ABOUT INSIDE DATELINE

Inside Dateline is your Web line into Studio 3B, providing you with a personal behind-the-scenes look at how we bring you our stories.

Whether it's a gripping crime tale, a hidden camera investigation, or a celebrity newsmaker profile -- Dateline correspondents and producers spend days, months, and sometimes even years researching and reporting the story. Learn more about what goes on inside our investigations, and find out more about some of the people we've met.

Ann Curry hosts Dateline. Dateline's producers, correspondents and host post here often. Previews to upcoming stories, more information on our reports, and follow-ups can be found on this blog.



Kidnapped teen: 'Bunker was hell'

Posted: Thursday, March 06, 2008 7:14 PM by Dateline Editor
Filed Under: , ,

Elizabeth Shoaf, the brave high school girl who was held hostage for ten days in an underground bunker and managed her own rescue, speaks out in great detail for the first time to "Dateline's" Keith Morrison in "Into the Woods," a very special two-hour Dateline, airing Friday, March 7, at 9pm on NBC. Below she writes about the experience.

By Elizabeth Shoaf

Down in the bunker was hell.   When I first went in, it was very dark and cold. I couldn’t see anything and everything looked creepy.  After Vinson turned on the lights, it was even creepier. It looked unreal, almost like I was in a really bad dream.

I saw a bunch of shelves made out of trees and rope, with food on them. Tables were made of coolers and plastic mini tables, along with a strange bedlike thing literally made out of trees, swimming floats and comforters. The toilet was made of a nasty bucket and a broken plastic chair over it with a hole in the middle.  Later on, I noticed more shelves with things like batteries and a lot of electronic stuff that I still don’t know what they were. There was also a chimney made out of aluminum that went out to the ground that he would actually use to make fires.

When I was first down there it was chilly. It was always like that at night, but in the mornings when I woke up it was dreadful. It was muggy and hot and I had to sleep in a single person bed with him and me in it and I could never get comfortable. Down there it was very dirty.  No matter where you went in the bunker you would get dirt on you, so you couldn’t stay clean.

While I was down there in the bunker I prayed all the time. Of course at first I prayed for him not to kill me. After a few days, when I had the feeling he wasn’t going to, I started to pray about my family and for them to somehow know that I was OK.

When I started to try and escape I prayed for God to help me find a way to get out. Also I prayed for God to forgive me for whatever I did because I kind of thought I was being punished. I wanted God to forgive me and help me to get away and take me safely back to my family, boyfriend and friends. I also prayed a lot to God for him to help me to calm down and pretty much stay cool. When Vinson found out on the news that I sent a text message I of course prayed that he wouldn’t kill me.  After he left I thanked God so much for everything and I still do a lot.  When I prayed it helped me to calm down more and to have hope. At the moment though, I sort of didn’t believe that my prayers were being answered , because every time I prayed nothing would happen until finally the day Vinson left.

Without my family and boyfriend and friends and prayer I wouldn’t have made it. I never really prayed a lot. I would only pray every so often whenever I was in need. And now it isn’t any different I still pray the same, I also feel the same about God, too. I still worship him and believe in him like I always have.

I think that Vinson, the man that kidnapped me, is just stupid. He isn’t crazy because if he was, he would have killed me or done something worse.  He knew what he was doing and he got outsmarted. Not to be snobby, but he thought he could get away with kidnapping and raping me for 10 days and I, 14 years old, outsmarted him -- a 36-year-old man.

He is a sore loser to me and I will never forgive him ever in my life. He doesn’t deserve it. He changed sooo much that will never be fixed again.  He took my innocence. He took my trust in people. Now I get depressed. At one moment for a few months, I couldn’t sleep. I had panic attacks and I still think about it all the time.  I can just walk around and see something and it will remind me of when I was down there, and sometimes it can make me sad and some times it can even put me into a panic attack. He pretty much scarred me and I will never forgive him for it.

I hope this haunts him the rest of his life. He deserves worse than he is getting and he better be thankful that the cops caught him and not the public. I haven’t written him yet and I don’t plan on it. I don’t care for him and I couldn’t care less if he knew about how I feel about what he did to me.

Click to read Elizabeth's mom telling how she first heard her kidnapped daughter was still alive.

For those interested in communicating with the Shoaf family, e-mail shoafs5@gmail.com.

Keith Morrison compared the relative strength of Elizabeth Shoaf and her captor Vinson Filyaw.

Click here for complete coverage of this case.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Elizabeth,

Right now you are very mad at him and that is totally understandable.  In time you will realize that you will need to free yourself from this tragic event and from him.  As long as your angery, he has control of you.  It will still be difficult for years to come but as time goes on it will get better.  I promise you this.  I wasn't kidnapped but I was molested and raped and the only way that I could gain control myself was to trust in God and to forgive the ones that did the things to me.  It took me years to see this but it did happen.  Just because you forgive him doesn't mean that you have to trust him.  I'm not saying that you have to forgive and forget because that is impossible.  But the forgiveness is more for yourself and your salvation then for him.  As for God, we cannot have that in our hearts if we want God to be with us.  He's a loving God but we must forgive and love others even if they don't love us or even if they hurt us.  You were very brave, a survivor, a hero, and God has plans for you that are unknown to any of us.  Trust in what I am telling you, trust in the Lord,  and in time you will be free of the nightmares that haunt you.  Don't let this man ruin who you are.  As long as you have anger, fear, and hate in you then he is in control.  I pray that you find the peace in your heart that you deserve.
I hope the press is happy with themselves after their reporting the text message nearly got her killed.  Their lack of judgment when a scoop is possible never ceases to sicken me.  They would eat their own children if they thought it would sell papers or translate into nightly news ratings.
The power of prayer and a calm attitude can get us far. I am so proud of this young lady for her courage to stay strong. I really hope that she can get all the help that she needs. There is this quote, Nothing in Life is to be feared, just understood. She sure did this, and look, she is alive, and her with her family and friends, and here to share her courageous story with others like me. I thank her, and wish her and her family nothing but peace and happiness.
Wow,what a couragous young woman ! It's difficult to read about her ordeal, but so incredibly inspiring to see how she's dealing with this horrible experience & moving on with her life.She is an incredibly strong person & I hope she continues to deal with it & grows away from it.She deserves all the happiness that awaits her.The strength in her faith is the grace that sees her through.Good Luck & God Bless.
Elizabeth I hope you can find a way to put this behind you. In my opinion homocidle murders and rapists get no forgiveness on this earth. They will pay a price worse than your imprisonment guarenteed! I know one thing is that you realize your power is God! The press stink and are of the devil. Money for nothing but inflicting pain and stress on others. Do you realize at this very moment there is someone or more than one person trapped and being tortured and raped. This horrid subhuman existence must come to an end but it never will as long as God in not first in peoples lives Earthy things are first. I hope you but your experience in a place you can store it away feeling grateful to be here among the loving people in your life. Praise God!
Elizabeth- You are a very courageous young girl and in time this will heal. You are right-you are changed and you will never be who you were. But...good does come out of bad. I was raped and molested by my father and friends as a child and as long as I was angry and afraid they retained control of who I was and who I became. For me-forgiving meant letting go and  taking my power back. What they did was wrong-they are sick and evil people but they no longer control me or my life. Sometimes forgiving is simply accepting it happened-it changed me-now I will refind my onnocence and goodness and LIVE my life. You will do that in time too!!!God bless you...
I HAVE A 13 YEAR OLD DAUGHTER WHO REFUSES TO BELIEVE THAT THESE THINGS CAN HAPPEN TO HER.
HELP! WHAT CAN I DO??
Elizabeth, you are so brave! Thank you so much for sharing your story. You are a great role model for my young girls. I'm sure your story will help save others. Thank you!
As a psychologist, I can only say that you are a truly remarkable person, and I hope the best for you and your family.  As a parent, I'm so sad that this how are children can be treated in our society today.  In time, you will heal, and you will be much stronger.  Thank you for sharing your very moving story
I'm praying for you sweetie. Your a brave girl. I can't imagine what you went through and I am so sorry he hurt you that way! As for forgivness, I believe that will come in time. He will spend every single day of the rest of his life harboring in the horror he created in doing that to you. Letting go for you is a cleasning and relief, it doesn't do anything for him. God loves you, your family loves you, and your public loves you:0) Thank you for sharing your story with us. Other girls who have been through similar situations know they aren't alone. You are a beautiful girl with a whole life ahead of you, God bless you!!!!!  :0)
Elizabeth,
  You are a very strong and brave girl.I also was kidnapped and tortured and raped the only difference is that mine had a gun to my head and he said he was going to kill me.I kept my calm and managed to get his gun and you can probably guess the rest.It changed my life forever.Do me a favor never stop therapy,I never got help,my family is/was like if we pretend it didn't happen then we don't have to feel the pain our daughter went thru.Keep strong honey and god bless you.
Elizabeth,  I am so sorry that this happened to you, noone deserves this ever.  I admire your ability to have not given up hope and outwitted this man under dire circumstances.  I hope you will take this accomplishment and empower yourself with it, most of us would be dead!  You now know you can literally be sent to hell and make it out alive and stronger. That is a true test if I've ever seen one!  I think we all suffer from some level of low-grade depression for things that happen to us in our lives for which we have no control (I know I do).  I just look for my blessings everyday no matter how down I get and it usually lifts my mood.  For every sicko out there like that man, there are millions of people who are kind and good, focus on them and how they make the world a better place.  We are too programmed to focus on the negative.  When I watched your interview, I thought to myself, "this girl will turn this negative into a positive and do something great with her life."  YOur strength of character shows through.  Best of luck.
you are a very smart young lady who did what you needed to do to stay alive..my heart goes out to you..you deserve everything you want out of life and i hope you get it..im sure in time you will learn to forgive,,but that is your choice if you do..good luck in all you do..
i know i could never even imagine something as horrible as this...this is the type of thing you would see in a horror movie. i hope you and your family live life to the fullest. good luck in the future, im sure you will accomplish a lot of great things!
I saw you on the "TODAY" show, and you truly touched my heart. You are an amazing girl, brave beyond your years. My thoughts go out to you and your family, God Bless You all. The HELL you went through is unthinkable. There is no justice for what he's done, but at least that loser can rot in jail, until he goes to HELL.
She will be in our prayers. I cant imagine being that age and going through that. I was raped and kept hostage when I was 18yrs old by a former boyfriends uncle. I tried so many times to get away but everytime I did the mans mother would call him at work and tell him that I got away and he would come and find me and take me back. He took any identification that I had away from me. I know I was only 4 yrs older than she but just cant imagine going through that at that age. She went through conditions that were more extreme than I as well. I applaud her and somewhat applaud the police for catching him. The man that raped me to this day is free. He threatened to kill me if I ever told anyone. I have grown from this and she will too. Unfortunately, she will not trust as easily. It is hard to do so even after so many years since. I am 35 now and still think about it. Though I dont think about it as much it is still in my thoughts from time to time. I even got introduced to my childrens biological father by the man. I wish I knew then what I know now. I went through 6-7 yrs of all kinds of abuse from him. My son is special needs because I was abused while I was pregnant I was abused repeatedly. He even broke my daughters arm when she was six months old. My children are terrified of him. Fortunately, he is not allowed around us. It has been 8 yrs since we were last near him. Last time being near him in the court room trying to get another protective order and communicating threats. We have grown from this and now I am married to a man that is wonderful. Has taken my children as his own and is loving and nurturing. Even though he does not have children of his own. As well as knowing that I cannot have children myself. The only was is by surrogacy. But that is extrememly hard to do and expensive. We are a marine corps family and they dont pay us enough to pay for something like that. After all of this I could not even wish this on my worst enemy. I will keep her in my prayers and hope that the family will be able to get through this. People like that that can put someone through something like that I think are sick. I dont know what is going through their minds when doing these things. You will be in our prayers.
The Carter Family
Marine Corps Family
Camp Lejeune North Carolina
I am glad that this young girl got rescued but that is no thanks to the news that had to mentioned that she was text messaging. Does nobody care anymore? Furthermore I find that Meredith is the worst interviewer because she had to repeat that the girl was raped and then ask her how she is coping? I noticed that she keeps asking people the same questions like how did you feel? I mean how would anybody feel if they had been kidnapped? I guess Meredith would have gotten points if the girl would have braken down and cry. This is just as bad as the news leaking that the girl was really smart and was texting.The news are not helping, they are making things worse. The parents raised a smart kid hopefully this helps any other child that gets ever kidnapped or the criminal now knows to not ever trust his victim and let them have access to a phone.
Hi, Elizabeth
I am a Social Worker and I am strongly reccomend you to get Trauma Therapy (Traum Empowerment therapy for adolescent). It will help you a lot specially with guilty feelings and forgiveness. Is a new approach to trauma that will relief your emotional pain. But no doubt about it you are really amazing.
Just how stupid is today's media?  Obviously Elizabeth was alive, yet still under the control of a maniac.  She was extremely lucky he didn't kill her on the spot.  The news director should be fired, along with anyone else connected with releasing the information relating to Elizabeth's test message.  
May God the Father of our Lord and savior Jesus Christ bless , protect and comfort you and all of your loved ones. Also please forgive and pray for Vinson that God may forgive and heal him, please read your Bible, You asked God for forgiveness and God provided Jesus Christ. You can show forgiveness to others in Jesus name.
Such an amazingly strong girl!  I don't know many adults who would have had the strength and courage to get through those 10 days of hell.
God always provides for us in His amazing wisdom.  It's not always the answer we were looking for and not always when we thought it should come, but He is always there, holding us in His hands.
I am so glad that Elizabeth was able to get through this with prayer, and I will pray daily that she can find it in her heart to forgive this man just as God forgives us.
I agree with Kimberly from Indiana. You really need to forgive him so you can carry on with your life. You may forgive but not forget. You cannot carry this with you, you need to leave it at the altar. I am truly sorry about what happened to you and I guess it's easy to look from the outside in and make comments about what you should do but in due time you will find it in your heart to forgive. "Forgive them Father for they know not what they do". Think about and pray about it. I hope you get better and I will pray for you.
God has special plans for your life. You went through
a hell but there is no doubt that God will use you
to help others that have experienced horrific things. Stay strong in the Lord and He will see you through! May God Bless You and your family! 2 Timothy 1:7
God has special plans for your life. You went through
a hell but there is no doubt that God will use you
to help others that have experienced horrific things. Stay strong in the Lord and He will see you through! May God Bless You and your family! 2 Timothy 1:7
My heart goes out to you for this terrible tragedy.  Although it is understandable why you use God to comfort you, I believe at some point you may come to understand that there is no God.

Where was God when you were abducted?  Where was God when you were raped?  Where was God when other young girls like yourself were in fact killed by a sick man.

If you believe prayer works, place a penny on your desk and pray it will move.  Have other join you. ...
If prayer cannot move a penny, how can it change the world around you?

It is far better to understand that there are evil people and terrible events and sometimes we are just in the wrong place at the wrong time.

This youg girl is intelligent and used smart judgement to escape. It would be nice if the "adults" who report the news showed some sign of intellgence. If they were at least as smart as this 14 yr old, they would realize that publicizing her text message(s)could aggravate her captor and place her life in danger.
We see this immature reporting daily and unfortunately, this will not change their mindless reporting.  
Best wishes to Elizabeth!
Elizabeth, We are so glad you are home safe. We live just down the block from you. My 2 boys ride the same bus you do. Our prayers were with you. My oldest son Joshua was looking for you. He kept telling me "Mom i know she is around here some where." "she is ok moma i can feel it." I keep telling him baby we just have 2 keep praying that God would bring her home safe. And that God did. It was so hard 2 believe that someone so sick was in our little area. It is just so sick of him 2 so something so wrong 2 one of our own. Our prayers are with you honey. If you ever need anything just let us know. Thank God you are home and that sicko man is away. But they should have killed him. May god bless you in everything you do. don't let this man rob you of your dreams. Like I let my brother and father who rapped me for many years before i got help. it still bothers me today and my father is dead and my bother many miles away. Just keep you eyes on God and you head up kido. With love and prayers. The Neeley Family
I posted a comment about the EMDR website, it very important that when you search for a Doctor you find someone who is certified in EMDR or has at lteast a part 2 training in EMDR training and then has had years of specialized training in the area of trauma that you are dealing with. You will see if you go to  search for a clinician that they will vary as to what they specialize in. Good Elizabeth! I'll be thinking of you ;)
elizabeth,

you have survived a horrific event. i am 38 and was a victim of incest and suppressed it for a long time. i have spent the last few years really healing from the event. writing helped me and i couldn't have done it without a book called the courage to heal by ellen bass and laura davis. i recognize many of your feelings as i read your story.  my experience is that healing doesn't happen overnight, but it can happen. i am not quite to the place of forgiveness, but i am a lot closer. i know one day i will wake up and i will have forgiven and so i will live my life, continue to heal and know that it will happen. i want to forgive for me because it has been a chain around me.

you are in my thoughts and prayers.
You are strong enough to get through this - you've already proven that.  As time passes it will get easier, but don't feel under any obligation to 'forgive' him.  You can only forgive those who are sorry for what they have done, and that burden is not on you.  You didn't deserve this, didn't 'ask' for this - but you did beat it.  Peace of mind will come from your own strength in time (just like your freedom did).  Don't ever feel pressured into forgiving that fool - he doesn't deserve such a gift from you unless you are convinced that he is forever sorry for what he did to your life, and not just sorry that he got caught.  (Try reading 'The Sunflower' by S. Wiesenthal - another survivor story that deals with forgiveness, and all that true forgiveness carries with it.)  I truly admire you.
I hope that all of you realize that the only reason that this young girl was able to be so calm in such a scary situation was because she had God. I pray that the Lord can use her story to tell the world of the power that He has. I can't tell you why this even had to happen to an innocent girl, but I can tell you that God does everything for a reason and you have to turn every bad thing into something positive. I have a feeling that if she will pray for God to soften her heart and try to forgive him then she will get past this alot faster. I know that it is easier for me to sit here safe in my home and saying this. But I do have a strong faith in God and I know that prayer changes things. God Bless!
YOU ARE A GOOD GIRL. GOD BE WITH YOU.
It's remarkable that this young woman was able to save herself despite the incomprehensible errors of the police.  First they refuse to consider the possibility that she was abducted; insisting she was a run-away then refused to issue an Amber alert.  Then, they released the information to the media that she sent a text msg for help.  Didn't they consider that  the captor was watching the news?   Incredulous.  This family had to reach out to family and friends as their only hope.  I can't imagine their frustration and despair, and hope at the very least they received or will receive a substantial settlement.
Elizabeth,  Never forget, but don't let this man ruin your life.  Forgive yourself.  As long as the hatred is deep inside you, he still has you.  God has givin you a second chance, don't let him take it away.  God bless you
I'm proud of you Elizabeth. I'm proud of your family for raising you to be so strong. You're an inspiration and a treasure to have in this world.
way to go girl , and you can bet he will get whats coming to him for what he's done ... you are so smart and courageous you will go far in life, and at a young age you are someone to look up to and admire i am so proud of you and i dont even know you... And about the police I Think they need to listen to people  instead of jumping to conclusions and thinking the way they do , why would they say you were a runaway when they dont even know your home situation ?? I dont understand ! like i said you are smart, beautiful, and you will go far in life. and i could tell your parents are so very proud of you and they love you dearly. I Pray the rest of your life is as wonderfull as you are .you are truly a miracle and an inspiration to us all!!! Betty  
God does not exist and relying on an imaginary friend in a situation like this is downright dangerous.
Absolutely amazing that he was not more deranged..One lucky girl.  He didn't have anything planned past the rape it sounds like.  I believe that it can effect you even more the older you get because things will become even more realistic and shocking. Don't let this monster destroy the rest of your life...fight it and out think it like you did when he had you hostage! Good luck sweetie!
Elizabeth,

You went through an ordeal that most of us could never imagine, and I realize you are hurt and angry.  Your choice to rely on God through this ordeal is what kept you alive no doubt, but your decision to be angry at this person completely opposite to what God would want you to do.  Let Hm judge your kidnapper.  You need to forgive him and get on with your life.  Trust me, as a person who has struggled with anger, in that you will never be able to go on with your life if you are constantly rehashing the past.  If you are one of God's children, then you know that the debt of sin you and I carry is far greater then what that man did to you...  God forgave you, you need to forgive him.
Elizabeth,
I think a hypnotherapist would be of great help to you.  A hypnotherapist can help you with the imprints that are left in your subconscious mind.  Many people don't believe in hypnosis because of all the misconceptions out there, but hypnosis (not stage hypnosis) is very beneficial to the way we live.  Hypnosis is just a very deep state of natural relaxation and it's during that deep state of relaxation,  that the hypnotherapist can give the subconscious suggestions for improving/changing one's habits/life.  I really hope you check into it.  I think you'd really benefit from it and it would help you with the panic attacks, the depression, and just the overall ordeal that you went through.  
Elizabeth,

Stay strong.  Don't let 'em grind you down.  That freak took enough from you; he doesn't get to take the rest of your life.  Keep going.  You've got the heart to do anything.
He who angers you enslaves you.  Don't let anybody do that to you.  Rise above him and his actions and let your light out.
I would find it difficult to even forgive the press for releasing the text messege information. This was irresponsible and reporting it had no bearing on finding her. Our prayers are with you young lady. You take care.

Patrick
Why would the press ever be allowed to air what had happened , knowing that she could have been killed by this man? Obviously the kidnapper had access to a television ,so they must have known that they were risking her life when they aired this story. Luckily the 14 year old girl had more intelligence than the media, and anyone who leaked this story. She saved her own life. Whoever leaked this story , should be fired.. what a dumb mistake. She would be dead right now, if it were not for the grace of God and her own intelligence.
Elizabeth,
I cannot imagine what you faced, but keep in mind that the same God that brought you thru will enable you to substain.  God said in His Word that we are to forgive so He can forgive us. Pray that God will give you the power to forgive.  This does not mean you have to like him or trust him but Love thru God. May God continue to Bless you and your family.  You are in my prayers.
Ditto Troy!!!
I don't typicaly respond to these postings, but after reading Kimberly's response, I have to say something: Elizabeth, do what feels right FOR YOU! If you are healthy and happy and empowered, you will be fine! As for the common" let go of your anger" directive- you obviously have fabulous judgment, don't let anyone tell you what you should/shouldn't do or that any choice they made is the WAY to peace. There are many ways to survive hell and however you hav emanaged to be standing strong at this point has served you incredibly well.This man did nothing to me and I'M ANGRY over the fact that he still breathes, albeit in jail, and eats provided meals, and sleeps in a clean cell each night. So, Elizabeth, stay brave, stay strong, and know that it is o.k. to be MAD! You will make your own peace in your own time. Congratulations on being a truly exceptional person, even at 14!
We're all calling her brave becasue the clown didn't kill her. She says that he didn't kill her because he's stupid. Or maybe he's just confused. Maybe he didn't really want to hurt anybody. Maybe he's just crazy. Maybe he was hoping she would clean the place up or something. Or maybe decorate it.
Dear Elizabeth,
Thank God you're ok and back home. I understand your anger and sadness at someone who did mean things to you. I carried the burden of hate and anger for many years. Finally, I couldn't carry it anymore, it was all just too heavy and interfered with my moving forward. I am prayerful as well and I asked God to help me, take the pain and suffering from me. I offered it up to Him and, almost immediatley, I felt it lifted away from me. It took many years for me to realize I could do this.
I wish you all the best and a happy life.
Dee
Wow, you are so brave.  I'm 18 years old and I'm not even sure that I would have that much courage.  I hope that you will be able to get on with your life soon, and I hope that you will be able to push on through life.  You are such a brave young woman, and I commend you for escaping the hell that you were in.  Hoepfully that man will be put away for life so that you can feel safe once again.  Good Luck and God Bless you and keep you strong.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://insidedateline.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=739278