ABOUT INSIDE DATELINE

Inside Dateline is your Web line into Studio 3B, providing you with a personal behind-the-scenes look at how we bring you our stories.

Whether it's a gripping crime tale, a hidden camera investigation, or a celebrity newsmaker profile -- Dateline correspondents and producers spend days, months, and sometimes even years researching and reporting the story. Learn more about what goes on inside our investigations, and find out more about some of the people we've met.

Ann Curry hosts Dateline. Dateline's producers, correspondents and host post here often. Previews to upcoming stories, more information on our reports, and follow-ups can be found on this blog.



For Eric Volz, a fight for a different kind of freedom

Posted: Friday, January 18, 2008 4:24 PM by Dateline Editor
Filed Under: , , ,

by Keith Morrison, Dateline NBC correspondent

Eric Volz is a nervous man.  Understandably so, too, given the nightmare he has been living through.  Has been - is still - living  through.

So on the morning we meet for the second time, he is driven the short city block from New York's Today Show studio to Dateline's interview facility. He's accompanied by his mother, step-father, and a young woman who has been acting as a publicist for the family (together, these three generated and kept alive the international pressure that helped Eric win his freedom).  All of them greet us warmly, and all, especially Eric, wear the look that says this isn't over.

I'll back up a minute. The first time I met Eric he was the best-known inmate of the Modelo Prison, a huge maximum security institution not far from Managua, Nicaragua.

He'd been sentenced to 30 years, convicted by a Nicaraguan court of  murdering his one-time girlfriend, a striking beauty named Doris.  The killing was particularly shocking for its extraordinary brutality, and Doris's mother, as well as many people in her town, and one of
Nicaragua's most popular newspapers, appeared determined to ensure Eric was held responsible.

In fact, after one of his court hearings, a local mob chased him through the streets of town, intent on - well, we don't know what. After Eric's parents hired security guards to protect him, rumors circulated in Nicaragua that Eric's people were trying to bribe their way to an acquittal.  And, in spite of clear and convincing evidence that Eric was hours away when the crime occurred, he was convicted.
 
So, to say that Eric was living through a nightmare was, if anything, something of an understatement. 

His imprisonment lasted 15 months, while promise after promise of an appeals court review came and went without result. Then, just in time for Christmas, Eric was finally freed, after the appeals court judges agreed he simply could not have committed the crime.

But it was not a man who wore a look of contented relief who joined me for our second visit, back in New York.  For one thing he was, he said, tired... though gaining strength every day that he's free.  He quibbled with the inclusion in our first report of a portion of his interview which made it seem, he felt, as if he'd behaved as a bit of a jerk toward Doris.

This time he went out of his way to repeat how sorry he was that the loss of Doris has not played a larger roll in his story. His demeanor seemed to me to be that of a man who has been on a campaign somehow extended beyond its expected end.  He worried about the fate of the appeals judges. Reports in Nicaragua suggest that one of them, at least, has been threatened, and an official investigation has been launched to reconsider their decision.

Does that mean Eric will become a wanted man? Will he been tried again, this time in exile?  Will he ever again be able to travel in Central America?  The morning of our meeting, those questions were clearly eating at him.
 
So, when Eric told the story of his experience in that prison, he seemed to be hampered by an odd 'disconnect,' as if he is still unable to face those memories, at least until he knows the end of his story.

It was only when he read from his prison diary that his daily trials somehow came alive.
 
Will he write a book?  Someone already has, he said, and without talking to Eric at all!  Will there be a movie?  He doesn't know.  All questions to be addressed later, said Eric Volz and the family who surround him, after the long, strange, campaign for freedom is done.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I watched that story and I am truly astonished at what has happened to this poor man!  Everything pointed that he was, in fact, absolutely innocent and the thought that he even has to fear that this is a never-ending battle is unfathomable.(sp)  My heart is out to Eric and his family.  Because although he is free now, and may be for the next thirty years, I don't suppose he'll ever be able to walk straight ahead without having to look over his shoulder.    
Everyone has an expectation on how people should act under certain situations.  Eric has been through Hell!  Does that mean that he has to be crying and screaming aloud that he loves life and is happy to be in the U.S again?  Maybe...maybe not.  He is still recovering from something that ripped his life away.  He just got his life back...give him time to find himself and he will come around.
I wonder how the Nicaraguan authorities would feel about this little bit of information on Eric Volz's sister?  Not so savory..

check it:
http://www.nashvillescene.com/Stories/Cover_Story/2008/01/17/The_Other_Volz/
Hi Eric ! You were two hours from the sciene of the cirme. I was 8 thousand miles from the sciene of the the crime and never been in South America before. In 1989 when I arrived for my vacation was arrested, jailed, misstreadted for 8 month for crime was impossible for me to commit. Better go to the Moon than to that lawless, coruppt place. A belgian man van Bakel.
Welcome Home, Eric. There are a lot of us who fought for you and are prepared to continue the fight in whatever manner you deem appropriate. Point us in the right direction and we've got your back, my friend.
Why do our upperclass Americans feel that the world is their playground?  Those of us who grew up in a USA where we as individuals had to work for everything we wanted and did not have any expectation of having a top legal team if we found ourselves on the wrong side of the law. His worry (now that he is safe at home" is " Will he ever again be able to travel in Central America?"  Surely you jest! Honestly if he can't find enough to occupy his time right here in the Good Old USA maybe he really needs to revisit Nicaragua.
Eric could change his "U.S. citizenship" status to that of the National of the state in which he was born, which would put him outside the jurisdiction of any statutroy/admiralty/maritime court in the United States. (That is if he is afraid that he will be extradicted back to Nicaragua through some "deal" cut between the U.S. and Nicaragua politicians, that is done for a political 'show and tell' to 'prove' that fairness and objectivity and JUSTICE exists between the two countries. Yadda Yadda.)
We do not need to go all the way to Guatamala to find this happening.  Children in the US are being snatched under the guise of state agencies who are supposed to be protecting them.  Good mothers in the United States are losing their children.  
i have read the news on eric volz, and am appauld that the latino country is so backwards in time. this makes me sick. i am 100% latino and my family is from PUERTO RICO. he was not even at the scene. give me a break, give his freedom back. that was me i would not go to central america.upstate ny luz eleana pabon lewis.
When this story previously aired, me and tweleve others were in the process of planning a trip with our travel group to Nicaragua. At that time we all decided to go to Costa Rica instead and had a fantastic time. That was about $15,000 that was spent in Costa Rica versus Nicaraga. Hope the judge is helping to support the Nicaragua economy in a big way.....
MY heart really goes out to him He clearly is distraught by the entire experience. He obviously still is at loss of words and does not know what is going to happen. Hes waiting for the final chapter of this to end so he finally can move on with his life with peace of mind.
As an American who also lives in Nicaragua and has also had an incident with the Nicaraguan Court System, I was sadly disappointed that there was no mention that the Nicaraguan Legal System is not the same as the U.S. legal System. My local Nica lawer explained it as "Here in Nicaragua you are guilty until proven innocent" My crime was nowhere near as serious as his, but I was treated with respect throughout my ordeal, even though there were communication barriers and misunderstandings that were eventually cleared up.  Nicaragua is changing and growing at a very fast pace thanks to the Americans who are starting to move there, and in alot of ways the local communities are being helped by the influx of Americans, but they are still a third world country with a different legal system and those of us who live there need to remember that.
What an obvious set-up to stir up anti-American sentiment.  They don't know how to collect semen?  Proud of Eric - what a together young man. Just threw out all of MY travel brochures to Central America.
After viewing the show, I feel that Dateline could of have done a better job at not making Eric look like a spoil rich person, with money and power to by his way of things or making the story incomplete….anyway…glad he’s innocent but Dateline could of present more from Doris’s family side or farther investigation on the court decisions, I like to know if the judge was threaten to not free him or what? and more on his fight for freedom. However, time is a issue…so understandable but hopefully he’ll get his freedom one day…if he fights for it and he’s innocent, he will go free.  
I'm glad that this story came out.  People all over should see that foreigners to explore third world countries on their own run high risks.  Easy money comes with a price which could include imprisonment and death.  The people of Latin America are not benefiting much from the economic boom of the developers on the coast lines. How much better it would be if the people could benefit from a rising economy which would include housing, schools, hospitals, etc.  Gringos should learn to stay out of these places.
Why are facts, like scratch marks found on Erics back that match a struggle, renting a car to go to a funeral before it was public knowledge, and threats Eric made on Doris's life previous to the murder always left out of this "innocent" American abroad story?
I've visited San Juan del Sur, the last time just after Eric was convicted.  Though the Nicaraguan people are on the whole friendly and gracious, I could feel the tension toward an American (male).  I regret to say, I'll never return to Nicaragua. It's just too risky, especially given the bias of their legal system.
His fear is an altruistic fear. That fear of being known as a murderer, some criminal creature, some monster, and by some evil cruel moniker that he does not deserve and that he cannot shrug off.
The fact that people cannot understand this kind of fear doesn't speak to his guilt but instead to the loose morality that pervades modern human existence. Cut off as we are by technology that all at once connects us and separates us, so that we can say what we want to who we want without the fear of having to own up to our words. I will prove my point by signing this Vincent which isn't my name from Connecticut which isn't my state.
It was discusting to watch a Dateline-victimized Eric Volz last night! I wonder why your program is not devoting any time to interviewing Doris' mournful mother in Nicaragua. Don't make of Eric a potential star who could use his hypocritical pursue of freedom a case for a book! Ask Nicaraguans and you'll get the picture. Dateline is presenting American viewers with a partial murder story. Shame on the program!
After watching Dateline on January 20,2008 about Eric's story, I was deeply touched. I would love to stay on top of this story of Eric. I do believe you are an innocent "American" Man. I couldn't imagine the fear you experienced by the Nicaraguans. Thank God everyday for your mother and her strength to fight for your freedom.
I do not believe that it is wrong or selfish to wat to see and appreciate life and thee world beyond the "Good Ol USA", I am a US citizen living in England due to a better oppurtunity financially for my family; Is it wrong to do so? No, One must know however that wherever you go, anti American semtimism is at an all time high, and that wherever you are you are subject to that countries legal system, corrupt or not.If you comprehend that the country you are going to visit is poor; expect corrupt government and officials, and a huge proportion of uneducated and oppressed citizens ready to take out aggressions and resentments on any given American.
You have to comprehend that in America we hold our justice system to a higher standard than other countries, and you cannot bring American justice to another country, not in today's world where America is essentially regarded as evil and spoiled.
I have had wonderful eperiences here. I do not fear unfair treatment due t my nationality, but it absolutely is a fact of life, and even thoug American's are persecuted and retaliated against, nobody should say that we should just not travel and explore the world, the world doesn't belong to anybody after all.
The family practically bankrupted themselves working hard to get Eric out of jail and all some can say was that money paid off officials. He scratches his back carrying the casket at his slain ex-girlfriend's funeral and people say they were Doris' claw marks. At the first sign of trouble he rents a car to get down to the scene and all some can say was it was pre-emptive grief for a murder he paid to have done. Now that he is out, some say he's stoked to have a book deal. Leave this happy ending alone. There better be a movie---it's this year's Shawshank Redemption!
i really feel for this family and as inga stated about his sister well illegals should not be in our country without the proper papers i am certain eric was not in nicarauga illegally. i really cant see any similarities here inga.
Americans need to remember that when another person comes from another country to live here, they want the rules to be followed... so if an american wants to make chaep $ off a beautiful land and decides to live there... he MUST RESPECT that country's law and he better not hink he can get away with anyhting just because he's american... YES USA, EVERYONE HATES YOU!!!
i cant find the e-mail address for keith morrison but i have 2 new scams that i recieved in an e-mail would love to forward so he could warn others
Eric seems to be a very strong man and he will fight his way through this. My heart and prayers go out to him and his family. Sad to say there are alot of cases similar to Erics out there.    I also dont understand want Inga thought posting that ad was going to prove when Megans actions have nothing to do with Eric or the Nicaraguan government.
This is a tragedy all around. The only people I don't feel sorry for are the judge, the prosecutor and the Nicaraguan media. They should have known better rather than fanning the flames of the out of control mob mentality. Shame on you. You just cost your country hundreds of thousands if not millions of dollars in lost tourist revenue. I'm not anti-Nicaraguan. I've been there on business and met really good people. It's a shame that some uncompassionate individuals ruined the reputation of a good country.
It's really sad. He was so far from home and in a horrible place. I know he's not the first and won't be the last.
I am hoping that this will be read by Eric directly... Eric, I have researched many stories about what has happened to your life with this tragic event. I sincerely believe in your innocence, and I am so sorry for what you have been through. You seem to be a very strong,intelligent, and beautiful man. I understand the chaos still surrounds and haunts you,  but hopefully you can continue to pull from that inner warrior strength God has blessed you with to get through all of this and continue pursuing your dreams. Hang in there and know that there are plenty of your fellow Americans praying for your peace. That all being said, I hope you realize how fortunate you are to have such a wonderful strong mother :) and may God bless the mourning family of Doris as well....
Thank You Cris Hanson! Job well done for attemptimg making the internet safe for our children, But We should teach parents to monitor our children. Keep the computer in a public area where everyone can see. My exwife attempted to get my oldest son on chat rooms at the age of 13. She felt that it was okay, She was having an afair with a Jewish Canter that she met online, and she felt that it was sake for my son. He received many emails from "Johns"
I did not see this story on television, I read it on the internet.  I deeply feel for this poor man that lived through that hell and made it home.  
I think this is a wake up call to all Americans, when you are out of the United States, be aware that other countries laws and punishments are different of those in the  United States, be very cautious of what you do, where you go and what you say.
Its frightening to see that this happened.  In most cases, the evidence showing his innocence most likely wouldn't have been so plentiful as it was here.  It is almost bizzare to me that so many seemed not only content to send an innocent man to prison, but that  they were ok, as well, with not seeking out the true murderer.
What a rediculous comment this person makes!

"Americans need to remember that when another person comes from another country to live here, they want the rules to be followed... so if an american wants to make chaep $ off a beautiful land and decides to live there... he MUST RESPECT that country's law and he better not hink he can get away with anyhting just because he's american... YES USA, EVERYONE HATES YOU!!!"

I understand that Americans can't expect all coutries to have the same justice systemt, but it doesn't mean that when a clear injustice happens, just because were Americans in a third world country we deserve it!
I agree that if a country is known to be corrupt or anti-american one should think twice before visiting, but all these arguments don't make the injustice of this situation correct.  People always need to fight for justice where there isn't any.  If everyone had the attitude that this person has, then change for the good would never happen.  I also hope the Nicaraguan people start wising up and electing responsible leaders - this one situation will cost them.
I just can't believe that people have the nerve to write horrible things about nicaragua and worry about a man who you don't even know. Nicaragua is a wonderful place and beautiful people.Nicaragua is changing and growing at a very fast pace thanks to the Americans who are starting to move there, and in alot of ways the local communities are being helped by the influx of Americans, but they are still a third world country with a different legal system and those of us who live there need to remember that. This is a tragedy all around. The only people I don't feel sorry for are the judge, the prosecutor and the Nicaraguan media. They should have known better rather than fanning the flames of the out of control mob mentality. Shame on you. You just cost your country hundreds of thousands if not millions of dollars in lost tourist revenue. I'm not anti-Nicaraguan. I've been there on business and met really good people. It's a shame that some uncompassionate individuals ruined the reputation of a good country.
How pathetic to see how many people critize on central america. And believing everythin they hear!
I have been to Nicaragua Plenty of times and Nicaragua is getting it all together.
I didn't see the dateline story, but read it here. Praise God his family and others were able to help him! Most Americans don't realize the dangers of living or working in foreign countries. After so long there, it's heartening to read he back in the USA. Unfortunately there are others in jail overseas serving terms for things they didn't comitt & very little to help them. It's horrid to hear of any women (or man)being attacked or killed, yet it is happening in our country too.  
After all Eric has been through, I can't imagine why he, or any other American, would ever want to visit Nicaragua again. If he feels the need to travel, there are plenty of other countries out there which aren't so backwards and anti-American.

Good luck, Eric.  My prayers are with you and your family.
Hey John Doe from Seattle, too scared to state your name.  If you saw the story, you would see that the scratch marks were from the coffin he was carrying at her funeral.  This wasn't left out, I saw it on TV.  How do you know he threatened her? You must have been there? What does renting a car for the funeral before it was public knowledge have to do with anything? How are you privy to all this information?
If someone has a link to the original trancripts from the proceedings in Nicaragua I would be fascinated to see them. Miles from the scene of the crime ? Unexplained scratches ? This would not be the first time an American commited a crime in another country and was freed by placing money into the hands of the proper officials. I spent thirty one moths in prison in Mexico for a crime I was guilty of .Some $40,000 later all charges were dropped . The only accounts we have of this come from the U.S which unjustly convicts and incarserates thousands of people every year. Not to mention the " suspected" terrorists who are held and tortured without ever seeing the inside of courtroom. These travisties of justice exist world wide . There are thousands of American citizens being held throughout the world whose families sinpmly do not have finacial means to see them freed . If indeed this yound man is innocent them he has my sympathy .
personaly I have my doubts.














Dane, This is a message from your past, one of the guys with whom you shared B-9 at 1228 E. Belmont.  Last year I had become aware of the nightmare of your family.  I just found out your stepson was released just before last Christmas, correct?  If so, I bet it was your best Christmas ever.  I actually heard about it through reconnecting recently with Don Jones.  If you get this mail, please write me back if you can.  It would be great to catch up.

BLessings,
Greg Sarensen


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://insidedateline.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=589004