece of journalism. I did not feel it was slanted in any sense of the word. Moag did it to himself.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

john doe seattle wash. — Sun, 02 Sep 2007 05:59:37 GMT

dateline this is to you. you approved the nutcase comments against pat moug but you wouldnt post my comment about how none of the viewers got the whole story from your show.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Joseph, Stockton, CA — Sun, 14 Oct 2007 20:20:21 GMT

Moag was correct about there being a narcissist in this sad story, but it was not Tom Morgan. Moug is the sorriest excuse for a law enforcement officer I've ever heard of. His parents, and the good citizens of Livonia, Michigan should be ashamed.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Suzy Mahony, Rio Rancho, NM — Sun, 14 Oct 2007 22:01:43 GMT

Hello, I just viewed this story today Oct. 14, 2007. With regard to the Jennifer Morgan case. I am very intersted in what is happening now. As well as wanting to know how the last few minutes ended? My DVR cut to another program to be recorded. I would like to know if you have a schedule either weekly or monthly? Will this show be aired again and when. Thank you for these programs they are very informative.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

mike kramer — Sun, 21 Oct 2007 05:11:52 GMT

would like to know when this will air agian

Dueling movie versions of a crime

Ellie P. Yorkville, Ohio — Sat, 12 Jan 2008 14:57:50 GMT

It's Saturday morning, Jan. 12, 2008, and I interrupted my bread making to watch MSNBC's documentary on the death of Jennifer Morgan. It aired from 6 to 8 am. EST. I can't, by any stretch of the imagination, think that Tom Morgan or any member of his family had anything to do with his sister's death. With 10 minutes remaining, I was hoping that there would be some sort of a conclusion to this baffling mystery. I feel everyone connected to this investigation wasn't really seeing the big picture, they can't see the forest for the tree.Instead of focusing on Jennifer's immediate family, they should broaden their sights on any possible outside person/persons of interest. Unfortunabely, this airing, although informative, was anti-climatic. There will be closure for the family, just keep the faith because through God, all things will come to pass.

Dueling movie versions of a crime

FMU ALUM -------and proud of it! — Tue, 13 May 2008 14:52:24 GMT

I also went to Francis Marion with Jennifer and she was my neighbor at the on campus apartments for 2 years. I remember the day she was moving out to move to the trailer park across the street. She said she was just ready to move off campus. I always felt like the trailer park was shady and was confused on why she and her friend would move over there. But all that does not matter. What does matter is that an innocent girl with her whole life ahead of her is not here anymore and some killer is out there. I think we should all concentrate on finding the killer. Her brother had an alibi a solid one. As for her boyfriend , I knew him too. I would be shocked if he had anything to do with this. Shocked but do understand that people snap. However, I don't know. We need to pray her murder be brought to justice. God Bless You Jennifer