ABOUT INSIDE DATELINE

Inside Dateline is your Web line into Studio 3B, providing you with a personal behind-the-scenes look at how we bring you our stories.

Whether it's a gripping crime tale, a hidden camera investigation, or a celebrity newsmaker profile -- Dateline correspondents and producers spend days, months, and sometimes even years researching and reporting the story. Learn more about what goes on inside our investigations, and find out more about some of the people we've met.

Ann Curry hosts Dateline. Dateline's producers, correspondents and host post here often. Previews to upcoming stories, more information on our reports, and follow-ups can be found on this blog.



Life after a child gets murdered

Posted: Tuesday, May 01, 2007 1:40 PM by Dateline Editor
Filed Under:

a guest blog entry by Tom Yates, father of Amy Yates

My name is Tom Yates, I am the father of two daughters, Amy and Danielle. On April 26, 2004, Amy was led into the woods of the mobile home park where we lived, by a 16-year-old boy that she knew and considered to be a friend. The boy told her that he wanted her to come listen to the birds with him. After entering the woods and walking far enough so that no one could see what he was going to do, he tried to rape her, and when she screamed for help he strangled her and then dumped her body further in the woods. The events that have unfolded that day seem like they could only happen in a movie, a horror movie for my family. (Tom, pictured with Amy on the right, and Danielle, left)

April 26 was like any other Monday. Sometime around 4:20 p.m. my girls got off the school bus and walked down to the house. Both girls had homework to do but because Amy had been doing so well at school we told her that she could play first and then do her homework later. Amy’s 9th birthday was just nine days away. We had bought her a pack of Hello Kitty invitations to give to her friends. After she had watched a little T.V., she wanted me to help her with the invitations so we worked on them together.  She asked me if she could go over to her friend’s house to give an invitation and play. I told her that it was fine but that I was starting on dinner and she had to come home at 7 p.m. I was standing at the front door when Amy got on her bike and rode across the street to her friend’s house. The girl wasn’t allowed to go out and play, so Amy came back home to ask if she could go to another friend who lived just three trailers over from us. Again, I said that was fine and to be home at 7 p.m.

Then I watched as she rode her bike in between two trailers, never imagining that I would never again see my daughter alive.

At 7:05 p.m. Amy had not come home so my wife, Shari, walked over to the Gossett’s trailer to go and get her. When she got there she was told that Amy never showed up. Shari came back to the house and told me that the Gossetts said that Amy wasn’t there. At that point I left the house mad, thinking that Amy had disobeyed us, but as Shari and I were walking back over towards the Gossett’s we noticed Amy’s bike parked on a concrete pad in an empty lot, just two lots to the left of the Gossett’s home, which is about 75 feet away.

At this point we knew that something was wrong. It was now about 7:20 p.m. and no one knew where Amy was so I called 911 and reported her missing. The sheriff’s department issued a statewide amber alert and send out a K-9 unit to help with the search, but the dog couldn’t lock onto her scent. Just after 10 p.m., my family and I were sitting at home waiting for someone to tell us that they had found our daughter when a local news channel came on TV and said, “Amy Yates has been found alive and has been returned home to her family.” But Amy wasn’t with us.


I ran up the street to the command center and asked where Amy was and they said they didn’t know but that there were two officers at my home who needed to talk to me. I ran back home thinking that I must have passed Amy and the officers on the way to the command center, but when I got home, Amy wasn’t with them. I asked the officers where my daughter was and they said that before they would talk to me I first needed to talk to two other officers. At this point, I got very upset with the officers and demanded to know where Amy was. Just then the officers opened my front door and let in two more officers who were wearing little gold crosses on their shoulders and right then I knew… Amy wasn’t coming home.

 

From that moment, and for a few days after, I don’t remember much. For those who have never lost a child or don’t have children, there is no way you could ever know the pain, loss, hurt and devastation of losing a child. I wish that no one ever has to endure the pain that my family and I have had to go through.

It has now been two years and nine months from the time of my daughter’s death and a lot has happened with the case. For those who haven’t followed the stories or don’t know of my daughter’s case, I will explain:

Just after Amy’s death, the local sheriff’s department charged a 12-year-old boy who lived in the mobile home park with her death. Our sheriff’s department and the D.A.’s office assured us that he was the one who killed Amy. After several court hearings and a year and a half later, the boy took a plea bargain called an Alford Plea, which means, “I feel that you might have evidence that would find me guilty if I were to go before a jury, so instead I will just say I did it and keep my innocence.” He was sentenced to serve two years in a psychiatric hospital.

Just the thought of someone serving two years for murder was mind-boggling. Our state’s juvenile code at the time said that no juvenile under the age of 13 could serve more than two years. That had my family and a lot of other people very upset. We campaigned for a change in the code to allow young offenders who commit violent crimes resulting in severe bodily injury or loss of life to be detained until their 21st birthday. We called the new law Amy’s law, and in July of 2006 it became legislation. But things didn’t end there.

Almost two years after Amy was murdered, a 19-year-old man named Chris Gossett confessed to Amy’s murder.  Within a few hours the sheriff’s department sent him home after telling his family that he had nothing to do with Amy’s death. At first we also didn’t believe him but after talking with friends of the Gossett family who were there when Chris confessed, we began to wonder if we had the right person. Two days later I called the Gossett home and spoke with Jean, Chris’s mom. Jean said Chris was sitting across from her on the couch. I said, “Jean, you ask him right now, did he kill my daughter?” Jean then asked, “Chris, Tom wants to know, did you kill Amy?” Chris replied, “I did it Mom, I did it. I keep telling everyone I did it but no one will listen.” I couldn’t believe what I had just heard. I just hung up the phone and began to cry.

For the next few months I worked closely with the attorney of the 12-year-old boy to help get him released. We succeeded but now we had the task of proving that we had enough evidence to indict Chris Gossett. On October 23, 2006, a Grand Jury gathered to hear evidence against Gossett and indicted him on the charge of involuntary manslaughter. This was an injustice. The Grand Jury said that they felt that Chris didn’t mean to kill Amy because of his IQ of 63; when Amy screamed he got scared and in the process of trying to keep her quiet he killed her. But that’s not the case. If they had paid attention to Chris’s first confession video, Chris said that he was taking Amy into the woods to have sex with her. That’s rape! So what Chris did is called Felony Murder.

Because the Grand Jury asked for involuntary manslaughter, if found guilty, Chris Gossett will only serve 2-10 years for the murder of my 8-year-old daughter. The system has once again failed the victim.

For now I wait for the day when this is all over and I can once again try to move forward with my life. As for my family, after Amy’s death, my wife and I tried for two years to make our marriage work for Danielle’s sake, but we were unable to stay together. I have since remarried and Danielle lives with me. My new wife has an 8-year-old daughter so now Danielle has a stepsister. Like all siblings, they fight like cats and dogs, but love each other to death. As for Shari, she has moved and met someone new, and might remarry this spring.

The report, "A Killing in Carrollton," aired Dateline Tuesday, May 1, 8 p.m. Click here for the transcript.  Click here for the full crime files.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

May she rest in peace.This is so sad.If something happen to me.I'll be with her.
May she rest in peace.It is so sad.If something happen to me.I'll be with Amy?
Hi.  I just watched this on msnbc and I wish you and your family, including your ex-wife, emotional healing.  I'm sorry this broke up your family.  I have to say, though, that the first time I saw the Gosset boy, I knew he was the one who did it and I knew why.  I'm surprised that the police did not utilize a forensic psychologist or a child psychologist, at the very least, in their questioning and their assessment.  Individuals with low IQs are often much more sexually active than their higher IQ'd cohorts because they lack impulse control.  The Gosset boy should have been questioned by someone who is familiar and experienced in working with these populations.  I do have to agree with you that the law enforcement officials looked foolish.  To me, they looked very foolish because they thought the Gosset boy was incapable of doing this because of his IQ!  That's absolutely ludicrous.  This boy was probably curious about sex, perhaps even to the point of obsession, and even a retarded person knows what's right and what's wrong.  That's why he didn't speak up for two years - he knew what he had done was wrong, not just for killing your daughter, but for molesting her.  Emotions are often felt much more strongly in individuals with low IQs because they lack the mentality to temper their emotions with reason.  That's why they often do things that are impulsive and not well thought out.  I am glad to hear that the Gosset boy will be tried as an adult.  As I'm sure you are now well aware, be very leary of an older boy, particularly one who has a lower IQ, who has an interest in a little girl, or a little boy, for that matter.  These individuals will naturally seek sex with someone they feel close to in age, particularly someone with whom they are familiar and have easy access.  A 16 year old boy, even one who has the mental capacity of an 8-10 year old, still has the raging hormones and the body of a 16 year old.  I hope you and the Adams boy have made amends.  I blame the police department for this error.  Grieving parents, in particular, cannot be objective and most people tend to believe what the police tell them.  I hope you're not beating yourself up over this.  But I do hope you've made amends.  Good luck to you and your family, and God Bless.
Tom, this is the first time I've heard of Amy's story and I am so sorry you had to go through this. I have a daughter myself that just turned nine. She is my only child and I can't imagine losing her. I am so glad to hear Danielle lives with you. You can heal together. Take care of each other!
2 years ago my husband and I lost our 3 month old son to SIDS.  My heart goes out to you.  Because there is no known cause for SIDS, I understand how it feels to lose a child and have more questions than answers.  I still find myself wondering if it was something that I did or if something was wrong with him that I didn't see.  As parents who lost a child, we will always question our actions or in-actions.  However, God has a reason and everyone has a purpose. Amy is in a much better place with my Harley and they are always watching over us.

May God bless and keep you.
I am so sorry for your loss.  I am a parent and even though I have never experienced this, WOW!  It brought tears, I hope through God, faith, love and humanity you get the results that you need.

May Amy live on forever in your heart and through good deeds done in her memory.

God bless all of your family members!  That day Amy was found not only changed all of your lives but changed the course that all your lives were to take. I hope you all find peace and justice for Amy!!!!
i have a 22 year old son and a 6 year old daughter and i can't imagine the horrific pain you and your families must be and going through. my thoughts and prayers are with you all. we as parents and a nation need to ban together in many ways to protect our and each others children. as well as changing the laws that somehow seen to protect the guilty trash and not us and our innocent children.
I cannot and will not tell you that I know how you feel, because I have never lost a child.  I do know, though, that God heals the broken heart. Know that God has your little girl cuddled in His arms and is taking very good care of her.  He has to.  She is His child.  She was His before He lent her to you.  All things that happen isn't meant for us to understand in this life.  I know you miss her, but don't let her death be in vain.  I feel, from her drawing, that she loved God, so you carry on her love for God.  That way, her death won't be in vain.  She will be smiling down on you for it.
My heart goes out to you and your family!  I am a mother of 3 and I can't imagine loosing one of them! To any type of death, much less something like this.  I am sorry that you and your wife could not find a way to stay together, but most often, this type of stress tears at people even more and it is hard to withstand the normal pressures.....  I hope that both of you can find happiness and move on from this tragedy.  I hope Danielle can live a normal life and live in fear, or agony of what happened to her sister.  But she was young at the times, so hopefully she can move on as well.  May God bless you all.  I also thought that it was the Gosset boy, and not the one they orginally charged.  I hate the way the police department handled this case!  They were really idiots in this case....  they never even looked at any other possibilites.  They latched on
to the Adams boy and never even considered any other person could have commited the crime.  The lead investigator sure has a hard time saying I screwed up!!!!!  Good luck with the remainder of the case!  
I hope the the sentence Chris Gosset to much more than 2 years....  but no matter what,  no matter what amount of time the give him, it will never bring back Amy....  and there really is NO amount of time they could give him to make ammends for that!~~  Again I am so so sorry for your loss.
Mr. Yates, my heart and eyes hurt after watching this story tonight of your lovely daughter, Amy, and of her death.  The conviction of murder by 12-year-old Johnathon Adams, and your changing the law regarding time to be served for murder by a juvenile - I totally commend you for.  Then finding out that Chris Gosette, age 16, confessed to your daughter's murder and what he said regarding unzipping her pants, etc. and the sheriff's dept not disclosing certain information for the D.A. is appalling!  But you know what...  This is how the sheriff's departments operate.  Unfortunately, you are left with a system having victimized you, and your family.  Especially your daughter, Amy.  However, rest assure, the public watching this story has learned valuable information along with realizing this could happen to any of us and our loved children as well.  It doesn't help any for me to say that, but it is all I can offer.  It angers me how law enforcement gets away with this!  I guarantee if it was one of their own this never would have happened!  Furthermore, this bit of cops drilling people over and over, especially young people, must STOP!  It messes up a conviction by doing that.  I feel the cops and the district attorney both did not want to prosecute the Chris Gosette case because he is mentally challenged.  He doesn't seem mentally challenged enough to have not thought of sex!  And killing someone is nonetheless murder.  I always think of the victim.  Amy died due to his actions.  Two years is ridiculous for a time served of murder or lesser charges (to try and keep him out of jail).  When Chris Gosette used God and his baptism as a remake on HIS personal life... that was the same as a convicted killer's guilt that they use every day.. GOD.  I think Chris Gosette is alot smarther than the local sheriff's department!
Dear Mr. Yates,
 Please accept my condolences in your grief that now I and many others share with you and the families involved.
 I believe some sort of "restorative justice" might best ease the pain for all those whose lives have been touched adversely by this unfortunate event.
 Perhaps you, your ex-wife, the Gosset boy and his family, and even the other boy and his family might better address or repair your hearts by perhaps speaking to other retarded youths--ages 12-16. And also talk to their parents. Chris' mother could talk to mothers of mentally disabled boys, and you can talk to fathers of boys like Chris. They need to know probably how to deal with thier hormones and sexual development. Possibly you and others of us who grieve with you can encourage  pregnant women and new mothers get omega oils and other nutrients to best chances for highest brain function. (Can also help prevent post-partum depression).
  You could possibly create a non-profit organization named after Amy to do positive actions that somehow honor her life and spread ripples of love into the community. Grief, and anger will only harm YOU--your body and spirit. Let them guide you to do work that can let you express the love you have for your daughter and, for her, protect other girls. At the end of your life, wouldn't you like to look over a journal of all the positive things that were able to happen out of your love for her. I think others would like to help do good work to honor Amy too.
 There is a father I know that has been doing service work to honor his daughter's life.  (His daughter was killed at age 17--I believe by a drunk driver.) The Kent YWCA might be able to have him call you.

Hope this helps.
Sincerely,

 
Mr Yates,

Our heart and prayers go out to you and your family.  I saw the report last night on T.V. and just felt your pain speaking as a father myself.  I applaud your efforts and determination to see justice served.  One day you will be reunited with your daughter.  "God Bless You".
Tom, Please read WISDOM 17.
It reminds us that one cannot escape the wrath of God in their conscience. I know it will not bring Amy back; but hopefully you can find peace in knowing that God is administering justice to him in this life and will continue in the next-- and we cannot be priveledege to either one. Mentally Handicaped he may be, but he had the presence of mind to take Amy's life--and now he's serving time in his mind--whether he's behind bars or not. Please read Wisdom 17.
My heart continues to be with you and your family Tom. I do believe with all my being that Chris Gossett killed your beautiful child, and for the reasons he gave to not only the police, but to the gentleman on Dateline. (It's being replayed as I type this.) I understand your rage Tom. I pray that this is settled soon. Hang in there, and know you did all you could to change the laws that so unjustly allowed a child to be jailed for something he didn't do.
I want to start this off by saying Chief Deputy Brad Robinson is a fool
And started to make himself look more of a fool toward the end of the
interview with Stafford(By the way...i love how you get those idiots tied up
in a knot by pointing things out that no one payed attention to or was just
trying to ignore to keep thereselves not being the one that was wrong).
Stafford pointed out that adams never mentioned the ditch or the unbuttoning
of the pants but chris mentioned everything in the crime scene.  Robinson's exuse wasnt
enough. Johonathon im sure was pushed to the point where he had to say he did it.
Like Johonathon said..he just wanted to go home. A child will do anything to go home.
They automatically assumed Johnathon did it because he was the last to be seen with amy.
About the fiber...there kids..for all we know they couldave been playing football, soccer
and ran into each other alot. They couldave just been tackling each other just being kids.
I also  believe someone manipulated Chris into saying he didnt do it after some time so the police
wouldnt look so bad. Chris made an effort to do self harm so im sure he had the mental capacity
to hurt someone else..which he may not have been in the right mind at the time..he is mental and
i believe thats what the police used as an advantage to do the manipulating. And tom...i know its
hard..but its probally best to forgive chris.  He does have a mental disablity and i could see in the
interviews hes terribly upset for what he done..its something that will remain on his concsions forever
and i think that might be enough. Peace be with you and god bless. And for Robinson, the fantasy of
being perfection is just a fanatasy..get over it..im sure your report cards werent perfect.
My heart goes out to you and your loved one’s Tom. I have an eight-year-old daughter as well and I’m not sure how I would react to such a tragedy. I just hope the Justice System keeps a close watch on Chris Gossett, low IQ or not.

That poor child, alone with the perpetrators. The only consolation is that God will take care of them in his own good time. And unless they repent, their punishment is very bad and will last for ever.
Why didn't they fingerprint the white notebook?  If somebody threw it, it would have his prints on it.
I just watched "Dateline-MSNBC, The Murder of Amy Yates” and I am once again horrified at the authority’s arrogance in the light of their obvious incompetence. Specifically in pressuring a confession out of a 12 year old boy and piecing together as they wish whatever random statement the child made in hopes that he would be sent home. Why are authorities still questioning minors without the presence of a parent, guardian or lawyer? Why are these prosecutors so adamant in getting a conviction that (even when I believe at some point they know they are wrong) persist in convicting innocent people Is it that they’re pride will not allow them to admit to making a mistake?. Where are all the Sherlock Holmes? The real "Gumshoes". Who are these lazy individuals who more fittingly should be taking my order and asking me if I would like to "Super-size" my order? These are all rhetorical questions because I know that we will never get an answer. I believe that overzealous prosecutors are in the minority and I look up to many other honorable prosecutors as dutifully protecting us from the “scourge”. However I cannot help but feel for Mr. and Mrs. Yates and thank God that the prosecutor didn’t try to come up with some “hair-brained” story that implicated these loving parents. I must add how incensed I was to witness the officers lighting Mr. Yates up with a Taser gun for being upset at the prospect that his daughter’s killer was going to get off with 2 years. In closing I believe that John Gossett is truly Amy’s killer and that he deserves whatever he gets. God help him.
Hello, I'm sorry for the lost of your daughter, I still will be thinking about this for while, when you are being scard for life, I'm sad for the way the police handle this too. I hope everybody can remember her how she was, and being happy when she was on earth. She is an angel now with god.
Tom,

I just watched the story of your family on Dateline NBC.  I cannot begin to express my deepest condolences to your entire family, but in particular to you, because I am a father of an 8 year old girl too.

I want you to know that I admire all that you have done to honor Amy.  You have gone above and beyond and I know she is smiling knowing how much her daddy loves her and that she is protecting you and your family now that she is with God.

I can only imagine the frustration you have endured throughout the case.

Tom, please let me know if I can help you to further encourage politicians to enforce strictier penalities to anyone who preys on our children.  My email is carlosi72@hotmail.com.

God bless you and Shari.  I am sorry for your divorce and I want her to know that my heart is with her as a parent as well.

I must admit that I was in tears when I saw the tattoo in Amy's honor.  My mother passed away in 2005 from cancer and I also got a tattoo on my right arm just where you have yours.  The last statement you made about it made me want to shake your hand.

Best regards,
Carlos Ibarra - carlosi72@hotmail.com
I believe there should be a law that does not allow a 12 year old child to be questioned by police without the parents being there.  The detectives hound these kids to get them to admit to something they did not do.  I have heard that some detectives tell the kids that if you just say you did it you can go home with your parents.  This should be against the law. No child under the age of 18 should be questioned without the parents and a lawyer.
This is A sad world we live in. What gets me the most is that you have to fight to make sure Justice is served for your daugter.And the sick part is that Chris Gossett is still out there .And most likey will hurt some one else.The DA and every one involed in this case is as guilty as chris.
Last night I watched MSNBC and learned about the horrific murder. I am 21 years old and thought I don't have any children I can only imagine what it's like to lose a family member, especially a child. I hope Chris gets a harsh sentence. Regardless of his IQ, murder is murder and for that he should pay the consequences. My heart goes out to you and your family.
Tom, I just saw your story on Dateline the other night. I am so sorry for your loss. Amy is very pretty. I have three kids myself, I feel for you and your family. God bless you and your family.
I feel very sad. I don't want to purge grief, but it must be one of the must painfullest thing to lose.
I have two sisters and if I would lose one, I wouldn't survive days and nights without them arguing over music.
I hope that you'll meet paths with her in the lifes that lies ahead of you.
I'm 14, and I'm sad that her life ended so early. It is a sad fact that we lose people during time no matter how hard we try to cling on to them.
Mr. Yates,

I understand what you are going through. My daughter was Murdered in July of 2005. It seemed that no one cared that she was taken from me and my family. I am so sorry that you and your family are going through this. My daughter was taken from me in a very brutal way and it is hard for me and my family to except what has happened. I just want to let you know from a father that their is no justice in this System we call society. My daughter was 18 and she was full of life. I can say that it has not been at easy at all to deal with my daughters death. My daughters name was Nabila Neverette and she can be found on My Space. We set up a Memorial site to honor her memory. My heart goes out to you and your family and hope that you can find some peace in the following days of your lives. You can contact me and my family if you wish. Take Care and God Bless.

                        William Neverette
I cannot say how sorry I am that this happened to you and your family. I have watched this show on dateline twice and it makes me cry everytime. I have a daugher and I cannot imagine what this feels like. I also believe that Chris did do this horrible thing to your daughter. It has happened many times before where people who have disabilities like Chris end up hurting or killing someone. So, just because he has a disability does not mean he didnt do it. My heart and prayers are with you.
God Bless You!!! and your ex-wife. You are truely pillars of faith. I know the pain of lossing a child but not so tragically and as you said it is something you would not wish on your worst enemy and only someone whos been there will know. I know! Keep your head up and her memory alive! God bless!      
I just want the world to know that the DA and the Carroll Sherrif Dept decided to arrest Thomas for getting angry when they decided to try Chris Gossett as a Juvenile when they annouced prior that he would be tried as an adult and Thomas Struck the Sherriff who was not really injured at all.  They gave Thomas Yates 18 months probation and ordered him into Anger Management Classes.  This is a joke!  Of Course he got angry.. Wouldn't you?  
I had the pleasure of meeting Amy Yate's father at my place of work, he happen to take the time to tell his story of his daugher and it really pulled at my heart strings,for i have a little girl of my own.I went straight home and got online and learned more about his story and cryed like a baby.all my love and prayer go out to the yates family.was a honor meeting you Tom Yates.I also wish you the best on your new job . sincerly, kathy from P.A.
I am so incredibly sorry and sad for what this family had to go through and is still and will undoubtdly always go through.  I am interested in one thing though....what was the race of the boys in question?  The 12 year old and the actual murderer.  Just wondering how much liberty was taken in them deciding who murdered this lovely little girl.  May Tim, Shari and little Danielle have God's arms wraped tightly around them.  May they find peace.
I will begin by saying I’m sorry for your family’s tragedy. I have a 10 yr old and I talk to her often about these types of tragedies…in hoping I will never have to live through a nightmare like yours.  It boggles me how a 12 yr old boy was convicted of something he didn’t do. How did his family allow for him to bargain a deal like that if he was innocent. I do believe the 16 yr. should serve time…he has an IQ if 65; that is a poor excuse in trying to justify a horrifying act he done to Amy.  I honestly don’t think rehab will ever help him. I would only wonder if he has done this before…maybe he has raped others. Maybe, someone needs to investigate this boy. I only hope your family can heal.  
I am so sorry for your loss we just lost my 4 year old nephew he was beat to death by my sisters boyfriend I dont know how to keep going reading your story and knowing that life does go on has helped me thank you and God bless you and your family
HELLO TOM MY NAME IS KAROLYN I WAS READING ABOUT YOUR DAUGTHER I AM SO SORRY ABOUT WHAT HAS HAPPEN TO AMY BUT I WANT YOU TO KNOW I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOUR FAMILY HAS TO FACE AND SOME JUST DONT HOW MUCH PAIN THERE IN YOUR HEART BUT I KNOW I FEEL THE SAME WAY BECAUSE MY OLDEST SON GARY WAS MURDERED ON MARCH 25,20007 NOBODY IS IN JAIL FOR HIS MURDER THEN ON AUGUST 20,2007 MY DAUGTHER WAS ALSO MURDERED AT A BACK TO PARTY ON AUGUST 19,2007 NOBODY IS NOT IN JAIL FOR MURDERED AT ALL I HEAR IS WE ARE STILL LOOKING BUT THAT IS NOT WHAT I WANT TO HEAR THE PERSON OR PEOPLE WHO DONE THIS TO MY CHILDREN AND MY FAMILY MY LIFE IS NOT THE SAME WITHOUT MY 2 CHILDEN BUT I KNOW I HAVE TO GO ON WITH LIFE FOR MY OTHER CHILDREN I STILL HAVE 3 DAUGTHRES AND 3 SONS 2 GRANDSONS FROM THE TO CHILDREN WHO WAS MURDEDED I DONT  TALK MUCH ABOUT THE CASE OF MY TWO CHILDREN BECAUSE I CANT SO I GO ONLINE AND TALK TO SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTANDS WHAT HAS HAPPENS.   THANK YOU AND GOD BLESS YOUR FAMILY                                                                                      
I want to know if this case will ever be settled, really...Our hearts go out to the Yates family.  We are residents of Carrollton and I too have a now 111/2 year old and an almost 3 year old.  I am really scared about how the Sheriffs Dept handled this entire case. Brad, should have been more thorough and before talking to Stone Phillips of MSNBC things should have been made right.  The poor Yates family who miss their daughter daily should be put at ease with a COMPLETE case and an ending that is TRUE and right so that they can try and get some peace from all of this.  I hate this for them and wish that I could comfort them in some way.  But honestly I do not see me EVER being comforted if I ever lost one of my boys.  God bless them and Brad, you need to completely close this case!!!!
I have also lost a child so I AM sympathetic to Amy's Mother. Watching the movie about the investigation of Amy's death my first impression from the start was to wonder if it ever occurred to anyone to question the father as he was so emphatic about Amy being home by 7 pm and not to be late. Maybe he went looking for her and found her and his temper got the best of him by the time he found her, as you can clearly see the man has quite a temper. He may have opened her button to make it look like a sex crime but could not actually remove his own daughters clothes as he is her father and not sick in that way. He and Amy's Mother have since divorced. Did the marriage finally disolve because Amy's Mother also had doubts on what happened. To start with I don't believe I would have been calling the police within twenty or thirty minutes of my child not being home on time. Maybe he had reason to know that she was not coming back and he called to cover his own guilt by acting concerned. I feel for the mentally challenged young man and his family. Of course watching the movie we aren't seeing the real people that were involved so we can't see their eyes to feel what is going on inside of them but this young man felt that Amy was his friend. She was nice to him as everyone says she was to everyone. She is probably the only one of those kids in the neighborhood that was decent to him all his life. He probably got picked on and made fun of by everyone else. I don't feel that he could be capable of hurting his friend in this way. Of course stories got around in two years that weren't supposed to be let out. Who are they trying to fool with saying that he said things two years later that was not given to the public. Just tell 10 people something and see how fast it will get around. I would not be convinced that that boy did not hear everything that he told the authorities from another source. I know they feel they found the right one now but I wonder.  
Hi my daughter and i watched the movie about Amy and
the other two boys that the police were questioning
and i do believe both boys were in on it. As the boy
named Cris i feel he did kill her as he was more stronger and left bruises. Cris is with special needs
and can't under stand his motivation and he does need
help. I feel Cris should get life and the other boy named Johnathon should get the same. I'm sorry this had to happen to your family and my heart goes out to you. Never under stood why you both had to divorice as this is the time to pull together.
11/24/07 6:00 p.m.
oh my gosh that sarid i am really sorry to hear that but there always a bright side you will be with her one of these days and rember she always in your heart and she never leave she looking over you
how do we live any with any deep feelings, it is too painful to truly feel, i lost my 26 year old son to a brutal murder, now i have to murder trials to face.
if i can find an ounce of his strength, his passion, his desire for the people and things he loved, maybe i'll find a way
i cannot even imagine-i will always remember the moment i read this-the pain you have experienced is unreal. Please understand you do not deserve this but you have  chosen to gain stregnth by continuing to share Amy's beautiful life. Please do not be discouraged; you will accomplish your purpose in life through Amy's story. I am so sorry
Has anything new happened in 2008?
Is the now Man still in jail?
With such a low IQ, did he go to adult jail?

I am sorry you and your wife didn't make it in your marriage.  My husband lost a child with his first wife and they didn't make it either--it is such a sad sad thing when such a small innocent child dies.

God Bless you and your family!
To the Yates Family-
I can only begin to imagine what it is like going through what you went through.
I am so very sorry. Knowing that will never bring your precious daughter back, but I am heartfelt sorry.
I just saw your story on Discovery Dateline. And I feel terrible about this. I am not pointing fingers, I am just appealing to you in a time of one of the worst things that could ever happen to a parent.
Our prayers and thoughts go with you.
I have a eleven year old daughter and I love her very much.I cant not imagine not having her in my life.Im so
very sorry for the loss of your little angel.I hope you can prove that this man brutally killed your daughter,I  
hope that he spends the rest of his life in prison.With this man free whos to say he might not do this again.What is wrong with our justice system? They have his confession ,but yet he has not been convicted
WHY?!!!!! I will pray for you and your family.I will pray that your little angels soul can find peace.I will also pray that the guilty man will be punished to the full extent of the law.Our god is a vengeful god may his will be followed.Thou shalt not kill!!!!!!  
i am so devistated after reading this no one in the worl can tell you how this fells i am 13 years old and i am all ready deep in this failing system. i am so sorry for you and your faimly
I work where Mr. Yates works, and I know how hard he works.  He has fought so hard to have justice for his beautiful daughter.  I know God will take care of you, and your family Tom.  I am so sorry your family has to go through this.
Dear Tom, 29 years ago I lost a daughter also. I will say time helps, it hasnt helped me. the only thing that helps me is my faith in knowing someday i will be reunited with her. Our children are only on loan. I pray for peace and understanding for you and yours Tom. Keep her memory alive
I am so sorry for your loss. My daughter knew Amy from a previous grade at school. Your loss really hit home with my family and I cannot imagine what your family went through. Sometimes I take my I stop by Amy's grave and pray for your family. God Bless you all!
No child should die that young. I never even knew her and I'm crying right now. I heartbroken and devestated to what happend to your daughter. No father of Mother or family should be going threw this. I'm 12 years old and even I know that.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://insidedateline.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=176994