ABOUT INSIDE DATELINE

Inside Dateline is your Web line into Studio 3B, providing you with a personal behind-the-scenes look at how we bring you our stories.

Whether it's a gripping crime tale, a hidden camera investigation, or a celebrity newsmaker profile -- Dateline correspondents and producers spend days, months, and sometimes even years researching and reporting the story. Learn more about what goes on inside our investigations, and find out more about some of the people we've met.

Ann Curry hosts Dateline. Dateline's producers, correspondents and host post here often. Previews to upcoming stories, more information on our reports, and follow-ups can be found on this blog.



Life after a child gets murdered

Posted: Tuesday, May 01, 2007 1:40 PM by Dateline Editor
Filed Under:

a guest blog entry by Tom Yates, father of Amy Yates

My name is Tom Yates, I am the father of two daughters, Amy and Danielle. On April 26, 2004, Amy was led into the woods of the mobile home park where we lived, by a 16-year-old boy that she knew and considered to be a friend. The boy told her that he wanted her to come listen to the birds with him. After entering the woods and walking far enough so that no one could see what he was going to do, he tried to rape her, and when she screamed for help he strangled her and then dumped her body further in the woods. The events that have unfolded that day seem like they could only happen in a movie, a horror movie for my family. (Tom, pictured with Amy on the right, and Danielle, left)

April 26 was like any other Monday. Sometime around 4:20 p.m. my girls got off the school bus and walked down to the house. Both girls had homework to do but because Amy had been doing so well at school we told her that she could play first and then do her homework later. Amy’s 9th birthday was just nine days away. We had bought her a pack of Hello Kitty invitations to give to her friends. After she had watched a little T.V., she wanted me to help her with the invitations so we worked on them together.  She asked me if she could go over to her friend’s house to give an invitation and play. I told her that it was fine but that I was starting on dinner and she had to come home at 7 p.m. I was standing at the front door when Amy got on her bike and rode across the street to her friend’s house. The girl wasn’t allowed to go out and play, so Amy came back home to ask if she could go to another friend who lived just three trailers over from us. Again, I said that was fine and to be home at 7 p.m.

Then I watched as she rode her bike in between two trailers, never imagining that I would never again see my daughter alive.

At 7:05 p.m. Amy had not come home so my wife, Shari, walked over to the Gossett’s trailer to go and get her. When she got there she was told that Amy never showed up. Shari came back to the house and told me that the Gossetts said that Amy wasn’t there. At that point I left the house mad, thinking that Amy had disobeyed us, but as Shari and I were walking back over towards the Gossett’s we noticed Amy’s bike parked on a concrete pad in an empty lot, just two lots to the left of the Gossett’s home, which is about 75 feet away.

At this point we knew that something was wrong. It was now about 7:20 p.m. and no one knew where Amy was so I called 911 and reported her missing. The sheriff’s department issued a statewide amber alert and send out a K-9 unit to help with the search, but the dog couldn’t lock onto her scent. Just after 10 p.m., my family and I were sitting at home waiting for someone to tell us that they had found our daughter when a local news channel came on TV and said, “Amy Yates has been found alive and has been returned home to her family.” But Amy wasn’t with us.


I ran up the street to the command center and asked where Amy was and they said they didn’t know but that there were two officers at my home who needed to talk to me. I ran back home thinking that I must have passed Amy and the officers on the way to the command center, but when I got home, Amy wasn’t with them. I asked the officers where my daughter was and they said that before they would talk to me I first needed to talk to two other officers. At this point, I got very upset with the officers and demanded to know where Amy was. Just then the officers opened my front door and let in two more officers who were wearing little gold crosses on their shoulders and right then I knew… Amy wasn’t coming home.

 

From that moment, and for a few days after, I don’t remember much. For those who have never lost a child or don’t have children, there is no way you could ever know the pain, loss, hurt and devastation of losing a child. I wish that no one ever has to endure the pain that my family and I have had to go through.

It has now been two years and nine months from the time of my daughter’s death and a lot has happened with the case. For those who haven’t followed the stories or don’t know of my daughter’s case, I will explain:

Just after Amy’s death, the local sheriff’s department charged a 12-year-old boy who lived in the mobile home park with her death. Our sheriff’s department and the D.A.’s office assured us that he was the one who killed Amy. After several court hearings and a year and a half later, the boy took a plea bargain called an Alford Plea, which means, “I feel that you might have evidence that would find me guilty if I were to go before a jury, so instead I will just say I did it and keep my innocence.” He was sentenced to serve two years in a psychiatric hospital.

Just the thought of someone serving two years for murder was mind-boggling. Our state’s juvenile code at the time said that no juvenile under the age of 13 could serve more than two years. That had my family and a lot of other people very upset. We campaigned for a change in the code to allow young offenders who commit violent crimes resulting in severe bodily injury or loss of life to be detained until their 21st birthday. We called the new law Amy’s law, and in July of 2006 it became legislation. But things didn’t end there.

Almost two years after Amy was murdered, a 19-year-old man named Chris Gossett confessed to Amy’s murder.  Within a few hours the sheriff’s department sent him home after telling his family that he had nothing to do with Amy’s death. At first we also didn’t believe him but after talking with friends of the Gossett family who were there when Chris confessed, we began to wonder if we had the right person. Two days later I called the Gossett home and spoke with Jean, Chris’s mom. Jean said Chris was sitting across from her on the couch. I said, “Jean, you ask him right now, did he kill my daughter?” Jean then asked, “Chris, Tom wants to know, did you kill Amy?” Chris replied, “I did it Mom, I did it. I keep telling everyone I did it but no one will listen.” I couldn’t believe what I had just heard. I just hung up the phone and began to cry.

For the next few months I worked closely with the attorney of the 12-year-old boy to help get him released. We succeeded but now we had the task of proving that we had enough evidence to indict Chris Gossett. On October 23, 2006, a Grand Jury gathered to hear evidence against Gossett and indicted him on the charge of involuntary manslaughter. This was an injustice. The Grand Jury said that they felt that Chris didn’t mean to kill Amy because of his IQ of 63; when Amy screamed he got scared and in the process of trying to keep her quiet he killed her. But that’s not the case. If they had paid attention to Chris’s first confession video, Chris said that he was taking Amy into the woods to have sex with her. That’s rape! So what Chris did is called Felony Murder.

Because the Grand Jury asked for involuntary manslaughter, if found guilty, Chris Gossett will only serve 2-10 years for the murder of my 8-year-old daughter. The system has once again failed the victim.

For now I wait for the day when this is all over and I can once again try to move forward with my life. As for my family, after Amy’s death, my wife and I tried for two years to make our marriage work for Danielle’s sake, but we were unable to stay together. I have since remarried and Danielle lives with me. My new wife has an 8-year-old daughter so now Danielle has a stepsister. Like all siblings, they fight like cats and dogs, but love each other to death. As for Shari, she has moved and met someone new, and might remarry this spring.

The report, "A Killing in Carrollton," aired Dateline Tuesday, May 1, 8 p.m. Click here for the transcript.  Click here for the full crime files.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

oh i am so so sorry , i have tears in my eyes and a sickness in my bones, . I am a mother and a gransmother , i cont and cant imaganine what u went thru and still go thru , To think that a 19 got please sickins me !!! Isnt it funny how the police in some areas are just too stupid to see what is right in front of them im sorry for that and i belive better insight is needed . I am glad to hear u remarried and your oldest has another in her life. Im sure she will never get over that incident as for Shari, im sure she is suffering in a way only a mother ccould no , shari my heart goes ou to you too . Love ( really ) lynn from RI.
I'm so sorry this has happen to you and your family. I feel for you. No , I haven't lost anyone, but yout story is just sad!
I believe police just look for the easy answer instead of what is the truth.They badger the person into a confession. Their work is now done. Not even a confession from the real killer will change their minds. That might mean more work.They wonder why some officers get a bum rap?? Think guys think. People are tired of this kind of thinking.
This is a horrible story. I just happened to see it on dateline. 10 years is not enough for the individual responsible for this. I hope you find some kind of closure to this. Find some comfort in knowing that Amy is with God. This killer will have to spend eternity in hell.
I was just watching this on TV and was shocked to see it. I can't imagine what it would be like for me if that happened to any of my family. I can't even imagine how I'd feel.
Tom I just watched your story on Dateline. I cant imagine the horror you and your family have lived for nearly 3 years. My heart goes out to you and your family and can only hope that someday you will be able to put this all behind you and grieve your loss. You are a true hero to your daughters for having dedicated your life to solving and finding truth in this horrible horrible tragedy. Please stay strong as the rest of your family still needs you. I have all the confidence in the world that Amy is watching you now and is so proud to have such wonderful parents. My heart goes out to you and your family.
I can't understand how anyone could take life from a child!!!!!! I have 3 boys and could not imagine any of them being charged with such a crime we all think we know our kids perhaps Chris has been slow to realize what he did was wrong> .Its hard to know my prayers are with you.God only knows the truth and bless you.Let your faith lead you to the truth
Tom - My emotions are so high, I don't know where to begin. There is so much on my heart but I'll try to keep this brief. You were duped by the justice system and then victimized over and over again. But you were not the only victim, so was Jonathan amidst many others. When will we stop allowing "bullies" to abuse our children and intimdate them into confessing? This is the most egregious and deplorable and shameful act of supposed professionalism imaginable! I can hardly stomach it!! Thank you so much for sharing a very painful story and revealing your deep pain. I have learned from it and can relate to you on so many levels - too many to name in this blog. God Bless!
My most sincere sympathies and condolences in your family troubles. I will remember you and Amy and the rest of your family in prayers. In a spirit of jurisprudence, I would like to share an already known case of wrongful conviction that has the same legal hallmarks of prosecutorial and police malfeasance. I speak of the man, Wilton Dedge of Brevard County, FL. In 1982 he was convicted of rape and sentenced to life. The witness was a known jailhouse rat, but considered a good witness for court. Ha. So, Dedge gets one DNA test which fails to exonerate him. Well, it was old science and a later try established that the DNA did not match. Now this is a finding with the improved DNA protocols and is absolute. So, to a Scientific Certainty, Wilton Dedge is proven innocent. The DA never offered to right the wrong. They knew that Dedge was innocent, even to the point of agreeing with the new DNA evidence. That didn't matter to the current prosecutor, who was not part of the team that convicted Dedge in the first place. Citing the "timing" being to late to file an appeal, they managed to keep him in jail for 3 more years while the higher courts took their time to release him. To further twist the knife, after 22 years of an unjust and probably criminally prosecuted miscarriage of justice, the state did not even want to pay him dollar one for completely ruining the life of an innocent man. You can share this with your lawyer (if he isn't already on it)as additional anecdotal evidence of standard prosecutorial misfeasance and malfeasance. Good Luck and Give 'em Hell
Tonight I sat and watched Dateline NBC. I was very moved by the show. My thoughts and prayers are with you Tom and your family. I pray that justice will be served. God bless you..
I heard this story for the first time tonight when it aired on NBC's Dateline.. And I have to say that I am completely outraged!!! First for the poor family who lost their daughter but also for the family of the boy who was wrongly convicted..What kind of a police department is this??? All i can say is that i am sure glad that my family and i do not live in Carroll County Georgia. I majored in Criminal Justice in college. Although i didn't pursue a career in that field i sure know enough to know that the way this "So Called" Police Department responded is absoulutely ridiculous and they should all be fired !!! At least the ones who handled this case!!!!! But back to the families. I sure hope Mr. Yates gets the justice he seeks and the one who did do it spends more than a decade in jail. I know that will never bring back his little girl.. but at least he might be able to sleep at night knowing his daughter's killer is in prison where he belongs!!!I have an 8 year old little girl and a 6 year old boy.. they are my life ..i could not go on with out them.. Mr. Yates.. I just cant imagine the pain you are going through and I sure hope i never have to.. But my thoughts and my prayers are with you. God Bless you, your family, and your little girl Amy...May she rest in peace...
I saw the story and the devistation on msnbc tonight,It is a horrindous event that nobody should endure.God Bless u Tom.I believe that both boys had something to do with it,I believe that the slim boy got Chris to do it for whatever reasons.Both of them should have been charged with this murder of your precious daughter.What a system we have,its a shame.
I also saw this on Dateline last night, and I was shocked at the attitude of this boy. I saw no remorse or sympathy for your family. It was like it was just another accident like knocking over a lamp. It is obvious to me that this young man knew he was doing wrong and didn't want to get caught. My heart goes out to you and your family. Only God could know why these unspeakable acts of violence happens to such innocent children.God bless
This is said and the sentencing for the 19 year old murderer is absolutely unbeliveable. My sister is developmentally delayed, her iq is 59. she knows the differance between right and wrong and she knows you do not hurt people. she is now 47 and has never hurt anyone. should she have been the one to take an innocent life such as your daughters, i would want them to punsih her to the fullest extent of the law. what type of message does this send to others? i will pray for your family and my heart truly aches for you.
I am so sorry for your loss. There are no words, I could type to comfort you, I have lost someone my bestfriend I realize this doesnt compare to a child but I know the hurt you wake up with every day never goes away. You probably wake up and have to relive everything all over again. But you are doing the right thing. I am so sorry your story makes me cry and I will tell her story and pray for your family
I am sorry to hear of your loss. i could never imagine lossing my little babies. And when you found out that it was someone that you trusted to be someone you could trust... WHAT IN THE WORLD IS A 16 YEAR OLD GETTING THAT KIND OF STUFF FROM. What is the world coming to letting kids do things like this. I hope things get alittle better for you.
after reading this i had tears in my eyes. My condolenses to you and your family.
I KNOW EXACTLY WHAT ITS LIKE TO LOSE A CHILD MY SON WAS MURDERED 17 MONTHS AGO BECAUSE HE TURNED IN A CHILD MOLESTER. HE WAS 16 YEARS OLD. MY HEART AND PRAYERS GO OUT TO YOU AND YOUR FAMILY, IT DOESN'T GET EASIER AND IT NEVER ENDS BUT KNOW MY SON WILL BE LOOKING OUT FOR YOUR DAUGHTER. JUSTICE WILL BE SERVED IN ONE WAY OR THE OTHER, EITHER IN THIS LIFE OR THE NEXT. GOD BLESS YOU.
Now I see how someone could easy just decide to take the law into their own hands & get their own jsutice- as they see fit- I dont know how this father prevents himself from seriously harming that man. citizens may need to soon take over anyway=-justice is sanity How so sorry I feel for this grieveing family- what a slap in the face
Tom, My heart is hurting for you and your family. I really don't understand how anybody could do such a thing even if he was a minor. I really don't understand the justice system. I belive if you take anybodys life even if your a minor should serve life or death. That is wrong! May God bless you and your family always! Just remember that she is watching over all of you!!!
I remember hearing about this terrible tradegy as it unfolded, being a Georgia resident myself. I can't imagine losing my daughter, especially at such a young age and in such a brutal manner. My heart aches for your family, and for the beautiful child taken from you. The young boy initially charged was a victim as well. I pray your family and his, by the grace of God, will be able to find peace one day.
I am a mother of a 3 year old boy who I love more than anything in this world and I can't imagine my life without him. Your story have really hurt my heart just like any other time that I hear that someone have taken a innocent childs life. May God bless you and your family.
wow. I don't even know how to respond. I am numb. My heart cries when reading your words. May Amy rest in peace.
I can't even imagine what you are going through, I am a mother and grandmother and I feel so lost when my only grandson leaves me for his home! Having to live the rest of your life without your child is the most devastating thing a person can go through. No one should have to do that. My heart goes out to you and your family.
It is very sad,that all the groups feel sorry for the criminal. what if it was there girl or there grand baby.I think anyone that is old enough to do a crime like this should be hanged by the balls at the town square, and all tree hunging criminal lovers should have to hold the dead bodies in there arms for hours.If you touch a kid for any wrong reason you need to be treat to a life in prison with baba packing your peanut butter daily and people that say oh is IQ or he is not right in the head should spend time with baba also...
I don't even know what to say - my heart breaks for you and your family. I can only pray that God will heal your heart and bring you peace. May Amy rest in peace.
Tom, My heart is with you as are my prayers. I lost both my wife and son to a drunk driver many years ago, so I know the pain you are feeling. The driver who killed them served 18 months. I agree that the system does not work in the victims' favor and all family members and friends are victims as well. It affects all. I will keep you and your family in my prayers. The pain lessens a little as years go by, but the emptiness lingers. I hope you find some peace soon. My deepest sympathy to you and yours,
Hi,I'm 14 and I just read your heartbreaking story on the net.I'm so sorry for you.I'm sending condolences all the way from Grenada in the Caribbean.
IM SORRY TOM.
man im sorry this is so terrible i feel bad for the father and the boy who spent that time in prision for something he did not do.as for the boy who did it if that was my child he did that to he would of never made it to the court room.
I have a 6 year old daughter, and just the thought that something like that could happen to her keeps me up most nights. I watch her like a hawk, but they are never really safe are they? My heart and my prayers go out to you and yours, it's a damn shame that our justice system is so determined to help the wrong person in this case. It sounds like the person knew what he was doing was wrong or else he wouldn't have taken her somewhere where no one would see, try to keep her quiet and then hide her body. All that shows intent and the fact that he knew right from wrong, there should be no mercy for a predator like that.
i am a loving mom of three beautiful kids and i can say with all my heart, i can completely feel the pain that you and your are suffering! my kids are my life and i am so very sorry that this horrible thing was inflicted on your daughter. i commend you for all you did to clear the innocent boy of the wrongful charges and helped to nab the real monster!god be with you and your family and please always know that your little angel is still smiling down on you all. here's to wishing all of you happier days and peace of heart and mind. god bless you!
My thoughts and prayers are with you, Tom. I have not lost a child but if anything happened to my son, I know I will not be able to go on. I hope that your daughter's soul rest in peace and that you and your family remember all the good memories of her. I wish Shari all the best.
Tom i read your story and feel so sad. every morning and night i pray for the children around the world that our(LORD JESUS)who love them so mutch will keep them all safe,i have one son four daughters and three grand sons and i dont know how i would feel if eny thing happen to one of them. may (GOD) bless your family,we have never had that happen in the cayman island, so i dont understand why wicked peoplee kill little babys just know she is in heaven happy with the other kids, may GOD help you to forgive and fine peace
Tom I am so very sorry about your beautiful ANGEL, but know that GOD loves you and I PRAY for you and your family right now.
I was sadden when I read your story. Yet I wasn't surprised at how the system handled the case. My daughter, at a young age of 6 was sexually molested in Tennessee. The attorney that was assigned to the case refused because of conflict of interest,(she had a friend who once dated the perpetrator and he was found naked in the room with her young daughter, who also was naked.)Anyway, the perpetrator was given a sentence of 24 years but plea bargained and got only 6 yeaars in prison. A law was passed after he was sentenced that all sex offenders have to register. Those sex offenders who offended before the law came in don't have to register. My daughter, who is now 22, has to live with this the rest of her life and the perpetrator gets off with only 6 years and now can go on with his life, to do as he pleases.
I feel bad for you! That's simply terrible that the kid who did it isn't getting a life sentence! My sincere sympathy to you and your family! God Bless You and Be With You!
I just read your story and I can understand what you're feeling one of my cousins was kidnapped and murdered it has been 20 yrs and they never found the person who did it. Not a day goes by that I don't think of her and what was robbed from all of us. We were robbed of watching her grow up and many more things. But I think if the laws in this country were more strict against child predators there would not be a lot them doing what they do. They give them a slap on the hand with a 2yr sentence or whatever and they are out on the streets and in our neighborhoods without us knowing and they do it again and again. But I think when it hasn't happend to you, it's hard to understand. If this had happened to the presidents daughter or the governors daughter I would bet they would look at it very differently.
this is the first i heard of this case. I felt like Mr. yates was really wronged by the police dept and the prosecuter's office in that town.With the forensic dept's today,how could this ever happen. then the all important confession,knowing about the girls pants etc,what is wrong with the police down there. then they don't want to prosicute.god bless you mr yates for your patience. your daughter is looking down on you from heaven.
It's a shame that in this day and age that the police still cant get it together when it comes to child crimes. I agree, if a minor do something he should be punished. It's a shame you get more time for selling drugs than you do for murder. Also, the other tragedy was the divorce. I never understand how when couples are faced with a problem why it seperates at the core instead of making it work and not settling for anything else. Im very glad you are happy now and so sorry for your loss.
Robin Drumm of Battle Creek Michigan, totally hit the nail on the head with his contributing comment, like nobody else's. It is absolutely infuriating.
I'm so sorry for your lost. I just wanted to let you know that I do understand your lost. I losted my Daughter Four years ago too cancer. I don't wish that on anyone. katlingoard.com I just know that Amy and Katlin anr playing right now, and are best of Freinds. God Bless you and your Family.
I have a son who is sitting in jail for something he didn't do while the real criminals are out doing the same crimes. The Police only want to make an arrest to try and say that they are solving the crime problem. God forbid if you have a past record and is trying to go straight. Forgive me for going on but I am truly sorry about the loss of your daughter and what your family had to go through.
Our hearts and prayers go out to you and your family. It is impossible to imagine how it would feel to lose a child especially at such a young age and Lord knows I hope nobody else has to go through what you and your family has had to endure. The victim (Amy) should not be victimized again by her perp getting away with such a horrible crime and only serving a minimal amount of time. He should be deprived of "freedoms" and benefits of being able to socialize with his family and friends. My family and I are truly sorry for your loss and pray things will get easier with time.
You need to rely on God. Believe me, he is with the daughter you lost. She cannot be hurt again, and he blesses her for having to endure what she did. She is Safe!! Know this in your heart, and lean on God, with all your faith. For your pain, God will find ways to make you find ways to deal with it. God never allows us to go thru anything, without a way out. But we have to see the way out. Sometimes it's so hard to see the way out of the pain, because the pain is so unbearable...it feels like that's all there can be. Life here is just a parenthesis in infinite time for your precious little girl, and you and your family. You will see her again, in a way that there will be no memory of this incident and all will be well, and safe, and happy. I believe God allows evil to do this to lives... for one he now has your daughter in his care, right? That would lead you and your family to his care right? Then, when life become eternity... you will all be together in his care. Some families don't get to do that... you will. Sure, it's hard to imagine now,... but it's real. Believe me, it's so real. God does not do evil... but he gives us free will, to love, and that included a choice to be evil. People make that choice, unknowing the lasting effects, but death is still a lie. God has plans for us all beyond death... go to God, where she is... he will get you thru it all. And later you will understand the entire process of life, learning, choices, mistakes, and death. And it will never happen again. I have lost a child too , in a different kind of a way... it's the hardest. Love her still, love her mother, and sister, and all others,...even love the child that committed this horrible act. Love God because there is life beyond this. Try so extra hard for forgiveness... and this releases her and your family for a better faith and love and blessings from God. Release her from that hold... forgive him. Love you, and your family, because your creations of God J
Your family has experienced not only the loss of your beautiful daughter but, of faith in the justice system.
You have been victimized over & over again by people with the power to do us.  It's a shame that the people we put in a position to serve & protect,can cause harm & destruction.  The bigger problem is everything turns into a huge cover up. When will these people be held accountable for the wrongs that have damaged peoples lives forever.  How do they sleep? Sounds like crimminal behavior to me.
I am ten years old. Iread your story about Amy's murder and I almost cried.   I really hope that your family recovers from this.
All of the bloggers have expressed sentiments felt by many. I saw a small portion of this on T.V. tonight. Then I did a little research and found this page. I am thankful that the dad shared so much. It helps me grasp this situation more fully and am grateful to those who have expressed so much compassion. God Bless All.
What a beautiful daughter! I am so sorry for your loss. It shouldn't have happened. I am sure she was so special and wonderful and I can not believe someone would harm her that way. I send my blessings to your new found family and hope that only wonderful things come your way.
hi i watched and read you story and it is sickening that one of her friends would brutally murder a girl who was so small and i wish the best for you and your family and all other family's that have had children killed and i semd my remorce to you and all of you family


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://insidedateline.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=176994